What do you think?
Rate this book
El naufragio de "El río de las estrellas"
This is a compelling tale of the glory that was. In the days of the great sailing ships, in the mid-twenty-first century, when magnetic sails drew cargo and passengers alike to every corner of the solar system, sailors had the highest status of all spacemen, and the crew of the luxury liner the River of Stars, the highest among all sailors.
But development of the Farnsworth fusion drive doomed the sailing ships, and now the River of Stars is the last of its kind, retrofitted with engines, her mast vestigial, her sails unraised for years. An ungainly hybrid, she operates in the late years of the century as a mere tramp freighter among the outer planets, and her crew is a motley group of misfits. Stepan Gorgas is the escapist executive officer who becomes captain. Ramakrishnan Bhatterji is the chief engineer who disdains him. Eugenie Satterwaithe, once a captain herself, is third officer and, for form's sake, sailing master.
When an unlikely and catastrophic engine failure strikes the River, Bhatterji is confident he can effect repairs with heroic engineering, but Satterwaithe and the other sailors among the crew plot to save her with a glorious last gasp for the old ways, mesmerized by a vision of arriving at Jupiter proudly under sail. The story of their doom has the power, the poetry, and the inevitability of a Greek tragedy. This is a great science fiction novel, Flynn's best yet.
But development of the Farnsworth fusion drive doomed the sailing ships, and now the River of Stars is the last of its kind, retrofitted with engines, her mast vestigial, her sails unraised for years. An ungainly hybrid, she operates in the late years of the century as a mere tramp freighter among the outer planets, and her crew is a motley group of misfits. Stepan Gorgas is the escapist executive officer who becomes captain. Ramakrishnan Bhatterji is the chief engineer who disdains him. Eugenie Satterwaithe, once a captain herself, is third officer and, for form's sake, sailing master.
When an unlikely and catastrophic engine failure strikes the River, Bhatterji is confident he can effect repairs with heroic engineering, but Satterwaithe and the other sailors among the crew plot to save her with a glorious last gasp for the old ways, mesmerized by a vision of arriving at Jupiter proudly under sail. The story of their doom has the power, the poetry, and the inevitability of a Greek tragedy. This is a great science fiction novel, Flynn's best yet.
574 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 2003
59 people are currently reading
845 people want to read
About the author
Michael Flynn
115 books237 followersLibrarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. Please see this page for the list of authors.
Michael Francis Flynn (born 1947) is an American statistician and science fiction author. Nearly all of Flynn's work falls under the category of hard science fiction, although his treatment of it can be unusual since he has applied the rigor of hard science fiction to "softer" sciences such as sociology in works such as In the Country of the Blind. Much of his short fiction has appeared in Analog Science Fiction and Fact.
Flynn was born in Easton, Pennsylvania. He earned a B.A. in Mathematics from LaSalle University and an M.S. in topology from Marquette University. He has been employed as an industrial quality engineer and statistician.
Library of Congress authorities: Flynn, Michael (Michael F.)
Michael Francis Flynn (born 1947) is an American statistician and science fiction author. Nearly all of Flynn's work falls under the category of hard science fiction, although his treatment of it can be unusual since he has applied the rigor of hard science fiction to "softer" sciences such as sociology in works such as In the Country of the Blind. Much of his short fiction has appeared in Analog Science Fiction and Fact.
Flynn was born in Easton, Pennsylvania. He earned a B.A. in Mathematics from LaSalle University and an M.S. in topology from Marquette University. He has been employed as an industrial quality engineer and statistician.
Library of Congress authorities: Flynn, Michael (Michael F.)
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews
January 7, 2022
The MSS "River of Stars", the grandest of the great magsail liners, was launched in 2051. But the new Farnsworth fusion thrusters rang the death-knell for the magsails, and the now-obsolete liner was converted to fusion power in 2084. Two decades later, she has become a tramp freighter, bound for Dinwoody Poke, Jupiter space, on what will be her final voyage....
The Middle System -- Mars, the Belt, Jupiter space -- has not developed tidily, and the crew is made up of casualties of the great 21st-century space boom. The Wreck of the River of Stars is their story.
The Wreck of the River of Stars is a tour de force of character developement. We watch, riveted, as these motley misfits squabble, beef and try to cope, in the hermetic isolation of a ship becalmed in space -- two of her four Farnsworth engines have been ruined in a freak accident. The ship has 19 days to rebuild the engines, or she will pass the balk line, the point of no return, and drift endlessly away from settled space.
The repairs go slowly, but the ship's Engineer is a master of improvisation, and no one doubts he will fix the engines in time. No one, that is, but the oldest magsailors, who remember that the River of Stars still has her original sails, unused for decades. They decide to fix them up, just in case. No one likes, or trusts, the acting captain, so they don't tell him (or the Engineer) their plan -- which has a large share of nostalgia for the lost Age of Sail. And there isn't enough superconducting hobartium on board to repair both engines and sails....
