Following on from his best-selling Tintin: The Complete Companion, Michael Farr portrays the little-known but fascinating life of Herge, the remarkable artist behind Tintin, the boy reporter who continues to thrill and delight an ever-widening audience. In seven separate sketches, he presents his picture of a man whose life is the key to his creation.
Michael Farr (born 1953 in Paris) is a former British journalist and an expert regarding the comic series The Adventures of Tintin and its creator, Hergé. He has written several books on the subject, as well as translating several others into English.
Critique: This is simultaneously fascinating and frustrating. It is fascinating as a biography of Georges Remi, the Belgian cartoon strip artist who created Tintin, and he led a pretty interesting life: living through both world wars, the innovations of modern art, the evolution of cinema from silent pictures through talkies to modern film, the development of television, and the development of the space program through landing on the moon to the space shuttle. It is frustrating in its format: the book does not proceed chronologically through Remi's life from beginning to end. Or rather, it does so, but it does it multiple times, again and again in each chapter. As such it is very repetitious. Each chapter of the book is not on a particular period of his life, but rather a particular theme in his life, and each chapter is like an essay that was written separately from all the rest. So you get the presentation of the broad timeline of Remi's life again and again, often including the same or substantially similar language, as if each chapter was an essay written for a school project: "Talk about Remi's life as it relates to art," "Talk about Remi's life as it relates to China," "Talk about Remi's life as it relates to his relationships." It's a very weird format for a biography book; I could believe that each essay was written at a different time for a magazine article, and they were then later collated into this book. Effectively, the book is a compilation of 7 different biographies.
The other tension I experienced in reading this book was between delight and disillusionment. It was simultaneously interesting to discover all the influences and inspirations that Remi had in creating Tintin, and disappointing to discover how unoriginal his work was: every character was based on someone he knew in life or had read about, every scene was based on photographs or illustrations he had seen, every gag was inspired by (some were outright lifted from) stuff he had seen in movies. It's a strange thing to simultaneously be impressed at the craft and sad at the loss of wonder.
The book is filled with illustrations: excerpts from the comics, reference photos, and pictures of Georges himself in different periods of his life. These are excellent photographic records of his life and his work, but here again there's a weird repetition: each picture had a caption taken verbatim from the text of the adjacent page, as if they were displays in a museum with little plates explaining their context, rather than photographs illustrating a book's text.
However I feel about the book as a whole, I ended it with a fierce desire to re-read my collection of Tintin books, which is probably the author's desired outcome. Good for him!
I have loved Tintin since I first read one of his adventures when I was about seven years old. There's just something so special about the Tintin books (especially the two Moon books!). So I was happy to find this biography of Herge, the creator of Tintin. There's a lot of interesting information and pictures in this volume, and it's a fun and easy read. My only reservation is that the author decided not to tell his biography in chronological order, but as separate subjects in each chapter, spanning his entire life. He talks about the influence of the Boy Scouts, for example, or Herge's love of China. Because of this, he repeats himself quite frequently, which can be quite annoying. Not annoying enough, though, to ruin the book, which is certainly an entertaining read otherwise.
Odd book, very strangely organized -- not exactly chronological, more like select episodes from Hergé's life that seem haphazardly thrown together. Much of the material is well-worn and found in greater detail or with more insight in other biographies of Hergé. Also a lot of repetitive material from chapter to chapter. And I wish there were more illustrations of scenes from the books that are discussed in this one. On the other hand, the book is beautifully designed and filled with wonderful photos and behind-the-scenes artwork. That alone makes it worth the read.
A fantastic companion to Farr's extensive 'Tintin: The Complete Companian', showing again why he is the English-speaking world's preeminent Tintinologist. Those looking for a more straight-forward and chronological account of Herge's life would be better served by Pierre Assouline's brilliant biography; here, Farr makes the odd, but ultimately-satisfying choice, of exploring his subject through a series of themes that defined his life, including Herge's love of scouting and his friendship with Chang.
I couldn't make heads or tails of the different characters drifting in and out of its pages or even of the basic facts of Herge's life. The illustrations were no fun to spend time with, too spiky and kind of artless a rendering, by my taste. I would rather spend time rerearing old Tintins than finish The Adventures of Herge. I wish it were otherwise.
You havta know getting into this that this isn't a biography of Herge per se. It's more a look at different interests of Herge and how they influenced his Tintin books. For what it's meant to do, it's a fair book. The best parts are the historical photos of Herge and Tintin-related things.
A bit odd organizationally in terms of the order in which events are presented, and some of the figures are left randomly uncaptioned, but a good read overall!
4.5 stars Downgraded because of the way the book is organized- or not. A friend took this out of the library and now libraries are closed so I borrowed it from her. I never read the Tintin books- why? I remember my kids reading them, but even then I didn’t. I found this biography interesting because Herge had been at the edge of my reading experience but without any information. He was Belgian and began writing the Tintin stories as fillers for a scouting magazine when he was young. He took the pen name Herge as a transliteration of his real initials: “R” “G”. The bio talks about his wishes to be a reporter and lifetime of scouting experience. The values and style of Tintin are explained through Herge’s own values and desires. Extensively illustrated with photos and drawings. Made me seek out the Tintin books!
Often tries to be a little too insightful, leading to entire chapters speculating on things that MIGHT have influenced Herge's Tin Tin.
And the book does something I found extremely annoying---the captions under each photo or piece of art were exactly taken word for word from the text, so that as I read along, for instance, I'd look at a repo panel from Tintin and the Picaros with a caption of "In Tintin and the Picaros the streets of Tapiocapolis offer a setting for the sculpture of Marcel Arnould and---etc. etc. and then as I read the text for the page I'd run across the exact same passage. This would happen again and again.
Incidentally, the above example is from a chapter on Herge's passion for art, and it was a sad chapter in my mind. Herge had abysmal taste in art, falling in for the whole Warhol crowd, and "artists" like Lucio Fontana and Serge Poliakoff. Herge yearned to be as "important" as their like, which is so amazing to me, as the man (Herge) had more artistic talent in his nose hairs than the whole Warhol crowd had in their total possession.
Actually, I should back away from that. Warhol did have talent, as witnessed in his early illustration work, but he threw away Warhol the artist in order to become Warhol the Artiste. Shame, that.
Back on track, this book was middle of the road, often over-reaching into speculative boundaries, but when it stayed on track it was a worthy successor to Farr's more cohesive book, Tintin: The Complete Companion
Always interesting to learn about significant people. This book is not a typical biography but rather a selection of topics that the author organizes stories or biographical details around to tell the life of Herge. So you will get some facts repeated multiple times.
His life long passion for art was interesting as is realizing how much of himself is reflected in Tintin.
The art itself was great - in the style of Herge. Herge himself, it turns out, was not so very interesting to me or admirable. As is so often the case - the author does not hold a candle to his creations.
Hagiography! I love Tintin, but this book is clearly a "how wonderful is Herge." I thought this book better--Assouline, Pierre (2009). Hergé, the Man Who Created Tintin
Definitely inspiring and worth looking through the history Herge and his beloved creation Tintin. His works never cease to inspire other writers and artists.