Loy Machedo’s Book Review - Still Surprised: A Memoir of a Life in Leadership by Warren Bennis and Patricia Ward Biederman
Warren Bennis Who?
Born in 1977, being raised as an Indian in the Middle East (Dubai) and reading Self-Help books only a few years ago, I seriously had no idea who Warren Bennis was. However, since his name came up in the Leadership genre, I decided to pick up the book anyways.
So here is a brief intro of Warren Bennis (courtesy Wikipedia).
Warren Gamaliel Bennis (born March 8, 1925) is an American scholar, organizational consultant and author, widely regarded as a pioneer of the contemporary field in the avenue of Leadership studies. Bennis is University Professor and Distinguished Professor of Business Administration and Founding Chairman of The Leadership Institute at the University of Southern California.
Now, this being his first book which I got my hands on, I was excited. In fact, even Tom Butler-Bowdon praised his book on Leadership titled “On Becoming A Leader” as among the Top 50 Success Classics of all Time made me want to read his material even more.
But as checked the ratings on amazon, I was confused. “On Becoming a Leader” had only 65 Reviews with an average rating of 3.8. And then to make matters worse, this book highlighted only 11 Reviews with an average rating of 4.5 – which I am sure must have been done by his well-wishers (or by appointed reviewers)
So, I read the book from cover to cover and this is a brief outline of what I have to say about the book:
1) In the 1st Half, Bennis talks about 2 World Wars experiences he had at the age of 19, his years as a Student at Antioch College in Yellow Springs, Ohio, the impact of Captain Bessinger, Douglas McGregor and his former wife Lucille Rose, his relocation to Boston area where he continued his education at MIT
2) He discusses his year abroad studying at the London School of Economics, his renewed association with MIT and the intellectual community in Cambridge, his involvement with the National Training Laboratories and its T-groups, the Institute for Management and IMEDE in Lausanne, the State University of New York at Buffalo, the University of Cincinnati, and the University of Southern California; also time on the faculties of Harvard and Boston University, the Indian Institute of Management Calcutta (IIM-C), INSEAD and IMD. He also discusses his service as chairman of the Advisory Board of the Center for Public Leadership at Harvard University's Kennedy School, as a visiting professor of leadership at the University of Exeter (UK) and as a senior fellow at UCLA's School of Public Policy and Social Research.
3) The current and last years of his life where he takes to what old age does to you and makes you go through.
Parts of the book I loved:
1) The author maintains an informal, almost conversational tone with his reader without seeming disingenuous or self-serving.
2) I was quite surprised that the author had been to IIM Calcutta and stayed in India for a brief period of time.
3) And if there was one chapter I could say I loved the most, it was the ending – the last chapter where he gave an account of what old age does to you. He was unashamed to expose himself as a physically dependent person who was in the last autumn of his life.
Drawbacks to this book:
1) If you do not know who Warren Bennis is or if you are not familiar with the American Culture / Personalities present at that time period, you will surely get lost reading this book.
2) Almost three-quarters of the book is filled with the author’s recollection of his younger days and towards the ending – the harsh realities of the incoming old age. So if you are anything like me, only the last chapter may appeal to you.
3) The book is not a recipe for leadership or management. Neither is it a compelling autobiography. Rather I felt, it was a reflective memoir which the author decided to put up as he was entering the last moments of his life. So, which is why I guess it has not appealed to the readers at large. Personally, I only liked the last few pages. The rest was a total waste.
Moment of Truth
A book with many pages, lots of memories and episodes – which may not appeal to most readers. If you can get your hands to read the last few chapters, that would be enough. Otherwise, the book is a total waste.
Overall Rating
2 out of 10.
Loy Machedo
loymachedo.com | loymachedo.tv