What do you think?
Rate this book
Jane Smith #2
Hard to Kill
Jane Smith is being hailed as James Patterson’s greatest character yet, a tough-as-nails attorney up against a relentless killer. Hard to Kill features possibly the author’s most stunning twist ever.
Attorney Jane Smith is mounting an impossible criminal defense.
Her client, Rob Jacobson, is the unluckiest of the unlucky. No sooner is he accused of killing a family of three in the Hamptons than a second family is gunned down.
It’s not double jeopardy. It’s not double murder. It’s double triple homicide.
Jane’s career has spanned from NYPD beat cop to Hamptons courtroom. She’s tough to beat. She’s even tougher to kill.
The defense may never rest.
Attorney Jane Smith is mounting an impossible criminal defense.
Her client, Rob Jacobson, is the unluckiest of the unlucky. No sooner is he accused of killing a family of three in the Hamptons than a second family is gunned down.
It’s not double jeopardy. It’s not double murder. It’s double triple homicide.
Jane’s career has spanned from NYPD beat cop to Hamptons courtroom. She’s tough to beat. She’s even tougher to kill.
The defense may never rest.
384 pages, Hardcover
First published July 29, 2024
4811 people are currently reading
10324 people want to read
About the author
James Patterson
958 books356k followersOfficial US Site
Official UK Site
JIMMY Patterson Books
ReadKiddoRead
James Patterson is the most popular storyteller of our time and the creator of such unforgettable characters and series as Alex Cross, the Women’s Murder Club, Jane Smith, and Maximum Ride. He has coauthored #1 bestselling novels with Bill Clinton, Dolly Parton, and Michael Crichton, as well as collaborated on #1 bestselling nonfiction, including The Idaho Four, Walk in My Combat Boots, and Filthy Rich. Patterson has told the story of his own life in the #1 bestselling autobiography James Patterson by James Patterson. He is the recipient of an Edgar Award, ten Emmy Awards, the Literarian Award from the National Book Foundation, and the National Humanities Medal.
Official UK Site
JIMMY Patterson Books
ReadKiddoRead
James Patterson is the most popular storyteller of our time and the creator of such unforgettable characters and series as Alex Cross, the Women’s Murder Club, Jane Smith, and Maximum Ride. He has coauthored #1 bestselling novels with Bill Clinton, Dolly Parton, and Michael Crichton, as well as collaborated on #1 bestselling nonfiction, including The Idaho Four, Walk in My Combat Boots, and Filthy Rich. Patterson has told the story of his own life in the #1 bestselling autobiography James Patterson by James Patterson. He is the recipient of an Edgar Award, ten Emmy Awards, the Literarian Award from the National Book Foundation, and the National Humanities Medal.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 796 reviews
August 13, 2024
This is the second novel in the Jane smith series, and I hated this one. I enjoyed the first one and I still love the character of Jane but the story in this was awful. With a lot of the same characters from the first I just didn’t care about anyone but Jane and Jimmy and found myself skimming quite a bit. Characters were all over the place.
I’m starting to think I just don’t like Mike Lupia’s writing, cause I remember reading House of Wolves and not liking it either. By the looks of the other reviews I’m in the minority.
I do like the characters but the story was not memorable at all. This missed the mark for me. Two and a half stars
I’m starting to think I just don’t like Mike Lupia’s writing, cause I remember reading House of Wolves and not liking it either. By the looks of the other reviews I’m in the minority.
I do like the characters but the story was not memorable at all. This missed the mark for me. Two and a half stars
August 23, 2024
Another successful novel by Patterson and Lupica. At the end of this book you will be saying, “Is there no end to Jane Smith?”. I do enjoy the teamwork of Smith and Cunniff. They seem to attract trouble no matter who or what they are investigating. And they have not even made it to the trial yet. She is battling the side effects of chemotherapy, trying to protect her sister (whose own a cancer has come out of remission), keeping all alive that means something to her and preparing for a trial which she is not sure of the innocence or not…I guess you would think she has her hands full.
I can foresee a sequel on the horizon. This series is not for all readers but if this tickles your taste buds … have at it.
I can foresee a sequel on the horizon. This series is not for all readers but if this tickles your taste buds … have at it.
Read
January 14, 2025DNF...... A SOLID CONNECTION TO ITS PREDECESSOR, UNFORTUNATELY GOT LOST TOWARDS THE END!
August 7, 2024
This is the second book in the Jane Smith series, but I missed the first one. This is a joint authorship with Mike Lupica. I normally enjoy Patterson's books so I picked this one up to try.
Description:
Jane Smith is being hailed as James Patterson’s greatest character yet, a tough-as-nails attorney up against a relentless killer. Hard to Kill features possibly the author’s most stunning twist ever.
Attorney Jane Smith is mounting an impossible criminal defense.
Her client, Rob Jacobson, is the unluckiest of the unlucky. No sooner is he accused of killing a family of three in the Hamptons than a second family is gunned down.
It’s not double jeopardy. It’s not double murder. It’s double triple homicide.
Jane’s career has spanned from NYPD beat cop to Hamptons courtroom. She’s tough to beat. She’s even tougher to kill.
The defense may never rest.
