Two kids, two bikes, and an idea they can change their world.
It’s 2077. There’s no apocalypse, but some things are different. Things like the weather, the internet, and food. In twelve-year-old Clare’s world, blueberry is just a flavor and apples are found only in fairy tales.
Then one day Clare meets an old woman who teaches her about seeds and real food. The woman (Ana) tempts Clare with the notion that food exists other than the square, processed, packaged food she has always known. Under Ana’s tutelage, Clare and her friends learn about seeds and gardening despite suspicions that such actions are illegal.
When the authorities discover the children’s forbidden tomato plant and arrest their mother, Clare and her brother flee. Clare has heard of a place called "The Garden State," and with their bikes, a little money, and backpacks, the children begin a lonely cross-country journey that tests them both physically and spiritually. Will they succeed in their quest to find a place of food freedom? And can they, only children, help change the world?
Treasure is a gentle dystopian, frightening only is the possibility that we may not be far from the future it paints.
This author also writes under the pen name Sandra Smith.
S. Smith grew up on a farm with a tremendously large garden. Though she lives in the city now, her love of growing vegetables and flowers endures. Her first published series, Seed Savers, was born from this desire to plant each spring.
A licensed ESL (English as a Second Language) teacher, Ms. Smith has enjoyed teaching students from around the world.
She gardens and writes at her home in the beautiful and green Pacific Northwest.
The first four books of the Seed Savers series are currently available: Treasure, Lily, Heirloom, and Keeper, as well a Christmas short story featuring Lily and Arturo.
The entire concept of the Seed Savers series is a bit chilling, primarily because, as the publisher's blurb states, it paints a future we can easily see coming our way. But the story itself is not edge-of-the-seat frightening, and would be suitable for most children of 9-12. Clare is a likable heroine, and if she and her little brother get along a bit unbelievably well, they have good reason to stick together, especially once they are on the run.
I found the beginning of the story a little slow. It takes time for Clare, Dante and their friend Lily to learn about the whole idea of seeds and growing plants, which is understandable, but the story might do better to move more quickly through this. For me, the story takes hold when the food police (as it were) arrest Clare & Dante's mother and the kids flee. Their view of the world has been pretty circumscribed, not just with regard to food, and we see them growing and expanding as their world does. I can't help liking that they make their escape to Canada by bicycle, nor do I miss that the heavy guard the border carries is to keep people IN the US, not out.
One thing which made me a little uncomfortable was the use of religion in the story. I kind of get it, but it doesn't seem necessary to have them be religious, nor does it seem necessary to the story to focus so on prayer and scripture (well, maybe the latter makes some sense, because it is partly the Bible's agrarian roots that sabotage the efforts to make everyone forget where food comes from; this works because while the government controls science education, they have apparently chosen to leave religion alone, a plausible development in today's world). I might like to see a more overt consideration of the implications of religion, not as a means for the children to pray and make things okay, but as something which seems to be simultaneously a controlling tool of the government--and the source of the rebellion. That might be asking a bit much of a children's book, though!
Recommendation: This book and its premise are (pardon me) food for thought that everyone should consider. Those whose children are not Christian may need to talk about the religious aspects, but that doesn't seem so bad either (everyone should be willing to read about people of other religions). And everyone, of whatever age, would do well to ask themselves where their food comes from--and in the case of the vast bulk of processed foods in our stores, what it might be made of.
Claire (12) and Dante (7) are a sister and brother duo who live in a futuristic society where gardening is prohibited. The Green Resource Investigation Machine (GRIM) is the corporation in charge of policing the distribution and use of seeds. In fact, GRIM has been so effective in its job that even the language around seeds, planting, and gardening has been erased from the collective memory of society. In this society, nutrients and vitamins are distributed in tablet form instead, creating a complete disconnect between food and their point of origin.
There exists an underground movement known as the “Seed Savers” who are intent on keeping the knowledge alive and who collect and protect seeds from various vegetables and fruits. Claire, Dante, and their friend Lily meet Ana, a seed saver, who secretly teaches them about gardening and who gives them a few precious seeds. But when GRIM discovers their ruse, they confiscate their plants, imprison their mother, and the children flee, undertaking a dangerous cross-country trek, enlisting the help of seed savers along the way, until they reach safety in Canada(!).
