What do you think?
Rate this book
Evil-ish
A disillusioned teen dreams of fame and villainy in this hilarious and heartfelt young adult fantasy graphic novel from debut author/illustrator Kennedy Tarrell.
Hawthorne Vandercast has big plans: join the infamous Brigade of Shade, move into a glamorous castle, and leave their mundane life as a potion barista behind. But when they finally get the chance to join the Brigade, Hawthorne finds themself overshadowed by Maple, a bubbly, bright, flowery girl who could not look further from evil. After an accident ends in death and suddenly Hawthorne is leading the Brigade, they begin to realize that maybe villainy isn't actually all it's cracked up to be.
Evil-ish spins the classic tropes of good and evil on their heads in a hilarious and tender story about a teenager who feels bigger than their job, their town, and their circumstances...and finds out that what they thought they wanted might not be what they actually need.
Hawthorne Vandercast has big plans: join the infamous Brigade of Shade, move into a glamorous castle, and leave their mundane life as a potion barista behind. But when they finally get the chance to join the Brigade, Hawthorne finds themself overshadowed by Maple, a bubbly, bright, flowery girl who could not look further from evil. After an accident ends in death and suddenly Hawthorne is leading the Brigade, they begin to realize that maybe villainy isn't actually all it's cracked up to be.
Evil-ish spins the classic tropes of good and evil on their heads in a hilarious and tender story about a teenager who feels bigger than their job, their town, and their circumstances...and finds out that what they thought they wanted might not be what they actually need.
208 pages, Hardcover
First published July 22, 2025
7 people are currently reading
533 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 162 reviews
March 31, 2025
A YA graphic novel about a young person who dreams of joining a notoriously evil and powerful group, despite being not as evil as they think themselves to be. An accident results in their acceptance into the group, but things aren't quite what they expected...
This was an entertaining portrait of teen angst with a non-binary main character, though I was left wanting more from the story. It's wrapped up a little too neatly and doesn't get as deep into the subject matter as I might have liked. But it was still fun and the artwork is excellent. I received a copy of this book for review via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
This was an entertaining portrait of teen angst with a non-binary main character, though I was left wanting more from the story. It's wrapped up a little too neatly and doesn't get as deep into the subject matter as I might have liked. But it was still fun and the artwork is excellent. I received a copy of this book for review via NetGalley, all opinions are my own.
April 20, 2025
firstly, thank you to the publisher for an arc!
3.5 stars
evil-ish stars our nonbinary mc hawthorne and their goal to become part of the brigade of shade, a villainous group of evil baddies. but when an accidental death forces hawthorne to become the leader of the brigade of shade, they realize villainy is not all it’s cracked up to be.
my biggest issue with the plot was hawthorne’s reasoning to join the brigade of shade: they had no real reason to join an evil organization (perhaps outside of teenage angst…) so it felt kind of flimsy…
the art style was super unique!
3.5 stars
evil-ish stars our nonbinary mc hawthorne and their goal to become part of the brigade of shade, a villainous group of evil baddies. but when an accidental death forces hawthorne to become the leader of the brigade of shade, they realize villainy is not all it’s cracked up to be.
my biggest issue with the plot was hawthorne’s reasoning to join the brigade of shade: they had no real reason to join an evil organization (perhaps outside of teenage angst…) so it felt kind of flimsy…
the art style was super unique!
November 10, 2025
This was fun. Relatively short (as many graphic novels are) and therefore the plot went very quickly but it was fairly solid and enjoyable. It was funny at times and serious at others (mostly on the humorous side) which I also always appreciate. I liked the art and how it was mostly realistic with some room for creative whimsy.
As I said it was short and simple, so I don’t have a lot to say, but it definitely succeeded in its goal of being a fun story and an enjoyable read. I would recommend this, especially if you can find it at your library like I did (I hate to say this but although I love reading graphic novels I cant see myself ever buying one; I read them far too fast!)
As I said it was short and simple, so I don’t have a lot to say, but it definitely succeeded in its goal of being a fun story and an enjoyable read. I would recommend this, especially if you can find it at your library like I did (I hate to say this but although I love reading graphic novels I cant see myself ever buying one; I read them far too fast!)
October 23, 2025
I found the story predictable (think Nimona without all the jokes) but the main character was very challenging to root for.
What elevated the book and made it worth finishing was the art style. So I'd be interested to read something from them again in future once they've honed more of their storytelling craft.
What elevated the book and made it worth finishing was the art style. So I'd be interested to read something from them again in future once they've honed more of their storytelling craft.
