It’s the end of the curse as we know it! Saeyama dodges a bullet but is then set up to fail in a case that seems tailor maid for him. When things turn out to be no idol threat, it’s one more chance to deduce and be smug for somebody who’s very good at both.
Yee haw! Now that’s how you close out a series… unsatisfactorily. Except not. While the actual epilogue is a big old dump of ‘pretty sure that this series got cancelled so here’s all the fun ideas you won’t get to see’, this final volume is just a single giant case of an idiot running rampant again.
And that’s perfect - I have adored every silly, silly volume of this goober series about a jerk and his brain (plus assistant). Those loose ends are flapping in the breeze like mad tendrils of a dead god, but it doesn’t matter because realistically this series could never have stayed this good forever and I’ll take four perfect volumes of this, no notes.
It should go without saying that the combination of maids with idols is so clever that somebody has to have tried it in the real world, but the semi-identical singers of Maid On make for a delicious mystery, even if I had no clue who was named who most of the time anyway.
As usual, it’s the doofy brinkmanship that makes this so fun. Saeyama is such a smug, punchable arse the entire time and that’s why he’s such a brilliantly fun detective. There are plots, counter plots, counters to those counters, etc etc. You can expect every initial reveal to give way to three or more subsequent ones before the whole thing runs aground.
Oh the motives are dumb, waah waah, whatever. It’s a story of obsession and trying to impress a girl, of all things, by killing people, naturally. Curses are flying, office politics and backdoor deals come into play. It’s a real stew.
But it works. The mysteries are curse-derived, but as usual they always, always play fair - each curse has a defined set of rules that it does not change mid-case. Plus, there are enough clues given that you can figure things out if you feel like putting the effort in, or you can just crest the general wave of insanity.
I loved this. It felt like a fair play mystery that was always willing to be zany, but never used that as an excuse to be poorly written in terms of its structure. I’ll read this again sometime and be just as charmed as I was the first time through.
Yeah, that ending’s a bummer, but it definitely delivers in one sense - leaving the reader safe in the knowledge that somebody out there is ready to save us from curses. Probably while smoking a pipe and being a jerk. I wish it could have closed the main storyline off, I truly do, but what I got from this was so good I won’t begrudge it.
5 stars - how do you end a series that stopped ahead of it’s time? By simply doing the same thing it did every volume and just as well. Having a sumptuous last meal of a mystery really softened the blow of the abrupt ending, especially with how good it was.