“But by no means did I ever imagine that one day I would be an instructional designer of self-paced, online e-learning programs. Never. This was a complete accident.”
This was a good, very basic, introduction to Instructional Design. I thought the book started quite strong, but as the chapters went by it became more and more repetitive. It seemed like some of the chapters could've easily been half the size.
Unfortunately, for a book about instructional design, it only covered principals, and provided very little actionable advice to implement these principals - it was a bit too abstract in many of the sections for me to fully comprehend how it can be applied. This may be because I come from an academic instructional design position, rather than corporate training; so what examples there were, just didn't translate particularly well to my job.
One thing I did notice, was she repeated a few times about not patronizing adult learners, but Chapter 11 "Secret Handshakes" came across pretty patronizingly. The idea being good learning designers should know the theory behind learning design - seems reasonable. But then she talks to you as though you'll only learn about theory with moaning and groaning! If you're reading her book, you're probably interested in the theory; if your job is around helping other learn their best, you probably have at least some interest in how people learn. I found that a bit offputting at the end - she needed to take her own advice, and trust that I'm an adult reading this (the last 20 pages even!) because I want to be.
The end of the book also provides some suggested resources to go looking for, which I am grateful for. I think I just expected a little more from the book than it gave. As a truly, accidental instructional designer, I wanted a bit more oomph to help me really get started.
“While my wish for you is that you don't become the CBT Lady, my even greater wish is that you, too, never stop being a happy accident.”