What do you think?
Rate this book
Soul Without Shame: A Guide to Liberating Yourself from the Judge Within
Whether we call it the inner critic, superego, or just plain nag, most of us have a "judge within" who's constantly on our case. A comprehensive guide to understanding how the inner critic works, this book offers practical, positive suggestions for breaking free of it. Using straightforward language and examples from everyday life, Byron Brown shows:
• Where the inner judge came from
• How it operates
• Why it trips us up
• Why we believe we need it
• How to develop awareness of it
• How to disengage from it
• The "soul qualities" we can develop to weaken its influence
Each chapter begins with an episode of the "Frank and Sue story," dramatically illustrating how the inner critic works; each chapter ends with a simple exercise designed to help the reader move along the path of self-discovery.
• Where the inner judge came from
• How it operates
• Why it trips us up
• Why we believe we need it
• How to develop awareness of it
• How to disengage from it
• The "soul qualities" we can develop to weaken its influence
Each chapter begins with an episode of the "Frank and Sue story," dramatically illustrating how the inner critic works; each chapter ends with a simple exercise designed to help the reader move along the path of self-discovery.
320 pages, Paperback
First published December 1, 1998
295 people are currently reading
1878 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews
June 12, 2013
Helpful. I preferred Hal Stone's "Embracing Your Inner Critic" for two reasons: 1) Brown works too hard to sell the reader on his own brand of spirituality and speaks in vague, esoteric language some of the time. Stone is more down to earth and leaves off the baggage of "the diamond approach" or whatever it was. 2) in the end, Stone has a more holistic, less adversarial vision for handling the critic (subverting and utilizing through "embracing" rather than overcoming) that I think is both more empowering and more realistic.
May 2, 2022
This book should come with a trigger warning. There are a LOT of negative self-talk examples throughout the book that are obviously designed to hit a nerve. While that can be helpful to getting to the core of an emotional wound, I found myself turning the book off in Audible several times because it was ruining my mood with it’s screwed negative-to-positive ratio of content. I’m also not totally sure I agree with all of the methods discussed for silencing the inner-critic, but I think the author’s way of explaining what the inner-critic is and sounds like was extremely helpful, offered a unique perspective, and worth the read. Just be aware that you may find yourself skipping over several of the more graphic scenes in the book if you are trying to avoid spiraling into a day ruled by rumination on your past failures and traumatizing life events.
January 2, 2022
Byron Brown’s Soul Without Shame is a powerful and very enlightening book about the inner critic or judge. It brought much more clarity to an area that I haven’t previously given much thought. I was impressed with the thoroughness of the book; Brown goes into a great amount of detail about our true nature, how the judge distorts our reality and how we can defend against the judge.
The book starts by discussing each human’s soul, which is pure consciousness and the essence of who we are. Our soul or true nature can only be experienced as a field of awareness that contains our mind and body. Brown then describes the judge, which is a part of our mind, but not part of our true nature. In one sense, the soul and the judge are diametrically opposed entities, which was a new perspective for me.
I’ve often thought that having an inner critic is helpful for me to attain my goals. However, Brown points that out that the judge actually resists movement toward growth and development. It does this by maintaining the status quo: keeping me from what it might consider dangerous parts of myself and directing me towards ideals that will make me more successful. Again, my eyes were more opened to this shift in perspective.
As I continued reading, and as Brown actually points out, I realized that judgement is much more pervasive in our consciousness than we realize. Much more than just criticism, the judge also works through guidelines, motivation, advise, and even praise! I began to see the judge in many more aspects of myself than I previously recognized. Even as I write this, I can feel the weight of this knowledge. It’s an unpleasant surprise to realize that the judge has been dictating much more of my life than I realized.
Brown then gets into how to deal with the judge, starting by not engaging with it. For any engagement further acknowledges the presence of the judge and gives it more life. I’ve been engaging with the judge most of my life by rationalizing, absorbing and collapsing. By not engaging, we can prevent any sustained effects of the judge’s attacks.
Next, we must learn to resist the judge, which I’m only just starting to do as I learn how to better identify the judge in my life. Resisting the judge is not subtle, but full of strength. As Brown points out, much of my strength has been suppressed by years of succumbing to the judge. I’m learning to find the strength to resist the judge, whenever it rears its head. I realize this will be a long process.
