What do you think?
Rate this book
Searching for Fannie Quigley: A Wilderness Life in the Shadow of Mount McKinley
At the age of 27, Fannie Sedlacek left her Bohemian homestead in Nebraska to join the gold rush to the Klondike. From the Klondike to the Tanana, Fannie continued north, finally settling in Katishna near Mount McKinley. This woman, later known as Fannie Quigley, became a prospector who staked her own claims and a cook who ran a roadhouse. She hunted and trapped and thrived for nearly forty years in an environment that others found unbearable.
Her wilderness lifestyle inspired many of those who met her to record their impressions of this self-sufficient woman, who died in 1944. To many of the 700,000 annual visitors to Denali National Park she is a symbol of the enduring spirit of the original pioneers.
Searching for Fannie A Wilderness Life in the Shadow of Mount McKinley goes beyond the mere biographical facts of this unique woman’s journey. It also tells historian Jane G. Haigh’s own story of tracking and tracing the many paths that Fannie Quigley’s intriguing life took. Uncovering remote clues, digging through archives, and listening to oral accounts from a wide array of sources, Haigh has fashioned this rich lode into a compelling narrative.
In Searching for Fannie Quigley , Haigh separates fact from fiction to reveal the true story of this highly mythologized pioneer woman.
Her wilderness lifestyle inspired many of those who met her to record their impressions of this self-sufficient woman, who died in 1944. To many of the 700,000 annual visitors to Denali National Park she is a symbol of the enduring spirit of the original pioneers.
Searching for Fannie A Wilderness Life in the Shadow of Mount McKinley goes beyond the mere biographical facts of this unique woman’s journey. It also tells historian Jane G. Haigh’s own story of tracking and tracing the many paths that Fannie Quigley’s intriguing life took. Uncovering remote clues, digging through archives, and listening to oral accounts from a wide array of sources, Haigh has fashioned this rich lode into a compelling narrative.
In Searching for Fannie Quigley , Haigh separates fact from fiction to reveal the true story of this highly mythologized pioneer woman.
185 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2007
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews
October 1, 2017
This is going to be a slightly longer review, because I think it's a very deep book and I do not want to disrespect either the topic or the historical work that the author put into it.
I would first like to give a brief background on what this book is about. On a recent trip I made to Alaska, I was one day walking around the mining ghost town of Kantishna, situated at the Western (and more remote) boundary of Denali National Park, in full view of Mt. Denali. As I was peeking into the abandoned log cabins that the frontier miners had once inhabited, I noticed that one of them had been especially well preserved and was now being administered by the National Park Service. It was the home in which Fannie Quigley (nee Fannie Sedlacek, formerly Fannie McKenzie) spent her last years before she died in 1944. She had lived in Kantishna (which at the time had no roads, and was 150 miles away from the nearest settlement) for almost 40 years, and by the time she died she was one of only two villagers left. I was fascinated by her story, and struck by a sense of calm and homely familiarity at seeing pictures of her tending her garden, so I returned home determined to learn more-and after a bit of googling, I came upon the present book, which was written by a historian from Fairbanks who had done a lot of work and dedicated years of her life to finding out the true story of Fannie Quigley.
Fannie was born in 1870, in Nebraska, to a family of poor Czech immigrants who had to work incredibly hard to be able to just survive the harsh environment of what was then the US frontier-the Wild West, if you will. Despite their relentlessness, her family lost a lot of children to sickness and malnutrition, and as soon as she was old enough to leave the home, she learned to earn her livelihood cooking for the teams of workers who were building the railway, and slowly moved West with them as sections were completed and new ground was broken. Although she had attended at least one year of school in English, she was illiterate well into her twenties, and she is said to have first learned English from the Irish railway workers. Eventually, lured in by the promise of the Northern gold rushes (first to Yukon, in Canada, then back across the border to Fairbanks, in Alaska, and finally to Kantishna, also in Alaska), she took life into her own two hands, and became a self-made gold prospector, traveling to the North American arctic on foot (which earned her the nickname "Fannie the Hike"), earning her keep by selling food, staking gold claims, and trying her hand at scraping the earth alongside the hundreds of men who hoped to find the gold which would liberate them from the strictures of their economic condition.
Fannie became a legend in Alaska, as it was extremely unusual at that time for a woman to even be there, least of all be a gold prospector able to live off the land and endure the harshness of the arctic, where weather was deadly, law enforcement was non-existent, and men outnumbered women by a ratio of 20:1.
