What do you think?
Rate this book
Mark of the Lion #1-3
Mark of the Lion Trilogy
This classic series has inspired nearly two million readers. Both loyal fans and new readers will want the latest edition of this beloved series. Books in this latest edition include a foreword from the publisher, a preface from Francine Rivers, and discussion questions suitable for personal and group use.
#1 A Voice in the Wind: Torn by her love for a handsome aristocrat, a young slave girl clings to her faith in the living God for deliverance from the forces of decadent Rome.
#2 An Echo in the Darkness: Turning away from the opulence of Rome, Marcus is led by a whispering voice from the past into a journey that could set him free from the darkness of his soul.
#3 As Sure As the Dawn: Atretes. German warrior. Revered gladiator. He won his freedom through his fierceness . . . but his life is about to change forever.
#1 A Voice in the Wind: Torn by her love for a handsome aristocrat, a young slave girl clings to her faith in the living God for deliverance from the forces of decadent Rome.
#2 An Echo in the Darkness: Turning away from the opulence of Rome, Marcus is led by a whispering voice from the past into a journey that could set him free from the darkness of his soul.
#3 As Sure As the Dawn: Atretes. German warrior. Revered gladiator. He won his freedom through his fierceness . . . but his life is about to change forever.
1468 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1993
About the author
Francine Rivers
60 books21.8k followersNew York Times bestselling author Francine Rivers continues to win both industry acclaim and reader loyalty around the globe. Her numerous bestsellers include Redeeming Love, A Voice in the Wind, and Bridge to Haven, and her work has been translated into more than thirty different languages. She is a member of Romance Writers of America's coveted Hall of Fame as well as a recipient of the Lifetime Achievement Award from American Christian Fiction Writers (ACFW).
www.francinerivers.com
www.facebook.com/FrancineRivers
Twitter: @FrancineRivers
www.francinerivers.com
www.facebook.com/FrancineRivers
Twitter: @FrancineRivers
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 921 reviews
November 23, 2009
Absolutely one of the BEST series I've read. This is another author I resisted reading...for y-e-a-r-s because I had preconceived opinions about what she would write because she's a Christian.
I was so very, very wrong.
The story begins in early Rome with a young girl character. By the end of the book, she's grown, and you will have run a gamut of emotions, experienced love, total suspense, extreme pain, joy, tears, hope, fear, and burning anger, and I would be surprised if you don't lie awake many nights thinking, "I've GOT to put this book down and go to sleep....but I c-a-n-'t!"
The main character appears and plays a large part in the second book in the series but there are other characters that evolve and come to the forefront.
The story line continues over time and through the last book and through many situations pertinent to the time. And the culture and practices of the period are written with such detail that you are left with a solid understanding of what life was like in Rome and how people lived.
This is a love story, a history, a story of cruelty and torture and hate and unconditional love, varying relationships and all the dynamics involved, and amazing characters and the events in their lives. I can't recommend it highly enough.
I was so very, very wrong.
The story begins in early Rome with a young girl character. By the end of the book, she's grown, and you will have run a gamut of emotions, experienced love, total suspense, extreme pain, joy, tears, hope, fear, and burning anger, and I would be surprised if you don't lie awake many nights thinking, "I've GOT to put this book down and go to sleep....but I c-a-n-'t!"
The main character appears and plays a large part in the second book in the series but there are other characters that evolve and come to the forefront.
The story line continues over time and through the last book and through many situations pertinent to the time. And the culture and practices of the period are written with such detail that you are left with a solid understanding of what life was like in Rome and how people lived.
This is a love story, a history, a story of cruelty and torture and hate and unconditional love, varying relationships and all the dynamics involved, and amazing characters and the events in their lives. I can't recommend it highly enough.
July 29, 2016
This has got to be the best, and I mean, THE best Christian trilogy I've ever read. You know those good ol movies such as Ben Hur and The Robe? This trilogy reminded me of the movies. In fact, how I wish they would make a movie out of the books!
The only problem I have with the series (two of the books anyway) is Hadassah, the heroine of the tale. She was too perfect, too good, and... she spoke Christianese. What I'm saying is this - nobody is that perfect a Christian in real life. Although Hadassah is a meek and fearful person, she was never angry, never hated anyone and never imperfect in her behaviour when it comes to being a Christian. Therefore, I found it difficult to relate to her.
Marcus, on the other hand, is a well-rounded, flawed character. Someone who has doubts, someone who gets angry, hates, gets disgusted and yet is capable of love and compassion. That's a real human being there.
Still, the series is simply amazing. I couldn't put it down, and created a love in me for all things Roman. If you know any more Christian novels set during Roman Times, do tell me. I'm always on the prowl for one. Meanwhile, let me slake that thirst with Rosemary Sutcliff's works...
The only problem I have with the series (two of the books anyway) is Hadassah, the heroine of the tale. She was too perfect, too good, and... she spoke Christianese. What I'm saying is this - nobody is that perfect a Christian in real life. Although Hadassah is a meek and fearful person, she was never angry, never hated anyone and never imperfect in her behaviour when it comes to being a Christian. Therefore, I found it difficult to relate to her.
Marcus, on the other hand, is a well-rounded, flawed character. Someone who has doubts, someone who gets angry, hates, gets disgusted and yet is capable of love and compassion. That's a real human being there.
Still, the series is simply amazing. I couldn't put it down, and created a love in me for all things Roman. If you know any more Christian novels set during Roman Times, do tell me. I'm always on the prowl for one. Meanwhile, let me slake that thirst with Rosemary Sutcliff's works...
October 6, 2008
Loved, loved, loved, them!!! These are can't put down, aren't going to feed the kids or the dog, not doing laundry kind of books!
