I'm torn with this particular review, because I know that Gallowglas is a tremendous writer and I know what he's capable of, having already reviewed the excellent short that is Jaludin's Road.
Having said that, I cannot in good conscience give this a 4, I agree with another reviewer who pointed out that it's more of a 3.75. It's a good work, but it didn't quite blow me away and there were bits that niggled at me to the detriment of the work.
Our protagonist Julianna is very much the coming of age character who has been blessed or cursed by the Gods. What differs about her from the usual is that she isn't some farm girl or bar maid, but rather of wealthy upbringing.
Now we come to the inherent problem I had with the book: I can't remember any of the other characters. I'm aware there was a man following her called Faelin, and there were a few others that made an appearance, but it was either so fleeting or inconsequential that I couldn't keep their names in my mind.
Speaking of names, the nomenclature of the characters and beings in question may have led to this confusion. There are multiple points of view but they're all compressed into what averages out as a very small book for its particular genre. There was no need for the alternative spelling of demons and saints either, as it led to further confusion.
I had no empathy for Julianna, and her trials were mirrored by my own trials to finish the book. I also can't remember the name of the antagonist or their primary motivation.
In his defense, there's more than a touch of the Zelazny about the prose of Gallowglas, with a great magic concept and deeply rooted faith that I enjoyed reading about. There's no denying that the quality is there, but the constraints of the book meant that it wasn't allowed to flourish.
The short, sharp chapters and constant switching of the points of view with little to no recapping of previous events meant that each time I picked up the book to continue I was lost. A longer volume with more fleshed-out chapters may have prevented this.
It won't be the first and it certainly won't be the last time I make this complaint of a self-published fantasy work, but the book was just starting to heat up when it ended. That irritated me greatly, as it felt like an incomplete third of whatever tale was being told.
In spite of my various gripes with the text, I do feel that there's great potential with the Tears of Rage series as a whole. This is one of the more popular works that I've reviewed and I acknowledge that while the above seems harsh, it's written in the understanding that the prose is a cut above the rest.
Given the calibre of the author and the fact that this is an early work, I do suggest that people pick it up. I may not have been in the right mindset to appreciate the story as a whole, so I'd advise you read the other reviews before purchasing it.
Overall I consider this a solid if inauspicious start, but many a great author has done just that before catapulting themselves into something special. Gallowglas may well manage that given time.