Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Bone

Tall Tales

Rate this book
Ever wonder what happened before the Bone cousins got lost in the uncharted forest of the Valley? This is a hilarious companion to Jeff Smith's bestselling, award-winning BONE saga! Long before the Bone cousins were ever lost in the uncharted forest of the Valley, Big Johnson Bone, the discoverer of the Rolling Bone River, founded Boneville. But little is known of the mighty explorer's adventures before he started his famous trading post. So when Smiley Bone sits down with a group of young scouts to retell the legendary stories of Boneville's origins, what they hear are wild antics complete with Rat Creatures, Dragons, and a snarky little monkey!

128 pages, Hardcover

First published January 1, 2010

93 people are currently reading
4230 people want to read

About the author

Jeff Smith

620 books1,422 followers
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See other authors with similar names.

Born and raised in the American mid-west, Jeff Smith learned about cartooning from comic strips, comic books, and watching animation on TV. In 1991, he launched a company called Cartoon Books to publish his comic book BONE, a comedy/adventure about three lost cousins from Boneville. Against all odds, the small company flourished, building a reputation for quality stories and artwork. Word of mouth, critical acclaim, and a string of major awards helped propel Cartoon Books and BONE to the forefront of the comic book industry.
In 1992, Jeff’s wife Vijaya Iyer joined the company as partner to handle publishing and distribution, licensing, and foreign language publications. In the Spring of 2005, Harry Potter’s U.S. publisher Scholastic Inc. entered the graphic novel market by launching a new imprint, Graphix with a full color version of BONE: Out from Boneville, bringing the underground comic to a new audience and a new generation.
In 2007, DC Comics released Smith’s first non-creator owned work, SHAZAM! Monster Society of Evil, a four-part mini-series recreating a classic serial from comic’s Golden Age. Between projects, Smith spends much of his time on the international guest circuit promoting comics and the art of graphic novels.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
7,630 (60%)
4 stars
2,722 (21%)
3 stars
1,717 (13%)
2 stars
382 (3%)
1 star
147 (1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 262 reviews
Profile Image for Chad.
10.2k reviews1,047 followers
January 13, 2022
Smiley Bone takes some Bone children camping where they proceed to tell tall tales around the fire. It's fun. Only the first 40 pages or so are new. The rest is filled out with the main story from Bone: Stupid Stupid Rat-Tails. It features Big Johnson Bone visiting the Valley where he rides a tornado and beats up rat creatures. He's also the reason why rat creatures no longer have tails.
Profile Image for Mario.
Author 1 book222 followers
March 29, 2015
It was so good to be back, once more, in the Bones world. Really missed those fellas.

Great collection of short stories. Enjoyed them all, especially first one, 'cause it brought us back to the beginning. Only wish it was longer.
Profile Image for Saturn.
603 reviews76 followers
November 24, 2023
Una serie di storielle simpatiche per gli amanti di Bone. L'ultima, la più lunga, è anche quella che merita maggiormente attenzione perché più articolata e con una serie di trovate divertenti - su tutti il personaggio della scimmia.
Noto con piacere che Collodi fa scuola... O lui, o Luciano di Samosata.
Profile Image for Mitchell Friedman.
5,741 reviews218 followers
December 17, 2021
The short stories were actually pretty cute. But they were overshadowed by the boring awfulness of Big Johnson Bone. It actually made Smiley seem pretty good. From an art point of view I think Bartleby is my favorite. This could have been worse.
Profile Image for Nikki in Niagara.
4,351 reviews162 followers
October 23, 2010
Reason for Reading: This is a Cybils '10 nominee and required reading for me as a panelist.

I have never read a Bone book in my life before this. I actually have reading the series as one of my goals for next year. Fortunately, Tall Tales is a collection of short stories that happen before the events of the Bone series making them entirely readable for someone who hasn't a clue about the series itself.

The book, which calls itself a "Companion" to the series is set in the here and now as Smiley and Bartleby take the Bone Scouts camping. As they sit around the campfire, Smiley tells some rather Tall Tales about the early days. One involves Fone Bone and Phoney Bone in the days before Thorn was Queen and the rest are about Big Johnson Bone's early adventures. There are a total of four stories with a segue back at camp connecting them. The first three are indeed short stories, while the fourth one takes up almost the entire book with the main tale of Johnson Bone's adventure of how he subdued the terror of the rat creatures.

