A Return Engagement - Stephanie Laurens ⭐⭐
Setting: 1826
Tropes: Second chance romance, matchmaking family members
Page count: 68
Nell and Robert were courting once upon a time, but a marriage proposal was not in the offing and the two parted ways. Nine years later, they find themselves back in each other's orbit when Nell's sister Frances marries Robert's friend Prince Frederick in some small German principality.
"Bland" is the first word that comes to mind. Is this meant to be part of a series? I feel like these two are secondary characters from a previous novel, and all of their history and previous interactions are detailed there but glossed over here. This story is mostly about the Vayne Family Curse, of all the females having panic attacks prior to their weddings, and how Nell has to manage Frances within an inch of her life to make sure these panic attacks don't ruin her royal wedding. Frankly, I think it'd be more impressive if a noble-but-not-royal bride didn't have panic attacks in the run up to her wedding, so this whole Family Curse business was overplayed 1000%. Meanwhile, there is no romance - Nell and Robert go from looking longingly in each other's direction when the other isn't looking to ultra-purple-prose flowery sex without so much as a by-your-leave. It was like romance whiplash.
The Imposter Bride - Galen Foley - ⭐1/2
Setting: ???
Tropes: Enemies to lovers, mistaken identity, big misunderstanding
Page count: 82
This story was a hot mess, right from the start. There is no setting given, so we're supposed to take the context clues to figure it out. Two fictional kingdoms which lay side by side in the Alps are constantly at war with each other, and Prince Tor of the northern kingdom decides enough is enough and he'll seal a marriage treaty with Princess Guiletta of the southern kingdom to bring peace to their people. The northerners are described as Viking Tuetonic Danes, whereas the southerners are a weird amalgamation of Middle Eastern/Mediterranean, complete with veiled women, polyamory, and camels for transport. Is this supposed to be medieval times with that marriage treaty and Viking hero? Or some more modern period, considering our Viking Danish hero is basically a 21st century man parading around with his lion's mane and Adonis body? And so many cringey cultural stereotypes about "hot blooded southern women" vs the "barbarian northerners." Just, yuck.
The story could've been interesting, if our heroine Minerva (BFF of the bratty Princess Guiletta) had used her words. She steps in to fulfill the marriage ceremony after Guiletta flees into the night, but doesn't bother to tell her new husband of this until Prince Orsino, Guiletta's older brother, unexpectedly shows up and demands to know where his sister is, almost setting off yet another war between the kingdoms. Everything is wrapped up in a neat little bow at the end and it's just, WTF did I just read??
Lord Lovedon's Duel - Loretta Chase - ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Setting: 1835
Page count: 45
The shortest and BY FAR the best story in the collection. Chloe Sharp overhears Lord Lovedon insulting her sister on her sister's wedding day, and challenges him to a duel. They are both falling down drunk, but Chloe has piqued Lovedon's interest, so he holds her to her vow even after she regrets making it the next morning. The two do actually duel, with a rather surprising conclusion!
The characters are sharp and witty and fun, and the pacing was very nicely done. Ms Chase didn't try to tell too much story in too few pages, and though this does tie in with her Dressmakers series, it isn't overshadowed by the recurring series characters. If you only read one story in this collection, let it be this one.
I impulse-bought the paperback edition released by Avon in April 2020. A mere 195 pages are actual stories, with the rest being filler material excerpts from other books by these authors. Is it worth paperback prices? No. Is the original digital anthology worth the price? No. Do yourself a favor and find another way to read this Chase story (preferably the library!). The other two can be left alone and nothing of value will be lost.