April 30, 2017
Books 1 & 2 need to be read as if they are one book. If not, all the darkness (esp Julia) in book 1 may turn you off bc it nearly did for me. Plus, it's tough to get into at first, but don't give up. Book 2 is the redemption part! SO good. I loved it! Couldn't get enough of book 2 and I didn't want it to ever end.
I have mixed feelings about Book 3. I rated it 3.5 stars/5 but I was disappointed about the last quarter of the book, esp Atretes treatment of Rizpah. It's still a good book but it frustrated me and made me not like the trilogy (as a whole) as much.
So, I definitely recommend the first two books with book 3 being optional. These books will make you think, learn some historical facts, and maybe make you cry...at least they did for me. Good stuff!
I have mixed feelings about Book 3. I rated it 3.5 stars/5 but I was disappointed about the last quarter of the book, esp Atretes treatment of Rizpah. It's still a good book but it frustrated me and made me not like the trilogy (as a whole) as much.
So, I definitely recommend the first two books with book 3 being optional. These books will make you think, learn some historical facts, and maybe make you cry...at least they did for me. Good stuff!
June 18, 2008
I cannot say how much I love these books! I read them every couple of years. The characters come alive and I think about them often. Sometimes I will find myself asking "what would Hadassah do in this situation?" A MUST READ!!
September 4, 2013
These three books are amazing! The first book takes a little while to get pulled into, but once you do, you won't put either of the books down! Amazing series with several stories being told within. Top 10 of my favorite books!
January 2, 2020
I have to admit, most Christian fiction would only get a C from me. I don’t give out five stars lightly, and most of this genre of literature just isn’t that good.
And then there’s these books. They made me cry — really cry — more than once. They made me double over with laughter, and cease to breathe in anticipation.
They are masterfully written and absolutely unforgettable.
The characters are rounded and engaging, the plot has a good pace, and religion is woven throughout without coming off as preachy!
The romance grips the heart and gives the stomach butterflies (without being smutty?! Who knew THAT was possible! *side-eyes every other romance novel accusingly*)
It felt like the Christian conviction of the characters bared my soul, and convicted me on more than one level. They’ve changed my spiritual life for the better.
Read them. Whether you’re Christian or not — read them.
And then there’s these books. They made me cry — really cry — more than once. They made me double over with laughter, and cease to breathe in anticipation.
They are masterfully written and absolutely unforgettable.
The characters are rounded and engaging, the plot has a good pace, and religion is woven throughout without coming off as preachy!
The romance grips the heart and gives the stomach butterflies (without being smutty?! Who knew THAT was possible! *side-eyes every other romance novel accusingly*)
It felt like the Christian conviction of the characters bared my soul, and convicted me on more than one level. They’ve changed my spiritual life for the better.
Read them. Whether you’re Christian or not — read them.
April 18, 2017
Francine Rivers books never fail to give me deeper insight into the heart of Christ and His love for the world, as well as spark my faith. Reading these books is a reminder of the power and presence of Christ. The author doesn't shrink from hard topics or gloss over human pain. It's all there, raw and un-hidden, a testament to the glory of God.
These books are passionate and emotional, so prepare yourself for all kinds of drama. I am both passionate and emotional, so the series fit me well, but I'm not sure how well the kind of people who didn't cry at the end of Toy Story 3 would appreciate it.
In my opinion, the best part of the books is the mindset that they put you in. I always walked away from these books with prayer swirling around in my head. It's amazing how much just a book can change the way a person looks at the world and approaches the throne of God.
A good read, heavy in drama and emotion, impossible to put down, and uplifting and encouraging.
Unless you didn't cry at the end of Toy Story 3, in which case I don't have anything for you.
These books are passionate and emotional, so prepare yourself for all kinds of drama. I am both passionate and emotional, so the series fit me well, but I'm not sure how well the kind of people who didn't cry at the end of Toy Story 3 would appreciate it.
In my opinion, the best part of the books is the mindset that they put you in. I always walked away from these books with prayer swirling around in my head. It's amazing how much just a book can change the way a person looks at the world and approaches the throne of God.
A good read, heavy in drama and emotion, impossible to put down, and uplifting and encouraging.
Unless you didn't cry at the end of Toy Story 3, in which case I don't have anything for you.
November 3, 2024
Opening line of Book 1. 'The city was silently bloating in the hot sun, rotting like the thousands of bodies that lay where they had fallen in street battles.'
Opening line of Book 2. 'Alexander Democedes Amandinus stood at the Door of Death waiting for a chance to learn more about life.'
Opening line of Book 3. 'The guard of the lower dungeon threw the bolt and led the way.'
The Mark of the Lion series was the first thing I read by Francine Rivers, and it is the series that is responsible for making Francine Rivers one of my favorite authors.
These books impacted me greatly. I recently reread the books for the third or fourth time (I can't remember for sure!) and it was just as interesting as the first time. There are a few historical inaccuracies, as well as one or two scenes that do not ring true in regard to character development, but Francine Rivers is still one of the most emotionally charged, and memorable writers of Christian fiction.
The first book, A Voice in the Wind, was written in 1993, as a statement of faith by the author, as she found herself too timid in witnessing to others about her newfound faith. The main character, Hadassah, suffers from this same timidity, and it is refreshing to have a heroine who has to grow in faith, and who deals with some very human failings. Hadassah is gentle, plain, and a great role model, as she fights against temptation, is obedient, and always strives to do the Lord's will. Some readers find Hadassah too perfect, but indeed she is not. If it takes her until the last chapters of a 400-plus page book to speak of her Christian faith, she certainly does suffer from fear!
The three main characters are Hadassah, Marcus, and Atretes. Marcus is a fascinating character, and some of my favorite sections are those dealing with him, especially in the second book. Marcus' sister Julia is also a focal point of the story, and while she provides interest, she is also sometimes extremely irritating, as she makes one wrong decision after another. But she is also an excellent example of how God loves all of us, even the most wayward.