The Wreck of the River of Stars is a classical tragedy. Hubris, small mistakes, misunderstandings, mishaps and personal conflicts collide, echo and feed back in a downward spiral that will ultimately wreck the great ship. It wouldn't be fair to reveal the ending, but it's not a happy one. There are no real villains here, just flawed people trying to cope, at times heroically. But the Fates are not on their side.
Michael Flynn tells his story in the third-person omniscient, with dry asides as he develops his characters. The omniscient narrator is the Greek chorus to the inevitable tragedy, which develops with an awful majesty. Flynn's writing is masterful. His pacing is grave, controlled, ironic. His characters will break your heart as they work, love, fight, grow, grieve and die. This is a wonderful book, easily Flynn's best. The Wreck of the River of Stars is set in the future of Flynn's popular near-future "Star" tetrology (also recommended), but is a stand-alone novel. This is the best hard-SF tragic novel of character yet written (though this is an uncrowded niche). And the cover art, by Stephan Martiniere, is just flat gorgeous. Highly recommended.
Reviewed for SF Site in 2003, https://www.sfsite.com/07a/wr155.htm
The Middle System -- Mars, the Belt, Jupiter space -- has not developed tidily, and the crew is made up of casualties of the great 21st-century space boom. The Wreck of the River of Stars is their story.
The Wreck of the River of Stars is a tour de force of character developement. We watch, riveted, as these motley misfits squabble, beef and try to cope, in the hermetic isolation of a ship becalmed in space -- two of her four Farnsworth engines have been ruined in a freak accident. The ship has 19 days to rebuild the engines, or she will pass the balk line, the point of no return, and drift endlessly away from settled space.
The repairs go slowly, but the ship's Engineer is a master of improvisation, and no one doubts he will fix the engines in time. No one, that is, but the oldest magsailors, who remember that the River of Stars still has her original sails, unused for decades. They decide to fix them up, just in case. No one likes, or trusts, the acting captain, so they don't tell him (or the Engineer) their plan -- which has a large share of nostalgia for the lost Age of Sail. And there isn't enough superconducting hobartium on board to repair both engines and sails....
The Wreck of the River of Stars is a classical tragedy. Hubris, small mistakes, misunderstandings, mishaps and personal conflicts collide, echo and feed back in a downward spiral that will ultimately wreck the great ship. It wouldn't be fair to reveal the ending, but it's not a happy one. There are no real villains here, just flawed people trying to cope, at times heroically. But the Fates are not on their side.
Michael Flynn tells his story in the third-person omniscient, with dry asides as he develops his characters. The omniscient narrator is the Greek chorus to the inevitable tragedy, which develops with an awful majesty. Flynn's writing is masterful. His pacing is grave, controlled, ironic. His characters will break your heart as they work, love, fight, grow, grieve and die. This is a wonderful book, easily Flynn's best. The Wreck of the River of Stars is set in the future of Flynn's popular near-future "Star" tetrology (also recommended), but is a stand-alone novel. This is the best hard-SF tragic novel of character yet written (though this is an uncrowded niche). And the cover art, by Stephan Martiniere, is just flat gorgeous. Highly recommended.
Reviewed for SF Site in 2003, https://www.sfsite.com/07a/wr155.htm
May 9, 2011
I started reading "The Wreck of the River of Stars" because someone on Amazon said it read like Jane Austen and that intrigued me.
The book by Michael Flynn wouldn't automatically make you think of Jane Austen. It's set aboard a former luxury liner the MS The River of Stars that plied the Earth-Mars route on solar sails. But the Farnsworth engine removed the need for sail and the once glorious ship has been turned into a hybrid tramp freighter that retained it MS designation -- Magnetic Sail -- only as an afterthought. The ship still carries its sails, almost forgotten and unused for years, but which may save the ship when the Farnsworth engines fail en route to Jupiter.
It's a ship of ghosts and the most recent ghost is Captain Evan Dodge Hand, who dies at the beginning of the book but whose presence, and most keenly his absence, is felt throughout the book. Captain Hand has assembled a crew of misfits, from the acting captain Stepan Gorgas to the engineer Ramakrishnan Bhatterji to the third in command Eugenie Satterthwaite. There are so many ghosts in this book, from all the captains of The River of Stars to the previous engineer who never it made to the ship after an EVA to the ship's artificial intelligence seemingly on the brink of self awareness.
