Rating the Idea of the Book: 5/5
Rating the Writing of the Book: 2/5
I started the book with a lot of expectations, convinced that I will be able to get a gameplan by "Dr" Shad Helmstetter. Being a behavioral "researcher", I expected the book to be filled with actual research, reference to scientific studies, etc.
How wrong I was. The narration comes across as a hypocritical "uncle" speaking.
The book starts with shitting on other self-help books, so I felt convinced that this is the book I should read and practice to change my inner narrative or "programming" before I could begin to reshape my life. But the next few chapters just keep rehashing the same idea again and again and again and again and again.... Without any actual scientific evidence, just using plain old tangents and word vomits.
He goes on to shit on motivational speakers, and explains really well the difference between instrinsic and extrinsic motivation. That part was good. But then spends the majority of the next few chapters acting and speaking like one! Like, bro, practice what you preach.
And one part of the book was downright problematic. Here:
"Any of us can talk ourselves into depression and discouragement—and we can as easily talk ourselves out of it."
NO! NO NO NO NO NO NO! As much as we'd want to believe that Depression (the mental illness) can be rid with Yoga and positive thinking and self-talk, sometimes you do need medical intervention and professional help, and statements like these do little to alleviate the stigma that exists for getting help for mental illnesses.
I think that the author meant "feelings or periods of sadness" when he used the word "depression". But not making that distinction comes across as really ignorant and irresponsible from the part of "Dr" Shad Helmstetter.
Another gem:
"The primary reason for this success is that life coaches are “results” oriented, rather than therapy oriented. Well-trained life coaches are very effective in helping their clients produce realistic positive results in multiple areas of their lives—and they help their clients without using past-probing techniques of therapy and psychological counseling."
The author just shit on Therapy as a viable practical source of help and instead promoted "life coaching" as a miraculous, snake oil treatment to life's problems. That too with a full section on life coaching smack in the middle of a chapter that had nothing to do with it. It seems like a lazy after-thought from the author, "Oh, I just remembered I also run a life coaching business. Need to advertise, this page seems appropriate to place it."
If you think you need therapy, PLEASE GO FOR IT!
Don't get me wrong, despite the bad writing, advertorials, and some problematic ideas, I would still recommend this book as a read, but better done with this plan:
Chapters 1 to 9 - Read them.
Chapters 10 to 13 - Skip or Skim.
Chapters 14 - Read (warning: later part of the chapter will be an advertisement for the author's audio tapes, just skim through this part)
Chapter 15 - Definitely Skip.
Chapters 16 to 20 - Skim them.
Chapters 21 to 22 - Read them.
Chapter 23 - The conclusion. Nothing ground breaking. Bad attempt at being a motivational talk (the irony). Can skip or skim.
Again, the idea of changing the inner narrative is very interesting and definitely something I will be starting. I have personally been told that the way I talk of myself seems to underplay me. And there were some nice tips that the book provided.
Maybe the book presented ground breaking ideas when it was first published, but it has not aged well. I will be starting my own course of changing my self talk, but don't think I will credit this book for being an activator. A catalyst? At best, maybe.
Cheers.