What do you think?
Rate this book
Nook
First published January 1, 1989
''I will show you fear in a handful of dust.''
''For a moment Roderick Burgess is scared. He thinks of the effrontery of his action: to capture Death... to bind the Reaper... For a moment he hesitates. But only for a moment. The words of the spell toll inside his head. Burgess realizes that he couldn't stop now. Not even if he wanted to… ''
The issue in which an immortal entity and the living personification of dreaming (otherwise known as Dream, Morpheus, and other names) gets summoned, robbed and then imprisoned inside a transparent prison. His captors never get the answers they sought after but they get far more than they bargained for.
The Good:
1 The story has some outstanding historical realism and gothic fantasy. Niel Gaiman uses a lot of allusions to events and people of the recent and distant past. Like the horror of the first world war, the trauma of losing one’s child in battle, and the influence of cult figures like Aleister Crowley. And then he crafts a dark and unfamiliar world on top of the familiar one. And in doing so, Gaiman is both subversive and entrancing in tone- he casts a spell on you. And the magic is just beginning.
2 The villains have depth. I feel Gaiman excels at creating great villains, they all have some form of humanity. For example, the villains here, Roderick Burgess and his son Alex have easy to understand and nuanced motivation. They aren’t cliché comic book villains, they don’t want to destroy the world out of pure evil. They are living with very human and authentic desires that we all endure. Like the ambition to be respected by one’s peers, gain a superior knowledge of the natural world, and not grow old and dye weakly. Their acts are monstrous, but they are only human.
The Bad:
1 The pacing is a bit of a slog. The issue is 41 pages long, and in those pages, 70 years pass, and multiple characters are introduced and then killed off; basically, it’s a lot for the story to contain. And because of that, it can be a little hard to follow. It feels especially redundant when one realizes that almost half of the characters introduced here don’t make a return appearance ever. Gaiman does an admirable job with the stories, but he was young and maybe a little too ambitious.
The End:
That’s it! Thank you for reading this far, for engaging with my opinion of this graphic novel, and for reading it if you choose to.
Thank you multiple Eisner award-winning DC editor and Vertigo founder Karen Berger! For granting almost total freedom of creative control to your writers. Including Gaiman and the many others who you worked with and helped inspire. You make this industry a better place for us all.
[3.5/5]
I'd also recommend: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/1...