There are few innocents on board and most of the characters are so damaged and so carefully examined by the omniscient narrator that there is no hero or heroine. I found it difficult to read and yet I read this 480 page novel in a few nights because beyond the Austen comparisons, and yes I will explain that, it evokes so many other wonderful stories. I've always had a fondness, you see, for the Great Eastern, the giant ship built by Isambard Kingdom Brunel, the engineering genius of the Victorian era. It was supposed to be so large that it could easily reward its investors by ferrying the emigrant trade to America, but a series of disasters brought it low until it ended its days as little more than a giant floating billboard, although it had one shining moment laying the trans-Atlantic cable that bridge the Old World and New. There is such a beautiful sadness in a ship made obsolete by time and technology.
And I've always had a fascination with sea stories that almost end in tragedy because good people fail to communicate, such as "The Caine Mutiny," or where obsession leads inexorably to tragedy, like "Moby Dick." In Flynn's book, the now first officer 'Abd al-Aziz Corrigan begins the tragedy when he thinks to use some of the long stowed solar sails to buy time until the Farnsworth engines can be repaired, but then Satterthwaite and cargo master Moth Ratline complicate matters when they suggest bringing the ship safely to port under full sail. And they carry their plans out in secret, not telling acting captain Gorgas who is too lost in memories of his lost wife and his lost career and drowning his sorrows not in drink but in endlessly replaying historical battles with the ship's artificial intelligence. And they fail to tell the engineer, who has no truck with sails, of their plans. And because they do not work openly, they work long hours in secret exhausting themselves.
Now as to Jane Austen: this book obviously isn't a Regency England costume drama, but the characters all suffer from an excess of pride and prejudice and sense and sensibility. Jealousy and anger and resentment and compassion and love fuel the dynamics of the people on the ship just as if they were in a Regency house party. Admittedly, the price of failure in Austen generally means you spend your life as a spinster instead of being doomed to a hyperbolic orbit that sends you out of the solar system.
All the characters here make incorrect assumptions. The crew believes that if the acting captain really wants something, like the position of a asteroid, he'll ask for it repeatedly. A young girl feels rejected by the engineer Bhatterji, unaware his taste tends more to young boys. The ship's only passenger falls for the awkward ship's doctor, unaware that it's a chemical romance.
It's tragedy and I hate tragedy and yet some of the best lines in literature come from tragedy. One of the great lines in this book, and the most Austen like, is: "She was the sort of person who, like God, creates others in her own image and, when they fail to behave as the image ought, labels them as disingenuous." This line sums up the tragedy of the book rather neatly. Everyone has an image they think they project but it's rarely the image that others perceive.
It almost makes you believe that any group of people can't help but fail in any endeavour, especially when you realize the roots of the tragedy can be traced all the way back to the dead captain Hand, who brought together a crew of damaged souls but like a king who fails to plan for his succession, fails them by dying.
I would highly recommend reading "The Wreck of the River of Stars" and I highly suspect you will feel rewarded for having read it. I can only warn you that I will likely never re-read it because I hate tragedy.
The book by Michael Flynn wouldn't automatically make you think of Jane Austen. It's set aboard a former luxury liner the MS The River of Stars that plied the Earth-Mars route on solar sails. But the Farnsworth engine removed the need for sail and the once glorious ship has been turned into a hybrid tramp freighter that retained it MS designation -- Magnetic Sail -- only as an afterthought. The ship still carries its sails, almost forgotten and unused for years, but which may save the ship when the Farnsworth engines fail en route to Jupiter.
It's a ship of ghosts and the most recent ghost is Captain Evan Dodge Hand, who dies at the beginning of the book but whose presence, and most keenly his absence, is felt throughout the book. Captain Hand has assembled a crew of misfits, from the acting captain Stepan Gorgas to the engineer Ramakrishnan Bhatterji to the third in command Eugenie Satterthwaite. There are so many ghosts in this book, from all the captains of The River of Stars to the previous engineer who never it made to the ship after an EVA to the ship's artificial intelligence seemingly on the brink of self awareness.
There are few innocents on board and most of the characters are so damaged and so carefully examined by the omniscient narrator that there is no hero or heroine. I found it difficult to read and yet I read this 480 page novel in a few nights because beyond the Austen comparisons, and yes I will explain that, it evokes so many other wonderful stories. I've always had a fondness, you see, for the Great Eastern, the giant ship built by Isambard Kingdom Brunel, the engineering genius of the Victorian era. It was supposed to be so large that it could easily reward its investors by ferrying the emigrant trade to America, but a series of disasters brought it low until it ended its days as little more than a giant floating billboard, although it had one shining moment laying the trans-Atlantic cable that bridge the Old World and New. There is such a beautiful sadness in a ship made obsolete by time and technology.
