Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The Westmacott-Christie Reader: Six Novels by Agatha Christie Writing Under the Name Mary Westmacott

Rate this book
Giants' bread --
Absent in the spring --
Unfinished portrait --
The rose and the yew tree --
A daughter's a daughter --
The burden

933 pages, Hardcover

First published December 1, 1983

19 people are currently reading
897 people want to read

About the author

Mary Westmacott

22 books684 followers
Pseudonym used by Agatha Christie to write her dramatic novels about relationships.

Associated Names:
Мэри Вестмакотт (Russian)
Мері Вестмакотт (Ukrainian)

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
80 (48%)
4 stars
46 (28%)
3 stars
21 (12%)
2 stars
10 (6%)
1 star
7 (4%)
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews
Profile Image for T.R..
Author 5 books29 followers
March 30, 2014
       Many people are familiar with Agatha Christie's mysteries. We've grown accustomed to stumbling over bodies in libraries, discovering that seemingly innocuous, hen-pecked husbands are actually homicidal maniacs, and having perfectly innocent train rides turn into murder scenes. Oh yes, Agatha Christie, as the Queen of Crime, is a well-known, well-respected figure.       But Mary Westmacott…who has ever heard of her? Her novels, full of psychology, romance, and the complexity of human relationships, are nothing like Agatha's spine-tingling who-done-its. This is the work of an extremely intelligent, highly-sensitive literary artist. But if you read closely…if you study the language, the sentiment, the well-crafted plot twists and turns…you begin to see the truth.       Mary Westmacott is Agatha Christie, all right. But she's an Agatha who most people never bother to get to know. She's a softer, more vulnerable Agatha, an Agatha who is writing from the heart rather than the brain. If you're a true fan of the Queen of Crime, Mary Westmacott's novels are not to be missed
Profile Image for MTK.
498 reviews36 followers
April 5, 2017
Τρία αστεράκια για την ποιότητα των βιβλίων αυτών καθαυτών (είναι καλογραμμένα και ενδιαφέροντα, αλλά επίσης κλισε, μελοδραματικά και παρωχημένα), αλλά για τους φαν της Αγκάθα Κρίστι τα συστήνω ανεπιφύλακτα, γιατί το Mary Westmacott είναι το ψευδώνυμο με το οποίο εκδόθηκαν τα πολύ λίγα μη αστυνομικά μυθιστορήματά της. Όπως και η αυτοβιογραφία της, προσδίδουν επιπλέον βάθος στο έργο της.
Profile Image for Claire W.
24 reviews1 follower
May 7, 2023
It was intriguing to read these novels Agatha Christie wrote under a penname. They were haunting, thought-provoking, and often sad. Wouldn't recommend for people easily affected by the deeper and darker side of humanity. At times I was conflicted about some of the topics. But I came away from multiple books pondering myself and my own actions and thoughts in a different way. Definitely slower paced and more introspective than any other of Christie's books I've read. The depth of her characters and their complexities immerses you in the stories.
Profile Image for Gina House.
Author 3 books128 followers
March 25, 2012
Agatha Christie is my favorite author, but these stories all seemed to have the same theme. They were very well written, but horribly depressing and a bit on the preachy, monologue side to me. Not sure if I'd read these again. Disappointed :(
Profile Image for Andrea.
6 reviews
July 24, 2012
Read these when I was very young...wish I still had it to re-read!
1,271 reviews1 follower
August 24, 2020
I have this book of 6 novels and am rereading it. The first one, Giants' Bread is great. Vernon is such an interesting child who grows up to be a troubled musician composing what was at the time considered modern music---lots of crashing metallic sounds. Something of a romance, 2 women are besotted with him and he marries one, goes to war and loses his memory but regains it with the help of childhood friends.
Profile Image for Michael.
7 reviews1 follower
July 20, 2017
These six novels are a bit uneven in terms of quality. None of them is as thrilling as her mysteries, and some of them are downright dull (Giant's Bread and Absent in the Spring in particular). They tend to focus on a mixture of romance and the daily trials of being a woman in twentieth-century Britain, and they emphasize (very SLOW) character development over plot.