January 27, 2025
We all know the feeling of not belonging. Well, maybe not ALL of us, but the people that know that feeling, should definitely pick up Evil-ish. It’s all about finding your place in the world, even when it isn’t where you thought it would be.
Hawthorne has dreamt of joining the Brigade of Shade their whole life. Being evil is all they’ve been able to imagine: idolizing the villains and wishing to be by their side. The stories of the dissent they sowed and the places they’ve been are the stuff of legend. So when they put out a flier saying they are accepting applications, it’s finally time!
But then they don’t get in. And yet Maple, the bubbly girl who sings to birds and looks nothing like your typical villain, does.
As Hawthorne is lying in their room, crying over what should have been, Maple shows up to offer help at asking for a second chance. Which, of course, goes terribly wrong and the leader of the Brigade ends up dead… leaving Hawthorne their new leader.
This was delightfully fun and full of queer characters. I mean, there are 2 nonbinary characters and I imagine Hawthorne and Maple becoming a thing somewhere down the line, so even though it’s not fuuuuuuuuuully canon, it is in my head. I love Hawthorne’s growth throughout the story and how they may not have fit in with the town they live in, they just needed some coaxing and a little evil to show them the way.
My favorite part/character of the story was Hawthorne’s mom giving them an apron that said Mx. Manager on it. She asked around for the correct thing to say on it so that they would feel properly represented. It’s that extra step of caring and affection that really show a parent’s love and devotion to their child. I wish more parents were like fictional ones.💜Every queer kid needs this kind of love.
Hawthorne has dreamt of joining the Brigade of Shade their whole life. Being evil is all they’ve been able to imagine: idolizing the villains and wishing to be by their side. The stories of the dissent they sowed and the places they’ve been are the stuff of legend. So when they put out a flier saying they are accepting applications, it’s finally time!
But then they don’t get in. And yet Maple, the bubbly girl who sings to birds and looks nothing like your typical villain, does.
As Hawthorne is lying in their room, crying over what should have been, Maple shows up to offer help at asking for a second chance. Which, of course, goes terribly wrong and the leader of the Brigade ends up dead… leaving Hawthorne their new leader.
This was delightfully fun and full of queer characters. I mean, there are 2 nonbinary characters and I imagine Hawthorne and Maple becoming a thing somewhere down the line, so even though it’s not fuuuuuuuuuully canon, it is in my head. I love Hawthorne’s growth throughout the story and how they may not have fit in with the town they live in, they just needed some coaxing and a little evil to show them the way.
My favorite part/character of the story was Hawthorne’s mom giving them an apron that said Mx. Manager on it. She asked around for the correct thing to say on it so that they would feel properly represented. It’s that extra step of caring and affection that really show a parent’s love and devotion to their child. I wish more parents were like fictional ones.💜Every queer kid needs this kind of love.
July 26, 2025
A cute and vivid graphic novel I've read in one sitting.
Hawthorne is a non-binary teenager who feels they don't fit in, life is a chore and they're destined for bigger things - like joining the local villain's entourage! But neither joining nor leading the gang will be as easy and glamorous as Hawthorne dreamed, and their self-confidence will be sorely tested.
In the end, it's a humbling tale about false first impressions, and that chasing "fun" means being saddled with the negative consequences of it. It also conveys a positive message about the power of friendship and supportive community.
This is marketed as YA, but I'd say it fits for MG readers too. It's very short and fast paced, the illustrations are very dynamic, there's nothing drastic shown but mostly implied, big problems are surprisingly easily solved, it focuses on friendship, and the main characters' behaviour with worshipping their idols and throwing fits resembles a 12-14yo.
I would recommend this for reluctant readers of upper MG and younger YA age bracket who want a quick, easy to absorb story.
I loved the diverse characters: mc is non-binary, there's a Black side character and another side character who is a butch-presenting woman. There's also another non-binary character who mc idolizes.
Thank you Netgalley, Macmillan Children's Publishing Group and Feiwel & Friends for the ARC! It's the first time I'm approved for a graphic novel / comic outside of "Read Now" titles, so I'm double grateful for this one!
Hawthorne is a non-binary teenager who feels they don't fit in, life is a chore and they're destined for bigger things - like joining the local villain's entourage! But neither joining nor leading the gang will be as easy and glamorous as Hawthorne dreamed, and their self-confidence will be sorely tested.
In the end, it's a humbling tale about false first impressions, and that chasing "fun" means being saddled with the negative consequences of it. It also conveys a positive message about the power of friendship and supportive community.