I was particularly inspired by the chapter where Brown discusses how the judge continually undermines our capacity for exploration. We often don’t think about our inner critic as it relates to exploration and joy. However, in its attempt to protect us from the world, the judge restricts the easy flow of the heart and the movement our soul. I think I felt this on some level, but I’m now much more aware of how the judge interferes with my sense of joy.
Perhaps the most powerful thing that I learned from this book is that compassion is the antidote to the judge. Anything that that judge might attempt is quickly neutralized by the compassion of an open heart. This has been the cornerstone of my own development as I learn to guard against the inner critic. However, I’m also learning this is a long process and will require some significant rewiring of my brain.
After finding self-compassion comes defending ourselves against the judge. Brown writes that this is a conscious act of reclaiming our strength and aggression and using it to speak in an active way. Actually speaking to my inner critic felt unusual at first, but as I do it more, it’s slowly becoming easier. In short, “Speak [to the judge] as though you expect to say nothing more.”
The last bit that stood out for me was Brown’s description of truth, which is knowing based on immediate contact with with reality through experience. It can be the ultimate ally in confronting the judge because our sense of knowing what’s true supports our ability to exist free of the judge’s influence. However, we may not recognize the truth because it often contradicts our judge’s need to maintain beliefs about ourself. So my intention is to be more in touch with my direct experience as a way to combat the judge.
Soul Without Shame is a wonderful source for clients who may be developing their relationship with with their inner critic. It can be useful reading as a complete book or specific chapters that are most relevant to a client. In addition to being a comprehensive guide to the inner critic, it also contains valuable insights on the soul perspective, acceptance, strength, spaciousness, self-value and truth. It’s been an invaluable tool for my developmental journey, and I’m sure it will provide value to many others.
The book starts by discussing each human’s soul, which is pure consciousness and the essence of who we are. Our soul or true nature can only be experienced as a field of awareness that contains our mind and body. Brown then describes the judge, which is a part of our mind, but not part of our true nature. In one sense, the soul and the judge are diametrically opposed entities, which was a new perspective for me.
I’ve often thought that having an inner critic is helpful for me to attain my goals. However, Brown points that out that the judge actually resists movement toward growth and development. It does this by maintaining the status quo: keeping me from what it might consider dangerous parts of myself and directing me towards ideals that will make me more successful. Again, my eyes were more opened to this shift in perspective.
As I continued reading, and as Brown actually points out, I realized that judgement is much more pervasive in our consciousness than we realize. Much more than just criticism, the judge also works through guidelines, motivation, advise, and even praise! I began to see the judge in many more aspects of myself than I previously recognized. Even as I write this, I can feel the weight of this knowledge. It’s an unpleasant surprise to realize that the judge has been dictating much more of my life than I realized.
Brown then gets into how to deal with the judge, starting by not engaging with it. For any engagement further acknowledges the presence of the judge and gives it more life. I’ve been engaging with the judge most of my life by rationalizing, absorbing and collapsing. By not engaging, we can prevent any sustained effects of the judge’s attacks.
Next, we must learn to resist the judge, which I’m only just starting to do as I learn how to better identify the judge in my life. Resisting the judge is not subtle, but full of strength. As Brown points out, much of my strength has been suppressed by years of succumbing to the judge. I’m learning to find the strength to resist the judge, whenever it rears its head. I realize this will be a long process.
I was particularly inspired by the chapter where Brown discusses how the judge continually undermines our capacity for exploration. We often don’t think about our inner critic as it relates to exploration and joy. However, in its attempt to protect us from the world, the judge restricts the easy flow of the heart and the movement our soul. I think I felt this on some level, but I’m now much more aware of how the judge interferes with my sense of joy.
Perhaps the most powerful thing that I learned from this book is that compassion is the antidote to the judge. Anything that that judge might attempt is quickly neutralized by the compassion of an open heart. This has been the cornerstone of my own development as I learn to guard against the inner critic. However, I’m also learning this is a long process and will require some significant rewiring of my brain.
After finding self-compassion comes defending ourselves against the judge. Brown writes that this is a conscious act of reclaiming our strength and aggression and using it to speak in an active way. Actually speaking to my inner critic felt unusual at first, but as I do it more, it’s slowly becoming easier. In short, “Speak [to the judge] as though you expect to say nothing more.”