And I've always had a fascination with sea stories that almost end in tragedy because good people fail to communicate, such as "The Caine Mutiny," or where obsession leads inexorably to tragedy, like "Moby Dick." In Flynn's book, the now first officer 'Abd al-Aziz Corrigan begins the tragedy when he thinks to use some of the long stowed solar sails to buy time until the Farnsworth engines can be repaired, but then Satterthwaite and cargo master Moth Ratline complicate matters when they suggest bringing the ship safely to port under full sail. And they carry their plans out in secret, not telling acting captain Gorgas who is too lost in memories of his lost wife and his lost career and drowning his sorrows not in drink but in endlessly replaying historical battles with the ship's artificial intelligence. And they fail to tell the engineer, who has no truck with sails, of their plans. And because they do not work openly, they work long hours in secret exhausting themselves.
Now as to Jane Austen: this book obviously isn't a Regency England costume drama, but the characters all suffer from an excess of pride and prejudice and sense and sensibility. Jealousy and anger and resentment and compassion and love fuel the dynamics of the people on the ship just as if they were in a Regency house party. Admittedly, the price of failure in Austen generally means you spend your life as a spinster instead of being doomed to a hyperbolic orbit that sends you out of the solar system.
All the characters here make incorrect assumptions. The crew believes that if the acting captain really wants something, like the position of a asteroid, he'll ask for it repeatedly. A young girl feels rejected by the engineer Bhatterji, unaware his taste tends more to young boys. The ship's only passenger falls for the awkward ship's doctor, unaware that it's a chemical romance.
It's tragedy and I hate tragedy and yet some of the best lines in literature come from tragedy. One of the great lines in this book, and the most Austen like, is: "She was the sort of person who, like God, creates others in her own image and, when they fail to behave as the image ought, labels them as disingenuous." This line sums up the tragedy of the book rather neatly. Everyone has an image they think they project but it's rarely the image that others perceive.
It almost makes you believe that any group of people can't help but fail in any endeavour, especially when you realize the roots of the tragedy can be traced all the way back to the dead captain Hand, who brought together a crew of damaged souls but like a king who fails to plan for his succession, fails them by dying.
I would highly recommend reading "The Wreck of the River of Stars" and I highly suspect you will feel rewarded for having read it. I can only warn you that I will likely never re-read it because I hate tragedy.
May 10, 2013
I wanted very much to love this book: first, because Eifelheim is one of my favorite books ever, and second, because I think the title is so very great. It just sounds like an awesome book, the River of Stars being the name of a (space) sailing ship.
I was probably ignoring the obvious (in hindsight) fact that this really isn't my thing in the first place. I love the concept -- so the ship was originally a luxury cruise space ship, but now it's outdated so it's been retrofitted with some sort of fusion engine (I think, I saw the word fusion a few times, but more on that later) and is hauling freight with a skeleton crew. But this is also the kind of book that has A LOT of information about fictional technology, and you have to at least moderately pay attention to it because it factors into the plot. And even worse, a frightening amount of space slang. I'm sure some people get it right, but usually I find too much space slang (or any kind of fictional world slang) very cringy. As this was.
On the other hand, I did get a kick out of how the author indulged a bit in some cute literary references in the narrative voice. As well as puns. If you're writing a book this long, you might as well have some fun with it, so hats off to Mr. Flynn (although there was one pun that clearly and disgracefully crossed the line into Unforgivable).
It's the kind of book that assumes a future where men and women are equal to the point of non-comment -- they have equal potential for roles in running a ship, which was nice. At the same time, I was a little surprised to see that this came out in 2003, because there was a gay character whose being gay seemed associated with an attitude of, okay how to describe this? Like being gay was perfectly all right, but still seemed to come with a feeling of being fated for disappointment. It's a view that always reminds me of the mid-1990s.
By the last 1/4 of the book, it had gotten very exciting, but it's a long 3/4 of a book that comes before. And the hardest thing for me to overcome with this book is something that I read in the acknowledgements. I know someone who refuses to the read the acknowledgements before reading the book, on point of principle, which I always thought was a little dramatic. I mean, what's the worst that can happen? Maybe the author mentions his/her love for someone completely awful, but how often can that happen? Now I'm thinking maybe that person has a point, because in the acknowledgements I read that the author first had the idea for this story after learning about
That sounds like a lot of trauma for a book that I still enjoyed well enough. And I think that someone who already likes this kind of techy space book would enjoy it even more. This is also the review, though, where at the end, I strongly recommend that people go read Eifelheim.
I was probably ignoring the obvious (in hindsight) fact that this really isn't my thing in the first place. I love the concept -- so the ship was originally a luxury cruise space ship, but now it's outdated so it's been retrofitted with some sort of fusion engine (I think, I saw the word fusion a few times, but more on that later) and is hauling freight with a skeleton crew. But this is also the kind of book that has A LOT of information about fictional technology, and you have to at least moderately pay attention to it because it factors into the plot. And even worse, a frightening amount of space slang. I'm sure some people get it right, but usually I find too much space slang (or any kind of fictional world slang) very cringy. As this was.
