This was the most ambitious, masterfully plotted of the author's innovative mysteries. The Appeal and Twyford Code fans should be delighted with Janice Hallett's new book. Told in her unique style, the narration consists of emails(often with added emojis), text messages, chats on WhatsApp and Facetime, pages torn novels and screenplays relevant to the case, newspaper clippings, handwritten notes, and transcripts of recorded conversations in person or by phone. I was drawn in and entertained from the beginning and impressed by how brilliantly the author built a complex plot with well-developed characters using the mixed media format. This is Hallett's most ambitious and complicated novel.
The story is told through files researched and collected by true crime novelist Amanda Bailey. Many have been transcribed by her intelligent assistant, Ellie Cooper. Ellie adds comments to these transcripts in brackets or by sticky notes with her thoughts, advice and humour.
Amanda hopes to tie all her research into a new crime novel about the Alperton Angels told from a new perspective. The time is the present, and the Alperton Angel case occurred 20 years ago, in 2003. The Alperton Angels were a small cult led by the charismatic and manipulative Gabriel. His followers were led to believe that they were angels. With the end of days approaching, their duty was to sacrifice a baby he termed the Antichrist. The teenage 'mother' Holly escaped with a young man and the baby; their whereabouts are unknown. In the aftermath of the 'devil child's disappearance, the remaining followers were reported to have committed suicide, and their bodies were displayed in a ritualistic fashion. The number found dead at the scene was disputed.
Several books and screenplays had been based on the events. The missing baby is now approaching their 18th birthday. If Amanda can find the young person, it would be a coup, adding interest and publicity for her book. She also wants to interview Gabriel, now serving time in prison.
This witty, clever, and multi-layered plot is a dark story relieved by touches of humour. Amanda is compelled to work with a rival author, Oliver Menzies, who is also writing a book about the Angel's case for a different publisher. Amanda was deeply hurt by him in the past but decides to cooperate. They agree to focus on different aspects of the case for their upcoming books. Amanda is considered the better reporter, but Oliver has better connections. Oliver publishes in a newspaper some of Amanda's work and a photograph she took. He is not embarrassed or apologetic for his deception and manages to get an interview with Gabriel. He refuses to share anything regarding this interview with Amanda. Oliver seems to have fallen under Gabriel's spell and is becoming obsessed with supernatural spirits, angels, demons, and the Antichrist. People are concerned about his break from reality, but Amanda insists he will snap out of it.
As the two journalists gather information for their books, they face contradictory evidence, baffling twists, and dead ends. For example, the number of deceased cult members after Holly escaped with the baby, the existence of satanic symbols at the death scene, a member brandishing a knife, and the more outlandish recollection that the teenage Holly escaped Gabriel's clutches in the early 1990s instead of 2003. There were also differences in reports of what police and social workers were present at the time of the Alperton deaths. Several people already interviewed or soon to be questioned have died. Is there a conspiracy, and are Amanda and Oliver in danger?
The discrepancies in evidence could be due to memory lapses after twenty years, deliberate lies, or a conspiracy to cover up what really happened, but what could the motive be? The truth is darker and stranger than one could imagine. Recommended!