I absolutely love the concept behind this book. In this future, dystopian world, there is no need to worry about post-apocalyptic warfare and violence. The problem is much more subtle in this original and clever story. Imagine a world where growing your own food is against the law! Seed Savers is an attempt to think through what would happen if people had no idea where their food comes from, the nutrients from food are only available in pills, and one corporation “owns” and controls all of the seeds. Ummm… Hello?! Do we realize how close we actually are to this reality? That’s what makes this book so brilliant.
The author cleverly integrates real events (changing the names of the corporations involved) to pinpoint where the decline in society began. For example, she discusses how some fictional corporations [*cough, cough* starts with "M" and rhymes with "ponsanto" *cough, cough*] created genetically modified seeds that are drought, insect, and disease resistant but that are also “terminator seeds” (the plant does not produce seeds). Hmmm… so how does a farmer plant next year’s crops? I guess they have to purchase the seeds all over again. That’s a real money maker! And, then there is the issue with cross-pollination occurring with neighboring fields who do not use GMO seeds. See the problem there?
Ok, I have to say it … This is me expressing my absolute outrage at a certain corporation being awarded the 2013 World Food Prize. The purpose of this prize is to recognize “…the achievements of individuals who have advanced human development by improving the quality, quantity or availability of food in the world.” Grrr….
I think this story is an important one because it is quite conceivable that we are heading toward a society such as the one described in Seed Savers. I thought there was a great collection of characters with the two main characters Clare and Dante; Ana, their mysterious mentor; and the other seed savers they meet along the way. I do feel that Lily, Clare and Dante’s friend, abruptly exits the story and that felt a bit awkward. The second book in the series, Seed Savers: Lily focuses on her story so perhaps this will be clarified.
One final note is that there is a religious theme woven through the story. Clare, Dane, and Lily secretly meet Ana under the guise of Bible Study and I felt that this was a convenient and believable cover story. However, there are several prayers and passages from the Bible that are quoted throughout the story. There is even one point at the very end when Clare and Dante are terrified of being caught and Dante quotes “Even though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil, for thou art with me.” I felt that these passages from the Bible were out of place with the story and, frankly, I think the story would have flowed better without them.
My bottom line:
I loved the concept behind this story and the themes covered in this book. Seed Savers presents a frighteningly real dystopian society where gardening is forbidden and corporations control food production and distribution exclusively. I think there are important lessons contained in this story and I highly recommend this book for tweens and teens who enjoy reading the dystopian genre and who are looking for a non-violent and thought-provoking story. Ages 9+.
*** This book was provided to us free-of-charge by the author in exchange for an honest review. All opinions expressed are my own. ***
This is a Middle Grade SciFi book about gardening. Actually it is about escape from totalitarian regimes and a return to fresh food and freedom of choice to grow it, but on the surface it is just about 12 year old Clare, her seven year old brother Dante and their friends Lily (same age as Clare) and Ana, who is substantially older – kind of my age. Their adventure is about growing food – in secret.
Seed Savers is what I believe in. In S Smith’s world, food choice has long gone, since the corporate agribusinesses managed to hoodwink governments into belief in factory farming on a national scale, using genetically modifed crops. Furthermore it has prohibited the preservation of biodiversity and natural selection in food plants that keeps us with robust strains likely to adapt to climate change and weather patterns, pests and diseases, and, most importantly, enable people to save their seeds year after year to provide for the future. Ana, a volunteer at the after-school club at the church, is dedicated to passing her seed-saving knowledge on to the next generation. and resorts to using passages from the Bible as a good method of teaching people that have never heard of fruit or vegetables, since all their food comes in blocks of goodness (hmmph) from Stores. The Bible has many references to stewardship of the land and saving seeds, and God providing the fruits for people to use (the Koran seems to be good on Allah providing fruits, too) and religion, or at least church attendance, is still encouraged in this world.
S Smith outlines these societal changes as we meet the people who rebel, still, against the consequences of these disastrous government actions. She writes it in an engaging and gripping style. I made myself put the book down a third of the way through, to take a breather, since I was scared of what was going to happen. Then I couldn’t wait to pick it up again, and I finished it in one sitting.