On the other hand, I did get a kick out of how the author indulged a bit in some cute literary references in the narrative voice. As well as puns. If you're writing a book this long, you might as well have some fun with it, so hats off to Mr. Flynn (although there was one pun that clearly and disgracefully crossed the line into Unforgivable).
It's the kind of book that assumes a future where men and women are equal to the point of non-comment -- they have equal potential for roles in running a ship, which was nice. At the same time, I was a little surprised to see that this came out in 2003, because there was a gay character whose being gay seemed associated with an attitude of, okay how to describe this? Like being gay was perfectly all right, but still seemed to come with a feeling of being fated for disappointment. It's a view that always reminds me of the mid-1990s.
By the last 1/4 of the book, it had gotten very exciting, but it's a long 3/4 of a book that comes before. And the hardest thing for me to overcome with this book is something that I read in the acknowledgements. I know someone who refuses to the read the acknowledgements before reading the book, on point of principle, which I always thought was a little dramatic. I mean, what's the worst that can happen? Maybe the author mentions his/her love for someone completely awful, but how often can that happen? Now I'm thinking maybe that person has a point, because in the acknowledgements I read that the author first had the idea for this story after learning about
That sounds like a lot of trauma for a book that I still enjoyed well enough. And I think that someone who already likes this kind of techy space book would enjoy it even more. This is also the review, though, where at the end, I strongly recommend that people go read Eifelheim.
January 19, 2008
Excellent book! I fell in love with the way Flynn uses words.
This is hard sci-fi, but mostly it's a character study. The author used the Myers-Briggs personality types to create 15 disparate characters and placed them on an interplanetary spaceship - a former luxury cruiser now serving as a cargo freighter.
We observe as they squabble, or make love, or isolate themselves; as they project their own desires and inadequacies onto the motivations of others; as small mistakes and misunderstandings slowly add up to a tragedy.
I'll admit that in the beginning of the book the character analysis almost gets in the way of the story. By the halfway point, though, the stage was set and I began to get a sense of where the story was going. The author is skilled enough that I was never once confused by the multitude of characters.
This is hard sci-fi, but mostly it's a character study. The author used the Myers-Briggs personality types to create 15 disparate characters and placed them on an interplanetary spaceship - a former luxury cruiser now serving as a cargo freighter.
We observe as they squabble, or make love, or isolate themselves; as they project their own desires and inadequacies onto the motivations of others; as small mistakes and misunderstandings slowly add up to a tragedy.
I'll admit that in the beginning of the book the character analysis almost gets in the way of the story. By the halfway point, though, the stage was set and I began to get a sense of where the story was going. The author is skilled enough that I was never once confused by the multitude of characters.
March 27, 2011
The cover looks magnificent. Flynn is back with a near future tale mirroring the twilight days of the age of sail. “The River of Stars” has long ago furled it’s magnetic sail in favor of a more modern engine. The past glories of the ship are almost forgotten as she plies her trade as a tramp freighter. But an engine failure forces a difficult decision. Her crew want to use the sail to save the ship in a last tribute to her old days of glory.
Incidentally, the story is set in the same universe as the Firestar series, with quite a few inside references sprinkled around for the avid Flynn fan.
It took me more than a month to read this book. Flynn’s prose is unusually fine, but it takes a long time to get through it. The title says it all, I guess, and the ending is more or less foretold from the beginning. This novel concentrates on the characters and their interactions. Long gone are the glory days of The River of Stars, and her crew is made up of a collection of misfits and losers who cannot find another berth. The Captain dies in the very first chapter, and things go downhill from there. Gradually the flawed crewmembers dance out their dance of death, and maybe they know their fate all along, which makes the drama even stronger.
I should point out that this book is intensely psychological, and does not, despite the setting, move very fast at all. Descriptions of feelings and motivations and interactions are drawn out almost to breaking point. It is a tribute to Flynn that he manages to hold the reader’s interest. So be warned, this is not a light summer read, but its majesty will captivate you.
http://www.books.rosboch.net/?p=181
Incidentally, the story is set in the same universe as the Firestar series, with quite a few inside references sprinkled around for the avid Flynn fan.
It took me more than a month to read this book. Flynn’s prose is unusually fine, but it takes a long time to get through it. The title says it all, I guess, and the ending is more or less foretold from the beginning. This novel concentrates on the characters and their interactions. Long gone are the glory days of The River of Stars, and her crew is made up of a collection of misfits and losers who cannot find another berth. The Captain dies in the very first chapter, and things go downhill from there. Gradually the flawed crewmembers dance out their dance of death, and maybe they know their fate all along, which makes the drama even stronger.
