I am not a hardcore fan of Transformers, but I still dearly love the franchise and the characters. I may not admire all of the fans, or some of the decisions made in the name of fandom, but I can see potential when I see it.
I read this book back in January. Not a long read, and it does give some background to the Aligned Continuity, as well as provide background to the 'Prime' TV series. I actually read this book because of that show. Anyways, the writing is simple and gets the job done, but at the same time, there are some contradictions and some out-of-character characters.
For example, Shockwave. He is described as being a sadistic and mad scientist bent on changing Cybertron into his science lab. Yet it's clear in most continuities - G1, Animated, and Prime - that he isn't sadistic at all. He is dedicated to logic and science. He does things for the sense of practicality, not because he is insane. In 'Prime', he asks Megatron what is the point of ruling two planets when there would be clear issues in their governance; and he doesn't see the point of needlessly torturing people for the sake of torture; he does things because they NEED to be done, as well as see what the limits of their bodies can do. In some cases, Shockwave can even show tenderness. He did with his Predacons pets and those close to him.
The background between Megatron and Optimus Prime can be considered cliched, but it is done in a way that is predictable and original. Megatron is the gladiator that wants to abolish the caste system - like Maximus fighting to avenge his family in 'Gladiator' (and it certainly had that feel) - and Optimus Prime - then Orion Pax - wants a life like that of Golden Age Cybertron where people lived as they pleased. The caste system, like that of India or Mesoamerica, bases and labels people on what they can do and their backgrounds and places them in society on a scale: the fairest and most intelligent are at the top, considered High Caste, and the ugly and stupid and useless are placed in the bottom, ergo, the Untouchables. I really wished the creators could have based the caste system on these a tad bit more so we could have some authenticity, but I guess for the sake of diplomacy it was pushed aside. Fair enough. Not all like that life and refuse to admit that it still exists.
Megatron - then D-16 - is tired of the injustice and wants bots to be judged on what they can DO, not what they ARE. Optimus and him strike up a friendship because of their shared ideals for a better world. When Megatron does some nasty things behind the scenes like bomb an amusement park (No Vangaboys were hurt) and other sites and blames them on the Other Guy, Optimus and Megatron are brought before the High Council - the ultimate High Caste - and they are judged. To make it short, Optimus is made Prime and Megatron is tossed aside.
I've seen some fan explanations and theories on this on tumblr. The Matrix of Leadership doesn't really CARE who or what is Prime. It has a childish and even violent air to it and it can sway the holder to do what it wants and what it wants alone. It's omnipotent and we don't know where it comes from, but obviously it's just as mysterious and tricky as the AllSpark, the source for all life in their universe. Megatron wanted the Matrix as he thought he was worthy, and indeed we can see this: he fought his way to the top, he taught himself everything he needed to know and he knows how bots think. Optimus just happened to come in and get the Matrix. Megatron feels and insane sort of jealousy: 'Why should HE get it and not ME? What has he done?'
And long story short, the war begins.
Decepticons such as Barricade and Lugnut make an appearance, but they're not really expanded upon. I'm fond of the Animated Lugnut, and would have adored seeing him bow down before Megatron in that amazing David Kaye impression, but alas, we don't get it. Barricade was just there. Soundwave and his symbiotes are there: Laserbeak, Ravage, and Frenzy and Rumble, but they are just there. Yes, they do the spying stuff but that's it. Soundwave also speaks, while I am used to his silent, Slenderman-esque attitude in the 'Prime' series. It would have definitely made him stand out. But not all readers would have seen the show and would have been confused. Still, I would have opted to the silent Soundwave.
Starscream is described as being a scientist and not a scientist; this error was on the wiki. He is also described as being someone who can stand up to Megatron, though he is famous for his duplicity and cowardice, and intelligence. When Megatron becomes fancy-pancy with the Dark Energon, Starscream gets a whiff of it and becomes Darkened - ergo, the liquid MacGuffin makes him insanely strong. Yet according to the story, Dark energon burns out quickly and needs twice as much Energon to replenish. Eventually they poison Cybertron's core with Dark Energon, which, in the show, reawakens scores of dead Cybertronians and in the third and final season, Predacons. There are inconsistencies with all of them. I never saw the exact reason why Megatron wanted to poison the core. What's the point of controlling a planet full of zombies, and where you will eventually die from a lack of resources?
Starscream has some moments, especially the ones where he wants to rule instead of Megatron, but true to his character he never has the guts to plunge the knife in his back. Still, the inconsistencies of his character - him not being a scientist or being one - raises some eyebrows.
