Okay, so I'm clearly in the minority here because the reviews for this book are great. Warning, there will be spoilers for the entire book in my review, so if you don't want to see them, back away now!
That said, I struggled with several elements of the book. In general I'm not a fan of second chance romance, but this one felt even more frustrating because the reason things didn't work out in the past was due to a misunderstanding. Instead of one character asking the other about what they saw, they just stopped talking and became enemies for the next 15 years?? That is so stupid to me. I'm thinking okay, I'll chalk it up to them being 14, they are so young and haven't learned communication skills yet.
Welp, low and behold, they haven't learned them at 32 either. This might sound petty, but I can't stand when characters have something happen in their past and then decide they are going to blame every single one of their negative traits on that one event. Look, I get that the past can be traumatic, but Logan decided that her mom leaving her and her dad meant that no one would ever stick around for her, so instead of even TRYING, she sleeps around and never commits to avoid (what she thinks is) the inevitable, and having her partner leave her. This leaves a trail or hurt feelings in her wake, but no matter, it's all about her. Instead of going to therapy and trying to better herself, she just decided it gave her a pass to be uncaring to the people around her. I actually couldn't stand Logan for most of the book. I really struggled to feel empathy for her because she felt so immature for someone who is supposed to be 32. So much of the "conflict" between Logan and Rosemary was based on assumptions made by both of them, and that's frustrating as a reader. I love a good enemies to lovers romance, but it didn't feel like that either. I didn't feel any tension, angst, or sexual build up between them so it felt like there was no chemistry between them at all. Nit picking again, every time Logan wanted to curse, she'd use a queer celebrity name, like "Megan fucking Rapino" and it happened so many times and to me it felt cringy.
Secondly, this might just be a me thing because it's totally real life, BUT I could not get in the romance vibe when they were constantly talking about their smelly sweaty armpits, swamp ass, farting, burping, stains on clothes, breath that smells bad because they were just eating something, stepping in literal human poop, comparing one of the love interest's mount to a "cat's puckered asshole" several times, etc. I know> that in real life these are things that happen, but I kind of want the rose colored glasses in my romance books - I don't want to think about the bodily functions that are unpleasant, it kills the mood for me lol
Third, I mentioned a little bit above, but I felt no chemistry between the characters. I don't think there was enough detail about their past to see any feelings there either that might bleed into adulthood, it just felt like we were told about their feelings and not shown. Even the scenes where they were "together" felt kind of forced and awkward. I didn't buy into the love story. What I DID like was that in the one (mild) sex scene, Logan was very clear in making sure there was enthusiastic consent, especially knowing this was Rosemary's first time being intimate with anyone. She checked in with her several times to make sure she was still comfortable and consenting, and I did appreciate that element.
Lastly, on the plus side, I did love Joe and his story with Remy was so heartbreaking and wholesome at the same time. His dog Odysseus was adorable too. Joe's story was sad, and I was getting misty-eyed at the end, but I did really like how his part of the story came to a close.
Overall, I think this was a case of me just not being the right reader for this book. You can see tons of positive reviews for it, but I wanted to share my hangups with it in case you are similar to me!