I should point out that this book is intensely psychological, and does not, despite the setting, move very fast at all. Descriptions of feelings and motivations and interactions are drawn out almost to breaking point. It is a tribute to Flynn that he manages to hold the reader’s interest. So be warned, this is not a light summer read, but its majesty will captivate you.
http://www.books.rosboch.net/?p=181
October 3, 2013
Very interesting to read in terms of the writing itself. The way situations or feelings are described is clever, for example switching subtly between viewpoints of characters between sentences.
The characters have some depth and colour, but more important are the interactions between the characters. It's a novel about a spaceship but really it's about social conflicts in a small ship alone in big space.
The plot arc moves quite slowly so I found it easy to put down. However, I never wanted to leave it on the bedside table for too long, because the overall story is engaging enough that I wanted to fund out how it would develop.
I enjoyed the science themes, they were credible and well described, but not overwhelmingly technical. I never felt lost or confused about the setting.
Summary: Clever writing, creative story, and focus on social interactions in tight spaces.
The characters have some depth and colour, but more important are the interactions between the characters. It's a novel about a spaceship but really it's about social conflicts in a small ship alone in big space.
The plot arc moves quite slowly so I found it easy to put down. However, I never wanted to leave it on the bedside table for too long, because the overall story is engaging enough that I wanted to fund out how it would develop.
I enjoyed the science themes, they were credible and well described, but not overwhelmingly technical. I never felt lost or confused about the setting.
Summary: Clever writing, creative story, and focus on social interactions in tight spaces.
June 3, 2008
At first glance, this looks like typical hard science fiction. But once you get into it, you realize it's not really about spaceships at all. It's a lovely character study of the crew of a doomed ship--their inner demons, their secret desires, and the odd but curiously touching little community they create. It could just as easily be set on a sailing ship in the 1700s. Flynn is a top-notch writer who uses SF tropes to tell compelling stories about people.
January 24, 2014
Despite critical acclaim, I found this plodding narrative to be impossible to finish. All character development, no real story.
August 10, 2022
Michael Flynn is rapidly making his way into my pantheon of favorite authors. He is not for everyone, though. If I had to use a metaphor, I would say he is like port wine – too exotic for people used to your regular beers, vodkas and whiskeys, while at the same time perhaps too cloyingly sweet for someone looking for the proper tartness of fine wines. Yet somehow the balance he walks between rigidly hard SF, mainstream literary character-based introspection and wild outbursts of pure purple prose strikes the exact right chord in me. As for this novel, if I had to sum it up very briefly, I would say something like Carpenter’s Dark Star crossed with a deep dive into an ensemble cast of tragic misfits that, despite in some ways being caricatures, ultimately show us everything that can go wrong with just plain being (all kinds of) human in an implacable, uncaring universe.
December 8, 2018
I lost this book either in an airport or the back of a taxi, only a hundred pages or so from the end. A slow build, with 16 characters stuck together on a crippled spaceship, each of them representing a personality variant outlined in the Briggs-Myers Indicator. Pretty good idea. But the characters also represent a contrived spectrum of nationalities and sexuality, and Flynn's technology seems lifted from the time he wrote the book-- these people have e-mail!-- and his harping on clunky, sexist ideas of beauty and attraction bring the story close to Big Brother territory.
November 11, 2012
Unless you are a serious devotee of science fiction you've probably never heard of Michael Flynn; I hadn't until a couple of years ago, and I take my science fiction very seriously. He tends to fly beneath the radar, eschewing melodramatic space opera, in favor of highly detailed, very plausible multi-threaded stories, spread out on a very large scale. Unlike many authors of the genre, he publishes only once every several years, and the level of skill, commitment and imagination that goes into each novel makes the wait worthwhile.
I lucked onto Flynn with a novel called In The Kingdom Of The Blind, a fabulist present-day thriller about a plot (actually several plots) to control world events via the science of Cliology, or the mathematical analysis of recurrent historical trends (Clio is the traditional Greek Muse of history). I then went backwards, into Flynn's Firestar quartet; four sequential novels illustrating how one woman with a great deal of money (and a severe phobia of asteroid impacts), can seed an entire generation of high school students with the inspiration to reach for the stars, as well as the education to get there.
The saga follows several of these students (and some of their adult mentors) from the present to the near future, as they build a private fleet of commercial spacecraft and eventually develop the technology to open the solar system to paying customers. What makes the Firestar books unique is the hyper-realistic depiction of the enormous economic, political, social and especially personal costs of such an extraordinary effort. Lives are lost, reputations ruined, businesses destroyed and the world forever altered by the struggle to colonize space - but the benefits are equal to the price.