My thoughts:
Agreed - Jane Smith is a tough-as-nails attorney - they call her Jane effing Smith. She took chances and got herself into some very dangerous situations. Also, she's representing a guy she doesn't know for sure is innocent. She got him off once, but she wants the fame so when he's accused again of the same type of crime she takes the client again. The action was fast paced and exciting and the plot complex. There are certainly some tense moments. Jane Smith shines in her efforts to defend her client and also to find the truth.
Thanks to Little, Brown and Company through Netgalley for an advance copy.
Description:
Jane Smith is being hailed as James Patterson’s greatest character yet, a tough-as-nails attorney up against a relentless killer. Hard to Kill features possibly the author’s most stunning twist ever.
Attorney Jane Smith is mounting an impossible criminal defense.
Her client, Rob Jacobson, is the unluckiest of the unlucky. No sooner is he accused of killing a family of three in the Hamptons than a second family is gunned down.
It’s not double jeopardy. It’s not double murder. It’s double triple homicide.
Jane’s career has spanned from NYPD beat cop to Hamptons courtroom. She’s tough to beat. She’s even tougher to kill.
The defense may never rest.
My thoughts:
Agreed - Jane Smith is a tough-as-nails attorney - they call her Jane effing Smith. She took chances and got herself into some very dangerous situations. Also, she's representing a guy she doesn't know for sure is innocent. She got him off once, but she wants the fame so when he's accused again of the same type of crime she takes the client again. The action was fast paced and exciting and the plot complex. There are certainly some tense moments. Jane Smith shines in her efforts to defend her client and also to find the truth.
Thanks to Little, Brown and Company through Netgalley for an advance copy.
June 8, 2024
First and foremost, a large thank you to NetGalley, James Patterson, Mike Lupica, and Little Brown and Company for providing me with a copy of this publication, which allows me to provide you with an unbiased review.
Tackling yet another James Patterson collaborative effort, Mike Lupica joins the fray for this piece, the second novel in the series. The authors delve further into Jane F. Smith, a tough as nails attorney who is relentless in her efforts to defend her clients. Jane’s current cancer diagnosis has not been able to stop her quite yet, though she wants to make the most of the time she has left.
When she learns that a former client has been picked up once more for a multiple murder, she is baffled. She helped get a not guilty verdict for Rob Jacobson and stands by her defense. However, the new case makes her second guess her work. Battling alongside her investigator and against her cancer, Jane Smith is ready to toss it all out there and find the truth. Another gripping story that has Patterson and Lupica showing their true colours!
Jane F. Smith (Jane Effing Smith, to those who know her) has long been known as a cunning and ruthless criminal attorney. Her goal is to always provide her clients the best possible representation, leaving no stone unturned in trying to get to the root of any issue. This has made her well-known and feared in the New York legal community, while also creating a varied list of those who wish to engage her services.
One of these clients, Rob Jacobson, proves to be as unlucky as they come. After Jane was able to secure a not guilty verdict for the murder of a family of three, Rob is arrested once more. Another family has been murdered and Rob seems to be the most likely suspect, as the cases are quite similar. Jane sees the parallels and knows that while double jeopardy does not apply, the situation is too similar to ignore!
Working to defend Rob is more difficult, especially with the past case she argued, as well as her client’s own family who are ready to throw him under the bus. Jane uses her investigator, Jimmy Cunniff, to help uncover the truths that many would like buried, but when you look there is the chance you’ll uncover a snake or two. Rob’s personal choices and sexual endeavours make the targeting of mother-daughter duos all the more likely. While Jane cannot ignore the information she receives, she knows that Rob may have made enemies who are eager to see him suffer for life, even if that means bending the truth. As many people close to Jane are hurt or threatened, she has to wonder if this case might be best left to others. Still, she wants the best for her client. The law may be blind, but Jane Effing Smith does not want her client convicted when the court puts blind trust in past indiscretions. Patterson and Lupica deliver a stellar piece once more in this thriller.
While I have read a number of James Patterson’s thrillers, this one has been one of the stronger efforts. The narrative approach is swift and impactful, complemented by the Patterson traditional short chapter recipe. The narrative begins strong and offers the reader much entertainment as the mystery unfolds, less a legal thriller than one of investigation. When the truth becomes clear, the story’s speed helps prepare for the fallout of the final reveal. The characters are both relatable and interesting in their own way, flavouring the story effectively. Jane Smith proves to be tough and vulnerable simultaneously, which is a refreshing way of presenting a protagonist.
The twists within the book are both case-based and personal, fuelling many key plot points. The authors did well to build up the plot and keep things from getting too predictable, while never showing all their cards. While I was expecting something in the legal thriller genre, this tended more towards an investigation or police procedural. I am curious to see if there will be more to the series in the coming years, as I know Patterson and Lupica have some great ideas, likely able to create quite the story should they keep the series going.
Kudos Messrs. Patterson and Lupica, for bringing a great story to life.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
Tackling yet another James Patterson collaborative effort, Mike Lupica joins the fray for this piece, the second novel in the series. The authors delve further into Jane F. Smith, a tough as nails attorney who is relentless in her efforts to defend her clients. Jane’s current cancer diagnosis has not been able to stop her quite yet, though she wants to make the most of the time she has left.