Book 2 is An Echo in the Darkness, and it is my personal favorite of the series, as it deals with Marcus more personally, and has some beautiful passages about forgiveness, love, and healing. Book 2 bears out what you are beginning to think while reading book 1, that Hadassah is one of the loveliest, and most memorable heroines in all of fiction. And if the end of book 2 does not bring tears to your eyes, I don't know what will.
Book 3 is As Sure as the Dawn. This is the book that keeps me from giving the series 5 stars.
As Sure as the Dawn is slightly longer than book 2, and Hadassah and Marcus are not in it at all. The main reasons this book falls short are as follows-- this book is more detailed than it needs to be when it comes to physical desire, and Atretes' immoral thoughts. A good part of Atretes and Rizpah's relationship is built solely on physical attraction, and I found them hard to sympathize with, especially as they are both very frustrating at times! Also I find it a little hard to understand why Francine Rivers decided to have numerous miracles happen to Rizpah, and not to Hadassah. Hadassah is far more faithful and devout, yet it is Rizpah that (SPOILER ALERT!) is raised from the dead, and then miraculously saved from death a second time. Why Rizpah?
The entire series deals with mature subjects, including physical relationships, abortion, death, pagan religion, starvation, venereal disease, and homosexuality. So these stories are not for younger readers, but for someone more mature they are worth reading, and highly recommended.
All in all, my opinion is this-- Book 1 and book 2 are outstanding, but book 3 is worth skipping, at least upon reread.
Opening line of Book 2. 'Alexander Democedes Amandinus stood at the Door of Death waiting for a chance to learn more about life.'
Opening line of Book 3. 'The guard of the lower dungeon threw the bolt and led the way.'
The Mark of the Lion series was the first thing I read by Francine Rivers, and it is the series that is responsible for making Francine Rivers one of my favorite authors.
These books impacted me greatly. I recently reread the books for the third or fourth time (I can't remember for sure!) and it was just as interesting as the first time. There are a few historical inaccuracies, as well as one or two scenes that do not ring true in regard to character development, but Francine Rivers is still one of the most emotionally charged, and memorable writers of Christian fiction.
The first book, A Voice in the Wind, was written in 1993, as a statement of faith by the author, as she found herself too timid in witnessing to others about her newfound faith. The main character, Hadassah, suffers from this same timidity, and it is refreshing to have a heroine who has to grow in faith, and who deals with some very human failings. Hadassah is gentle, plain, and a great role model, as she fights against temptation, is obedient, and always strives to do the Lord's will. Some readers find Hadassah too perfect, but indeed she is not. If it takes her until the last chapters of a 400-plus page book to speak of her Christian faith, she certainly does suffer from fear!
The three main characters are Hadassah, Marcus, and Atretes. Marcus is a fascinating character, and some of my favorite sections are those dealing with him, especially in the second book. Marcus' sister Julia is also a focal point of the story, and while she provides interest, she is also sometimes extremely irritating, as she makes one wrong decision after another. But she is also an excellent example of how God loves all of us, even the most wayward.
Book 2 is An Echo in the Darkness, and it is my personal favorite of the series, as it deals with Marcus more personally, and has some beautiful passages about forgiveness, love, and healing. Book 2 bears out what you are beginning to think while reading book 1, that Hadassah is one of the loveliest, and most memorable heroines in all of fiction. And if the end of book 2 does not bring tears to your eyes, I don't know what will.
Book 3 is As Sure as the Dawn. This is the book that keeps me from giving the series 5 stars.
As Sure as the Dawn is slightly longer than book 2, and Hadassah and Marcus are not in it at all. The main reasons this book falls short are as follows-- this book is more detailed than it needs to be when it comes to physical desire, and Atretes' immoral thoughts. A good part of Atretes and Rizpah's relationship is built solely on physical attraction, and I found them hard to sympathize with, especially as they are both very frustrating at times! Also I find it a little hard to understand why Francine Rivers decided to have numerous miracles happen to Rizpah, and not to Hadassah. Hadassah is far more faithful and devout, yet it is Rizpah that (SPOILER ALERT!) is raised from the dead, and then miraculously saved from death a second time. Why Rizpah?
The entire series deals with mature subjects, including physical relationships, abortion, death, pagan religion, starvation, venereal disease, and homosexuality. So these stories are not for younger readers, but for someone more mature they are worth reading, and highly recommended.
All in all, my opinion is this-- Book 1 and book 2 are outstanding, but book 3 is worth skipping, at least upon reread.
October 16, 2009
The "Mark of the Lion" series was wonderfully written. The author, Francine Rivers, has done her homework, and writes about the tyranny of Rome (about 200 AD)in a way that transports you back to that era. Indeed, to crack the cover of these books and begin reading is very like discovering a time-machine and traveling back in time.
As Jerusalum falls, you are there, feeling the terror of the Jewish people and early Christains as Rome persecutes and and nearly exterminates a whole group of people. You feel the pain of the early Christains as they face the lions in the arenas of Rome. You feel the forgiveness and mercy of one fine young Christain Jew as she loves her enemies and grows to become what Christ would have us all to be.
The third book in the series was almost anti-climatic for me, and wasn't' up to the quality of the first two, but even then, the third book is an excellent read. I strongly recommend these books.
As Jerusalum falls, you are there, feeling the terror of the Jewish people and early Christains as Rome persecutes and and nearly exterminates a whole group of people. You feel the pain of the early Christains as they face the lions in the arenas of Rome. You feel the forgiveness and mercy of one fine young Christain Jew as she loves her enemies and grows to become what Christ would have us all to be.