Flynn followed this series with The Wreck Of The River Of Stars, set decades after the Firestar protagonists have established the interplanetary trade. The title is the name of a legendary spaceliner, using magnetic sails to ply the interplanetary spacelanes between the inner planets and Jupiter's moons, carrying high-priced freight and glamourous passengers.
But the book begins long after the decline of the great sailing ships, inevitably replaced by faster, fusion-powered vessels. Once glorious, The River of Stars is now a lowly tramp freighter, her sails stowed, her passenger decks largely mothballed, and her sleek beauty marred by a quartet of retrofitted fusion motors. Worse still, her ranks of spiffy officers and cabin stewards have given way to a scruffy, mismatched skeleton crew of misfits and losers, held together solely by the grace of their remarkable captain, Evan Dodge Hand.
We never see Hand in action; the book opens with his untimely death. Simultaneously, a rogue pebble impacts the ship's fusion system, shutting down two of the engines. Depending largely on gravitational largesse to make its rendezvous with Jupiter, the ship needs at least three working engines to avoid missing port, and flying out into the eternal darkness. As the members of the crew try to work together to address the problem, they uniformly fail to see the more important issue: without the Captain to mediate between them, their individual failings, idiosyncrasies, and emotional baggage doom the effort from the start.
With a necessarily limited cast of characters, confined to a single locale, Flynn creates an unforgettable group of damaged personalities, each with a full complement of prejudices, recriminations and tarnished hopes and dreams. A ship's doctor sublimates her romantic and sexual needs with a drug addiction. The First Officer (now Acting Captain) with a horrible episode of indecision in his past, spends his time replaying old military battles on the ship's computer, abandoning any pretense of leadership.
Meanwhile, the ship's engineer trusts his own inflated ego (inflamed by the sexual rejection of his young and fatally inexperienced assistant) to repair the damaged engines before the deadline. And two other crewmembers, associated with the ship's halcyon sailing days, plot to outfox the engineer by hatching a daring plan to unpack the rigging, and fly into the Jupiter roads triumphantly, under full sail.
There are other crew, and other equally fascinating stories, aboard The River of Stars, and each has a vital part to play in the making of an avoidable disaster. In Flynn's world, character is destiny - each individual's flaws create an inescapable trap, all interweaving together in a blind inexorable march toward doom. This is epic tragedy, rendered on an intimate, almost tender scale. And the emotionally wracking "if only" moments of missed opportunities, failed communications, and personal hubris resonantly emulate such nonfictional catastrophes as the Titanic and the Hindenberg.
This is a dense, subtle, nuanced, and above all, human story - brimming with fallibility, questioning the possibility of redemption, examining the latent darkness of the human soul. I've had to read three times to see into its depths, and I do not plan to review the two unrelated books that Flynn has since written, Eifelheim and The January Dancer, until I have reread them thoroughly. On first acquaintance, though, both show themselves to be just as thoughtful, as imaginative, as realistic, and as moving, as The Wreck Of The River Of Stars.
I lucked onto Flynn with a novel called In The Kingdom Of The Blind, a fabulist present-day thriller about a plot (actually several plots) to control world events via the science of Cliology, or the mathematical analysis of recurrent historical trends (Clio is the traditional Greek Muse of history). I then went backwards, into Flynn's Firestar quartet; four sequential novels illustrating how one woman with a great deal of money (and a severe phobia of asteroid impacts), can seed an entire generation of high school students with the inspiration to reach for the stars, as well as the education to get there.
The saga follows several of these students (and some of their adult mentors) from the present to the near future, as they build a private fleet of commercial spacecraft and eventually develop the technology to open the solar system to paying customers. What makes the Firestar books unique is the hyper-realistic depiction of the enormous economic, political, social and especially personal costs of such an extraordinary effort. Lives are lost, reputations ruined, businesses destroyed and the world forever altered by the struggle to colonize space - but the benefits are equal to the price.
Flynn followed this series with The Wreck Of The River Of Stars, set decades after the Firestar protagonists have established the interplanetary trade. The title is the name of a legendary spaceliner, using magnetic sails to ply the interplanetary spacelanes between the inner planets and Jupiter's moons, carrying high-priced freight and glamourous passengers.
But the book begins long after the decline of the great sailing ships, inevitably replaced by faster, fusion-powered vessels. Once glorious, The River of Stars is now a lowly tramp freighter, her sails stowed, her passenger decks largely mothballed, and her sleek beauty marred by a quartet of retrofitted fusion motors. Worse still, her ranks of spiffy officers and cabin stewards have given way to a scruffy, mismatched skeleton crew of misfits and losers, held together solely by the grace of their remarkable captain, Evan Dodge Hand.