They use a giant telescope to poison the core (at least what I remember) and then Megatron fights Sentinel Prime. According to these dudes, there can only be one Prime at any given time, so why Sentinel and Optimus are in the same predicament was a continuity error. The civil war wasn't really described in detail; yes, we learn that many cities are bombed to rubble and whatnot, but it didn't really leave a lasting effect.
When the AllSpark is launched into space, there's a big race to go and find it. Before that happens, Cybertron's core is poisoned and it is saved when Bumblebee smashes a nest of crystals. It makes you wonder, again, whether or not Megatron should have seen this coming. I do understand that he DID destroy Cybertron, but at the same time, it was a collective effort of BOTH Autobots and Decepticons. You would have thought the swarms of the dead and Predacons would have roamed free, but as we see in the 'Prime' series, that is not the case.
When Optimus makes the Ark and sets off to space, he takes a ragtag group of Autobots with him. Sometimes when they're in a room talking, a character will suddenly appear out of nowhere. For example, when Prowl, Bumblebee, and Optimus Prime were talking about their situation CLIFFJUMPER was there, even though SIDESWIPE was there. Someone didn't edit their work!
The end event is when the Nemesis and the Ark get separated after a long chase when the Space Bridge explodes. Then our heroes are left stranded, musing that one day they will go home.
Yeah, no. Megatron shot a Senator, one of many unknown Senators we don't really know more about, because of a crass comment, and then Megatron goes (excuse the language): "@#$% this @#$%, I'm outta here." Then he pollutes the core because LOL SORRY. Even Megatron in the Prime series doesn't know much about the Darkened Energon, and wouldn't be so foolish to pollute his own home. He wanted to vanquish the caste system, got deluded doing it, started the Decepticon cause, and caused a war. He is a warlord, but at the same time, the Decepticons cannot be truly at fault. In this book they are the token enemies, but it's clear that they want to be in charge of their own future and want to do things based on reason - in a heavy-handed way, it is still reason - while the Autobots want to do it in a sheltered, non-existent peaceful state.
The other books feature the Quintessons - not sure why - but I haven't read them yet.
I wouldn't say this would be all out the 'official' history of the war for Cybertron, because the battles are, again, described in minute detail. I get there are tons of characters to go after, but if you focus on the more prominent ones, everyone will be happy.
Alpha Trion was a convenient backstory character, giving Orion Pax - and later Optimus - wisdom and telling him of what the Covenant of Primus says in subliminal messages. Alpha Trion stays behind in seclusion so he can record stuff.
Some of the explanations as to why the caste system is evil didn't really resonate with me. It's evil because it's evil? Why? The Primes made the caste system due to some sort of event. I assume it was because people took their freedom for granted or there were errors with the AllSpark. In any case, caste systems are usually not all that diabolical; it's more or less social Darwinism put in practice. We all do it in some way or another. Our abilities and what we are put us in different positions. It can be evaluated as bad or good, but for the most part, it does serve a purpose. In this case, the caste system was there to create order, and it seems that the Untouchables - Megatron and his gladiators included - were not considered useful. The whole 'why?' to this is never explained except that they were considered lesser robots. We learn that the Quintessons put the earliest Cybertronians into slavery, and there of course is the full-circle cliche of the so-called liberators doing the same thing.
The Insecticons make an appearance, though in the show it was said that they were made as patrols to watch the dead planet in the Decepticon's stead. They are eventually forgotten.
Megatron wants to abolish the caste system, yet he doesn't really understand it. I guess that is a character flaw of his, and we do sympathize with him when the Matrix picks Optimus over him. I would have liked to have seen the Matrix have a personality like I described earlier: devious, and not always 'good'. Same with the AllSpark, which is clearly a very powerful device capable of restoring entire worlds - or destroying them. In some cases, the way things are written are sloppy, and you'll probably forget what happens as I do. I have read worse, though.
I give this book three stars. While not perfect, it was still a good read despite some short-comings and some out-of-character interpretations. Shockwave is not a sadist. I would have expected a little more three-dimensional character interpretations, but eh, can't have everything.
The fights didn't really stand out, but were fair enough. I wanted to see more of the Wreckers, the Seekers, and more of Megatron. Maybe even Breakdown? Knock Out? C'mon you gotta have Dr. Sexy in there.
As said before, I didn't like the explanation for the death of the planet by Dark Energon (makes you wonder where they got all of it), the description of the battle scenes, and some of the OOC behaviour. It is not the worst I have seen, and I can deal with it.
If you want a better explanation for the events of Cybertron, I recommend the 'War for Cybertron' games.