This is marketed as YA, but I'd say it fits for MG readers too. It's very short and fast paced, the illustrations are very dynamic, there's nothing drastic shown but mostly implied, big problems are surprisingly easily solved, it focuses on friendship, and the main characters' behaviour with worshipping their idols and throwing fits resembles a 12-14yo.
I would recommend this for reluctant readers of upper MG and younger YA age bracket who want a quick, easy to absorb story.
I loved the diverse characters: mc is non-binary, there's a Black side character and another side character who is a butch-presenting woman. There's also another non-binary character who mc idolizes.
Thank you Netgalley, Macmillan Children's Publishing Group and Feiwel & Friends for the ARC! It's the first time I'm approved for a graphic novel / comic outside of "Read Now" titles, so I'm double grateful for this one!
January 23, 2025
I received an eARC of this book through NetGalley.
Super cute villainous graphic novel with a twist. The exposition of the first few pages was a little confusing to me, but once I met Hawthorne, I loved it.
Super cute villainous graphic novel with a twist. The exposition of the first few pages was a little confusing to me, but once I met Hawthorne, I loved it.
February 24, 2025
this was a cute graphic novel !! very cool to have a nonbinary protagonist whos arc doesn't revolve around coming out, or facing discrimination, or even romance --- although at the very end there are perhaps some romantic vibes? maybe? up to interpretation really
i don't think the cover is very representative of the story --- there were a BUNCH of panels that i thought would work better. i love hawthorne and their evil ambitions anyway though! and maple :((( she reminds me of nimona in a way, i think if youve read/watched nimona you'll definitely see what i mean.
recommend! check this out if you want something fast but impactful
i don't think the cover is very representative of the story --- there were a BUNCH of panels that i thought would work better. i love hawthorne and their evil ambitions anyway though! and maple :((( she reminds me of nimona in a way, i think if youve read/watched nimona you'll definitely see what i mean.
recommend! check this out if you want something fast but impactful
July 7, 2025
This graphic novel is soooo fun!!! I adore the art style and overall aesthetic!! The characters and dialogue are a delight and Hawthorne is so gender. I'll definitely be rereading aswell!! I won't spoil, but The ending is also very heartwarming and adorable!! I guess I wish it was longer/got more volumes but it's still a great read! (3.5 rounded up to 4) Ty netgalley for allowing me to read this :3 (cross-posted review on netgalley)
March 5, 2025
Hawthorn, a non-binary youth who has wanted to be in the evil Brigade of Shade ever since they can remember. They don’t have super powers, or anything, but isn't it enough to want to be evil? They certainly don’t want to keep working at their mom’s potion shop, selling drinks to the people of town.
So, they go to the audition, and don’t get in, because, well, they don’t have any powers. But then, Mapel, who has powers, says, why not go back and plead your case. So, they go to the do just that, and the leader of the Bridgade of Shade is killed and Hawthorne has to take her place.
But is that what happened? And how can someone without powers lead an evil group. And what sort of evil do they want to do?
Fun look at what happens when good people want to do bad, because it looks cool, and then realize, perhaps it isn’t all it is supposed to be.
Kept me reading, to find out how it would all resolve, and what was the deal with Maple.
This book was a lot of fun. I loved the tropes of what was evil, and how the villagers delt with it.
This book will be published on the 22nd of July 2025. Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review.
So, they go to the audition, and don’t get in, because, well, they don’t have any powers. But then, Mapel, who has powers, says, why not go back and plead your case. So, they go to the do just that, and the leader of the Bridgade of Shade is killed and Hawthorne has to take her place.
But is that what happened? And how can someone without powers lead an evil group. And what sort of evil do they want to do?
Fun look at what happens when good people want to do bad, because it looks cool, and then realize, perhaps it isn’t all it is supposed to be.
Kept me reading, to find out how it would all resolve, and what was the deal with Maple.
This book was a lot of fun. I loved the tropes of what was evil, and how the villagers delt with it.
This book will be published on the 22nd of July 2025. Thanks to Netgalley for making this book available for an honest review.
April 3, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
PG-PG-13 (dark themes, grief, tragedy, but nothing particularly inappropriate for older kids/teens/kids at heart)
A wonderfully emotive color palate and art style instantly caught my eye before I even read the synopsis. Came for the art, stayed for the plot.
I’m sure everyone can read a book synopsis themselves, so I’ll keep it brief:
Young potion brewer barista Hawthorne struggles to feel accepted and is convinced they’ll be part of a society far too rigid for their tastes. Doomed to a boring, unseen life. Until the coolest evil brigade in all the land sends out recruitment flyers that is! Hawthorne leaps at the opportunity with all the passion in their (presumably) dark heart.
