I knew I was going to love this book before I even started it. I had a feeling it would be my favourite of the three in the Escape to Paradise series. Perhaps because we already know the characters and it was easy to get back into their lives, perhaps because they've finally made it to Brazil and their adventures there are really exciting, or maybe it's because the romance here is really well developed, believable and heart-warming? If I'm being honest, it's probably because Hayden is the hero, but all the other elements of this novel were so engaging and well crafted together that the result was astounding. As engrossing and entertaining as the first book, Forsaken Dreams, Elusive Hope continues the story of the colonists and their quest to start a new town in Brazil. Fraught with danger, pirates, wild animals and the oppressive heat of the jungle, this book is exciting, suspenseful, and extremely romantic.
Who would have thought that pampered, rich, spoiled and selfish Magnolia would make such a good heroine?! At first I was disappointed when I read from the blurb that she was going to be the heroine, but as the story developed she became really interesting, and the more I learned about her, the more I liked her and the easiest it became to understand why she acted the way she did. Raised by a father who taught her that her external beauty was her only quality and of the utmost importance, and a mother too weak to contradict her husband, the beautiful Magnolia is used to having her every whim obeyed, her hair beautifully arranged, and her wardrobe filled with the prettiest dresses. Yet try as she might, her external appearance is never good enough for her father, and his constant reprimands have given Magnolia a very low self-esteem. She finds herself extremely miserable in Brazil and would give anything to go back to her former life in southern US.
Thus, when Hayden announces his intention to leave the colony on a personal quest of his own, Magnolia seizes the opportunity and runs away, following him in the jungle. We already know from Forsaken Dreams that the gorgeous Hayden is desperately looking for his father, and wants to make him pay for his crimes. He has absolutely no need for a beautiful young woman to accompany him on his journey (she would be a nuisance, of course), but Magnolia isn't a woman to be easily deterred. Having to travel with Hayden repulses her as much as having to face snakes, spiders and other bugs, but he is her only chance and she is determined to take it.
So, she nicknames him "toad" and he calls her Princess in a very condescending, sarcastic way, and sparks fly all the way to Rio de Janeiro. It was obvious from their constant bickering and mutual attraction already established in Forsaken Dreams, that Magnolia & Hayden had excellent chemistry and that a romance between them would be nothing short of highly entertaining. Watching Magnolia swindle such a great swindler as Hayden, and unwillingly making him fall as hard for her as she was falling for him, was oddly satisfying and heart-warming. Their romance was simply excellent, and although they had numerous difficulties to overcome, their problems and misunderstandings were not as frustrating as Blake & Eliza's and those of the other couple in Abandoned Memories. Hayden was really, really heart-melting and sexy, and his roguishness and complicated, sad past only added to his charm. Him and Magnolia form such an adorable couple!!
Following up the hints of fantasy introduced in the first book, Tyndall further develops that theme here by suggesting supernatural spiritual forces at work through the discovery of an old creepy temple, visions from the past, and a mirror that reflects the state of Magnolia's soul. The good vs. evil conflict is not at all resolved in this book, so again I suggest that you have the next book, Abandoned Memories, ready when you are done with this one. I really enjoyed the fantasy aspect and thought it blended really well with the rest of the plot. Since it was already a very adventurous, suspenseful kind of book, I thought that adding a fantastical spiritual battle only brought the story to a higher and more entertaining level.
We keep learning about the colonists previously introduced in Forsaken Dreams, and again the narration shifts points of view so that we get to know the characters even better. Eliza & Blake are there, of course, enjoying a sweet state of marital bliss despite all their difficulties, and it was lovely to see them again. Since this book closely follows the first one and is really a continuation of the adventure, I wouldn't exactly call Elusive Hope a stand-alone, and would strongly recommend reading Forsaken Dreams first. You won't regret it, as all books of the series are super good and leave you wanting more!