The third book in the series was almost anti-climatic for me, and wasn't' up to the quality of the first two, but even then, the third book is an excellent read. I strongly recommend these books.
October 20, 2014
This was a book club pick -- something different than the usual, which I was all for. Here's what I liked: I am a Christian, but have never read the bible outside of church. This was a great history lesson on the beginning of Christianity. It stirred up many emotions inside of me -- good and bad. Here's what I didn't like: The author's POV woven throughout all 3 books. I would have preferred more of a historical perspective, but instead I got her ultra-rightwing Christian POV shoved down my throat. Also, the third book was very boring to me -- It seems like the story wasn't "big" enough to fit what the word count needed to be so she threw in a gazillion prayers in italicized writing. So, in short, unless you want to be preached to, skip this series.
January 31, 2013
I was never a reader of Christian fiction, but this collection was recommended by a good friend; she was reading it aloud to her family, and said they had a hard time putting it down. They couldn't wait to return to it the next evening.
I found myself in the same situation. This is so well done - every single book holds the interest and the reader is hard-pressed to take a break. I became very invested in the main characters and was dying to know what happened next.
Highly recommended. I have the trilogy and will re-read.
I found myself in the same situation. This is so well done - every single book holds the interest and the reader is hard-pressed to take a break. I became very invested in the main characters and was dying to know what happened next.
Highly recommended. I have the trilogy and will re-read.
September 20, 2007
Best books I've ever read in my life. Period.
December 20, 2013
Some of the best books I've ever read!
August 12, 2016
How else would I know anything about Roman culture and come up with the name, "Hadassah" for a child! I read these as a young girl and look forward to enjoying them again with my children.
February 10, 2013
Great series! Couldn't put the books down!
September 8, 2024
This will be the longest review I’ll ever give for a book/trilogy.
I knew this trilogy was high praised and I did my best, not having to high hopes since I didn’t want to be left with disappointment. I understand when people want to praise and advertise their favorites books but I’ve come to realize that to often people over-praise and you’re left with unmet expectations.
But since I didn’t have any for this trilogy I was fine.
I was probably even a little biased and thinking this was gonna be some cringey christian romance novel.
I started reading *a voice in the wind* because I was bored of any other Christian fiction since everything I had read before seemed soooo predictable. But not with this one!
Oh and also I had caught a cold, was bored so lots of time to read.
(Took me about 3 days. 18-20.8.24)
I started reading it and the first thing I liked:
- the different povs
I was shattered by how
- similar worldview and challenges we are facing nowadays (religion, lgbtq+, faith/spirituality, family, war, etc)
and probably the thing I liked most was how
- You couldn’t predict what was gonna happen
Since I don’t want this to be a spoiler review I will say only so much:
I was shocked after the last chapters of this first book. I believed this was gonna end in some happy-ever after-marriage-romance-situation. (Which I was rooting for) But no it did not. Francine knows how to torture her readers.
Excited for the next book. I don’t know what I want to see Marcus doing. But I know I want him to do something.
(Oh and also I really despise Julia. Sorry. Not a lot of compassion for her on my side. But I wouldn’t mind if she was ultimately delivered by Marcus? Imagine Atretes and her both coming to faith and ending up being married. Lol. Maybe not!).
*an echo in the darkness*
(23-26.8.24)
I was positively surprised reading the second book. And I believe I enjoyed it more than the first.
But maybe that was because the first chapter already reveals so much hope for the whole book. You’ll just have to find out for yourself.
I liked how it got more challenging for Azar to be in the presence of Julia serving her and it was not just this “I’m a Christian, I love everyone and my heart is abundant for anyone no matter if they killed someone or not” all the time. She struggled. I loved it. It shows the reality of faith.
Sometimes I missed Alexander’s POV - what happened to his booth and his clients when Azar left?
Also the ending is pretty much cheesy. I sometimes disliked Azar for avoiding Marcus. But i guess in general I struggle to emphasize with shy characters.
I almost fear that the third book is a “I need to keep writing books because the first two are selling so well”.
I guess I would be fine ending this series with the second book.
But my guess for the second book is some sort of meeting with Atretes and Alexander? Tbh I don’t have high hopes for the third book but in case it’s bad I’ll take the dread so you won’t have to…
*as sure as the dawn*
(2-8.9.24)
I don’t know if it was my favorite or the worst…
This one took me the longest to finish and there were days I really couldn’t stand either Atretes or Rizpah but I loved them so much more than Hadassah and Marcus.
Rizpah was not perfect. She struggled with her temper and pride. Which makes this novel such a brilliant one. It was so different than the first two.
I think I could relate to the characters in this one more but sometimes it was just too much thinking, neglect, pride, instead of the story continuing. You will have to fight through maybe 30% percent of a lot of personal development and process growth whatever and then for the last 5% everything will go by so fast you won’t be able to comprehend it.
*Overall review mark of the lion collection*
Looking back I enjoyed reading it and I can see why people believe this is such a nice collection.
Yet, I can understand the withhold some will have with this. Sometimes it seamed to easy, to perfect, to faithy everything will turn out great.
I will recommend this to anyone who’s interested in reading. Just don’t get your hopes to high up - in some way this is a classic Christian romance novel so you will encounter exactly that.
One thing I have been thinking about a lot is: I believe you can read these books separate from each other.
You could read *as sure as the dawn* without knowing the first two, and you could read *an echo in the darkness* without reading the first one, as well as you can read *a voice in the wind* and never keep on reading the rest.
You can pick up any book in this series.
Have fun:)
I knew this trilogy was high praised and I did my best, not having to high hopes since I didn’t want to be left with disappointment. I understand when people want to praise and advertise their favorites books but I’ve come to realize that to often people over-praise and you’re left with unmet expectations.