The last bit that stood out for me was Brown’s description of truth, which is knowing based on immediate contact with with reality through experience. It can be the ultimate ally in confronting the judge because our sense of knowing what’s true supports our ability to exist free of the judge’s influence. However, we may not recognize the truth because it often contradicts our judge’s need to maintain beliefs about ourself. So my intention is to be more in touch with my direct experience as a way to combat the judge.
Soul Without Shame is a wonderful source for clients who may be developing their relationship with with their inner critic. It can be useful reading as a complete book or specific chapters that are most relevant to a client. In addition to being a comprehensive guide to the inner critic, it also contains valuable insights on the soul perspective, acceptance, strength, spaciousness, self-value and truth. It’s been an invaluable tool for my developmental journey, and I’m sure it will provide value to many others.
March 24, 2023
Wish I would have read this book in my 20s but better late than never tbh
March 26, 2020
When the student is ready the teacher is revealed.
I came across this book at a floatation centre and I couldn't put it down. So I bought a copy.
I was currently doing an inner bonding course with Dr Margaret Paul and this book was perfectly aligned with her teachings.
For truth seekers. For those wishing to come home to their true nature.
I came across this book at a floatation centre and I couldn't put it down. So I bought a copy.
I was currently doing an inner bonding course with Dr Margaret Paul and this book was perfectly aligned with her teachings.
For truth seekers. For those wishing to come home to their true nature.
November 2, 2021
"A child leaves her body until it is safe to return."
December 31, 2019
A clear and detailed book about how our inner judge prevents us from living in awareness and presence. This is a book to work with not just read and gives examples of how the judge dominates our thinking thus affecting every aspect of life. This is a book I will re read many times I think.
August 12, 2016
Self judgment really has held me back. This book provided me with insight that has helped me understand how to really work on those issues and break the cycle. And it's working.
The book was loaned to me and the person said 'give it a try'. I don't buy these books. Picked it up weeks later and started reading the chapter on 'The Judge'. It clearly explained where all this crap started, without the use of Ego and Super Ego terms.
Note
I didn't start at the beginning so I had no idea it was associated with the Diamond Heart work. Aah, I might check into it now, thanks to the reviewer who slammed it.
Hippy/New Age writing, not in the chapters I read.
This book is written for the 'lay' person, not a therapist or self-help want-to-be therapist.
The book was loaned to me and the person said 'give it a try'. I don't buy these books. Picked it up weeks later and started reading the chapter on 'The Judge'. It clearly explained where all this crap started, without the use of Ego and Super Ego terms.
Note
I didn't start at the beginning so I had no idea it was associated with the Diamond Heart work. Aah, I might check into it now, thanks to the reviewer who slammed it.
Hippy/New Age writing, not in the chapters I read.
This book is written for the 'lay' person, not a therapist or self-help want-to-be therapist.
March 19, 2015
This had a lot of good advice, but delivered it in an odd philosophical way. I also do not agree with the use of aggression to disarm the inner critic. It just seemed to me to exacerbate the problem, not soothe it. Spontaneity as a useful tool - yes, but verbal abuse is how we got in this situation in the first place, why in the world encourage more of such behavior inside your head?
Read
August 17, 2012Most valuable section for me was on anger. The "unfolding day" was a good aid for applying the learning.
December 22, 2018
Seems like I don't have enough shame left in me to truly benefit from this book :)
February 8, 2019
If you are hard or critical of yourself, get this book. It's the best book I know about dealing with the superego, and how to treat ourselves and other people with respect, and why we fail to do so.
July 14, 2020
This book is a bit repetitive and could have been condensed to half it's size. Though the author makes some excellent points and this is a book that helps us look deeply at our own thought patterns.
August 4, 2025
What I cannot understand is why a book about the inner judge/critic is written in the voice of the inner critic.
The author has chosen to address the reader directly. 'You' is probably the most frequent word in the book.
So he tells you why your life is the way it is, what you are doing wrong, and what you should do instead. This is identical to the way the inner critic speaks.
Consequently, listening to this audiobook was annoying and exhausting.
I don't think the concepts in the book are bad, but the presentation made it hard for me to connect with them. This discrepancy also makes me question the author's understanding of the topic.
I finally liberated myself from the voice of the judge within by quitting reading the book (at approx 40%).
The author has chosen to address the reader directly. 'You' is probably the most frequent word in the book.