When she learns that a former client has been picked up once more for a multiple murder, she is baffled. She helped get a not guilty verdict for Rob Jacobson and stands by her defense. However, the new case makes her second guess her work. Battling alongside her investigator and against her cancer, Jane Smith is ready to toss it all out there and find the truth. Another gripping story that has Patterson and Lupica showing their true colours!
Jane F. Smith (Jane Effing Smith, to those who know her) has long been known as a cunning and ruthless criminal attorney. Her goal is to always provide her clients the best possible representation, leaving no stone unturned in trying to get to the root of any issue. This has made her well-known and feared in the New York legal community, while also creating a varied list of those who wish to engage her services.
One of these clients, Rob Jacobson, proves to be as unlucky as they come. After Jane was able to secure a not guilty verdict for the murder of a family of three, Rob is arrested once more. Another family has been murdered and Rob seems to be the most likely suspect, as the cases are quite similar. Jane sees the parallels and knows that while double jeopardy does not apply, the situation is too similar to ignore!
Working to defend Rob is more difficult, especially with the past case she argued, as well as her client’s own family who are ready to throw him under the bus. Jane uses her investigator, Jimmy Cunniff, to help uncover the truths that many would like buried, but when you look there is the chance you’ll uncover a snake or two. Rob’s personal choices and sexual endeavours make the targeting of mother-daughter duos all the more likely. While Jane cannot ignore the information she receives, she knows that Rob may have made enemies who are eager to see him suffer for life, even if that means bending the truth. As many people close to Jane are hurt or threatened, she has to wonder if this case might be best left to others. Still, she wants the best for her client. The law may be blind, but Jane Effing Smith does not want her client convicted when the court puts blind trust in past indiscretions. Patterson and Lupica deliver a stellar piece once more in this thriller.
While I have read a number of James Patterson’s thrillers, this one has been one of the stronger efforts. The narrative approach is swift and impactful, complemented by the Patterson traditional short chapter recipe. The narrative begins strong and offers the reader much entertainment as the mystery unfolds, less a legal thriller than one of investigation. When the truth becomes clear, the story’s speed helps prepare for the fallout of the final reveal. The characters are both relatable and interesting in their own way, flavouring the story effectively. Jane Smith proves to be tough and vulnerable simultaneously, which is a refreshing way of presenting a protagonist.
The twists within the book are both case-based and personal, fuelling many key plot points. The authors did well to build up the plot and keep things from getting too predictable, while never showing all their cards. While I was expecting something in the legal thriller genre, this tended more towards an investigation or police procedural. I am curious to see if there will be more to the series in the coming years, as I know Patterson and Lupica have some great ideas, likely able to create quite the story should they keep the series going.
Kudos Messrs. Patterson and Lupica, for bringing a great story to life.
Love/hate the review? An ever-growing collection of others appears at:
http://pecheyponderings.wordpress.com/
August 11, 2024
“Hard to Kill” is the follow-up to last year’s fall thriller “12 Months to Live” from James Patterson and writing partner, Mike Lupica, bringing back their anti-establishment hero, defense attorney, Jane Smith. And yes, that appears to be her real name.
The book cover continues to promote their heavily advertised blurb – “Jane Smith is the best character we’ve ever created. Bar none.”
Although that’s quite a bit of self-promotion in order to increase sales, I also got to admit at the same time, there’s some truth to that statement.
“Hard to Kill’ continues Jane’s story and starts up right where the last book left off.
Jane’s previous client, Rob Jacobson, a liar and a cheat that Jane helped be found not guilty of killing a family of three in the Hamptons, no sooner is he set free than he finds himself arrested again when a second family is found murdered in cold blood and his DNA is found at the scene. Jacobson is being charged with triple homicide for a second time. Of course, he turns to Jane to defend him…
However, Jane is busy battling her own problems. One that involves life and death. Jane has stage 4 cancer and an estimated life expectancy of less than 12 months. This includes support from her best friend and personal doctor, Samantha Wylie, as well as her boyfriend and love of her life (following two divorces), Ben Kalinsky.
Not to mention, Jimmy Cunniff, Jane’s investigation partner, ex-NYPD police detective, and local bar owner, who is also trying to do his part and keep her out of trouble, but the more he looks into Rob’s background the worse it gets for Jane.
Jane now facing her biggest challenge – can she stay alive long enough to figure out what is going on with her client and the secrets of his family’s past? Or will the cancer win out?
After finishing this book, there were things that I liked and some things that I didn’t care for as much.
First, the good stuff. This is a heavy character driven book and story, even for James Patterson. What I mean by that is Jane Smith takes center stage and is in almost every scene that takes place. Although there are more chapters told from Jimmy’s point-of-view than the first one (and I really enjoyed them), Jane carries the weight of the overall story, pacing, and ambience. Don’t get me wrong. For the most part, it works. It works vey well. I found myself fully immersed in both of these books as Jane dealt with her professional challenges and personal medical issues.
Jane is an interesting character. Unfiltered. Outspoken. Flawed. Emotional. Stubborn. Underdog. Brilliant. And someone you cheer for. There were even moments in this one when Jane was struggling, I was really starting to feel the reality of her illness hit me. Hopefully, Patterson and Lupica will not take any cheap ways out in dealing with the outcomes when dealing with her serious medical issues. They have a chance of delivering on the promise of her being one of Patterson’s greatest characters.
