It’s time for a little colour theory, as Maomao tries her hand at a very specific puzzle, learns a lot more about art appreciation, and also steadfastly ignores the truth of Jinshi that all signs are pointing to.
Yes, there is finally a 4-star review for this series. It took me a long time to suss out why, but another review clued me in to what was feeling off for me - this volume is incredibly sedate, even by its own standards.
We get all the things I love, no worries there, but they’re in service to things that are not exactly barn burners in terms of plot. Also, I know it’s her nature, but Maomao’s continued ignorance regarding Jinshi’s actual position now feels it’s being stretched for narrative purposes rather than character reasons.
And these things are fine, but after all that abortion drama and visiting dignitaries from the last couple volumes and acknowledging that the poisoner might still even be on the loose just makes this stuff feel a little less special.
The big reveal with the doors carrying over from last volume is pretty good, but it doesn’t feel like it matches up with the reality of the series (I’m probably way off since this feels well researched, so it’s entirely down to my feelings). Also, these protracted explanations work best when in service to something truly exciting.
We are learning a lot of things that we already knew - Jinshi isn’t just a eunuch!? What!? - and that also kind of lowers the excitement. The story does its absolute best and I give it all the applause for what it does, but it still isn’t quite where I want these to be.
The backstory of the former emperor with the predilection for young girls is paramount to the second half of this and it does a lot right. We get introduced to the Empress Dowager, who is a really great addition to the cast just because she finally puts the screws to Jinshi about his intentions with Maomao. That’s been a long time coming too.
This whole revelation with the paintings and the truth behind the emperor’s curse is pretty good, although it feels like many a mystery story with its reveals and it just didn’t set the pages on fire.
The personalities and characters here are absolutely amazing and I have let five star reviews go through with much more glaring issues, but partly it’s down to the fact that this series is so good that when I don’t feel it operating at full strength it’s really apparent.
Although, it’s also true that Maomao isn’t as focused on medicine this time around and that might be part of it. I don’t know, it just feels okay, but not great.
Most times, a five star character will get me to overlook the flaws. And make no mistake, Maomao is probably my favourite creation I’ve seen since I got back into manga. She’s amazing and unique. This just doesn’t give her the material she needs to excel, sadly.
4 stars - as I say, possibly the weakest volume to date and it’s still great. Reviewed amongst other manga, probably a five still, but held to the standard I expect from the series? Not quite there.