Gorman can write mystery thrillers for sure but Black River Falls, while a fast and fun read, it not really that mysterious. That stated, it still packs a bit of a punch. This starts off with the police investigating the brutal murder of a college coed who lived off campus, and her best friend standing like a vigil outside her apartment for months every night...
Flash forward a year and Gorman takes us to Black River Falls, a small, midwestern town (Illinois?) and introduces us to Ben, our main protagonist. Ben, age 19, attends college and wants to be a veterinarian like his mother, who he still lives with in her old farmhouse/animal clinic. Introverted and largely antisocial, Ben is the opposite of his older brother Michael, a former high school star athlete and now town stud who owns a successful video rental place in town. Yet, Michael has a dark side as we quickly learn he is a killer and has been since he offed his first person when he was 14. Michael is best buddies with a local loser named Steve who is being sought by a PI who has been looking for the murderer of Alison's friend from the prologue.
Essentially, the story revolves around Michael's dark side and secret, namely that he and Steve killed the woman together, although Steve takes the fall. Ben, meanwhile, has fallen head over heals for Alison, who now lives in Black River Falls. Why? She also wants to find the killer, and she suspects it was Michael. Ben, however, loves his big brother and cannot believe he would have anything to do with the killing...
Tense at times, Black River Falls reels you in as Ben is a very sympathetic character, in love for the first time but still your basic nerd; he cannot believe Alison is attracted to him! Some touching family dynamics flesh out the story nicely. While I liked this, and Gorman writes well, it was pretty easy to see where this was going to go, taking the bite out of the mystery really early; it was just a matter of how it would unfold. 3 tense stars!