In Clare and Dante we have beautifully crafted characters, and Dante just keeps pulling out surprises as he has wisdom beyond his years – or maybe he just gains it through their journey.
It’s a story in three parts – Clare, Dante and Lily discovering about plants through Ana’s covert teaching; the escape into another grim society, and the journey to another, freer place. I was hooked into all three parts. It’s a lovely story with lots of bright ideas from the kids and twists and turns in the adventure.
Everyone should read this book. Especially if they aren’t sure how the food in their stores comes to be there. I’m looking forward to the next in the series.
A book with a cast of diverse characters importing real life lessons for children! Yes! Sign me up for the whole series please! A dystopian novel featuring teens that doesn't require romance to stand up on it's own two feet, sign me up twice.
It's the future but an uncomfortably near future. Growing your own food is banned and it only took a generation for people to forget how to plant things and to convince children that food only comes from a store but... There is a gentle rebellion happening though, no not a bunch of teenagers fighting to the death or dragons descending from the sky... but a rebellion of knowledge and in knowing your history. There are many parallels to present day here for readers but as each person might see or feel a different one, I'll leave those to be discovered by you.
In the very near future nearly everything is GMO, comes from a can and no one would know what to do with a sunflower seed if you spit it at them. Flavors don't exist as much more than a superfluous title for food colored mush. A few children have a chance encounter and their lives change. The story follows Clare, her brother and their friend Lily as they are allowed into an underground insurgence of seed savers and plant growers. It is a crime to have seeds in this world and Clare has been given a small envelope full of them and the knowledge needed to make them blossom into something world changing.
The children learn about plants, how to grow them, the patience and skill it takes for some and lack of skill for others. When the government agents come knocking Clare takes her brother on the run, where they learn the strength they have in themselves and show remarkable independence.
This is a great book series for middle age readers and garden lovers alike. There is diverse cast of children included, race, religion, socioeconomic backgrounds... and it's just like that, the characters exist as themselves without beating you over the head with "look this character is Christian and this one is Jewish" and I think the soft subtle differences help encourage young minds (subliminally) to be accepting - because people are different.
I will seek out the other books in this series and read 'em even if they aren't here for review, that's how much I like 'em. I'll go out and buy them.
**A free copy of this book was provided by the author in exchange for an honest review.**
This is going to be a difficult review to write, because while I noticed some flaws in the book, it was a quick, fun read.
I'll start with what I liked. First, I think that this would be a nice dystopian for someone who would like to read something from this genre, but wants a tamer, non-violent story. The dystopian society is lighter than many of the societies in other dystopian books; it's not too different from today, except that it is now illegal to grow food. Some people have chosen to rebel, however, and are known as 'seed savers.' So I think this would appeal to many people, younger readers in particular.
Second, the book moved quickly and didn't drag on unecessarily. The beginning of the book actually seemed to move a bit too quickly, but it slows down to a reasonable pace later.
There are a couple things that I wasn't a big fan of, though. At times, the conversations in the book felt a bit stilted; again, I noticed this mainly at the beginning, but it happened ocassionally throughout the whole book.
And I wish the characters had been a little more developed; I didn't really feel a connection with them; I got to know Clare and Dante a little bit more towards the end of the story, but I still felt that they were a bit undeveloped.
Lastly, there were a few typos, but they weren't very prominent and didn't keep me from enjoying the story. Honestly, I didn't notice them all that much; maybe three times at the very most. I just thought I should mention it.
All in all, three stars for a quick read that could use some fine-tuning.
In a not too distant future, gardening and growing your own food has become illegal. Real food has been replaced by "carbs", "proteins", "sweets" and "snacks" and come in either square or round packages. The food is nutrient poor and unhealthy. Children know nothing of seeds or that food actually comes from plants.
Twelve year old Clara meets an older woman named Anna, a "seed saver". Clara, her brother Dante and their friend Lily are educated by Anna about seeds and risk growing their own plants. When a tomato plant is discovered, Clara's mother is arrested and Clara and Dante flee.
Treasure: Seed Savers can be enjoyed by people of all ages, not just the young. There was an educational aspect but it is also a cautionary tale about the future of our food production. There already exists much controversy regarding GMO's and many are opposed to their use. I really enjoyed listening to Treasure: Seed Savers and the narration was well done, each character having a distinct voice. I would recommend this.