But since I didn’t have any for this trilogy I was fine.
I was probably even a little biased and thinking this was gonna be some cringey christian romance novel.
I started reading *a voice in the wind* because I was bored of any other Christian fiction since everything I had read before seemed soooo predictable. But not with this one!
Oh and also I had caught a cold, was bored so lots of time to read.
(Took me about 3 days. 18-20.8.24)
I started reading it and the first thing I liked:
- the different povs
I was shattered by how
- similar worldview and challenges we are facing nowadays (religion, lgbtq+, faith/spirituality, family, war, etc)
and probably the thing I liked most was how
- You couldn’t predict what was gonna happen
Since I don’t want this to be a spoiler review I will say only so much:
I was shocked after the last chapters of this first book. I believed this was gonna end in some happy-ever after-marriage-romance-situation. (Which I was rooting for) But no it did not. Francine knows how to torture her readers.
Excited for the next book. I don’t know what I want to see Marcus doing. But I know I want him to do something.
(Oh and also I really despise Julia. Sorry. Not a lot of compassion for her on my side. But I wouldn’t mind if she was ultimately delivered by Marcus? Imagine Atretes and her both coming to faith and ending up being married. Lol. Maybe not!).
*an echo in the darkness*
(23-26.8.24)
I was positively surprised reading the second book. And I believe I enjoyed it more than the first.
But maybe that was because the first chapter already reveals so much hope for the whole book. You’ll just have to find out for yourself.
I liked how it got more challenging for Azar to be in the presence of Julia serving her and it was not just this “I’m a Christian, I love everyone and my heart is abundant for anyone no matter if they killed someone or not” all the time. She struggled. I loved it. It shows the reality of faith.
Sometimes I missed Alexander’s POV - what happened to his booth and his clients when Azar left?
Also the ending is pretty much cheesy. I sometimes disliked Azar for avoiding Marcus. But i guess in general I struggle to emphasize with shy characters.
I almost fear that the third book is a “I need to keep writing books because the first two are selling so well”.
I guess I would be fine ending this series with the second book.
But my guess for the second book is some sort of meeting with Atretes and Alexander? Tbh I don’t have high hopes for the third book but in case it’s bad I’ll take the dread so you won’t have to…
*as sure as the dawn*
(2-8.9.24)
I don’t know if it was my favorite or the worst…
This one took me the longest to finish and there were days I really couldn’t stand either Atretes or Rizpah but I loved them so much more than Hadassah and Marcus.
Rizpah was not perfect. She struggled with her temper and pride. Which makes this novel such a brilliant one. It was so different than the first two.
I think I could relate to the characters in this one more but sometimes it was just too much thinking, neglect, pride, instead of the story continuing. You will have to fight through maybe 30% percent of a lot of personal development and process growth whatever and then for the last 5% everything will go by so fast you won’t be able to comprehend it.
*Overall review mark of the lion collection*
Looking back I enjoyed reading it and I can see why people believe this is such a nice collection.
Yet, I can understand the withhold some will have with this. Sometimes it seamed to easy, to perfect, to faithy everything will turn out great.
I will recommend this to anyone who’s interested in reading. Just don’t get your hopes to high up - in some way this is a classic Christian romance novel so you will encounter exactly that.
One thing I have been thinking about a lot is: I believe you can read these books separate from each other.
You could read *as sure as the dawn* without knowing the first two, and you could read *an echo in the darkness* without reading the first one, as well as you can read *a voice in the wind* and never keep on reading the rest.
You can pick up any book in this series.
Have fun:)
January 2, 2019
This series is full of fascinating historical research. I feel that I have been there and lived with these wonderful characters. There is definite clear and uncompromising religious ideas woven through and integral to the plot. I found it worthy of the understanding for the characters. Many if my God ideas are similar, so I enjoyed this aspect as well. Well written. Intricate in plot, and often surprising. And that whole nest historical information touch. Worth the read.
October 3, 2020
I can read this series over and over again, so wonderful and so relatable to me!
January 26, 2023
Good trilogy. Unique time of historical fiction. Didn't really like the ending. Felt like the author had a hard time with the ending.
December 14, 2023
She slay so hardcore🫡
September 3, 2025
Fantastic!
April 3, 2022
FAVORITE.
January 2, 2020
This historical fiction is hard to put down...
January 30, 2025
David and I LOVED this series :)
January 29, 2008
Now, I was a little apprehensive about these books at first because they were (cough, cough) "Historical Christian Romance" novels. Hmmm. But everyone at church kept going on and on about them. Including Kari Way. Now, Kari isn't the super girlie mushie lovie dovie type, so I concluded that they must be decent and not super cheesy. Which they weren't.
The first two books follow a young Jewish Christian girl named Hadassah as she is taken captive to Rome after Jerusalem and the temple are destroyed. She is then sold into the household of the Valerians, a very well to do family in the Roman Empire. I won't tell you much beyond that because: 1) I don't want to spoil ANYTHING, and 2) There's a lot to these stories and you'd probably be bored reading my recap. The third book revolved around Atretes, an ex-gladiator (and main character in book one), and Rizpah, a young Christian women with the fight of her life headed towards her.
What I do want to tell you is how interesting it was to read these books and understand what it meant to be a Christian in ancient Rome. It meant being sold as a slave because you were considered worthless. It meant being attacked and eaten by lions in the arena for the entertainment of the masses. It meant being crucified as your Lord was. It meant utter hatred and disdain from not only the Romans, but your fellow brothers and sisters, the Jews. As I read Acts, I see what risks were taken as people proclaimed Jesus the Son of God, and the consequences that than ensued. It encouraged me to see what boldness Paul and Peter had as they spoke of what would surely get them killed. And it encouraged me to read a fictional story of a girl with a belief in the Messiah that led her places I can never imagine being in my whole life. I know that I'll never be persecuted the way most Christians are as long as I live here in America. I may be mocked, or laughed at, maybe even one day spit upon, but never tortured to death while someone tells me to deny Christ. And there are hundreds of Christians around the world right now that are.