But, when a teensy mistake finds Hawthorne the new leader of all things evil, they find maybe being a villain isn’t as simple as they thought. After all, how can a real villain just be evil-“ish”?
Overall, I enjoyed the experience, but wished for more character depth out of most of the cast. The ending made sense, but was rushed. Still, I’d happily read any further adventures of Hawthorne, Maple, and co.
Thanks to Netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
PG-PG-13 (dark themes, grief, tragedy, but nothing particularly inappropriate for older kids/teens/kids at heart)
A wonderfully emotive color palate and art style instantly caught my eye before I even read the synopsis. Came for the art, stayed for the plot.
I’m sure everyone can read a book synopsis themselves, so I’ll keep it brief:
Young potion brewer barista Hawthorne struggles to feel accepted and is convinced they’ll be part of a society far too rigid for their tastes. Doomed to a boring, unseen life. Until the coolest evil brigade in all the land sends out recruitment flyers that is! Hawthorne leaps at the opportunity with all the passion in their (presumably) dark heart.
But, when a teensy mistake finds Hawthorne the new leader of all things evil, they find maybe being a villain isn’t as simple as they thought. After all, how can a real villain just be evil-“ish”?
Overall, I enjoyed the experience, but wished for more character depth out of most of the cast. The ending made sense, but was rushed. Still, I’d happily read any further adventures of Hawthorne, Maple, and co.
Thanks to Netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for an honest review.
December 28, 2025
There's nothing more punk rock than actively helping your community become a healthier place for everyone in it! This graphic novel had Nimona vibes (with less chaos) and a relatable main character who follows the very human, very teen impulse to hate the things they feel they don't fit in to. I do wish we got an actual look at why Hawthorne felt like they didn't belong- though who in this world hasn't gone through a point where you're sure you don't- and I think we could have seen more when it comes to them showing they actually care about community & the town, but graphic novels always have to speed run a bit. I was also expecting more to play off of the stereotypes of what evil looks like, and was a little disappointed to not see any real analysis of it in story. All in all, though, these characters are really fun to watch, the art is great, and the message is an important one.
October 2, 2025
It’s pretty, but not quite specific enough in the crucial action scenes. Overall, felt a bit surface level. But, props for inclusive characters and broad message.
April 20, 2025
Hawthorne has worshipped the Brigade of Shade for as long as they can remember, as a self-proclaimed evil doer who has never fit in, they are determined to be the next member at the Brigades audition. Unfortunately, they fail miserably and are laughed out of the audition, and with Maple the bubbly, flower crown wearing, singing to animals, annoying new girl from around town gets in well thats just insult to injury, however, when Maple shows up one night and tells Hawthorne she's got a sure fire way to get her in Hawthorne decides they've got nothing to lose.
This was a hilarious and yup absolutely adorable read about finding yourself but also being honest with yourself. Hawthorne is truly the least evil person on the planet, and once they start putting forth their "evil initiatives," that becomes fairly obvious (even though it pretty much is from the get-go). Well, okay, a laundry is actually evil, so that's maybe their most evil initiative. But that's as far as it goes. Their "attacks" on the town are nothing more than harmless pranks that delight the townspeople more than anything, giving them a little bit of entertainment in an otherwise mundane life. What makes this head towards the serious side is how Hawthorne's mom always knew this about them and can't find the right way to express this to Hawthorne. It's a classic parent/child dilemma.
It takes Maple's incredibly painful backstory for Hawthorne to see what it truly means to have no one actually see *you* and I loved how Tarrell uses this to show that without a guiding hand it is so easy for trauma and pain to become anger and resentment.
The art was wonderful as well. Hawthorne, especially, I find almost embodies the very idea of non-binary, Hawthorne was they/them before you even knew Hawthorne was they/them simply by the way they were drawn.
Highly recommend this one for a quick and fun read about learning to be true to yourself.
As always thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Children's Publish Group for the eArc!
This was a hilarious and yup absolutely adorable read about finding yourself but also being honest with yourself. Hawthorne is truly the least evil person on the planet, and once they start putting forth their "evil initiatives," that becomes fairly obvious (even though it pretty much is from the get-go). Well, okay, a laundry is actually evil, so that's maybe their most evil initiative. But that's as far as it goes. Their "attacks" on the town are nothing more than harmless pranks that delight the townspeople more than anything, giving them a little bit of entertainment in an otherwise mundane life. What makes this head towards the serious side is how Hawthorne's mom always knew this about them and can't find the right way to express this to Hawthorne. It's a classic parent/child dilemma.
