A cornerstone series of the gay mystery-romance subgenre and arguably one of the best, still to date—the Adrien English Mysteries by Josh Lanyon represent a unique moment in time that now only exists in our memories, encompasses the very real mindset of society then, delves into incredible fears, trauma, self-loathing and self-acceptance that puts most other titles to shame, and Lanyon does it all with quick wit, dry sarcasm, punchy narrative and glowing descriptions, and all the while, there’s a dead body or three in need of solving.
This is my umpteenth re-read of the series, but it’s been long enough since my last go that I’ve managed to forget the finer details so as to enjoy the digs, laughs, and gut-punches like it’s my first time all over again. We begin with Fatal Shadows, which introduces the reader to household names of the genre: Adrien English and Jake Riordan. Adrien is a bookseller, owner of the Cloak and Dagger mystery store, with the biggest selection of gay titles in California. He’s unattached and fine with it (so he says), living day-to-day with a disruptive heart condition, bills to pay, and an employee who’s starting to make him crazy.
That is, until Robert Hersey is found dead—stabbed to death in the alley behind his apartment. Enter Jake: the LAPD homicide detective who’s caught the case, and lo and behold, he’s so deep in the closet, so unwilling to accept he’s gay—and yet visits gay leather clubs, while dating a woman who has no idea, because nothing says "a human who cannot accept how they are wired" like this level of chaos and self-destruction—and he’s pegged Adrien as Suspect Number One in the murder of Robert.
What unfolds is a fantastic and compelling serial-killer-on-the-loose mystery, with the amateur sleuth who refuses to sit on the sidelines when it’s his life at stake. In between the beats of this plot is one of the absolute most perfect “oh no, I like you,” moments I have ever read, and this book isn’t even a romance—it’s a mystery, first and foremost. The ending of Book One, that revelation that hits both Adrien and the reader at the same time, good God. Even after all these years, it still takes my breath away and promises one of the best and most hard-fought for Happily Ever Afters of my life. This series is over 20 years old, and if my writing held up even half as well after so much time, that’d be something else.
If you read romance, if you read mystery, if you read a combination of the two, consider this series the most enjoyable homework assignment you’ll ever receive. This series set the groundwork and inspiration for what’s being read today in the gay mystery-romance world. No one does it like Lanyon.