I'm a ghost story junkie with high expectations, so I was a little surprised not only to discover how much I adored this book, but how I had gone for so long without hearing about Alexandra Sokoloff in the first place.
My immediate impression was that this book updated Shirley Jackson's The Haunting of Hill House for a modern audience. Laurel, the protagonist, is still reeling from a sudden break-up with her fiance and is struggling to fit in as a psychology professor at Duke University. After a short time, she stumbles across hundreds of research materials from the now-defunct Rhine Parapsychology Lab, which operated out of Duke University in the 1960's and was suddenly dismantled in 1965. The more Laurel investigates the events around the lab's final experiment in 1965, the more she realizes that something very unsettling happened, with everything centered around the mysterious Folger House - a sprawling, off-kilter mansion that seems as though it was spawned by Jackson's Hill House. With the assistance of her colleague, Brandon, and two psychically gifted college students, the four of them rent out the Folger House and investigate the supposed poltergeist phenomenon in the house. The reigning theory is that poltergeist infestations are a direct result of human psychic energy, but the more time Laurel spends in the house, the more she believes that something more supernatural and ominous is at work here.
I don't usually spend this much time on plot summary, but this really illustrates why I loved the book so much. The scientific study of ghosts and paranormal phenomenon is a fairly common theme in horror culture, but it doesn't always ring true. I loved that this book and the experiment described inside were actually based on historical events - the Rhine Parapsychology Lab was an actual organization operating out of Duke University, and they attempted to scientifically quantify psychic abilities in participants. This made the story seem much more realistic.
But inside the Folger House, there is something much more insidious roaming the halls, and the house itself actually becomes the antagonist. I love, love, love stories that can personify a house and turn it into a malevolent force, and this book hit all the right notes. If I compared this book to a horror movie, I'd say it's a good blend between The Haunting and Poltergeist.
This was a slower, more measured kind of horror, since the investigative team doesn't even reach the Folger House until two-thirds into the book. But by the time the house starts manifesting, you'll be hard pressed to put this book down.
This is a great option for readers who like unease and suspense more than outright terror, or who prefer bloodless horror stories.
Recommended for fans of: ghost stories, horror with a more measured pace, suspenseful but not terrifying stories.
Readalikes: I've already mentioned The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson as a good readalike, but here are a few others with a slower and more subtle build-up of horror.
The Woman in Black by Susan Hill. This short novel has all the touches of a classic English ghost story - misty moors, an abandoned mansion, a superstitious small town, and a vengeful ghost. The slow, atmospheric buildup makes this a good reading suggestion for people who don't consider themselves horror fans!
The Little Stranger - Sarah Waters. A doctor has been summoned to Hundreds Hall to care for a patient, but when he arrives, he finds himself tangled up in the lives of the Ayres family members, as well as the supernatural presence in the home. This story straddles the line between horror and literary suspense, but fans of The Unseen will likely appreciate the slow build-up of suspense and the subtle supernatural elements.
The Turn of the Screw - Henry James. A governess has been hired to care for two orphans living with their uncle in a remote country estate. The governess is soon disturbed by what she thinks are the ghosts of two evil servants who used to work in the house, but are they really ghosts, or just a figment of her imagination?