I was voluntarily provided this review copy audiobook at no charge by the author, publisher and/or narrator. This review is my honest opinion.
Seed Savers - Treasure by Sandra Smith is a sort of Dystopian middle grade story that struck me by its particularity. In a world where food as we know it is forbidden and doesn't exist, some children discover the existence of seeds, a woman named Ana will instruct them about them and together they will study the products that plants and trees can produce, trought Bible and experiences that come from the past.
A plot that apparently may not be interesting, turns out to be a real lesson for the little ones. What better way to make them acquire new knowledge, if not a book that doesn't force them to study but only to pay attention to a story? I liked the writing style very much, a simple English and suitable for the public to whom the book is aimed.
I just finished listening to this marvelous dystopian story of a world in which real food has become replaced with squares of processed foods and it is illegal to grow plants. Not quite Soylent Green but GMO has taken over.
Although the target audience is listed as 9-12, this excellent cautionary tale should be read by anyone concerned about the future of fresh food; but for kids it is a great adventure with the hidden agenda of teaching about plants and fruits and even a bit of geography.
Treasure by S. smith was a great Read. The year is 2077 and the world is much different than we know today. Food is not like we know today and a young girl named Clare finds seed savers. Although it's against the law to grow your own food, Clare decides to. I really enjoyed this book
*I was given the opportunity to review this book as part of Multicultural Children's Book Day.*
I found Treasure (Seed Savers, #1) to be quite delightful! It is a Juvenile Fiction book for ages 10 and up. Clare, Dante, and Lily live in a world where gardening by civilians has been outlawed; anyone who does is jailed or possibly worse. With the help of Ana (a caring adult who secretly gardens in her home), the children learn all about plants, seeds, fruits, and vegetables. Soon the local officials catch on forcing Clare and Dante on a dangerous quest to find a free gardening world. Sadly, they opt to live Lily behind due to time and for her own safety. While traveling, the children rely on their faith in God and help from strangers. I couldn't help but smile at parts and highly recommend!
Multicultural Children’s Book Day 2019 (1/25/19) is in its 6th year and was founded by Valarie Budayr from Jump Into A Book and Mia Wenjen from PragmaticMom. Our mission is to raise awareness of the ongoing need to include kids’ books that celebrate diversity in home and school bookshelves while also working diligently to get more of these types of books into the hands of young readers, parents and educators.
We’d like to also give a shout-out to MCBD’s impressive CoHost Team who not only hosts the book review link-up on celebration day, but who also works tirelessly to spread the word of this event. View our CoHosts: http://multiculturalchildrensbookday....
TWITTER PARTY Sponsored by Make A Way Media: MCBD’s super-popular (and crazy-fun) annual Twitter Party will be held 1/27/19 at 9:00pm. E.S.T.
Join the conversation and win one of 12 five book bundles and one Grand Prize Book Bundle (12 books) that will be given away at the party!
S. Smith in her new book, “Treasure” Book One in the Seed Savers series published by CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform gives us a fast-paced future thriller.
From the back cover: It’s 2077. There’s no apocalypse, but some things are different. Things like the weather, the internet, and food. In twelve-year-old Clare’s world, blueberry is just a flavor and apples are found only in fairy tales.
One day Clare meets Ana, who teaches her about seeds and real food, despite suspicions that such actions are illegal.
When the authorities discover the children’s forbidden tomato plant and arrest their mother, Clare and her brother flee. Clare has heard of a place called “The Garden State,” and with their bikes, a little money, and backpacks, the children begin a lonely cross-country journey that tests them both physically and spiritually.
Will they succeed in their quest to find a place of food freedom? And can they, only children, help change the world?