I absolutely loved this and cannot wait to read the other books now that I've had this sampling. Not having read Bone previously did not hamper my enjoyment of Tall Tales one iota and in fact I can recommend it as a way to check and see if you'll enjoy the humour of Bone, which is hilarious. I was snorting out loud as I read which is not something I do often, believe me! Completely entertaining, hilariously funny and a sure-fire winner for any comic reader.
Profile Image for Tommy Hancock.
160 reviews18 followers
July 12, 2015
Very solid. As funny as you'd expect of something from the Bone universe. Tall Tales is a collection of, well, tall tales, most of which take place before the main adventure and do not feature any of the cast you know and love if you read the series(minus the ones around the fire telling the tales). The stories are well done and entertaining and even give some insight into the main storyline. Sadly, though, this one didn't pack the same punch as the main series of books. I recommend it to other Bone fans, but just don't expect more of the same Magic Smith gave you over the course of the first 9 volumes.
Profile Image for Ronald.
1,450 reviews17 followers
May 28, 2019
This was good. Just a bunch of tales that might have some connection to the main Bone story line. I'm still not sure putting Smiley in charge of children is a good idea. But better than introducing another character that is greedy selfish and only cares about others by accident. Oh well. Otherwise a good book.
Profile Image for Gabriel.
70 reviews4 followers
August 29, 2017
Some funny entertaiing stuff. Dfinitely more of a children's book than the rest of the Bone universe.
Profile Image for Joey Nardinelli.
852 reviews2 followers
April 4, 2021
I finished this probably a week ago before realizing I’d never go entered it. It’s a fun series of stories about Big Johnson Bone and the origins of the Jekk and some early interactions between the Bone ancestors and the creatures of the valley. Coda somewhere noted the significance of the American tall tale structure in these particular stories, which I find endearing for its mostly colorblind orientation (the bone characters, while definitively white, have they subjective quality of simple emotive features that Scott McCloud discusses in Understanding Comics; also a rare moment where I’ll call it colorblind but I’m sure there’s a better way to describe it). Oddly feels like a great entry point for kids to the series.
Profile Image for Nick Katenkamp.
1,517 reviews1 follower
March 9, 2021
2.5 stars. Bone: Tall Tales is not without its charm, but it is also not a necessary addition to the series. While fans may enjoy, Rose was a more interesting and worthy addition to the series than Tall Tales.
Profile Image for Mari Mankle.
494 reviews2 followers
January 8, 2023
This was a cute little addition to the collection! Some fun and interesting stories in here that just added more to the lore of the bones.
10 reviews
April 7, 2025
Why would I want to read about a wanna-be Paul Bunyan
250 reviews
June 15, 2024
Earlier tales related to the world of Bone, in the same style as the original series, told by Smiley to the bone children.
Profile Image for হাঁটুপানির জলদস্যু.
293 reviews228 followers
April 27, 2019
ফোন বোন, ফোনি বোন, আর স্মাইলি বোনের অতিমানব (অতিবোনব, to be more precise) পূর্বপুরুষ বিগ জনসন বোনের গপ্পো। ঠিক যেন ঘনাদার মুখে কনকিস্তাদোরপ‍্যাঁদানো ষোড়শ শতকের বিটকেলপুরুষ ঘনরাম দাসের কাহিনী। উপভোগ্য।
Profile Image for Jon Hewelt.
487 reviews8 followers
February 29, 2020
ReRead 29 February 2020
---
FINALLY done with Tall Tales. It wasn't a bad read, per se, but it felt . . . different from what I remembered of the original Bone, and not in a good way.

Whereas the original Bone series seemed transcendent of the Adult/Kid categories, this spin-off definitely felt like it was geared more towards kids. Which, I suppose, makes sense, as most libraries classify it as a Youth Graphic Novel.

But in doing so, I felt as if it lost some of the charm and flow that the original had. The morals come a little heavy-handed, being emphasized too much. The art too, is always lovely with Jeff Smith, but at times it felt a little stale.

I'm not disappointed by it. I liked the opening stories just fine. But I felt the last one, the meat and potatoes of the book, was a little too long. It's an origin story, sure, but it simultaneously felt too small and too large to adequately cover all of Big Johnson Bone's legacy.