They're certainly a must-read for Agatha Christie fanatics like myself--I've now read everything Christie has published, including a few plays that are difficult to get a hold of--but they're certainly not a fun read.
Profile Image for Rita .
4,038 reviews93 followers
September 17, 2025
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

***

"Mi chiedo da dove nascano questi impulsi interiori a creare e a volte penso che ci siano momenti in cui ci si sente più vicini a Dio, perché ci è stato concesso di provare la gioia della creazione. Siamo riusciti a fare qualche cosa di diverso da noi, in una specie di unione ideale con l'Onnipotente."

★★★★☆: "Ti proteggerò", "Nell e Jane", "Rosa d'autunno"
★★★☆☆: "Il deserto del cuore", "Ritratto incompiuto", "Una figlia per sempre"
Profile Image for Sydney.
59 reviews
December 27, 2015
Agatha Christie wrote six novels under this pen name. These are not Poirot and Marple novels; style and content are entirely different from such and from one another. I really enjoyed them. Read them for yourself and see...
Profile Image for Kally Sheng.
475 reviews15 followers
December 12, 2020
These stories are not easy read. They are pretty heavy-hearted.
It took me six months to finish the book, and in between stories I had to break away to read something else so I could continue to the next one with a fresh eyes (heart and mind), so to speak.
I do not know WHY Christie wanted to write these stories, but I think, in my humble opinion, maybe she wanted to explore the vulnerabilities of relationships, any kind of relationship, the labour of love, the burden of love, in relationships. Well, I think it would take a burden of love on a reader’s part to read this particular book - wouldn’t recommend reading these stories consecutively, but very much worth the patience to.

CONTENTS

Giants’ Bread (https://www.agathachristie.com/en/sto...)
Vernon Deyre is a sensitive and brilliant musician, even a genius. But there is a high price to be paid for his talent, especially by his family and the two women in his life. His sheltered childhood in the home he loves has not prepared Vernon for the harsh reality of his adult years, and in order to write the great masterpiece of his life, he has to make a crucial decision with no time left to count the cost.


“As I grow older I am more and more convinced that there is nothing so pathetic, so ridiculous, so absurd, and so absolutely wonderful as Man.” - Carl Bowerman, the most distinguished of English musical critics, Pg. 8

“Things are never so frightening in front of you as they are behind you. Remember that. Anything seems frightening when it’s behind your back and you can’t see it. That’s why it’s always better to turn and face things - and then very often you find they are nothing at all.” - Pg. 31

To attempt to discover something new and force it on the world is always a thankless task. - Pg. 81

Nobody welcomes genius. - Pg. 81

They felt that age-long lovers’ delusion that everything must come right because they loved.. - Pg. 98

Life isn’t like a penny novelette. - Pg. 111

Half your dreams are only confused memories of the future. - Pg. 111

How little all the things you have got matter. - Pg. 113

Without courage nothing can ever be accomplished. Those without courage turn their backs on life. - Pg. 116

Friendship is not a kind of equilateral triangle. - Jane Harding, Pg. 125

Life is a difficult, dangerous but, endlessly interesting adventure. - Jane Harding, Pg. 125

A slave of convention [a slave of the unconventional](, makes just as much for narrowness and prejudice.) - Pg. 128

Separation in time is worse than separation in space. if you are the wrong age for a person, nothing keeps you apart so hopelessly. You may be made for one another, but be born at the wrong time for each other. - Pg. 128

When are thing’s offered you, you’ve got to choose whether you’ll except it or refused it. that’s destiny. And when you’ve made your choice you must abide by it without looking back. - Pg. 129

It’s the hardest thing in the world for people with different incomes to continue friends. - Jane Harding, Pg. 134

You can be clever, you can have the brains to foresee things, and the wits to plan things, and the force to succeed, but with all the cleverness in the world you can’t avoid suffering some way or another. - Sebastian Levinne, Pg. 145

If you pursued safety and nothing but safety. You would get your wings singed, perhaps, but that would be all. You’d build a nice smooth wall and hide yourself inside it. - Sebastian Levinne, Pg. 145

You had to have that wall of illusion and lies to help you to endure the solid facts. It was Nature’s way of providing a way of escape. - Pg. 152

Perhaps, if you had courage, things were always easy. Perhaps that was the great secret of life. - Pg. 156

The future exists at the same time as the past.
We travel through time as we travel through space.
- Pg. 217

Amazing things are sometimes born out of vice and filth and anarchy. - Pg. 218

The things that die endure, and the things that die perish. - Pg. 219

***
Love is a tangle of spider webs.
At first, I got really impatient with all that talk of love; romance is never my thing, but gradually I was drawn to the story and couldn’t put the book aside.
It’s very Titanic!