It is the future and we didn’t blow ourselves up, were taken over by intelligent apes or under control of a one-world leader instead we did something even worse. We have prohibited growing our own fruits and vegetables. The Green Resource Investigation Machine (GRIM) is the corporation in charge of policing the distribution and use of seeds. In fact, GRIM has been so effective in its job that even the language around seeds, planting, and gardening has been erased from the collective memory of society. However, there are those who remember the past and make it their mission to ensure it’s not forgotten, they are part of a secret group known as The Seed Savers. Their work is dangerous, but if they succeed children can once again experience the delicious tastes and healthy benefits of homegrown unprocessed food. Ms. Smith has provided us with a highly complicated plot. Clare, Dante, and Lily are interesting characters that develop and become more interesting as the story goes on. “Treasure” is loaded with twists and turns that will leave you guessing all the while you are flipping pages to find out what happens next. Ms. Smith has provided us with a fairly exciting book and well worth the read.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from Book Tours & Blasts. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255: “Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.”
I am finding this series enthralling. As a child this is something that would have appealed to me. As adults reading children's books we tend to forget the lure of adventure seen through a child's eyes.
Treasure; Seed Savers series #1; is a dystopian novel set in America in the not-too-distant future; mid-to-late 21st century (references to historical events within the story have led me to this conclusion). Food comes in pre-packaged forms. It arrives at Stores by Delivery Truck, and is referred to as Protein, Sweeties, Vitees, Carbos, and Snacks. The majority of people do not have refrigerator's because their food is GMO produced and full of preservatives; no need to worry about shelf life. "The old way of growing, selling, and preserving food was inefficient and cumbersome...It wasn't economical, practical, or safe." GRIM (Green Resource Investigation Machine) is a government agency which keeps track of subversive elements working against official food policy's. These subversive groups are made up of anarchists, environmentalists, and seed savers.
Clare first hears of "seeds" in church, and soon she, her brother Dante, and best friend Lily are being tutored by Ana, an elderly seed saver. Seed Savers are an underground group dedicated to saving and preserving non-GMO seeds for food growth. At first Clare is captivated by the adventure and mystery of something so unusual as food that does not come from round or square pre-packaged containers, but she quickly decides that seed saving is worth the risk. Then her mother is jailed and Clare and her brother run away, rather than reveling the true identity of their friend Ana. Clare and Dante travel by night, trying to stay out of sight from their pursuer, a man from GRIM. Along the way they learn how to seek out other Seed Saver's, as well as facing hunger, rain, and a harrowing escape within city limits. There is safety to be found north, in Canada. Will Clare and Dante make it across the border on their own?
This book is so appealing in all aspects for a child. As an adult reading it we might question the choices Clare, Dante, and Lily make, but a child will see the adventure and understand the children's quest. A cautionary tale, too; this is the story of what could easily be on the road to happening here in America. I will be purchasing this for my school library - thank you to author Sandra Smith for the advance copy!
In today’s worries over climate change and genetically modified foods, this book is very appropriate. Set in the near future, all home gardening is classified as illegal and food seems to come in some kind of pill form or chewable tablet at least. Everything edible is known as a sweetie, snack, protein or veggie and they are all square or round. Children think all food originates in the store.
When Clare, her brother Dante and their friend Lila meet an old lady named Ana who becomes their tutor and teaches them about seeds and gardening, a whole new world opens up to them. But when Clare’s mother is arrested for an illegal tomato plant found in their home, Dante and Clare take off in hopes of finding a place where growing food is not illegal.
Fleeing north towards Canada tests them mentally, physically and spiritually. With only their backpacks, a few provisions and their wits, they need to be especially careful of who they talk to as the authorities are looking for two runaways.
There are several twists and turns in this novel that adds some moderate suspenseful moments, but nothing too extreme for the middle-grade age category. It is an excellent adventure shared by two siblings.
I liked the educational aspect of Treasure. A lot of information about seeds and how plants grow from seeds was given. I found it quite interesting that most of that information can actually be found in the bible.
I liked the characters of Clare and Dante. I found them to be very endearing and courageous. I did think it was a little bit strange that they were willing to leave their mother behind and run away in order to find a place where they could grow food at their young ages of about 12 and 7, but depending on how much society has changed by then, perhaps it is possible that this was important enough to them.
I enjoyed Treasure. I think it’s quite a suitable book for any middle-grade child. I gave the book 4 stars out of 5.
Thank you to the author for providing a copy of the book in exchange for a fair and honest review. A positive opinion was not required. All thoughts are my own.
