I loved the part in this book where Sugden talks about the legends and myths that Drake inspired with later generations because that is exactly what drew me to this book, and--in consequence--my eventual history major. When my 8th grade history teacher taught about Drake, the man’s exploits seemed so daring, so outrageous, so exciting, I was in awe that such a person might have existed.
Well, he didn’t. At least, not in the way my history teacher described it. I don’t know if my history teacher was deliberately making stuff up or he had a sketchy memory, but Drake didn’t stop the Armada by putting a chain up across the English Channel (laughable, now that my adult mind considers even attempting such a feat--though something similar was semi-successfully done against Drake on a much smaller scale than the English Channel!). Nor did he do any number of the other, silly things that my teacher proposed. But my teacher did pique my interest. And, as an 8th grader, I decided that I needed to learn more about this amazing man.
So I went to the library, found this book, and was sucked in by stories that may not have held the extravagance of the tall tales my teacher told, but at least did boast the gritty, inspiring impressiveness of reality. I found that I enjoyed the whole picture of the real Drake even better than the made up portions of the fictional one. Then I kept on reading other stuff because, wow, history can be super cool. My history major can pretty much find its beginnings with my 8th grade history teacher’s lies!
Fast forward a couple of dozen years. I was invited to give a talk tied into seeking treasure to a group of youth and I thought the stories of Drake might be a perfect foundation. I had bought this book long before when this one website appeared on the internet that offered pretty much any book for sale that you could want. Skeptical, I typed in this title and author and found it. I ordered it immediately. I guess there might be something to this new “Amazon” website, I thought to myself at the time. Anyway, since I was doing this talk, I felt I should revisit a specific instance in Drake’s career and, to avoid embellishing the facts (á la 8th Grade History Teacher), I picked up this long-ago-purchased book and cracked it open. Little did I know the draw of Drake’s fantastic feats. I read what I needed to and then immediately started from the beginning and barely slowed down until the end.
I feel that I have a new perspective on Sugden’s book now, having read plenty of historical biographies, academic reviews, scholarly articles, and primary documents, ad nauseum, since that time. But the general takeaway still holds true. Drake is magnetic, and his boldness, ingenuity, and passion are points of inspiration to this day. I was struck by his piousness and civility--easy things to overlook when you’re dealing with someone who was essentially (though not in character!) a pirate for many of his adventures. I was amazed by his cleverness, not just in attacks (though those are the most obvious manifestations) but in dealing with issues with crew and politics of the court. I love his audacity in basically declaring war against the most powerful empire in the world--a simple sailor from Devon--and landing some solid punches while helping to tip the scales in England’s favor for centuries to come. I marveled at his seamanship in daringly venturing into waters that had barely been visited by Europeans into the far corners of the world--often times without even maps--and remarkably and skillfully pulling through with hardly any mishaps. I cringed at moments of barbarity, though taken in context they marked someone who was truly ahead of his time in his lack of excessive, unwarranted violence. I saddened as his sharpness and innovation declined following the battles with the Armada, losing the strength of his small, focused attacks as he allowed too many people to curtail his brilliance with demands of policy, and attempting to manage far too grand a scale of ships, men, and purpose. Overall, I admired the still-veiled character of a man who demonstrated that with the right passion, purpose, determination, and boldness, the extraordinary and remote are suddenly within reach.
Sugden’s best contribution to this is careful presenting of Drake’s incredible career without getting in the way and in a manner that allows us better access to the driving forces behind such a captivating figure. Sugden makes his case for his biography, and he keeps a level-head about him as he sifts through mounds of documents to give us the most likely story connected to Drake. He relies on the scholarship of a lot of other historians in many instances (though there are also plenty of primary documents as well), but he is not sloppy or lazy. Sugden knows his stuff and where there are competing ideas, he makes it known why he arrived at the specific outcome he presented. Other than that, his voice is subdued but present as he capably guides the audience through the years of El Draque’s accomplishments.
I was struck by some of the sparcity of sources on some level in regards to Drake’s beginnings or even some of his most famous events, such as the last third of his most dazzling feat: the circumnavigation. The sixteenth century in England just did not make some details very accessible (the only part that really allowed an in-depth description of the time were the details of a pre-meditated murder--connected only to Drake because it happened in Plymouth when Drake would’ve been there). Sugden works past these gaps as best he can.
As meticulous and thorough as Sugden’s work is, it does not have the touch of a master storyteller historian, who can piece it all together and delve it out in a way that captures the essence of the character, time period, and culture. Those kinds of histories, however, are rare. So I can settle for Sugden’s excellent job of giving a straight-forward, accurate, and interesting narrative of one of England’s most engrossing figures.
I think it is telling that about halfway through the book, I changed plans for my talk and dropped the Drake portion completely … but that did nothing to lessen my resolve in reading the rest. That is the magic of Drake, and as I would come to learn, history in general, and that is a credit to Sugden for allowing the magic of Drake happen to me … again.