The life of St. Columba, as detailed by Adomnan of Iona in his Vita Columbae (c.700AD) is vital source of information about life in the sixth century, and of religious belief in that century. The Vita Columbae contains the first reference to King Arthur, details of the Loch Ness monster, and the battles between those of Christian faith, and the Picts and their pagan beliefs. It is also a book espousing Christian rhetoric, propaganda and information. Beneath that surface, however, is a book of great interest, though all of its stories are transcribed from an oral tradition, and we are often told such things as:
“I have heard this as an undoubted fact from the lips of an aged and pious priest and soldier of Christ, called Oissene, son of Ernan, of the tribe Mocu Neth Corb, who averred that he had himself heard these very words from the lips of St. Finten, son of Tailchan, whose monk he himself had been.” (P.9)
Adomnan wrote his work a century after St. Columba’s death, and it is constructed around three central themes: “Of his Prophetic Revelations”, “Of his Miraculous Powers” and “The Apparitions of Angels”. Each of these books contains details of St. Columbia’s miracles and acts of God, some of them are Biblical in nature, with St. Columba imitating Christ (he turns water into wine, for instance), some (such as those involving sea creatures, such as the Loch Ness monster) come across as folk tales, often divorced from the usual monastic setting, and then those of everyday miracles.
When St. Columba died on the 9 June 597, a Sunday, in front of the altar at his Church on Iona, he left behind him a turbulent and interesting time, known now as the Age of the Saints. Christianity was spreading across the country with speed, and monasteries, such as the one at Iona, were becoming important centres of communities. He was a man of extreme authority in Iona, and during his lifetime his disciples would have been recording his actions for later generations – his sainthood would have been expected, even during his lifetime – so the Vita Columbae can be understood to have some factual basis, but as with any story celebrated and retold, losses and accretions can be expected within it. Those with agendas of hagiography might wish to glorify their study, or create a more dramatic story. The Vita Columbae is at points overly concerned with the dramatic.
Where Adomnan’s text fails is as an historical document. He is sparing with the dates, and with other contextualising details. There are incidents mentions that would be of great interest – such as Columba’s meetings with the Pict King Bridei, or that some Pict’s have books of their own, and that these people were intellectual and industrious – leading to the question of why no Pict work survives to this day? These questions are not deemed pertinent to the life of St. Columba, so form nothing more than background chatter to this epic life. For a nonbeliever, and a historian, it is this background noise that is the most fascinating, but one cannot penetrate Adomnan’s gushing to truly appreciate it.
There are other absences in Adomnan’s text. St. Columba’s age was, as previously mentioned, a century of great Christian expanse, and though we are often regaled with stories of visiting monks to Iona and the miracles they witness St. Columba performing (so they can return to their own monasteries and testify to St. Columba’s power), we never see St. Columba interact with other church’s or monasteries, despite the extensive travelling we are told he undertakes. So although Adomnan’s text provides a fascinating insight into the workings of St. Columba’s church, it gives nothing of this church’s place in the wider Christian Church. At times this creates the impression of St. Columba’s church being the only truly religious centre in Ireland and Scotland. Other events of his life go almost unmentioned or are passed over without comment:
“For indeed after the lapse of many years, when St. Columba was excommunicated by a certain synod for some pardonable and very trifling reasons, and indeed unjustly,” (P.79- 80)
This incident is not mentioned again, nor is any explanation of it ever truly forthcoming, for as it is with the Christian faith, all things are forgiven if one has atoned. St. Columba, according to this testimonial, does not even need to do that. One speaks for him:
“I have seen,” said Brenden, “a most brilliant pillar wreathed with fiery tresses preceding this same man of God whom you treat with contempt; I have also seen holy angels accompanying him on his journey through the plain. Therefore I do not dare to slight him whom I see foreordained by God to be the leader of his people to life” When he said this, they desisted, and so far from daring to hold the saint any longer excommunicated, they even treated him with the greatest respect and reverence. This took place in Teilte” (P.80)
The Vita Columbae is as unique, moving, frustrating and discordant as all lives of the saints are. It is a fascinating, if one sided, portrait, a beautiful piece of hagiography, if a little repetitive when read in one sitting. It is a work, like all religious texts, designed to be read in passages, for the aid of contemplation and affirmation of faith. As such, Vita Columbae is a great work.