So, please read these books. It made me realize the extreme extent of how blessed I am and how easy it is for me to be a Christian. I hope you see the same thing!
While you're at it, go to www.persecution.com and sign up for the free monthly magazine, The Voice of the Martyrs. Also, click on the left on Prisoner List and read about Christians around the world that are in chains for the gospel, and then send them a letter of encouragment! We can all do our part!
The first two books follow a young Jewish Christian girl named Hadassah as she is taken captive to Rome after Jerusalem and the temple are destroyed. She is then sold into the household of the Valerians, a very well to do family in the Roman Empire. I won't tell you much beyond that because: 1) I don't want to spoil ANYTHING, and 2) There's a lot to these stories and you'd probably be bored reading my recap. The third book revolved around Atretes, an ex-gladiator (and main character in book one), and Rizpah, a young Christian women with the fight of her life headed towards her.
What I do want to tell you is how interesting it was to read these books and understand what it meant to be a Christian in ancient Rome. It meant being sold as a slave because you were considered worthless. It meant being attacked and eaten by lions in the arena for the entertainment of the masses. It meant being crucified as your Lord was. It meant utter hatred and disdain from not only the Romans, but your fellow brothers and sisters, the Jews. As I read Acts, I see what risks were taken as people proclaimed Jesus the Son of God, and the consequences that than ensued. It encouraged me to see what boldness Paul and Peter had as they spoke of what would surely get them killed. And it encouraged me to read a fictional story of a girl with a belief in the Messiah that led her places I can never imagine being in my whole life. I know that I'll never be persecuted the way most Christians are as long as I live here in America. I may be mocked, or laughed at, maybe even one day spit upon, but never tortured to death while someone tells me to deny Christ. And there are hundreds of Christians around the world right now that are.
So, please read these books. It made me realize the extreme extent of how blessed I am and how easy it is for me to be a Christian. I hope you see the same thing!
While you're at it, go to www.persecution.com and sign up for the free monthly magazine, The Voice of the Martyrs. Also, click on the left on Prisoner List and read about Christians around the world that are in chains for the gospel, and then send them a letter of encouragment! We can all do our part!
March 28, 2015
More like 3.5, adding each volume together. I read them as separates but am writing a review of the trilogy as a whole.
v.1-2. How a slave girl from Judea, Hadassah, changes the lives of members of a Roman family living at the time of the Flavian emperors. The first two books in the trilogy I felt were superior. The Christian message was just enough for my taste, not overwhelming the action. The example of Hadassah's life spoke volumes to me and to the family.
The third volume carries on with the German ex-gladiator, Atretes, [a former lover of Julia--daughter of the Roman family], his search for his son, journey back to Germania and life with the villagers. The Christian message got to be a bit overwrought and strident. I felt as though the third volume was weakest and was tacked on the first two merely to give closure to the story of Atretes.
The story did become melodramatic and emotional sometimes, but I felt for the characters and their struggles. I did get misty-eyed in several places. The author didn't get all of the tiny details absolutely correct, but the power of the story overwhelmed that criticism. Something that does tickle me about Christian fiction set in early days of Christianity is how characters quote the Bible word for word centuries before the N.T. was codified officially [late 300's A.D.]. Recommended, especially the first two volumes. The third volume is optional reading.
v.1-2. How a slave girl from Judea, Hadassah, changes the lives of members of a Roman family living at the time of the Flavian emperors. The first two books in the trilogy I felt were superior. The Christian message was just enough for my taste, not overwhelming the action. The example of Hadassah's life spoke volumes to me and to the family.
The third volume carries on with the German ex-gladiator, Atretes, [a former lover of Julia--daughter of the Roman family], his search for his son, journey back to Germania and life with the villagers. The Christian message got to be a bit overwrought and strident. I felt as though the third volume was weakest and was tacked on the first two merely to give closure to the story of Atretes.
The story did become melodramatic and emotional sometimes, but I felt for the characters and their struggles. I did get misty-eyed in several places. The author didn't get all of the tiny details absolutely correct, but the power of the story overwhelmed that criticism. Something that does tickle me about Christian fiction set in early days of Christianity is how characters quote the Bible word for word centuries before the N.T. was codified officially [late 300's A.D.]. Recommended, especially the first two volumes. The third volume is optional reading.
January 6, 2009
These books are a great way to learn about what it was like for early Christians. They're set around 79 AD - sort of the first to second generation after Jesus was alive. Jerusalem has just fallen, Christians are being persecuted. Rome is at the height of decadence. Gladiator contests in the arena reign supreme for entertainment. Paul has just written letters to the churches in several major cities.
Even though they're very fictional accounts, I really appreciated the insight these books gave into the beginnings of Christianity. We take for granted now how easy it is to be Christian. Back then, if people found out you were Christian, you'd likely be fuel for torches or food for lions. But the faith of those people was nothing short of intense.
These books take a little while to get into. Rivers gives a LOT of historical context to really help you understand what's going on and where you are. So it's slow going at first. Once you dig in, though, you see real struggles in the lives of the characters. Their temptations aren't that different from ours. Hot issues aren't much different either. But they find peace in Christ...which is very inspiring.
Even though they're very fictional accounts, I really appreciated the insight these books gave into the beginnings of Christianity. We take for granted now how easy it is to be Christian. Back then, if people found out you were Christian, you'd likely be fuel for torches or food for lions. But the faith of those people was nothing short of intense.
