I had a lot of mixed feelings going into Top Cow's Rebirth of The Darkness and Witchblade. while I feel the relaunch has paid off in spades for The Darkness, Witchblade has been less than stellar. It almost feels like Top Cow has no idea what to do with Sara now that her life has literally been rewritten. Rather than delve into new territory, the writers are choosing to rehash old themes in something that reads more like a twisted version of Artifacts than a Witchblade relaunch. First, there are the versions of the Witchblade and Darkness made flesh, and now there's some convoluted storyline that keeps threatening but never quite delivering other players from Sara's old life.
There are also alternate realities accessible by shadow portals, and fantasy worlds with orcs and elves and....dinosaurs. Yep, dinosaurs. Also, something about a mana trade and a subplot about dark magicians that is being dragged out so long that it's ultimately going nowhere.
Witchblade has gone from being a cop drama with elements of the horriffic and fantastical to a flat-out mess, and this compilation is a perfect illustration of how far this series has fallen. I gave the relaunch 10 issues, but will be cancelling my subscription and sticking solely with Artifacts, The Darkness and their new series Think Tank. If I pick it up again, it will only be to see what happens when she realizes how Jackie Estacado has recreated her life, and that Hope is their daughter.