Absent in the Spring (https://www.agathachristie.com/en/sto...)
Returning from a visit to her daughter in Iraq, Joan Scudamore finds herself unexpectedly alone and stranded in an isolated rest house by flooding of the railway tracks. This sudden solitude compels Joan to assess her life for the first time ever and face up to many of the truths about herself. Looking back over the years, Joan painfully re-examines her attitudes, relationships and actions and becomes increasingly uneasy about the person who is revealed to her…


Life really was a series of petty dramas. - Pg. 236



Unfinished Portrait (https://www.agathachristie.com/en/sto...)
Bereft of the three people she has held most dear - her mother, her husband and her daughter - Celia is on the verge of suicide. Then one night on an exotic island she meets Larraby, a successful portrait painter, and through a long night of talk reveals how she is afraid to commit herself to a second chance of happiness with another person, yet is not brave enough to face life alone. Can Larraby help Celia come to terms with the past or will they part, her outcome still uncertain?

For it is not an open enemy that hath done me this dishonour; for then I could have borne it;
Neither was it mine adversary that did magnify himself against me; for then peradventure I would have hid myself from him;
But it was even thou, my companion, my guide, and mine own familiar friend.
We took sweet counsel together, and walked in the house of God as friends. (Psalm 55. Exaudi, Deus.)
- Pg. 522

The world is like that - full of cruelty and pain - because people are stupid. - Pf. 522

***
This kind of girlish/womanish love/romance story is really not my cup of tea. It drags on and on....
I am not saying it’s badly written but just not for me.
After I finished reading it, I cheated half way through by skipping here and there, I feel sad, a voided sadness that leaves a lump in my heart. We are selfish lots, and we are cruel; we may be surrounded with loved ones but fundamentally we are loners; and we live or prefer to live in our own worlds than face the reality.


The Rose and the Yew Tree (https://www.agathachristie.com/en/sto...)
A beautiful, upper class woman marries a working class opportunist, but his attempts to elevate himself lead to unforeseen consequences.


When you come to think of it, a bad film is exactly what history really is. - Pg. 539

How little it matters why a thing happens! - Pg. 544

The animal in pains knows only pain or the surcease of pain, it can concentrate on nothing else. - Pg. 544

Animals don’t think - their minds are relaxed, passive, until an emergency arises with which they have to deal. Thinking (in the speculative sense of the word) is really a highly artificial process which we have taught ourselves with some trouble. We worry over what we did yesterday and debate w hat we are going to do today and what will happen tomorrow. But yesterday, today and tomorrow exist quite independently of our speculation. They have happened and will happen to us no matter what we do about it. - Pg. 551

We have, all of us, progressed such a long way from simplicity that we don’t know what it is when we meet it. To feel a thing is always much easier -much less trouble - than to think it. Only, in the complexities of civilized life, feeling isn’t accurate enough. - Teresa Norreys, Pg. 593

Fine words butter no parsnips. - Pg. 620

What are politics after all but adjacent booths at the world fair, each offering their own cheap-jack specific to cure all ills?... And gullible public swallows the chatter. - Pg. 621



A Daughter's A Daughter (https://www.agathachristie.com/en/sto...)
The love between a mother and daughter turns to jealousy and bitterness in Christie's fifth novel published under the pseudonym Mary Westmacott. Ann Prentice falls in love with Richard Cauldfield and hopes for new happiness. Her only child, Sarah, cannot contemplate the idea of her mother marrying again and wrecks any chance of her remarriage. Resentment and jealousy corrode their relationship as each seeks relief in different directions. Are mother and daughter destined to be enemies for life or will their underlying love for each other finally win through?


