I was unfortunately very disappointed with Heavenbreaker. The premise itself is somewhat interesting and I enjoyed the SciFi-Fantasy genre mix (it is not romantasy at all, I have no idea why this novel is tagged as romantasy); however, I struggled with Wolf’s writing throughout the entire novel for four reasons:
First, the novel itself would have benefited significantly with a prologue instead of thrusting the reader directly into the middle of an active plot line. The opening scene is our protagonist Synali having just murdered her father moments ago. It’s an odd place to start the novel and it was poorly executed because the adrenaline and high of the character's actions weren't really introduced or capitalized on in the first few chapters. Because of this, there was less room for upfront context-setting that really would have helped with the readers’ confusion about what the f just happened, because Wolf doesn’t properly explain it at all (or at least not soon enough to mitigate readers’ confusion). This made for a pretty bad first impression and rough start to the book.
Second, world-building and imagery is so crucial in establishing immersion for readers, especially for SciFi and Fantasy books. Wolf’s writing had a severe lack of context, descriptive imagery, and placed too heavy of a burden on readers to “fill in the blanks” with their own imagination. This is somewhat difficult for readers to do because Heavenbreaker has medieval, futuristic, ritualistic elements all intertwined. These contrasting themes can make it challenging for readers to know what to picture, and I personally wish Wolf did a better job taking the time to build this world more thoroughly and providing us with more vivid imagery. What especially irritated me is that the writing felt lazy in this aspect. Rather than explicitly say what is happening, Wolf repeatedly just uses single words, something like “Black. Darkness. Falling. Pain.” This might have cool impact once or twice but she does this so. Much. It feels like lazy writing because I would much rather have complete sentences.
Third, WE GET IT. Synali is angry. Unfortunately, we as readers are not at all invested in her success, nor do we share her hatred for the nobles because, as I mentioned previously, we didn’t follow any of her storyline until the damage was already done and she had already killed her father. All we have as readers to go off of is Synali’s narration, which is not effective alone. A bunch of “I’ll kill every damn one of them”s is not enough to convince a reader to feel the anger with the character. We need to experience the events, observe the wrongdoings, and actually witness the consequences. Again, a prologue would have helped.
Lastly, Wolf’s narration and writing of Synali’s character was weak because rather than explore the complexities of the value she places on her own life, she instead just repeatedly hammers on the point of “I hate nobles.” This was so inconsistent however, because on one hand, Synali wants to destroy her father’s house, yet she also wants to die. Pick one, or explain the internal conflict better. There was such a huge missed opportunity here to continue the kamikaze-esque mentality of fighting until the dying breath and letting it consume your life in the process (an actual fascinating nugget of psyche the author only briefly touches upon). I would have loved to continue seeing an exploration of what it means to fight knowing that you will die, that you will not observe any benefits of a victory, what it will mean for the survivors / next generation, what the fine line is between the sense self-preservation in order to last in an active battle versus the sense of accepting your own demise. More importantly, what are the pieces of life and humanity that stand out to Synali and make her see value in living outside of just a desire for revenge. If Wolf was going to make being suicidal such a big unique character trait, I need to see it used more effectively or for it to have a more positive-trending character development.
I won’t be continuing the series but it was nice to have a refreshing novel that incorporates both SciFi and Fantasy themes well. Execution could have been better, but this is fully just my own opinion.