I appreciated how more of Jane’s personal life and family history was explored in this one. Her relationship with her mother and father. Her upbringing. Her relationship with one of her ex-husband’s. These various plotting elements were well-incorporated and help peel the onion of who Jane is and how she became the person she is. They were some of the best parts.
As for the things I didn’t like, the primary one was the overall storylines involving Jane’s scum bucket client, Rob Jacobson. Although this was an enjoyable, escapist read, it was heavy on style and delivery, and not so much on overall plot development. Most of the focus was on the death of Rob’s father and his underage girlfriend. The question coming out of the last book as to whether Rob’s father killed the girl and himself, continues in this one. Was it a death/suicide? Or did Rob kill them? Or did another person kill them? If not, does Rob know who did? And why?
These questions are investigated, revealing the possible involvement of bad cops, mobsters, and people with political and financial power (the usual in Patterson books). For me, it got fairly convoluted. Lots of characters. Two fathers. Two sons. Two protectors. Several cops. And a few mobsters. It wasn’t terribly too hard to follow, but it didn’t really propel the overall storylines forward that much. As a matter of fact, more questions were raised than answers provided. Right at the end, when it looked like you were going to get some closure on outstanding issues, nope, you get the rug pulled out from under you and you will have to wait until (at least) the next book…
This reminded me of the challenges of second books in a trilogy. They are essentially “in between” books that build on the first and set-up for the ending book. However, they don’t provide you any real reveals, answers, or climaxes. They mainly serve to continue the story and build on it, but only provide small, if any real payoffs. It’s to get you to the next book. That’s what this one was. A fun, enjoyable, and even emotional at moments, read. But you are left with more questions than answers.
Overall, compelling characters, especially Jane, made this a fast-paced entertaining read. However, just don’t expect a lot of plot development. The bigger mystery will carry on to the next entry in the Jane Smith series. I can’t help being left with the feeling that Patterson (and Lupica) are going to milk this as long as they can. To be honest, part of me appreciates that, but the other part is still struggling with the pacing of the plotlines. The good news is that isn’t stopping me from reading Jane Smith. You can make your own call...
3.5 stars out of 5 stars (and yes, Goodreads doesn't round off).
The book cover continues to promote their heavily advertised blurb – “Jane Smith is the best character we’ve ever created. Bar none.”
Although that’s quite a bit of self-promotion in order to increase sales, I also got to admit at the same time, there’s some truth to that statement.
“Hard to Kill’ continues Jane’s story and starts up right where the last book left off.
Jane’s previous client, Rob Jacobson, a liar and a cheat that Jane helped be found not guilty of killing a family of three in the Hamptons, no sooner is he set free than he finds himself arrested again when a second family is found murdered in cold blood and his DNA is found at the scene. Jacobson is being charged with triple homicide for a second time. Of course, he turns to Jane to defend him…
However, Jane is busy battling her own problems. One that involves life and death. Jane has stage 4 cancer and an estimated life expectancy of less than 12 months. This includes support from her best friend and personal doctor, Samantha Wylie, as well as her boyfriend and love of her life (following two divorces), Ben Kalinsky.
Not to mention, Jimmy Cunniff, Jane’s investigation partner, ex-NYPD police detective, and local bar owner, who is also trying to do his part and keep her out of trouble, but the more he looks into Rob’s background the worse it gets for Jane.
Jane now facing her biggest challenge – can she stay alive long enough to figure out what is going on with her client and the secrets of his family’s past? Or will the cancer win out?
After finishing this book, there were things that I liked and some things that I didn’t care for as much.
First, the good stuff. This is a heavy character driven book and story, even for James Patterson. What I mean by that is Jane Smith takes center stage and is in almost every scene that takes place. Although there are more chapters told from Jimmy’s point-of-view than the first one (and I really enjoyed them), Jane carries the weight of the overall story, pacing, and ambience. Don’t get me wrong. For the most part, it works. It works vey well. I found myself fully immersed in both of these books as Jane dealt with her professional challenges and personal medical issues.
Jane is an interesting character. Unfiltered. Outspoken. Flawed. Emotional. Stubborn. Underdog. Brilliant. And someone you cheer for. There were even moments in this one when Jane was struggling, I was really starting to feel the reality of her illness hit me. Hopefully, Patterson and Lupica will not take any cheap ways out in dealing with the outcomes when dealing with her serious medical issues. They have a chance of delivering on the promise of her being one of Patterson’s greatest characters.
I appreciated how more of Jane’s personal life and family history was explored in this one. Her relationship with her mother and father. Her upbringing. Her relationship with one of her ex-husband’s. These various plotting elements were well-incorporated and help peel the onion of who Jane is and how she became the person she is. They were some of the best parts.
As for the things I didn’t like, the primary one was the overall storylines involving Jane’s scum bucket client, Rob Jacobson. Although this was an enjoyable, escapist read, it was heavy on style and delivery, and not so much on overall plot development. Most of the focus was on the death of Rob’s father and his underage girlfriend. The question coming out of the last book as to whether Rob’s father killed the girl and himself, continues in this one. Was it a death/suicide? Or did Rob kill them? Or did another person kill them? If not, does Rob know who did? And why?