It takes Maple's incredibly painful backstory for Hawthorne to see what it truly means to have no one actually see *you* and I loved how Tarrell uses this to show that without a guiding hand it is so easy for trauma and pain to become anger and resentment.
The art was wonderful as well. Hawthorne, especially, I find almost embodies the very idea of non-binary, Hawthorne was they/them before you even knew Hawthorne was they/them simply by the way they were drawn.
Highly recommend this one for a quick and fun read about learning to be true to yourself.
As always thanks to NetGalley and Macmillan Children's Publish Group for the eArc!
April 22, 2025
Where can I even start with this book? With all the villain-ish whimsy, queer rep and thoughtful examinations of evil that made Nimona an all-time favorite, yet an altogether different premise and set of characters, I had a feeling I was going to love this one, and I absolutely did.
The art here is just so much fun. Tarrell nails every beat and image in this story with their wacky, colorful, ever-detailed art, and I couldn’t resist racing through its pages.
I also adore the characters. Hawthorne is absolutely a favorite—their determined, irreverent personality sparks across every page, and the utter enthusiasm they have for all things villainy made me fall in love with them from the start. While I could call out any number of other characters here—and indeed, all of them deserve it, especially Hawthorne’s family! —I have to enthuse a little specifically about Maple. Tarrell narrates her character arc with dazzling precision, every panel and detail of color accentuating how much she doesn’t seem to belong in a world of villainy, and yet how much it ultimately fits her.
But this isn’t just a story about villainy. Hawthorne’s reckoning with what they actually want from their life, what evil really is, and how they want to interact with the world around them propels forward a story as much about hope and being true to yourself as a well-placed maniacal cackle. I truly can’t recommend Evil-Ish enough, particularly to readers who always find themselves taking a second look at the villain!
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review! All opinions are my own.
The art here is just so much fun. Tarrell nails every beat and image in this story with their wacky, colorful, ever-detailed art, and I couldn’t resist racing through its pages.
I also adore the characters. Hawthorne is absolutely a favorite—their determined, irreverent personality sparks across every page, and the utter enthusiasm they have for all things villainy made me fall in love with them from the start. While I could call out any number of other characters here—and indeed, all of them deserve it, especially Hawthorne’s family! —I have to enthuse a little specifically about Maple. Tarrell narrates her character arc with dazzling precision, every panel and detail of color accentuating how much she doesn’t seem to belong in a world of villainy, and yet how much it ultimately fits her.
But this isn’t just a story about villainy. Hawthorne’s reckoning with what they actually want from their life, what evil really is, and how they want to interact with the world around them propels forward a story as much about hope and being true to yourself as a well-placed maniacal cackle. I truly can’t recommend Evil-Ish enough, particularly to readers who always find themselves taking a second look at the villain!
Thank you to the publisher and NetGalley for providing an e-ARC in exchange for an honest review! All opinions are my own.
September 12, 2025
If you were a fan of Neomia, be sure to pick up Evil-ish. Our non-binary main character Hawthorn wants nothing but to work for the Brigade of Shade, (i.e. the evil in town). But there was a very chirpy, happy girl that wants to join the brigade as well, because it’s the evil doers that are the popular ones. Hawthorn eventually gets their wish and does their version of evil. When another character is true evil comes out, it’s up to Hawthorne to realize that evil doesn’t make the world better. Everything works together as an ecosystem. That anybody can come back from being evil. This book was not only fun. It was heartfelt. There is this overarching message that when someone hurt you, you can come back from it. You’ll have down and bleak times. Times when you just want to destroy everything around you. But if you take the chance, you can come back and find happiness. I loved everything about this book between the artwork, the storyline, and all of it. This book is appropriate middle grade and up and I think I would have fun sharing it with those even younger because it’s a great message.
August 14, 2025
Evil-ish
This was a super cute graphic novel that I picked up on a whim that takes place in a magical world where there is this group called the Brigade of Shade, which kind of just wreaks havoc on the town. We follow a teen named Hawthorne who has dreamed of joining the brigade but is forced to help their mom run the town tavern. But Hawthorne has bigger dreams! They try to audition but fail pretty miserably. Meanwhile, a girl named Maple, who has pretty strong powers (she like grows nature really fast from what I gathered??) auditions and gets in, which frustrates Hawthorne because Maple is also like generally a pretty sweet girl so Hawthorne doesn’t think she deserves to be there. Hawthorne goes to talk to the leader of the brigade directly and accidentally kills her, which makes them the de facto leader. It’s fun at first, but then Hawthorne starts to feel bad about the destruction, especially with the safety of their mom and brother. Meanwhile, Maple embraces the evil and takes it to the extreme. But maple just has a sad backstory and eventually gives in and releases her powers and she turns into a tree. Hawthorne is celebrated for saving the town and later when Maple returns the two of them look like they’re going to fall in love. It was a sweet story and never gets that dark and is mostly lighthearted with some great rep. And great art!