Treasure is an inspiring middle grade novel that takes readers on a journey into the future where fresh foods are nonexistent and people survive on packaged processed food. However, there are those who remember the past and make it their mission to ensure it's not forgotten, they are part of a secret group known as The Seed Savers. Their work is dangerous, but if they succeed children can once again experience the delicious tastes and healthy benefits of homegrown unprocessed food.
When Clare, Dante, and Lily meet Ana they discover she is a seed saver. Eager to learn all Ana has to teach them the children beginning meeting with Ana at the church. Through books and seed samples she empowers them with knowledge. Ana encourages the children to secretly plant tomatoes and carrots so they can experience the miracle for themselves. The children must be very careful because growing your own food is considered a crime and the GRIM agents already seem to be suspicious. Ana is uneasy about GRIM's increasing presence and the group decides to end their meetings. Ana's uneasiness proves to be right as Clare and Dante return home to discover their mother and tomato plant missing. Determined to find a place where people are free to grow their own food Clare and Dante flee to the north. Will the two be successful on their dangerous journey?
With the current popularity of the dystopian genre, Treasure is a wonderful book for children. There is no violence, zombies, or deadly plaque which can sometimes be too scary, in my opinion, for kids. There is however plenty of action with a dangerous quest and characters willing to risk everything to change the world for the better. I feel the book is well organized and flows easily with likable characters. The rich plot is original and thought-provoking. I had no trouble believing the story could one day become a reality as processed food increases its presence in our society. The children's adventurous trek and the captivating storyline will appeal to middle graders.
What would you do if you lived in a world where it was illegal to plant seeds and grow your own food?
Clare, Dante and Lily live in a society where the government controls the food found on the grocery store shelves. Its packaged in square boxes supposedly filled with vitamins and nutrients. Backyard gardens were no longer in existence and any plant life in a home was just for looks and didn’t produce any fruits or vegetables. Clare, Dante and Lily don’t know about food producing plants or seeds, but they are learning about seeds and planting with bible verses and hands on from Ana, an older woman from their church. Ana belonged to a secret society that saved, stored and shared their seeds with each other. They called themselves the Seed Savers. Ana taught the children how scientist created biotec plants and how large corporations and the government now played a role in how they get food.
As the children learn about seeds and growing food, they are also aware they could be in big trouble if they were caught saving and planting seeds. The Green Resource Investigation Machine (GRIM) is always watching. And they were being watched. Clare and Dante knew they were in trouble when Lily didn’t show up to church one Sunday. They made a plan to go to the Garden State (Canada) to learn more and left their home and mom behind taking their books and seeds with them. What will the two seed savers find on their journey and will GRIM be waiting?
Author Sandra Smith has created a wonderful trilogy of adventure and faith. This fast-paced read is engaging, and readers will find themselves rooting for the characters. For young readers who love gardening this book is a special treat. Parents and teachers can use this as a tool to get kids thinking about what they eat, how it’s grown and even how they can start planting a garden of their own.
The three kiddos brought into this secret organization (the Seed Savers) of sorts are very brave and courageous…but as the story progresses they grow to be even more so. It’s not enough to defy the powers that be, you have to affect a change. Through their efforts, their sacrifices, their hard work and determination even at their young age, they are ushering in change. Even though this is only book 1 and there is much more to come, the simple acts and choices made here are bringing hope to those who’ve been waiting for a turn around for a very long time.
Can children change the future…you ask? YOU BET. The young, the old, the somewhere-in-between, we all have an impact on the world that surrounds us, but it’s up to us what that lasting impression is.
Whether you’re a big supporter of ecological causes or usually a passenger on the ride of life, this is a book with a message you can get behind. Let it empower you. Let it remind you of your own innate power. Let it encourage you to make meal time family time with a home cooked meal utilizing all the fresh goodness available to you, when the opportunity presents itself…or better still, MAKE an opportunity; life is only so long you know, gotta make it count.
A book aimed at Middle Grade readers that’s good for one and all. It does feature some scripture as Ana utilizes the “good book” to help train the kiddos up in the facts of life (nature’s abundance and what not) and as a diversion for any GRIM folks lurking about.
**review copy received in exchange for my honest review...full post can be seen on my site**
(I received a free copy of this book in exchange for a review).
(This review may contain spoilers).
This was a book that reminded me of books I used to read as a child. Even though I read a lot of grown-up books then, I enjoyed reading books aimed at my own age as well and they still have a special place in my heart.
