Overall, this is an excellent book for the beginning genealogist. Many people will be inspired by the successes and difficulties that Richard faced, and he has written this in a very readable, linear narration. With so many unknowns and blind corners as he faced, this book should also appeal to people who love a good mystery novel. I think this story has the potential to become a timeless addition to some reader's shelves.
This book also provides an excellent case study in scientific research. One of the deeper conclusions which can be drawn from this text is that it provides an object lesson in the difference between most probable truth, and actual truth. It should also provide an object lesson in the limits (as well as advantages) of DNA testing, particularly with an eye for use of a limited number of STR markers. Under no circumstances should a highly probable conclusion be accepted until all of the other likely possibilities can be ruled out using a test of sufficient resolution.
One of my lingering concerns about this book is that it provides very little context beyond a very personal story. For some readers, this is going to be a good thing- it avoids projecting the discouragement the author clearly experienced onto the reader: of the form, "well, he had setbacks, how am I going to possibly overcome that when faced with that kind of challenge?" However, there's very little to indicate exactly how difficult if the average person, interested in genealogy, attempts to trace their own tree.
Richard's experience is fairly representative, I think, even though a good percentage of people will face much thicker brick walls. The past comes to us in a sophisticated game of telephone, in which the simple errors of communication often amplify the effect of casuistry and outright prevarication. "It was a different time", it is said, when "fallen girls" would be whisked off in secrecy. His handling of what would be an outright scandal, "unspeakable", in some circles is adept and non-judgmental. If anything, the ability of himself and others to overcome popular prejudices and speak the truth is probably one of the most important factors in allowing him to make breakthroughs in his roadblocks.
I think that there are a lot of people who would have declared their own searches "done" in many of the earlier chapters because the provisional "facts" confirmed their own prejudices, and Richard does an exceptional job of treading the thin line between self-deception and "digging up old bones"- truths that injure more than they edify. It's one thing to believe fortuitous and happy lies to blur painful truths, but taking those secrets to the grave may cause irreparable harm in completely unanticipated ways. In some ways, reading this on a kindle where I wasn't watching or feeling the page number led me to feel very "mystery solved!" at a number of points too early. I consider myself fairly sophisticated, and my ability to fool myself with such a clear, plainly written tale should prove to most readers of this review that when I say simple, it doesn't mean easy.
Listening to your own reactions as the book progresses and as the story changes direction is in some ways, more instructive in your own biases and self-deceptions than it is about genealogy. As such, I highly recommend this book not for the genealogist shelf, but for moral instruction. This book would be a welcome addition at a number of Ethical Culture society and Unitarian Universalist Sunday school shelves.
For people with considerable experience in the field of genealogy, particularly genetic genealogy, this book is not going to provide you with anything you don't already know. This is why I am giving the book three stars: because for me, it seemed to read at a high-school level, and I was hoping for the story to be interspersed with a bit of generalizable advice. However, when trying to explain this field to others this book might be much more engaging to the general population, and especially due to the exceptionally clear and unsophisticated narrative, I would recommend this book to both mid-grade and high school readers. Taken as that- as biography, not as an instruction manual, this is a highly readable and personable story. The lack of "how-to" advice, which in this field can so quickly become dated, might promise to make this book much more of a timeless classic.