First read rating: 4 stars
Original review, 10/6/11:
I liked this. Joss wasn't my favorite from the Vlad books, but I liked him well enough to enjoy this. Although his personality seems slightly different than in the Vlad books, and sometimes it seems like the author's forcing him into this Slayer loyalty that it doesn't really seem like he feels. This book really sets up the Slayer Society as something with supposedly good intentions, but a pretty ruthless group in their own right, and I can really see why Joss would leave them later on. I saw somewhere that the author says this book is darker than any of the others, and it certainly is bloodier than the Vlad books, somewhat ironically.
I really enjoyed the reveal about Sirus at the end, and I very much hope that he's not really dead, as the story really leads us to like him. Given the off-screen death and lack of a body, though, I suspect Sirus will show up again. I look forward to seeing what happens with that, and also how Kat will figure into the story from here on.
I feel like this story doesn't quite fit perfectly with the Vlad books. In the Vlad books, the first time we find out what Joss is, he seems like a very confident, experienced Slayer, like he's been doing it for years. But according to this, he'd only have just gone through basic training for a couple months the summer before, and probably hadn't killed any vampires since then. And even during training, he'd never taken a vampire in a solo fight (except for that last right before the explosion, but I don't even know if that should really count). Also, he tells Vlad, "I'm a Slayer. I think I'd know a vampire if I saw one" (or something like that), which doesn't make much sense if, as we see in this book, he'd already been duped so thoroughly before. That would have left an impression on him, so even disregarding the untruth of the statement, he wouldn't have said it with such a seemingly cavalier attitude. Also, in this book, we never see him getting any training on how to identify a vampire (or, really, how to fight one and how that's different from fighting a human), which seems weird since this book is all about him training to be a Slayer.
*Update: 2/27/14 I tried re-reading this book, and I really liked it a lot less. Actually, I got less than 70 pages in before I gave up and skimmed the rest. I realized that the only character I even like very much is Sirus, and I don't like how he's treated in the story. There's a lot of actions that people take that don't make any sense and seem to be there only to purposelessly make Joss's life harder (even Joss's own actions sometimes). And it should be tighter and shorter than it is.
Second read rating: 1 star DNF