These books take a little while to get into. Rivers gives a LOT of historical context to really help you understand what's going on and where you are. So it's slow going at first. Once you dig in, though, you see real struggles in the lives of the characters. Their temptations aren't that different from ours. Hot issues aren't much different either. But they find peace in Christ...which is very inspiring.
April 11, 2024
An epic that faltered after a brilliant start. (4 stars)
Francine Rivers has made a name for herself with her enthralling three volume “Mark of the Lion” series. Her story-telling abilities, colourful characterization, and expertise in describing real feelings are superb. Unlike a great deal of contemporary fiction, the “Mark of the Lion” series is epic in scope and deep in content. It’s not just entertainment, it’s literary fiction of a high calibre. In each volume, Rivers addresses serious issues in the Christian life: witnessing to an unbelieving world, forgiveness and anger.
The first volume, “A Voice in the Wind” is easily the best. With a deeply-moving story that entertains, educates and enthrals, Rivers has crafted a captivating tale of the Christian Jewess Hadassah that takes readers on a breath-taking ride from the ruins of Jerusalem, to the godless hub of first century Rome, and the Artemis worshipping city of Ephesus. Particularly compelling is the touching manner in which Rivers portrays the special relationship between the slave Hadassah and her master Julia.
But especially outstanding is her portrayal of first century Rome. The culture of the Roman empire is described in vivid detail, complete with its godless and decadent lifestyle, political intrigue and corruption, infatuation with gladiators and games, sex and sensuality. The description of Rome’s decadence is at times almost too vivid, and consequently the book is not really suitable for younger readers. The inclusion of contemporary issues such as abortion, homosexuality, and common-law marriage at first seems anachronistic, but actually the decay evident in contemporary Western culture is merely a mirror image of the decay that also characterized and eventually destroyed corrupt Rome.
Over against the destructive decay of Roman culture, Rivers describes its counter-culture: Christianity. The only hope for a people trapped in an immoral and disintegrating world – both then and now - is the Saviour and restorer of life: Jesus Christ. Ultimately this age-old contrast between the church and the world is at the heart of this epic novel. It’s an incentive to be faithful Christians and live counter-culture in our equally corrupt times. It is especially this quality that makes “A Voice in the Wind” not only immensely satisfying, but also incredibly stimulating for your own faith.
The voice of God in Hadassah’s life echoes in the dark and empty lives of Marcus and Julia in the second volume, “An Echo in the Darkness.” In their lives Rivers creates a vivid and wonderful portrait of the truth of Ecclesiastes – the emptiness and vanity of a life where one pursues anything except God. Just like today’s world, Rome offers wealth, pleasure, power and knowledge. Both Marcus and Julia discover that the pursuit of pleasure, work, money and sexuality eventually proves to be meaningless and empty – the same conclusion as Ecclesiastes. But will they come to discover that meaning is found instead in God? Hadassah – now a miraculous healer beneath veils with scars that testify to the “mark of the lion” - proves to be instrumental in the resolution of their internal struggles, and in the end the lives of this three-some converge in a rather remarkable way.
The gladiator Atretes returns in the third volume, “As Sure as the Dawn”, and Rivers chronicles his journey back to his Germanic homeland, accompanied by the Christian widow Rizpah, nursemaid to his son. For Atretes, it proves to be much more than just a journey to his barbarian Chatti tribe, but especially a spiritual journey of faith. The portrayal of spiritual conflict as the gospel is proclaimed in pagan territory is particularly convincing. Rivers’ description of demonic powers at work among the pagans under the guise of their gods is powerful and accurate.
The preoccupation with internal struggles makes both “An Echo in the Darkness” and “As Sure as the Dawn” more introspective than “A Voice in the Wind”. Readers who enjoyed the excitement and action of Rome’s bread and circuses in the first volume, will be disappointed to find that instead of battles between gladiators and lions in the arena, Rivers focuses more on the inner battles of the heart, as Marcus, Julia and Atretes search for peace and meaning in their lives. Displaying a remarkable ability to convey and describe human emotions, feelings and struggles, Rivers demonstrates that she is as skilful at portraying inner conflict as she is at portraying outer conflict.
However, the last two entries of the series are also subject to a questionable theological proposition. Rivers sets her novels in an era when the church was already established and God revealed Himself almost exclusively through the written writings. Yet despite this, she incorporates signs and wonders that were unique to the apostolic era (direct revelation, the gift of tongues, and miracles). It is most unfortunate that these become decisive turning points in the lives of her characters. Not only do these miracles and wonders result in an overly optimistic story-line that fails to reflect the harshness of real life for Christians today, they are dependent on a tenuous theological position that apostolic wonders and miracles did not cease with the apostolic era.
Other flaws also emerge, notably her presentation of love and forgiveness as a Christian duty independent of repentance; Hadassah’s purity of character which belittles the reality of an ongoing sinful nature; and the extent to which romance overshadows religion in determining the course of events in Atretes’ life. The graphic allusions to Atretes’ sexual relations outside of marriage and frank discussion of sexual thoughts certainly makes this series unsuitable for children.
“As Sure as the Dawn” does overcome some of the weaknesses of “An Echo in the Darkness”, but not enough to match the brilliant start begun with “A Voice in the Wind.” Not bothering to read the entire trilogy can be justified, but to not bother reading “A Voice in the Wind” is to miss one of the best efforts in contemporary Christian fiction!
Francine Rivers has made a name for herself with her enthralling three volume “Mark of the Lion” series. Her story-telling abilities, colourful characterization, and expertise in describing real feelings are superb. Unlike a great deal of contemporary fiction, the “Mark of the Lion” series is epic in scope and deep in content. It’s not just entertainment, it’s literary fiction of a high calibre. In each volume, Rivers addresses serious issues in the Christian life: witnessing to an unbelieving world, forgiveness and anger.