These questions are investigated, revealing the possible involvement of bad cops, mobsters, and people with political and financial power (the usual in Patterson books). For me, it got fairly convoluted. Lots of characters. Two fathers. Two sons. Two protectors. Several cops. And a few mobsters. It wasn’t terribly too hard to follow, but it didn’t really propel the overall storylines forward that much. As a matter of fact, more questions were raised than answers provided. Right at the end, when it looked like you were going to get some closure on outstanding issues, nope, you get the rug pulled out from under you and you will have to wait until (at least) the next book…
This reminded me of the challenges of second books in a trilogy. They are essentially “in between” books that build on the first and set-up for the ending book. However, they don’t provide you any real reveals, answers, or climaxes. They mainly serve to continue the story and build on it, but only provide small, if any real payoffs. It’s to get you to the next book. That’s what this one was. A fun, enjoyable, and even emotional at moments, read. But you are left with more questions than answers.
Overall, compelling characters, especially Jane, made this a fast-paced entertaining read. However, just don’t expect a lot of plot development. The bigger mystery will carry on to the next entry in the Jane Smith series. I can’t help being left with the feeling that Patterson (and Lupica) are going to milk this as long as they can. To be honest, part of me appreciates that, but the other part is still struggling with the pacing of the plotlines. The good news is that isn’t stopping me from reading Jane Smith. You can make your own call...
3.5 stars out of 5 stars (and yes, Goodreads doesn't round off).
June 1, 2024
I just love Jane Smith!! Or should I say Jane Effing Smith. She is the kind of woman that you want your corner when the going gets tough. She does not giv.e up, even if she tries to at times, she just can’t bring herself to quit.
Once again, Jane finds herself defending Rob Jacobson on a triple murder charge - what is it with this guy? He insists he wants Jane to defend him and nobody else. Only Jane is right in the middle of intense cancer treatment and it isn’t doing her any good to be working. But she can’t g
Help herself and keeps going.
This is a fast pace thriller, with a high body count, constant drama and lies. Jimmy is by her side all the time, as is Rip the dog. Look forward to more from Jane, and hope she can beat the cancer.
Thanks so much to Little Brown and Company for my copy of this book to read. Published on July 29th
Once again, Jane finds herself defending Rob Jacobson on a triple murder charge - what is it with this guy? He insists he wants Jane to defend him and nobody else. Only Jane is right in the middle of intense cancer treatment and it isn’t doing her any good to be working. But she can’t g
Help herself and keeps going.
This is a fast pace thriller, with a high body count, constant drama and lies. Jimmy is by her side all the time, as is Rip the dog. Look forward to more from Jane, and hope she can beat the cancer.
Thanks so much to Little Brown and Company for my copy of this book to read. Published on July 29th
July 17, 2025
4 Stars for Hard to Kill: Jane Smith, Book 2 (audiobook) by James Patterson and Mike Lupica read by Eva Kaminsky.
This is the second time that Jane’s client has been charged with a triple murder. And she is having her doubts about whether he’s innocent or not. Either way she’s going to try and keep her perfect acquittal record. He may be a bad man but she’s the one with the death sentence.
This is the second time that Jane’s client has been charged with a triple murder. And she is having her doubts about whether he’s innocent or not. Either way she’s going to try and keep her perfect acquittal record. He may be a bad man but she’s the one with the death sentence.
September 4, 2024
Worse than Book 1. The protagonist is a lawyer and there's not even a court scene. And the story is left hanging so wait for book 3. If you really are keen on punishing yourself more.
September 9, 2024
3.0 / 5.0
This book is one steaming hot mess of a book, I got trolled didn’t get my usual - what I was expecting was a courthouse thriller with a side of action packed crime on the side. What I got instead, was a steaming pile of mess, no law and just a wild goose chase. First and foremost, this books makes zero sense to those that have not read the first book- so don’t even try attempt reading this, secondly i found this book very convoluting. I know I’ve read the first book, but this was so confusing to follow - we have the same guys from the first book with even more names. And surprise, he’s been charged for doing the same crime twice! So original…. I only read this book for Jane Effing smith. It’s like ordering steak and chips and getting steak and spaghetti instead.
Honestly, questioning on if I should continue this series. In the end my interest fell off and the plot just went out the window for me. First book I’ve read of Patterson and it hasn’t hit. Disappointing, read at your own digression - better investing that time elsewhere sadly.
This book is one steaming hot mess of a book, I got trolled didn’t get my usual - what I was expecting was a courthouse thriller with a side of action packed crime on the side. What I got instead, was a steaming pile of mess, no law and just a wild goose chase. First and foremost, this books makes zero sense to those that have not read the first book- so don’t even try attempt reading this, secondly i found this book very convoluting. I know I’ve read the first book, but this was so confusing to follow - we have the same guys from the first book with even more names. And surprise, he’s been charged for doing the same crime twice! So original…. I only read this book for Jane Effing smith. It’s like ordering steak and chips and getting steak and spaghetti instead.
Honestly, questioning on if I should continue this series. In the end my interest fell off and the plot just went out the window for me. First book I’ve read of Patterson and it hasn’t hit. Disappointing, read at your own digression - better investing that time elsewhere sadly.