This was a super cute graphic novel that I picked up on a whim that takes place in a magical world where there is this group called the Brigade of Shade, which kind of just wreaks havoc on the town. We follow a teen named Hawthorne who has dreamed of joining the brigade but is forced to help their mom run the town tavern. But Hawthorne has bigger dreams! They try to audition but fail pretty miserably. Meanwhile, a girl named Maple, who has pretty strong powers (she like grows nature really fast from what I gathered??) auditions and gets in, which frustrates Hawthorne because Maple is also like generally a pretty sweet girl so Hawthorne doesn’t think she deserves to be there. Hawthorne goes to talk to the leader of the brigade directly and accidentally kills her, which makes them the de facto leader. It’s fun at first, but then Hawthorne starts to feel bad about the destruction, especially with the safety of their mom and brother. Meanwhile, Maple embraces the evil and takes it to the extreme. But maple just has a sad backstory and eventually gives in and releases her powers and she turns into a tree. Hawthorne is celebrated for saving the town and later when Maple returns the two of them look like they’re going to fall in love. It was a sweet story and never gets that dark and is mostly lighthearted with some great rep. And great art!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 17, 2025
Evil-ish is a feel good whimsical fantasy graphic novel that will leave you feeling joyful and refreshed. I loved this! It was so fun and the art was beautifully done!
We meet Hawthorne, a non-binary teen in a small fantasy town that is home to the Brigade of Shade, a well-known group of villains who live in a castle. All Hawthorne wants is to join the Brigade and have a life different from their current position at their family's Potion's café. After a random incident they somehow get to lead the Brigade which leads to a whole lot of shenanigans. I loved the character development in this story and watching Hawthrone grow into themselves.
If you love graphic novels, queer representation, and happy endings with beautiful art I absolutely recommend this graphic novel! I loved it! Thank you to the publisher for providing an advance copy via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
We meet Hawthorne, a non-binary teen in a small fantasy town that is home to the Brigade of Shade, a well-known group of villains who live in a castle. All Hawthorne wants is to join the Brigade and have a life different from their current position at their family's Potion's café. After a random incident they somehow get to lead the Brigade which leads to a whole lot of shenanigans. I loved the character development in this story and watching Hawthrone grow into themselves.
If you love graphic novels, queer representation, and happy endings with beautiful art I absolutely recommend this graphic novel! I loved it! Thank you to the publisher for providing an advance copy via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
January 18, 2025
I usually wait to read a book until closer to its publishing date, but this sweet graphic novel called for me to read it the moment I was approved!
Hawthorne lives above their family's potion/tea shop in a small town. But they have big dreams of joining the Brigade of Shade, a band of evils who wreak havoc on the town. When they show up at the open call for new Brigade members, Hawthorne meets Maple, the most unlikely, cheeriest of candidates. Together, they accidentally find themselves in charge of the Brigade, and must learn what it means to be good and evil, and how to live with the consequences of your choices.
This artwork captured my attention. The vivid use of color set the mood in each panel. I particularly liked Hawthorne's character design.
I'm hoping there's more coming in this series.
I received this ARC from @netgalley and publisher @macmillanusa. The opinions are my own.
Evil-ish will be released on July 22, 2025.
Hawthorne lives above their family's potion/tea shop in a small town. But they have big dreams of joining the Brigade of Shade, a band of evils who wreak havoc on the town. When they show up at the open call for new Brigade members, Hawthorne meets Maple, the most unlikely, cheeriest of candidates. Together, they accidentally find themselves in charge of the Brigade, and must learn what it means to be good and evil, and how to live with the consequences of your choices.
This artwork captured my attention. The vivid use of color set the mood in each panel. I particularly liked Hawthorne's character design.
I'm hoping there's more coming in this series.
I received this ARC from @netgalley and publisher @macmillanusa. The opinions are my own.
Evil-ish will be released on July 22, 2025.
December 9, 2024
Thank you to the publisher for this free eARC! All opinions are my own.