The first volume, “A Voice in the Wind” is easily the best. With a deeply-moving story that entertains, educates and enthrals, Rivers has crafted a captivating tale of the Christian Jewess Hadassah that takes readers on a breath-taking ride from the ruins of Jerusalem, to the godless hub of first century Rome, and the Artemis worshipping city of Ephesus. Particularly compelling is the touching manner in which Rivers portrays the special relationship between the slave Hadassah and her master Julia.
But especially outstanding is her portrayal of first century Rome. The culture of the Roman empire is described in vivid detail, complete with its godless and decadent lifestyle, political intrigue and corruption, infatuation with gladiators and games, sex and sensuality. The description of Rome’s decadence is at times almost too vivid, and consequently the book is not really suitable for younger readers. The inclusion of contemporary issues such as abortion, homosexuality, and common-law marriage at first seems anachronistic, but actually the decay evident in contemporary Western culture is merely a mirror image of the decay that also characterized and eventually destroyed corrupt Rome.
Over against the destructive decay of Roman culture, Rivers describes its counter-culture: Christianity. The only hope for a people trapped in an immoral and disintegrating world – both then and now - is the Saviour and restorer of life: Jesus Christ. Ultimately this age-old contrast between the church and the world is at the heart of this epic novel. It’s an incentive to be faithful Christians and live counter-culture in our equally corrupt times. It is especially this quality that makes “A Voice in the Wind” not only immensely satisfying, but also incredibly stimulating for your own faith.
The voice of God in Hadassah’s life echoes in the dark and empty lives of Marcus and Julia in the second volume, “An Echo in the Darkness.” In their lives Rivers creates a vivid and wonderful portrait of the truth of Ecclesiastes – the emptiness and vanity of a life where one pursues anything except God. Just like today’s world, Rome offers wealth, pleasure, power and knowledge. Both Marcus and Julia discover that the pursuit of pleasure, work, money and sexuality eventually proves to be meaningless and empty – the same conclusion as Ecclesiastes. But will they come to discover that meaning is found instead in God? Hadassah – now a miraculous healer beneath veils with scars that testify to the “mark of the lion” - proves to be instrumental in the resolution of their internal struggles, and in the end the lives of this three-some converge in a rather remarkable way.
The gladiator Atretes returns in the third volume, “As Sure as the Dawn”, and Rivers chronicles his journey back to his Germanic homeland, accompanied by the Christian widow Rizpah, nursemaid to his son. For Atretes, it proves to be much more than just a journey to his barbarian Chatti tribe, but especially a spiritual journey of faith. The portrayal of spiritual conflict as the gospel is proclaimed in pagan territory is particularly convincing. Rivers’ description of demonic powers at work among the pagans under the guise of their gods is powerful and accurate.
The preoccupation with internal struggles makes both “An Echo in the Darkness” and “As Sure as the Dawn” more introspective than “A Voice in the Wind”. Readers who enjoyed the excitement and action of Rome’s bread and circuses in the first volume, will be disappointed to find that instead of battles between gladiators and lions in the arena, Rivers focuses more on the inner battles of the heart, as Marcus, Julia and Atretes search for peace and meaning in their lives. Displaying a remarkable ability to convey and describe human emotions, feelings and struggles, Rivers demonstrates that she is as skilful at portraying inner conflict as she is at portraying outer conflict.
However, the last two entries of the series are also subject to a questionable theological proposition. Rivers sets her novels in an era when the church was already established and God revealed Himself almost exclusively through the written writings. Yet despite this, she incorporates signs and wonders that were unique to the apostolic era (direct revelation, the gift of tongues, and miracles). It is most unfortunate that these become decisive turning points in the lives of her characters. Not only do these miracles and wonders result in an overly optimistic story-line that fails to reflect the harshness of real life for Christians today, they are dependent on a tenuous theological position that apostolic wonders and miracles did not cease with the apostolic era.
Other flaws also emerge, notably her presentation of love and forgiveness as a Christian duty independent of repentance; Hadassah’s purity of character which belittles the reality of an ongoing sinful nature; and the extent to which romance overshadows religion in determining the course of events in Atretes’ life. The graphic allusions to Atretes’ sexual relations outside of marriage and frank discussion of sexual thoughts certainly makes this series unsuitable for children.
“As Sure as the Dawn” does overcome some of the weaknesses of “An Echo in the Darkness”, but not enough to match the brilliant start begun with “A Voice in the Wind.” Not bothering to read the entire trilogy can be justified, but to not bother reading “A Voice in the Wind” is to miss one of the best efforts in contemporary Christian fiction!
June 30, 2014
Amazing and addictive!!!!
Well-written, storyline that weaves the characters and places and happenings together addictively. Great for readers who love to know, really KNOW the characters and their struggles. If you aren't familiar with the story's timeline and culture, you definitely will be by half-way through the first book. This is not a quick read, but definitely so addictive you can't put it down. Emotionally and spiritually compelling, not watering down how enticing and destructive some temptations are. Action, romance, suspense, and drama. I am not one to re-read books in general, but this was the fourth time a read this set and I was still on the edge of my seat, even knowing what would happen.
Well-written, storyline that weaves the characters and places and happenings together addictively. Great for readers who love to know, really KNOW the characters and their struggles. If you aren't familiar with the story's timeline and culture, you definitely will be by half-way through the first book. This is not a quick read, but definitely so addictive you can't put it down. Emotionally and spiritually compelling, not watering down how enticing and destructive some temptations are. Action, romance, suspense, and drama. I am not one to re-read books in general, but this was the fourth time a read this set and I was still on the edge of my seat, even knowing what would happen.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 921 reviews