Pick it up if you've read the Bone series already. It's a nifty little companion piece: I just wanted more from it.
Profile Image for Becky B.
9,190 reviews181 followers
April 4, 2016
Smiley and Bartleby take the Bone Scouts camping and entertain the youngsters around the fire with some tall tales about a treasure hunt and the birth of Big Johnson Bone. One of the Bone Scouts then has dreams about the further adventures of Big Johnson Bone, how he lost an eating contest to a girl, survived a tornado ride, and freed a valley from the torments of the Rat Creatures.

There were moments when this was outright hilarious, and moments when I was rolling my eyes at Big Johnson Bone's big ego. A fun graphic novel with some good examples of typical tall tale elements.

Notes on content: One minor swear word. No sexual content. There's a skinned butt of a rat creature shown. Big Johnson Bone and everyone else are definitely 100% cartoon in that they go through things that should kill them, like getting eaten, riding a tornado, etc. and are ok. Some stomach juice grossness, tail chopping and a massive fart may turn off some readers (while thrilling others).
Profile Image for Gideon.
187 reviews3 followers
November 6, 2012
it was a good book. it had two story's in it. the main thing is smiley from the graphic novels has a camp in the woods and three little bones and smiley tells story's about a old famous bone.
37 reviews1 follower
April 29, 2016
it is a really good book has a lot of story in it if you love books that have a lot of stories this is your book.It tells about all of the books and how they meet and that one book tells all about the other books and I think that was cool.
Profile Image for Pete.
510 reviews28 followers
September 5, 2015
Not anywhere close to the standard set by the main series run. Lots of juvenile fart jokes and a sequence that is a direct rip off of Pinocchio. Pass.
Profile Image for Madison Henson.
44 reviews2 followers
September 26, 2016
Love it when little boy who take Smiley's hat and put it on. He get some dreaming as vision. Until to awoke and it happened in his dreams when Smiley tells them stories.
Profile Image for Gal.
456 reviews
November 28, 2024
שני הסיפורים הראשונים הרבה יותר כיפיים מהשאר.
Profile Image for 寿理 宮本.
2,236 reviews16 followers
August 24, 2025
This series strikes me as one big

Homer \noun\ 1. American bonehead 2. Pull a Homer—to succeed despite idiocy (drawing of Homer Simpson)

That is, the impression I get is when the characters succeed, it isn't exactly from skill or competence, but some exact convergence of the one thing they're capable of doing and extreme luck. Big Johnson Bone in particular feels like he has gall going for him more than talent or knowhow.

Then again, it's called "Tall Tales," so exactly how much of it is true is in the air.

The first three tales are told by Smiley to the Bone Scouts* Ringo, Bingo, Todd, and Bartleby, and the last (and longest) one is dreamed by Todd:

1. Powers That Be
Basically a cautionary tale, where Phoney tries to get out of doing chores and gets . It's too bad Fone got dragged along, but perhaps because he's too nice to just leave Phoney to his own fate.

2. Baby Johnson Bone vs. Old Man Winter
I'm not familiar enough with the series to know anything about Big Johnson Bone, but luckily the rest of the book tells enough about him. This story is about how Old Man Winter stole Johnson away almost the instant he was born, but .

3. Big Johnson Bone vs. The Cobbler Gobbler
A story about a food-eating competition and also . It's funny, but also depressing in the way of the characters even jokingly can eat more food in a single day than entire towns would eat in a week, and where exactly is all this food coming from in a *frontier town*...?

Yes, it's comedy, but it's also a ridiculous amount of WASTE. (If you're eating twice your body weight every day, guess what ELSE you're doing every day!)

4. The Lost Tale of Big Johnson Bone
Todd dreams this after swiping Smiley's Big Hat and wearing it to sleep: A long (compared to the other Tall Tales) story about Big Johnson, his pack animal** Blossom, and a talking monkey he "won" after cheating in a card game, encountering the rat monsters, and , as foreshadowed by Bartleby's "tale"—more of an explanation, since "rat creatures aren't very good at telling stories."

It's an interesting, but probably better enjoyed as a fan of the series. Newcomers might be confused, but hard to say.

*The fact that "Bone" everything exists makes me think they are, literally, talking bones (femurs in specific), but that seems patently WEIRD. Even so, tagging "talking objects" for that reason.