August 4, 2024
I had high hopes for this sequel novel about Jane Smith, a lawyer grappling with cancer, but unfortunately, it fell short on many fronts. The main issue is that Jane's story is completely overshadowed by an overwhelming number of characters. Instead of diving deep into her personal and professional struggles, the narrative gets lost in a maze of too many characters and subplots
Additionally, the author's decision to refer to God as "she" felt like a forced attempt to be "woke". This choice, combined with excessive use of “GD” and other foul language, detracted from what could have been a powerful and poignant narrative about resilience and hope. Ultimately, Jane's journey was lost in the noise, leaving me disappointed and disconnected from a story that had the potential to be interesting as well as impactful.
Additionally, the author's decision to refer to God as "she" felt like a forced attempt to be "woke". This choice, combined with excessive use of “GD” and other foul language, detracted from what could have been a powerful and poignant narrative about resilience and hope. Ultimately, Jane's journey was lost in the noise, leaving me disappointed and disconnected from a story that had the potential to be interesting as well as impactful.
July 8, 2024
I didn't like this one as much as the first. That said, I love Jane Effing Smith and Jimmy and want more of this series! There were a lot of mob characters to keep straight in this one, and at times, it got confusing, but it does make more sense toward the end. We still don't know if Rob is innocent or guilty, so I'm guessing (and hoping) we see a 3rd book. Thank you to Little Brown and Netgalley for an advanced copy in exchange for my honest review.
July 25, 2025
This is the 2nd book in the series.
Great series with character, Jane Smith.
Jane is a strong and smart criminal attorney.
Unfortunately, she has cancer.
However, Jane is determined to fight her cancer as well as continue her work.
Plus, there are wonderful supporting characters, including her sweet dog, RIP.
I recommend this new book by Mike Lupica!
Great series with character, Jane Smith.
Jane is a strong and smart criminal attorney.
Unfortunately, she has cancer.
However, Jane is determined to fight her cancer as well as continue her work.
Plus, there are wonderful supporting characters, including her sweet dog, RIP.
I recommend this new book by Mike Lupica!
August 27, 2024
Disappointing ending.
October 22, 2025
This is book 2 of 3, with a book 4 rumored to be available soon. Lawyer Jane "effing" Smith is asked to get her client off from another triple murder, while she is also fighting cancer. The book is set on the eastern part of Long Island and the author drops the names of a lot of businesses. It's an enjoyable read and probably makes more sense if you read the books in order.
May 10, 2025
Този дует на Патерсън не можа да ме спечели. Къси глави, накъсан сюжет с много имена, препратки към минало и настояще и двама главни герои, на които ще им трябват явно още 2-3 книги, за да бъдат развити.
May 29, 2024
Hard to Kill is another fast paced book featuring Jane Smith.
Make that Jane Effing Smith.
Jane is hard working, foucused, stubborn but nost of all dedicated to her friends, her clients and family.
Rob is back having been acquited of murder and now he faces the same charges, different victims.
Rob only wants Jane to defend him and will accept no one else.
Tension mounts up as Jane, Jimmy and her boyfriend Ben all are threatened with their lives.
Walk away or else.
You cant help but cheer Jane on, though sometimes I cringe at her choices.
Empathy is on her side as she continues to battle cancer, thugs and the courts.
James Patterson and Mike Lupica have written another fast paced, hold your breath thriller that has you wanting more of Jane, Jimmy and Ben.
One of my favourite Patterson and Lupica series and I cant wait to see what they put Jane through next time.
Thanks to NetGalley and LIttle Brown and Company for a taut thriller that keeeps the midnight oil burning.
Make that Jane Effing Smith.
Jane is hard working, foucused, stubborn but nost of all dedicated to her friends, her clients and family.
Rob is back having been acquited of murder and now he faces the same charges, different victims.
Rob only wants Jane to defend him and will accept no one else.
Tension mounts up as Jane, Jimmy and her boyfriend Ben all are threatened with their lives.
Walk away or else.
You cant help but cheer Jane on, though sometimes I cringe at her choices.
Empathy is on her side as she continues to battle cancer, thugs and the courts.
James Patterson and Mike Lupica have written another fast paced, hold your breath thriller that has you wanting more of Jane, Jimmy and Ben.
One of my favourite Patterson and Lupica series and I cant wait to see what they put Jane through next time.
Thanks to NetGalley and LIttle Brown and Company for a taut thriller that keeeps the midnight oil burning.
August 6, 2024
Where to start??? Usually it takes me about a page to get
“Hooked” on a story. After , less than 100 pages , I was introduced to a “buffet “ of characters. Some related by blood others by association. Their history muddied by sunprise !personal romantic involvement and oh the seemingly “ main villain” grew up with our heroine, who by the way is battling cancer and her sister is currently involved romantically with our villain/serial killer. All this introductory fluff , we are led to believe , will ultimately connect, make sense, prove to be the thread of solution.
