John Grisham gives me hope that someday my writing will become noticed and that I will be able to make a living as a novelist. I say this because The Rainmaker made it to number one on the New York Times best seller list despite the fact that it is only an average book.
The writing was good enough to keep me turning the pages, but the story lacked and the characters were painfully stereotypical, except oddly enough for the main character. For a good guy, Rudy Baylor was unlikable, not in an anti-hero fashion, but in a the-guy-is- kinda-nothing-special- fashion. I just didn't care for him, but as the book unfurled he became surrounded by people who were even more unpleasant so it began to seem he was changing, but not so much that I began to care.
Now the main problem with the book was with the story itself. It's a court case drama, but there is a definite lack of drama. You expect that there is going to be some sort of obstacle to Rudy winning this case and it helps to keep you interested, but after like three hundred pages,nothing. He wins and you know it long before it happens. Every fact, every witness, everything goes his way so that you know the evil insurance company is going to lose and it won't be close. But surely, when the defense has their chance there will be fireworks...no. Nothing on cross examination, no surprise witnesses. The bad guy are still bad and they still lose.
Oh, did I tell you the bad guys are evil? Yes evil corporate suit types just like you see in every movie and yes they have evil lawyers who are rich and powerful, but for some reason in this case they seem not to know which way up is, dazzled by this complete rookie. Yeah Rudy has never tried a case before. It's not believable.
Now two more bad parts. Sorry. The side stories are a complete waste of time and could be cut altogether. Lastly, the anti-climatic trial ends and then stuff happens that I don't really care about. Rudy kills some guy who's been domestically violent and for some reason, he decides to quit being a lawyer. Did you read that? Sort of out of the blue especially after sticking it to all the evil. I mean he just kicked evil's ass and then he quits lawering to become... you guessed it, a teacher. I had to shake my head and wonder if I missed a chapter somewhere.
My review might suggest that I hated the book, but that isn't true. It started slow, but picked up steam with good writing and the possibility of a court room brawl and for that I give it two and a half stars.