On the empowering hand, Fannie was used to surviving in the tundra (hunting bears, caribou, and moose all by herself, and preserving the lard and meat for her famous dishes), mining for gold, cutting timber, trapping fur animals, and hiking up to 30 miles a day. All the while, she was said to make the best blueberry pie in the Alaskan Interior, and to unconditionally feed every visitor who crossed her doorstep.
On the dis-empowering hand, however, Fannie was also an alcoholic, had incredibly colorful language (much of which consisted of cussing), and was often described by those who met her as representing a kind of femininity from another, more archaic age of humanity.
After reading the historical account of her life, put together as a puzzle from bits and pieces of frontier paper trail (newspapers, sheriff records, city hall records, and accounts of other people who'd met her), I however became convinced that the real Fannie Quigley has been forever lost, and replaced by a legendary larger-than-life figure who is not so much authentic, as a reflection of whatever people wanted to see in her.
Interestingly, because of the unusual nature of her circumstances, everyone who came in contact with her felt an urge (perhaps internally-driven) to assign her an archetype, or a role in their world. For the rich Easterners from New York, she was the token which confirmed their fantasy of Alaska as a land of extreme masculinity and pristine wilderness. To gold prospectors, she was a cheerful female figure that both understood them and brought a touch of homely memories to the harsh wilderness they were experiencing. To the feminists, she was a stout example of the limits of female worthiness and independence. To the wilderness enthusiasts, she was the ideal of shunning modern city life and returning to live in nature. And to modern Alaskans, she is a frontier legend in the historical fabric of the state.
The point is, to everyone who's ever met her, Fannie became a blank canvas onto which a stereotype would be projected.
I was interested in something altogether different while reading the book. I wanted to know whether Fannie had been happy out there in the Alaskan wilderness. Whether her humble origins, and her exceptionally harsh life (including a very long but childless marriage to Joe Quigley in Kantishna), had still allowed her to enjoy an existence rich not just with sensations, but with meaning and a sense of purpose. I suppose on some level, I wanted to know whether I could have potentially been happy having made life choices similar to hers.
I like to think that the truth that the historical records mentioned in the book and online spoke to me was more realistic than the projections of others. For sure, Fannie had learned to find happiness and purpose in her work. But she also struck me as a person who deeply longed to fill a void that she resisted naming-perhaps of family, perhaps of friends, perhaps of something altogether different. Her alcoholism, her awareness of her origins as a poor immigrant, her dislike of stereotypically-housewife middle class women, her strained relationship with Joe, her extreme sense of independence, and her inner drive to be a motherly figure to all the gold prospectors in the Alaskan interior make me suspect that she was at least partially unfulfilled.
Far from the mythical woman of legend, she appeared to me in a more humane form: perhaps a bit insecure, perhaps a bit rowdy, but overall a good person with her heart in the right place. And so the answer I was seeking-whether she had been happy or not-is not straightforward any more. She was neither happy nor unhappy (or rather, both happy and unhappy). She was human, and therefore, complete.
I would first like to give a brief background on what this book is about. On a recent trip I made to Alaska, I was one day walking around the mining ghost town of Kantishna, situated at the Western (and more remote) boundary of Denali National Park, in full view of Mt. Denali. As I was peeking into the abandoned log cabins that the frontier miners had once inhabited, I noticed that one of them had been especially well preserved and was now being administered by the National Park Service. It was the home in which Fannie Quigley (nee Fannie Sedlacek, formerly Fannie McKenzie) spent her last years before she died in 1944. She had lived in Kantishna (which at the time had no roads, and was 150 miles away from the nearest settlement) for almost 40 years, and by the time she died she was one of only two villagers left. I was fascinated by her story, and struck by a sense of calm and homely familiarity at seeing pictures of her tending her garden, so I returned home determined to learn more-and after a bit of googling, I came upon the present book, which was written by a historian from Fairbanks who had done a lot of work and dedicated years of her life to finding out the true story of Fannie Quigley.