I am an avid reader. Enjoy the adventure and journey books of all genres provide. Reading is the gateway for expanding our imaginations. Not, as this book was to me, an exercise in exhaustive identification of who, what, where, and most importantly WHY. It’s a good thing this wasn’t their first book
“Hooked” on a story. After , less than 100 pages , I was introduced to a “buffet “ of characters. Some related by blood others by association. Their history muddied by sunprise !personal romantic involvement and oh the seemingly “ main villain” grew up with our heroine, who by the way is battling cancer and her sister is currently involved romantically with our villain/serial killer. All this introductory fluff , we are led to believe , will ultimately connect, make sense, prove to be the thread of solution.
I am an avid reader. Enjoy the adventure and journey books of all genres provide. Reading is the gateway for expanding our imaginations. Not, as this book was to me, an exercise in exhaustive identification of who, what, where, and most importantly WHY. It’s a good thing this wasn’t their first book
August 6, 2024
I found it confusing. Why were they killing people? Didn't make much sense to me. I figured out who the person was who called the "shots." Even so it just didn't make much sense. Jane seems to be a good, new character for Patterson and Lupica but hope the next story is a better one. Disappointed is the best I can say about this one.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
April 20, 2024
Jane is many things- tough, spunky, snarky, a word that rhymes with rich, and determined to kick cancer. She may also kick certain bad guys unmentionable anatomical parts. It feels like Jane just got Rob acquitted for murdering a family, now another family has suffered the same fate. Her investigator, Jimmy a former detective, knows she’ll represent Rob again. She’s too stubborn to argue with, regardless, he’ll always have her back. Together they start pulling strings and the same names keep popping up. Jane has put her sister, her boyfriend and Jimmy in danger before but the bad guys double down this time. If you haven’t read 12 Months to Live yet, it’s a must- read, many of the mobsters, lowlife criminals and police are still in the plot.
It’s impossible not to root for Jane, she wants to win the battle in the courtroom and with the Big C. I found myself cheering her on, reflective of all those people who fight the terrible disease daily. Its not a morose or sad story, but one of a courage and resilience. Bonus – she’s funny and sarcastic and living her life. What a terrific book! The characters are permeated with Long Island local color and the gangsters are winning, until Jane sets her sights on them.
An advance reader copy of “Hard to Kill” Jane Smith (volume 2), by James Patterson and Mike Lupica, Little, Brown and Company, Hachette Book Group, Publication 07/29/2024, was provided by NetGalley. The above thoughts and opinions are my own honest personal thoughts given voluntarily without compensation.
It’s impossible not to root for Jane, she wants to win the battle in the courtroom and with the Big C. I found myself cheering her on, reflective of all those people who fight the terrible disease daily. Its not a morose or sad story, but one of a courage and resilience. Bonus – she’s funny and sarcastic and living her life. What a terrific book! The characters are permeated with Long Island local color and the gangsters are winning, until Jane sets her sights on them.
An advance reader copy of “Hard to Kill” Jane Smith (volume 2), by James Patterson and Mike Lupica, Little, Brown and Company, Hachette Book Group, Publication 07/29/2024, was provided by NetGalley. The above thoughts and opinions are my own honest personal thoughts given voluntarily without compensation.
November 16, 2024
Jane Smith is a lot of things. For one thing she has been called “Jane effing Smith”. She is in love for the first time in her life, despite being twice divorced. And, she is about to defend a man who most likely is a serial killer. She is defending Rob Jacobson for the second time. One thing Jane refuses to listen to, telling Jacobson she does not want to know, and that is whether he is guilty or innocent.
Jane’s newest case is a triple homicide, just like her first with Jacobson, and he was found innocent. However, Jacobson is not an easy client. By any means. But, that’s okay. Jane is no pushover. While Jane might have a perfect record when it comes to her legal career, life hasn’t been so perfect. In fact, Hard to Kill is book two in the Jane Smith series, with the first book, 12 Months to Live, and with a stage four cancer diagnosis, time is definitely not on her side.
Jane is excellent when it comes to how she conducts herself in the courtroom, if not a bit irreverent at times. However, her investigator and best friend Jimmy is always by her side, and keeps her as honest as possible. I want more of Jane and my Kindle is at the ready for the next book in this fabulous series.
Many thanks to Little, Brown and Company and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.
Jane’s newest case is a triple homicide, just like her first with Jacobson, and he was found innocent. However, Jacobson is not an easy client. By any means. But, that’s okay. Jane is no pushover. While Jane might have a perfect record when it comes to her legal career, life hasn’t been so perfect. In fact, Hard to Kill is book two in the Jane Smith series, with the first book, 12 Months to Live, and with a stage four cancer diagnosis, time is definitely not on her side.
Jane is excellent when it comes to how she conducts herself in the courtroom, if not a bit irreverent at times. However, her investigator and best friend Jimmy is always by her side, and keeps her as honest as possible. I want more of Jane and my Kindle is at the ready for the next book in this fabulous series.
Many thanks to Little, Brown and Company and to NetGalley for this ARC for review. This is my honest opinion.
April 26, 2024
This book was just okay. I was honestly a little disappointed in it. Way too many threads to keep track of, and even a feeling of too many characters. I would find my attention drifting at times. However, there was some good suspense, and the female lead seems pretty badass.
Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for allowing me to read this ARC.
Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for allowing me to read this ARC.
September 26, 2024
Too many characters.
Liked that it takes place on Long Island.
Won’t be reading anymore of the series.