I really liked the concept behind this book, especially since it's something I could easily see developing in reality. I especially liked the use of the Bible as a learning tool and the whole idea of Seed Savers.
I found the three main characters really easy to empathise with and I felt that their attitudes and actions really fit with their ages, as well as what they could do.
Probably unsurprisingly, I also really liked the religious aspects and use of prayer through this book. I also particularly liked the sense of community the Seed Savers had and how they helped the other characters.
It was really interesting to see seeds and their properties explained to the children, even if I felt that there were a couple of contradictory parts and that not all of the build-up was fully explored. Although there was quite a lot of explanation going on, I liked how it was handled and felt that the action later on worked really well.
I do have the next two books on my Kindle and definitely intend to read them soon. If you like this kind of genre, I think this is worth reading. It's written fairly simply, but it's a nice, easy read where the characters have true relationships and faith.
What would it be like if the government controlled all of our food sources? Twelve-year-old Clare, her seven-year-old brother Dante and Clare's best friend Lily grow up in a time when they don't know where there meals come from, other than trucks or stores. Owning, buying and planting all seeds are illegal and if GRIM caught you breaking this law, you'll be fined or jailed.
Clare, Dante and Lily meet Ana, an elderly woman who is a member of a secret society, The Seed Savers. She covertly teaches the kids about seeds and how these seeds can make food. Just as the children begin growing their own plants, Clare and Dante's mother is arrested by GRIM and their treasured tomato plant is confiscated. Clare and Dante now know it's time to seek out other Seed Savers and the great unknown.
I loved this darling, clever, family-friendly adventure. And the adventure doesn't stop there. "Treasure" is the first book in a Seed Saver series that could easily develop a child's interest in gardening while following the daring quests of Clare and Dante. As a Garden State native and gardener, I realize the importance of learning horticulture and agriculture. It's a lovely, gratifying hobby or profession that can last a lifetime. As for the adventure, well, I'm on to the second book entitled "Lily." I have to find out what happens to Clare's mom and her best friend!
Thanks so much to Sandra Smith for this beautifully written, wonderful read from a Twitter giveaway, Al Monte
One day, Clare brought back these things called seeds to her brother, Dante, and her best friend, Lily. She got them from Ana, a friend from church. Ana starts to teach them fruits, and vegetables, and what seeds do. They soon learn that saving seeds and growing your own food is illegal in the U.S.A. The only food allowed is the kinds you get from Stores. They decide to secretly become Seed Savers with the help of Ana. When the government finds out what Clare and Dante are doing, the kids flee to Canada with the help of other Seed Savers across the country. They think growing food in Canada is legal because it isn't part of the US. Can the kids get to Canada before they get caught by the government??
This was an interesting book. I like dystopian books where something "wrong/bad" has happened. In this book, it's an evil government that wants to control the food of their country. "Seed Savers" was really good. I like the character of Clare. She was really smart. Dante seemed like he should be 14 or 15 not seven, but he was still a good character. I think the cover art is cool. This was a good reading level for me. The story was involved and it read well. The plot was pretty unique. I like how the setting seemed to be some-what in the future. I also liked reading about the types of food they have (like "Sweeties"). I recommend this book to kids 9+.
NOTE - I got a free copy of this book in exchange for a fair review
Scary. But with all that's going on in the world today, seems like it just might be probable... I think it could be used as a classroom book for kids 4th grade up, particularly schools with botany or garden programs. Food worries and baffles me a good deal these days. I have noticed for about 30 years that kids are getting disconnected from the farm. Maybe more community gardens are needed. Anyway, briefly, I liked the characters of Clare, Dante, Lily, and Ana. They were likable and well developed. The plot sounds somewhat like what we are beginning to live- at least to me. Foods are become a source of conflict- gluten free, almond milk, artificial stuff, whole-grain, processed foods on one hand, heirloom veggies on the other... soaring obesity rate and food allergies...So much conflicting information... This story is set in the not too distant future, so kids reading it today, may well be living it someday. Read it and maybe get educated in preventing this future. Thoughtful and well written dystopian story.
I received a Kindle ARC from Netgalley in exchange for a fair review.