Never deny the truth. One must accept the fact that we have only one companion in this world, a companion who accompanies us from the cradle to the grave - our own self. Get on good terms with that companion - learn to live with yourself. That’s the answer. It’s not always easy. - Pg. 670

The natural second blooming is of the mind and spirit and it takes place at middle age. Women take more interest in personal things as they grow older. Men’s interests grow narrower, women’s grow wider. A woman of sixty, if she’s got any individuality at all - is an interesting person. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 672

Middle age is an age of great possibilities. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 672

Whatever one accomplishes in life, it is really very little and could always quite easily have been accomplished by somebody else. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 689

Humility should always lie behind effort. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 689

For work was one of the chief avenues by which one escapes from oneself. And to live with oneself, without subterfuge, and in humility and content, was to attain the only true harmony of life. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 735

Language is given you to conceal your thoughts as much as to express them. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 751

Half the troubles in life come from pretending to oneself that one is a better and finer human being that one is. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 770

Recognize the truth of your actions, by all means, but having done so, pass on. You can’t put the clock back and you can’t usually undo what you have done. Continue living. - Dame Laura Whitstable, Pg. 793

The Burden (https://www.agathachristie.com/en/sto...)
The bounds of jealousy, love and obsession blur in this tale of the fierce relationship between two sisters

“Friendship should never be strained too far.” - John Baldock, Pg. 816

“You need courage to get through this world, courage and a gay heart.” - John Baldock, Pg. 842

“Unselfishness in a woman can be as disastrous as a heavy hand in pastry.” - John Baldock, Pg. 842

“I’ve known a thousand ways of love
And each one made the loved one rue.” - Pg. 843

I've known a hundred kinds of love;
⁠All made the loved one rue;
” - Emily Bronte

“The fate of every man is bound about his neck.” - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 886

Happiness is one of the foods of life, it encourages growth, it is a great teacher, but it is not the purpose of life, and is, in itself not ultimately satisfying. - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 889

“We all have fantasies that help us to bear the lives we live.” - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 889

“We hurt each other, and hurt ourselves.” - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 892

“To encourage people to give of their best -“
“is forcing them to live at a very high attitude; to keep up being what someone expects you to be is to live under a great strain. Too great a strain leads eventually to collapse.” - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 899

“Men cannot be trusted with power, it rots him from within.” - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 911

“It is a question of being in harmony.” - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 912

“Does a person ever seem the same to two different people?” - Llewellyn Knox, Pg. 931

Don’t interfere. Why do we think we know what’s best for other people?” - Laura Franklin, Pg. 932
Profile Image for CindySR.
606 reviews8 followers
December 21, 2023
Mary Westmacott is Agatha Christie writing non-mystery stories. Absent in the Spring is the only story I read from this collection.

Joan is an incredibly self-absorbed woman, oblivious to the true feelings of her family, and clueless as to how they really feel about her. Due to a travel snafu, she is forced to spend a week in the Iraqi desert. There she almost goes crazy with her thoughts about the past and her family. She begins to see the truth about herself. Will her epiphany last? Short and interesting read by Agatha Christie aka Mary Westmacott.

And yet, I just cannot like a story when I want to strangle the leading lady. What a fool!
542 reviews3 followers
February 9, 2020
I am not a big mystery reader but I have great admiration for Agatha Christie's writing so I was thrilled to learn about her six non mysteries. What a find! I thoroughly enjoyed each and marveled at the diversity of characters and story lines; she was an amazing author and person. I would love to be able to have tea with her sometime!
Profile Image for Keri Sparks.
Author 5 books36 followers
May 25, 2025
I'm not all that fond of the first four stories in this collection. They started off interesting but halfway through, it felt like the story dragged and I got bored. But I loved A Daughter's Daughter, and "Baldy" in The Burden was an absolute riot. I rated the collection three stars but for the last two, I rate four stars.
Profile Image for Kim.
888 reviews12 followers
January 14, 2018
Thoroughly enjoyed this set of stories. Ms Christie's writing is so sharp, like cut glass.
Profile Image for edythe 💫.
18 reviews
May 14, 2022
i lovED IT!
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
19 reviews1 follower
July 14, 2023
Mary Westmacott is not nearly as good a writer as Agatha Christie
Almost abandoned it several times, but kept thinking "well maybe the next story will be better" - it never was =(
Displaying 1 - 18 of 18 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.