Fannie was born in 1870, in Nebraska, to a family of poor Czech immigrants who had to work incredibly hard to be able to just survive the harsh environment of what was then the US frontier-the Wild West, if you will. Despite their relentlessness, her family lost a lot of children to sickness and malnutrition, and as soon as she was old enough to leave the home, she learned to earn her livelihood cooking for the teams of workers who were building the railway, and slowly moved West with them as sections were completed and new ground was broken. Although she had attended at least one year of school in English, she was illiterate well into her twenties, and she is said to have first learned English from the Irish railway workers. Eventually, lured in by the promise of the Northern gold rushes (first to Yukon, in Canada, then back across the border to Fairbanks, in Alaska, and finally to Kantishna, also in Alaska), she took life into her own two hands, and became a self-made gold prospector, traveling to the North American arctic on foot (which earned her the nickname "Fannie the Hike"), earning her keep by selling food, staking gold claims, and trying her hand at scraping the earth alongside the hundreds of men who hoped to find the gold which would liberate them from the strictures of their economic condition.
Fannie became a legend in Alaska, as it was extremely unusual at that time for a woman to even be there, least of all be a gold prospector able to live off the land and endure the harshness of the arctic, where weather was deadly, law enforcement was non-existent, and men outnumbered women by a ratio of 20:1.
On the empowering hand, Fannie was used to surviving in the tundra (hunting bears, caribou, and moose all by herself, and preserving the lard and meat for her famous dishes), mining for gold, cutting timber, trapping fur animals, and hiking up to 30 miles a day. All the while, she was said to make the best blueberry pie in the Alaskan Interior, and to unconditionally feed every visitor who crossed her doorstep.
On the dis-empowering hand, however, Fannie was also an alcoholic, had incredibly colorful language (much of which consisted of cussing), and was often described by those who met her as representing a kind of femininity from another, more archaic age of humanity.
After reading the historical account of her life, put together as a puzzle from bits and pieces of frontier paper trail (newspapers, sheriff records, city hall records, and accounts of other people who'd met her), I however became convinced that the real Fannie Quigley has been forever lost, and replaced by a legendary larger-than-life figure who is not so much authentic, as a reflection of whatever people wanted to see in her.
Interestingly, because of the unusual nature of her circumstances, everyone who came in contact with her felt an urge (perhaps internally-driven) to assign her an archetype, or a role in their world. For the rich Easterners from New York, she was the token which confirmed their fantasy of Alaska as a land of extreme masculinity and pristine wilderness. To gold prospectors, she was a cheerful female figure that both understood them and brought a touch of homely memories to the harsh wilderness they were experiencing. To the feminists, she was a stout example of the limits of female worthiness and independence. To the wilderness enthusiasts, she was the ideal of shunning modern city life and returning to live in nature. And to modern Alaskans, she is a frontier legend in the historical fabric of the state.
The point is, to everyone who's ever met her, Fannie became a blank canvas onto which a stereotype would be projected.
I was interested in something altogether different while reading the book. I wanted to know whether Fannie had been happy out there in the Alaskan wilderness. Whether her humble origins, and her exceptionally harsh life (including a very long but childless marriage to Joe Quigley in Kantishna), had still allowed her to enjoy an existence rich not just with sensations, but with meaning and a sense of purpose. I suppose on some level, I wanted to know whether I could have potentially been happy having made life choices similar to hers.
I like to think that the truth that the historical records mentioned in the book and online spoke to me was more realistic than the projections of others. For sure, Fannie had learned to find happiness and purpose in her work. But she also struck me as a person who deeply longed to fill a void that she resisted naming-perhaps of family, perhaps of friends, perhaps of something altogether different. Her alcoholism, her awareness of her origins as a poor immigrant, her dislike of stereotypically-housewife middle class women, her strained relationship with Joe, her extreme sense of independence, and her inner drive to be a motherly figure to all the gold prospectors in the Alaskan interior make me suspect that she was at least partially unfulfilled.
Far from the mythical woman of legend, she appeared to me in a more humane form: perhaps a bit insecure, perhaps a bit rowdy, but overall a good person with her heart in the right place. And so the answer I was seeking-whether she had been happy or not-is not straightforward any more. She was neither happy nor unhappy (or rather, both happy and unhappy). She was human, and therefore, complete.
September 15, 2020
I believe I went into this reading experience with expectations way too high. I was somehow convinced that this book supposed be focused on details of survival in the wilderness, the topic I am genuinely interested in. But it wasn’t really. The half of a book was about gold mining business in Alaska and only two chapters out of eleven was actually about Fannie’s wilderness experience with not that many details as I wished.