Recently some writer friends of mine were discussing the fact that often children nowadays do not know where their food comes from. Panicked, I asked my 5 year old where a few items of food came from, and he answered correctly, however my 4 year old thought that milk came from the supermarket and that they made carrots there!
Just goes to show how lucky we are to be able to just buy our food, washed, prepared and ready to cook and eat.
Claire, Dante and Lily however live in a world where their food comes in block form, labelled as protein and vits, and seeds and growing food is forbidden and to them, an alien concept till they meet a woman with seeds and a bible.
As they learn about their ancestors and their food, the government are closing in on their infractions of the rules.
This book is a stunning effort, and a great YA/children's book. When my children are a little older, I shall be sharing this book with them.
I love the plot idea, and although the book is a little slow in places, it is very well written.
I received this book free in return for an honest review.
The Good...
This was very fast read. In fact, I finished it in one afternoon, which, imho, means this would be the perfect length for younger readers. I also loved that the kids in the story weren't dumbed down, but neither were they "gritty." The use of scripture in the story was spare enough to feel necessary, yet used often enough to mark the book as Christian. Along with that is level of teaching. I feel that any young person who picks this book up will naturally pick up on the wonder of growing food.
The Not-so-good...
While the level of teaching is high in this book, there were a few places where the story was bogged down by information overload. However, those were few and did not make me want to put the book down and walk away.
The Overall...
Seed Savers: Treasure by S. Smith was a wonderful read that I plan to share with my science-loving, question-asking daughter and would highly recommend to other parents.
This simply-written story is an adventure story about lots of big ideas! Middle grade dystopia strikes again!
12-year-old Clare discovers the existence of seeds in a world where growing your own vegetables is a crime. A teacher brings forbidden knowledge about plants into after-school homework help--using Bible verses to smuggle in basic botany. Tomatoes and peaches? This is the first time the children have ever heard of them. They've only ever eaten Protein, Sweeties, Vitees, Carbos, and Snacks. But now they are the ones who have to bring an important stash of vegetable seeds to safety in the North.
The power of this story is in the world-building: sometimes I wondered about something a character did or said, but I could always believe in this story world. It was a little surprising to have a world where the Bible wasn't banned, but seeds were. I had no trouble believing that such a world could exist.
Thought-provoking, clearly written, and a good book for discussions about all kinds of topics.
Well written with a story that could actually be true someday in this crazy crazy world. This story also has plenty of lessons to be learned while reading. The Seed Savers are a group of people that refuse to let farming go the way of the wind. They do not want over processed flavorless items that people now call food. It takes the courage of a girl and her little brother to take on the world of the seed savers and start showing some need for such things. Where will it take them and will they get caught? What about family and friends? This story is a bit on the religious side and does tell of many religions and there various natures, it does not take one stand and stick directly to it. It is a great read for any age!!!!
.E.R.F.E.C.T !! A dystopian novel, full of mystery, adventure and sacrifice. What is unique thing about this, the characters are teens!! No need romance to make the adventure more interest. What you need is to follow their trace using their bike to go to a safe place for them to grow their plant. The saddest thing, when they have to protect all those seeds from GRIM. What a brilliant way to educate teens how to protect nature for the best future.
Claire and Dante learn how wonderful and important growing a garden is. Unfortunately growing your food is illegal. This book is a great first book in the seed savers series. What a delight! My grandson enjoyed reading about Claire and Dante and the lessons they learn. He was anxious to read more of the series to see what happens. We had read this book when it first came out. We went on to read the whole series!
This is the kind of story that I wish I had written. It has adventure, education, and mystery. Claire and her brother, Dante, learn all about seeds and "real food" in this futuristic tale where gardens are illegal and people are arrested for growing their own food. I will most definitely read the rest of the series!
Set in the future, food production has been completely taken over by the government, and growing backyard gardens is forbidden. An elderly woman named Ana begins to teach 3 kids the secrets of fresh food -- but that leads to trouble.
I enjoyed this book. I think it would be good for middle grade readers, especially the ones who are concerned about environmental issues.
I really enjoyed getting to learn what life would be like if we didn't have fruits or vegetables of any kind. It was so shocking to find out about GRIM and the food police. It also makes me appreciate fresh fruits and vegetables that much more.