‘ The Walking Dunes is an area where I love to take Rip the dog or do a lot of reading. Back in 1921, a production company based in Astoria filmed some of the desert scenes in Rudolph Valentino’s classic silent movie The Sheik there.’
Liked that it takes place on Long Island.
Won’t be reading anymore of the series.
‘ The Walking Dunes is an area where I love to take Rip the dog or do a lot of reading. Back in 1921, a production company based in Astoria filmed some of the desert scenes in Rudolph Valentino’s classic silent movie The Sheik there.’
November 23, 2024
What can I say. I struggled through a third of the book before giving up. I rated the first Jane Smith book four stars, but I actually don’t remember much. This one left me looking for something more interesting to read. I got confused with all the characters and don’t remember the spark I got from the first book.
Unfortunately, I am no longer enamored with the Hamptons’ crowd.
Unfortunately, I am no longer enamored with the Hamptons’ crowd.
September 24, 2025
Jane Smith Will jot Stay Down
I have had it all wrong, with solving the mystery / who dun it! That's what makes this a pretty decent read., for me.
I did not give 5 stars because back title too redundant, and some predictability in what is or has happened. But the actual culprit...nah never guess that.
Jane maybe finds love, her sister is on the move, Jane is not getting any healthier, but Rip the dog is thriving.
Can Jane make it through another legal stand?
Is Rob Jacobson gonna commit more crimes and get away with it? How many bodies foes he have on him, and are they all buried in the Hampton s?
Taking place in the Hamptons, Jane is there for respite, when a desperate call for help on e again from Rob Jacobson. Yes of course he didn't do it? Everyone in lock up is innocent, and everyone on House arrest has no idea why... (Insert eye roll and sigh).
Jane finds that Jacobson criminal contacts has some 6 degree of separation stuff to her father. Her fathers indiscretions, or boy scout behavior has earned him a pass even in death. This pass protects Jane from being killed by one mob crime family, but, some one connected is still gunning for her demise and set to get her before cancer does.
I have had it all wrong, with solving the mystery / who dun it! That's what makes this a pretty decent read., for me.
I did not give 5 stars because back title too redundant, and some predictability in what is or has happened. But the actual culprit...nah never guess that.
Jane maybe finds love, her sister is on the move, Jane is not getting any healthier, but Rip the dog is thriving.
Can Jane make it through another legal stand?
Is Rob Jacobson gonna commit more crimes and get away with it? How many bodies foes he have on him, and are they all buried in the Hampton s?
Taking place in the Hamptons, Jane is there for respite, when a desperate call for help on e again from Rob Jacobson. Yes of course he didn't do it? Everyone in lock up is innocent, and everyone on House arrest has no idea why... (Insert eye roll and sigh).
Jane finds that Jacobson criminal contacts has some 6 degree of separation stuff to her father. Her fathers indiscretions, or boy scout behavior has earned him a pass even in death. This pass protects Jane from being killed by one mob crime family, but, some one connected is still gunning for her demise and set to get her before cancer does.
August 4, 2025
“I may be dying, but not tonight.“ “I’m Jane Effing Smith.“
I absolutely love Jane Effing Smith! She is such a strong character, even in her more vulnerable moments. She just never gives up, even when it would probably be smart to do so. I love the teamwork between her and Jimmy, their comradery, their banter. They just seem to keep making the wrong people angry! My heart hurt for Jane going through chemo and I love Dr. Ben. I hope Jane and her sister both have full recoveries. And, Rip better make it through the whole series (no killing the dog, please.). There was so much action and so many surprises. And, the trial hasn’t even started yet! I’m very much looking forward to the next book.
I absolutely love Jane Effing Smith! She is such a strong character, even in her more vulnerable moments. She just never gives up, even when it would probably be smart to do so. I love the teamwork between her and Jimmy, their comradery, their banter. They just seem to keep making the wrong people angry! My heart hurt for Jane going through chemo and I love Dr. Ben. I hope Jane and her sister both have full recoveries. And, Rip better make it through the whole series (no killing the dog, please.). There was so much action and so many surprises. And, the trial hasn’t even started yet! I’m very much looking forward to the next book.
April 27, 2025
3.5 ⭐️ Overall, I thought the book was a fun and easy read, but it’s definitely starting to feel a little too convoluted for me. I liked the first book — it felt tight and engaging — but this second one is a lot messier. The whole Rob Jacobson storyline just isn’t that interesting, and it ends up taking up way too much space without really moving the plot forward. The writing style also feels a little choppy and jumpy at times, which makes it harder to stay fully locked in, even though the actual reading itself is still quick and not hard to get through.
August 12, 2025
Jane Effing Smith. I really enjoy this series. It’s a quick and easy read, but exciting and enough twist and turns to keep you interested. I love the NYC/hamptons connections and setting. This is a great summer read for NJ/NY. I read book two in a week which is not a normal pace for me. Jane Smith and Jimmy Cunniff are characters you root for!
November 18, 2024
Typical James Patterson novel - vivid scene description, deep character development, large cast of players, complex weaving story lines. If you’re into that, you’ll like this novel & the continuation of the Jane Smith saga.
October 4, 2024
I'm halfway through So far So Good! Different than his others-Female Main Character for a change!😁
Displaying 1 - 30 of 796 reviews