So he tells you why your life is the way it is, what you are doing wrong, and what you should do instead. This is identical to the way the inner critic speaks.
Consequently, listening to this audiobook was annoying and exhausting.
I don't think the concepts in the book are bad, but the presentation made it hard for me to connect with them. This discrepancy also makes me question the author's understanding of the topic.
I finally liberated myself from the voice of the judge within by quitting reading the book (at approx 40%).
October 29, 2024
We all have that inner “judge” constantly evaluating every step we take, every decision, success, and mistake. Freud called it the superego, and being its slave can trap us in decisions dictated by that judge.
This book reveals techniques to free ourselves from it. And it all comes down to one essential thing: being present, living in the here and now.
Everything else is just noise. We already have the answer—now it’s a matter of working on it. Are you ready to try? #Mindfulness #Presence #PersonalGrowth
This book reveals techniques to free ourselves from it. And it all comes down to one essential thing: being present, living in the here and now.
Everything else is just noise. We already have the answer—now it’s a matter of working on it. Are you ready to try? #Mindfulness #Presence #PersonalGrowth
December 24, 2024
I found the writing a little robotic. I found it difficult to concentrate - the audiobook made me very sleepy. Perhaps it was the monotone voice of the audiobook narrator.
A lot of this resonated with me.
It's great to have a book that really gets into the whole "self-talk" thing.
Most of the book focuses on identifying and working to reduce the inner Judge. The book does give some practical solutions and examples but it can be hard to tease this out of the language which sometimes comes across as pure psychobabble.
A lot of this resonated with me.
It's great to have a book that really gets into the whole "self-talk" thing.
Most of the book focuses on identifying and working to reduce the inner Judge. The book does give some practical solutions and examples but it can be hard to tease this out of the language which sometimes comes across as pure psychobabble.
November 3, 2021
I almost skipped this book due to the vagueness of its title (the 'Soul Without Shame' part) but it proved to have a clear, well explained and important message, with insightful real life examples.
I am sure I will come back to it for reminders in the future, it's a game changer for me as I'm sure it's been for many people who are dedicated to the inner work.
I am sure I will come back to it for reminders in the future, it's a game changer for me as I'm sure it's been for many people who are dedicated to the inner work.
September 5, 2022
I recommend this book to everyone. This book changed my life. I can't see the world the same way. I found it difficult it to read, and at times it felt like I was moving through a muddy marsh, but the journey always felt worth it. I hope to come back to this book, as there are lessons that I'll need to revisit throughout my life.
April 11, 2023
absolutely brilliant
The first time I read this book some years back, I wasn’t ready. Reading it again now, and I get it. It’s one of the most practical and direct books on the practice of letting go of attachment and resistance and embracing presence. Through addressing the internal judge that’s essentially an internalised parent-child.
The first time I read this book some years back, I wasn’t ready. Reading it again now, and I get it. It’s one of the most practical and direct books on the practice of letting go of attachment and resistance and embracing presence. Through addressing the internal judge that’s essentially an internalised parent-child.
March 31, 2021
Dethrone the judge, forgive your inner child, and become present in your innate worth. Kind of unusual in its mix of expletives with new age sounding psychology, yet many points did ring true. Enjoyed.
July 4, 2021
The best book I've read on liberating ourselves from the inner critic. This book helps readers identify the origins of "the judge within," recognize its tricks, and break free of the limiting chains it's been using to hold us back.
November 24, 2018
an utterly essential resource.
December 21, 2018
Powerful tool to help me view my inner truth and disengage from judgements.
August 12, 2020
The first half of the book I found really interesting and useful. I lost my attention regularly during the last few chapters. There was a lot of repeating the same info.
August 25, 2020
A clear, accessible and guided approach to recognizing and defending against that inner critic, or judge or super ego.
October 15, 2020
Sometimes a little wordy, but ultimately delivers a useful and infinitely relatable set of truths and tools.
March 20, 2021
Thought provoking and practical.
May 1, 2021
An excellent resource on the mechanics of shame and how to disengage from your inner critic.
May 17, 2023
This book has some valuable information, but the narrator nearly put me to sleep in this audiobook.
September 27, 2023
Bit heavy going. Good ideas, very valuable, but needs a more succinct approach. Some of the sexual references were rather creepy, in my opinion!
Displaying 1 - 30 of 48 reviews