Hawthorne dreams of joining the Brigade of Shade and being evil away from their stifling life as a potions barista at their mom's shop. Unfortunately, they are overshadowed by Maple, a decidedly not evil young woman with plant powers. An accident leads to Hawthorne becoming the leader of the Brigade, but maybe they aren't as evil as they thought they wanted to be... Sometimes, all someone wants is to feel like they belong. #NetGalley #Evil-ish
Hawthorne dreams of joining the Brigade of Shade and being evil away from their stifling life as a potions barista at their mom's shop. Unfortunately, they are overshadowed by Maple, a decidedly not evil young woman with plant powers. An accident leads to Hawthorne becoming the leader of the Brigade, but maybe they aren't as evil as they thought they wanted to be... Sometimes, all someone wants is to feel like they belong. #NetGalley #Evil-ish
April 8, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and the publishers for this ARC in exchange for my honest review!!
This was such a sweet little graphic novel. I loved the colors and art a lot. Hawthorne seemed like a spoiled brat in the beginning but the character development was well done. I also really liked Maple. Her character design was so cute. This story had such a heartwarming turn to it and I’m looking forward to more from this creator!
This was such a sweet little graphic novel. I loved the colors and art a lot. Hawthorne seemed like a spoiled brat in the beginning but the character development was well done. I also really liked Maple. Her character design was so cute. This story had such a heartwarming turn to it and I’m looking forward to more from this creator!
April 8, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley and the publishers for this ARC.
This was such a cute, fun read! I really enjoyed the art style and the use of color. I really liked Maple and Hawthorne as characters. I appreciated the character development that we got to see from them as the story progresses.
This was such a cute, fun read! I really enjoyed the art style and the use of color. I really liked Maple and Hawthorne as characters. I appreciated the character development that we got to see from them as the story progresses.
July 10, 2025
This was a fun graphic novel, the best part was the art. I loved the art and the color palette it was vibrant and fun. The main character was also great, I loved their style and wanting to be evil even though they were not evil at all. The part where I got a bit lost was the story, it needed a bit more development and more information/dialogue to be more impactful for me. It was a fun quick read with lovely art but it left me wanting a tad more to be more memorable.
I received an eARC thanks to Netgalley and Feiwel & Friends. All opinions are my own.
I received an eARC thanks to Netgalley and Feiwel & Friends. All opinions are my own.
September 6, 2025
This was cute. I really liked the drawing style. The characters and backgrounds were drawn in such an aesthetically pleasing way. The storyline got a tiny bit confusing here and there throughout the book, but besides that, I liked it. I think it has a sweet moral that kids can benefit from.
April 19, 2025
A story about thinking you know what you want vs. finding out what you need.
Such a great story with awesome characters. Loved the story and the lesson in here.
Such a great story with awesome characters. Loved the story and the lesson in here.
December 10, 2025
this is a graphic novel about a non-binary teenager who wants to be evil and enters this competition/ running to join this evil group. it's a little wild and a little funny and super queer.
January 29, 2025
*I received an advanced copy via Netgalley. My thoughts are my own*
This was okay. It has some good but overall, it was just okay.
Good:
While the character art wasn't my favorite, I did really enjoy the aesthetic. And I'll always be amazed at people's skills. I also thought the idea was cute.
What didn't resonante with me:
The characters. I just didn't understand Hawthorne's character. His wanting to be "evil" but he just wanted to be a prank bro instead. It just didn't really make sense why he was the way he was and his evolving was very flat.
Some of the scene jumps were just too much. It went really quickly from one scene to the next in the middle which made me feel a little whiplashed.
Recommended audience:
I think this will do great for the intended audience, more of the younger side of the spectrum. While this does have some redeeming qualities - I think there was a lot more for the wanting.
But I loved Maple. She was the best character from start to finish.
This was okay. It has some good but overall, it was just okay.
Good:
While the character art wasn't my favorite, I did really enjoy the aesthetic. And I'll always be amazed at people's skills. I also thought the idea was cute.
What didn't resonante with me:
The characters. I just didn't understand Hawthorne's character. His wanting to be "evil" but he just wanted to be a prank bro instead. It just didn't really make sense why he was the way he was and his evolving was very flat.
Some of the scene jumps were just too much. It went really quickly from one scene to the next in the middle which made me feel a little whiplashed.
Recommended audience:
I think this will do great for the intended audience, more of the younger side of the spectrum. While this does have some redeeming qualities - I think there was a lot more for the wanting.
But I loved Maple. She was the best character from start to finish.
September 6, 2025
Teen angst in a fantasy world. Main character Hawthorne idolizes and wants to join the Brigade of Evil. Why? I really don't know, and this is the biggest weakness of the book. I never quite understood why Hawthorne thought they were evil, why they wanted to join the Brigade, or what they thought they would do once they got there. They mention several times that they just don't feel like they belong, but I don't know why they felt that way. I kind of think that may have been the point. Hawthorne is attempting to rebel for nebulous teenage reasons, but their heart just isn't in it. I think teen readers will have an easier time identifying with that.
