Suzie being back again can put some people off, as the idea has been done to death (pun intended), but I was pleasantly surprised with how unique and interesting a story Sarah Pinborough was were able to make out of what was at her disposal. DI Tom Cutler returns from the Torchwood novel ‘Into The Silence’ and given he was the best thing about that terrible book, having him be the hero and Suzie the villain really did work as a dynamic. The premise may be off putting but frankly I’m not someone who going to whine and complain about Jack not being in it. It’s made explicitly clear it’s set post-COE, and pre-Miracle Day. Suzie is the focus.
Everything Changes, They Keep Killing Suzie, Moving Target, Sync are all her appearances give or take and I never really liked her prior as i felt she was a bit two-dimensional, and although it’s nice to say someone is complex, actually showing us that is more convincing. That is done exceptionally well in this story, as you get to see the predominant malicious, sociopathic, killer part, but also a softness and humanity to her character. Cutler is as good as ever, an intelligent detective with a sort of weary charisma that makes you feel sorry for him knowing his past and still being on his side. There are a few characters threaded throughout the novel but they feel less important and don’t really contribute to the narrative aside from being victims.
Sarah Pinborough does horror/gore incredibly well. The retcon backfiring and people killing themselves in very descriptive and disgusting ways was excellent if not a bit uncomfortable and that plot line, although sadly not really going anywhere, did tie-in to the Suzie plot-line very well. Suzie’s killings are all disgusting and freakish, and the hell that people enter, the darkness and the shadows were all brilliantly described as you can really see the victims suffering, in a sickening, yet intriguing way.
The novel does take a bit of a while to get anywhere towards the middle, but definitely is worth holding on for, as once the climax had been reached, the final confrontation between Cutler and Suzie is incredibly excellent. Full of tension, drama, and brilliant atmosphere, it really engrosses you in that moment, and definitely is a superb payoff that ends her story, once and for all. There’s also a Jack cameo for literally no reason in the last 3 pages, I presume it’s for idiots who can’t enjoy anything Torchwood unless Barrowman is in it.