**I suspect a donkey, but I also can't rule out I don't actually know if she's a "real" animal or a Bone-specific one
1,607 reviews12 followers
July 18, 2017
Smiley has agreed to take the Bone Scouts and Bartleby camping…but you can’t have camping without stories by the fire. With the Bone Scouts and Bartleby as his enchanted listeners, Smiley tells them the tales of the adventurer Big Johnson Bone and his venture into the Big Valley long before Smiley, Fone, and Phoney found it. Big Johnson Bone’s encountered changed the course of the Valley and altered the lives of Rat Creatures forever!

Bone: Tall Tales is a compilation book which contains part of the series Stupid, Stupid Rat Tails #1-3 (December 1999-February 2000) by Tom Sniegoski in addition to new, original material by Jeff Smith. The standalone story was reprinted along with the color reprints of Bone by Scholastic.

I loved Bone, but I primarily liked the Bones. Both Stupid, Stupid Rat Tails and Rose were nice addendums to the series, but I always preferred to stick to the core storyline. Rereading Bone: Tall Tales reminds me why.

Bone: Tall Tales isn’t bad, but it also isn’t Bone. The story since it is short stories is rather fragmented and Big Johnson Bone just isn’t as compelling of a character as the cousins. Tom Sniegoski took the idea of American folklore like Paul Bunyan and Pecos Bill and wrapped it up into the story.

I love the Rat Creatures so the story does have that going for it. It is kind of odd that Smith allowed Sniegoski to reveal the “secret origin” of his great creations, but I imagine he had a lot of say on how the story was scripted and presented. The loss of the tails due to Big Bone Johnson fits in with the folklore aspect of the story but still isn’t as fun as the original series.

Fortunately, Jeff Smith did provide the art for both the series and the story. I think Rose worked because of how the story evolved, but taking another artist for this story just wouldn’t have worked. The Bones feel like they belong to Smith even more so than some other comic creations…they’re design is simple, but Smith breathes so much life into them in his work.

If you are a fan of Bone or a parent who wants more Bone to read to their kid, this volume is a much more family friendly version than some of the later volumes of Bone itself. The story is for completionists but still provides a quick Bone fix for those who miss the characters…plus, it is nice to see that the characters moved on after they left the Valley.
Profile Image for Comics Appreciation Project.
113 reviews
November 15, 2022
Bone: Tall Tales by Jeff Smith (Cartoon Books)

My favorite run in all of comics. After all these years and rereads, the characters feel like family to me now. I couldn't wait to share them with my children.

From humble buildings, to a Scholastic juggernaut, this series won eleven (11) Eisner Awards and eleven (11) Harvey Awards. I own both the original black and white hardcover versions and the new Scholastic color versions. The series is divided into nine books making three distinct acts. The first two acts are some of the best in comics. The character interactions are so enjoyable. However, the series does get darker as it goes on, so by the third and final act, we are pretty deep into the world Smith built and we have lost most of the whimsy and charm that resonated so well at the beginning. However, Smith sticks the landing and he has endured as one of the most beloved independent creators in the medium. I met him years ago at a convention and he was gracious and sincere. I hope Netflix can get the animated series back under production. If you haven't read this series, what are you waiting for?

I loved the format of this hardcover. This is a popular size for kids books, however I thought the corners were more sharp than most of the similar books in its category. I was disappointed that Scholastic didn't print more this way. I agree with some of the other reviews that the short stories don't capture quite the same charm as the original story...but I'll take all I can get from Jeff Smith.
Profile Image for Stephanie Bange.
2,052 reviews21 followers
May 30, 2021
REVIEWED October 1, 2010
Rating: Recommended
Recommended Grade Levels: 3-12

Smiley Bone takes the Bone Scouts camping. They pitch their tents after dark and sit by the campfire listening to Smiley tell stories about the past. First, Smiley tells them about the time Thorn tricked Fone Bone and Phoney Bone into doing the laundry by hiding a treasure map so they could find the “treasure”—their dirty laundry. The scouts beg for more stories. Smiley obliges by sharing some of the adventures of Big Johnson Bone, the founder of Boneville. Broken into five chapters, the stories flow together because of the short passages featuring Smiley and the Bone Scouts inserted between the stories; their conversation contains segue set ups, providing smooth transitions between stories. The authors make good use of pace in this graphic novel, continually propelling the reader forward. Some chapters in this book were previously published in the comic book Stupid, Stupid Rat Tails by Jeff Smith (Cartoon Books, 1999). Readers need not be familiar with Bone to enjoy; this volume stands alone. Fans of Bone will gobble this up!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 262 reviews

Can't find what you're looking for?

Get help and learn more about the design.