January 20, 2025
This was the most delightful YA graphic novel, and such a treat to read! I can definitely tell Tarrell's background is in animation, because this gave Disney vibes in the best way possible! The world of Idlewood is one that feels lived-in and fully imagined, and the art is an absolute dream. I was hooked from the first page.
Evil-ish centers on Hawthorne, a disillusioned potion barista who dreams of bigger things--namely, joining the evil Brigade of Shade that rules their town. The only problem is that tryouts are full of hopefuls, all with powers of their own. Hawthorne doesn't have powers, but they have a killer style, a sharp wit, and a big dream. But that's not enough. When they fail miserably at their audition, a surprising friend gives them a second chance, and they stumble their way into the Brigade. But is Hawthorne evil enough for the team they always dreamed of...and is evil really what they want to be?
I literally could not put down this graphic novel. It felt cinematic and cozy, and I adored the detail put into every panel. The character designs are great, from Hawthorne's slick, spiky style, to friend Maple's Disney princess charm. The members of the Brigade all felt distinct, too, with Dredimer being my favorite. I really enjoyed how Hawthorne and Dredimer's gender was never used as a plot point--they are both nonbinary, and that's normalized and accepted. It felt kind of like Owl House or She-Ra in that regard; queernormative, gender-normative, etc, and I think it's so important for teens to have media like that. I loved that Hawthorne had such a wonderful family, and I liked how the Brigade supported each other. Positive vibes all the way around! I also liked the messaging here: Hawthorne's idea of "evil" is more angsty outcast who wants to cause some mischief, and when confronted with true evil they understand where their values lie. Tarrell also explores the idea that hurt people hurt people, and how to stop that cycle, which I think is also important messaging.
I do wish, as some other reviewers stated, that there had been a bit more fleshed out motive for both Hawthorne and Maple, Hawthorne in particular. The plot moves so fast, which is not a bad thing, but I felt that I never understood Hawthorne's reason for wanting to join the Brigade so badly. I WAS that "too cool for this town" angsty teenager, so I totally get that not wanting to work at their mom's potion shop could be motive enough, or perhaps the fact that the Brigade has an absolutely enviable aesthetic. But I'm largely extracting that from my own teenage years, and less from what's on the page itself.
Many thanks to NetGalley, Feiwel and Friends, and Kennedy Tarrell for gifting me this e-ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!
Evil-ish centers on Hawthorne, a disillusioned potion barista who dreams of bigger things--namely, joining the evil Brigade of Shade that rules their town. The only problem is that tryouts are full of hopefuls, all with powers of their own. Hawthorne doesn't have powers, but they have a killer style, a sharp wit, and a big dream. But that's not enough. When they fail miserably at their audition, a surprising friend gives them a second chance, and they stumble their way into the Brigade. But is Hawthorne evil enough for the team they always dreamed of...and is evil really what they want to be?
I literally could not put down this graphic novel. It felt cinematic and cozy, and I adored the detail put into every panel. The character designs are great, from Hawthorne's slick, spiky style, to friend Maple's Disney princess charm. The members of the Brigade all felt distinct, too, with Dredimer being my favorite. I really enjoyed how Hawthorne and Dredimer's gender was never used as a plot point--they are both nonbinary, and that's normalized and accepted. It felt kind of like Owl House or She-Ra in that regard; queernormative, gender-normative, etc, and I think it's so important for teens to have media like that. I loved that Hawthorne had such a wonderful family, and I liked how the Brigade supported each other. Positive vibes all the way around! I also liked the messaging here: Hawthorne's idea of "evil" is more angsty outcast who wants to cause some mischief, and when confronted with true evil they understand where their values lie. Tarrell also explores the idea that hurt people hurt people, and how to stop that cycle, which I think is also important messaging.
I do wish, as some other reviewers stated, that there had been a bit more fleshed out motive for both Hawthorne and Maple, Hawthorne in particular. The plot moves so fast, which is not a bad thing, but I felt that I never understood Hawthorne's reason for wanting to join the Brigade so badly. I WAS that "too cool for this town" angsty teenager, so I totally get that not wanting to work at their mom's potion shop could be motive enough, or perhaps the fact that the Brigade has an absolutely enviable aesthetic. But I'm largely extracting that from my own teenage years, and less from what's on the page itself.
Many thanks to NetGalley, Feiwel and Friends, and Kennedy Tarrell for gifting me this e-ARC in exchange for my honest opinion!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 162 reviews