Anyway the book has some interesting insights into the gender roles in exploring of Alaska and eliminating women from this experience.
Anyway the book has some interesting insights into the gender roles in exploring of Alaska and eliminating women from this experience.
January 13, 2024
Overall, this was a pretty good read about someone I first stumbled across about a year ago. I first read about Fannie via the recipe for her legendary pies made from bear lard, and I was intrigued. The author does a good job of balancing her own journey to learn more about Fannie with a biography that follows Fannie's life from the plains of Nebraska to the mining camps of the Yukon and Alaska, where she became noted as a camp cook and a rather colorful personality as she lived for years in isolation in the shadows of Denali.
I did feel like the author occasionally belabored certain points, often repeating the same piece of evidence--finding primary sources on Fannie, who spent the first few decades of her life illiterate and whose story is submerged in so many other people's anecdotes, was difficult--but she is a good writer. Lots of interesting information in here in general on the early Alaska gold rushes and miners and how women like Fannie were an integral part of the story but often overlooked by their contemporaries and later historians.
I did feel like the author occasionally belabored certain points, often repeating the same piece of evidence--finding primary sources on Fannie, who spent the first few decades of her life illiterate and whose story is submerged in so many other people's anecdotes, was difficult--but she is a good writer. Lots of interesting information in here in general on the early Alaska gold rushes and miners and how women like Fannie were an integral part of the story but often overlooked by their contemporaries and later historians.
June 10, 2021
I picked this book up hoping to learn about Fannie Quigley and her life in Alaska. The book is instead about the authors search for information and her struggle to sift fact from fiction without many original source materials since Fannie wasnt literate and many people who knew her viewed her though their world lense. Instead of a biography this is a journey of sociology.
January 9, 2019
Great research on an Alaskan pioneer woman. As one of the first gold miners, Fannie didn't get much recognition. The book was difficult to research and verify, but read as an overdone thesis, in need of a good editor.
February 23, 2020
What a wonderful story! Jane put so much time in researching this book. I love Alaska and all the stories like this that goes with it!
August 23, 2014
While I enjoyed the parts of the book that were about Fannie Quigley, I thought the author spent too much time on how mining for gold was done in Alaska. I realized toward the end, as the author stated that not too much had been actually written about Fannie. In trying to stay true to the real story of her life the author chose to not spend too much time on legendary stories. In the long run this probably would have pleased Fannie Quigley who doesn't seem the type of person who wants to be remembered as larger then life.
December 21, 2014
I was fascinated by Fannie Quigley, a pioneerwoman who lived in the remote Alaskan backcountry in the early 1900s, when I visited Denali National Park earlier this year. This book provides as many details as are known about her life and story. The takeaway: Though she worked so hard (hunting and dressing her own food, cutting wood, etc.) she never really got to enjoy the fruits of her labor. It was almost like working was all she knew—and she didn't realize she could stop and enjoy her old age.
November 18, 2009
I might have enjoyed this book more if I had taken the title more seriously. I expected a biography but the book was about searching for information and what Fannie's life might have been like. There were quotes and certain facts that were VERY overused. Fannie Quigley lived an amazing life and I enjoyed the small part of the book that was actually about her life.
February 27, 2013
This was one of the most "REAL" books I've read, and I've read hundreds of wilderness biographies. There wasnt any romanticizing or glossing over in this rock hard woman's life, she was tough as nails! Her story is inspiring for those who have survived abuse and conquered or can conquer the mountains in their lives. Hers were real mountians, real guns, real work! She was one hellava woman!
August 2, 2007
still early in my reading, but i'm impressed with haigh's dedication to historical detail, and the bibliography is exciting! excellent historical photos of the denali/kantishna area. more to come...
March 10, 2011
Could use more story. Was looking for inspirational pioneer woman story.
July 11, 2011
I read this book after returning from an Alaska trip. You need to have been there to enjoy this read. Fannie was a tough woman, when you can see where she lived in Alaska
Catherine
Catherine
January 22, 2012
Interesting book on the nature of those early settlers of Alaska and the inner strength they had. Fairly interesting although as I read I knew I would never be one of those adventurers.
October 1, 2024
Very interesting biography about an Alaskan pioneer, Fannie Quigley who lived outside of Mount McKinley (now Denali National Park).
Displaying 1 - 15 of 15 reviews