We never see Hand in action; the book opens with his untimely death. Simultaneously, a rogue pebble impacts the ship's fusion system, shutting down two of the engines. Depending largely on gravitational largesse to make its rendezvous with Jupiter, the ship needs at least three working engines to avoid missing port, and flying out into the eternal darkness. As the members of the crew try to work together to address the problem, they uniformly fail to see the more important issue: without the Captain to mediate between them, their individual failings, idiosyncrasies, and emotional baggage doom the effort from the start.
With a necessarily limited cast of characters, confined to a single locale, Flynn creates an unforgettable group of damaged personalities, each with a full complement of prejudices, recriminations and tarnished hopes and dreams. A ship's doctor sublimates her romantic and sexual needs with a drug addiction. The First Officer (now Acting Captain) with a horrible episode of indecision in his past, spends his time replaying old military battles on the ship's computer, abandoning any pretense of leadership.
Meanwhile, the ship's engineer trusts his own inflated ego (inflamed by the sexual rejection of his young and fatally inexperienced assistant) to repair the damaged engines before the deadline. And two other crewmembers, associated with the ship's halcyon sailing days, plot to outfox the engineer by hatching a daring plan to unpack the rigging, and fly into the Jupiter roads triumphantly, under full sail.
There are other crew, and other equally fascinating stories, aboard The River of Stars, and each has a vital part to play in the making of an avoidable disaster. In Flynn's world, character is destiny - each individual's flaws create an inescapable trap, all interweaving together in a blind inexorable march toward doom. This is epic tragedy, rendered on an intimate, almost tender scale. And the emotionally wracking "if only" moments of missed opportunities, failed communications, and personal hubris resonantly emulate such nonfictional catastrophes as the Titanic and the Hindenberg.
This is a dense, subtle, nuanced, and above all, human story - brimming with fallibility, questioning the possibility of redemption, examining the latent darkness of the human soul. I've had to read three times to see into its depths, and I do not plan to review the two unrelated books that Flynn has since written, Eifelheim and The January Dancer, until I have reread them thoroughly. On first acquaintance, though, both show themselves to be just as thoughtful, as imaginative, as realistic, and as moving, as The Wreck Of The River Of Stars.
January 13, 2011
The River of Stars used to be one of the grand ships of the space lanes, a luxury magnetic sail passenger liner. Then she got older, and got demoted to carrying colonists to Mars. Then the fusion drive was developed, and The River lost a race, and started losing money, and a fusion drive was installed, and she became, of ficially, a hybrid ship. In reality, the sails and rigging were never used again. Eventually, a consortium bought her to keep her from being scrapped, and she became a tramp freighter.
Then her latest captain, Evan Dodge Hand, died while en route from Mars to Jupiter. And then her luck turned bad.
When two of her four Farnsworth engines are wrecked by a freak encounter with an asteroid (even in the asteroid belt, space is mostly empty), the crew, minus Evan Hand, has to get her fixed quickly or they'll miss turnover and not reach Jupiter orbit when Jupiter's there. Unfortunately, the crew minus Evan Hand is a disaster waiting to happen. Some of them are survivors of the old sailing days, and regard engines as an abomination. Some of them are of the generat ion that grew up regarding sails as old-fashioned and obviously inferior, while the cargo wranglers and the engineer's mate, Miko, are too young to regard sails as anything but stories out of a romantic past. Stepan Gorgas, the new acting captain, is obsessed with detail and contingency, and very slow to make decisions. He tends to assume that everyone has worked out the contingencies as thoroughly as he has, and that therefore when he gives order, it will be followed immediately without need for further explanation or follow-up. Most of the crew has come to assume that if Gorgas really wants something, he'll ask again. The engineer, Ram Bhatterji, is a firm believer in spontaneity and inspiration, not careful and detailed planning. 'Abd al-Aziz Corrigan, the second officer, is rigidly by-the-rules, hates the unexpected, and finds Gorgas and Bhatterji about equally incomprehensible. The third officer, Eugenie Satterwaithe, is also the sailing master (required by the ship's hybrid designation), and was briefly the captain of The River in the last of her sailing days and when she was converted to fusion drive. This explains why the cargo master, Moth Ratline, the longest-serving member of the crew (he came aboard as a cabin boy in the luxury liner days), tends to address her as "captain", to the ever-lovin' delight of Gorgas and Corrigan.
From there on down the characters start to get strange.
It's important to note that this mismatch of characters apparently worked, under Evan Hand. He chose his crew based on the potential he saw in them, put the effort forth to make sure he got that potential out of him while he was in command, and didn't properly think through what would happen if he weren't there.
None of the crew is incompetent. Not one of them intends to be irresponsible. They're all trying to do their best to save the ship--but in the right way, their way. And Bhatterji and Satterwaithe, in particular, aren't really trying to save the same ship.
The old sailors of the crew--Corrigan, Satterwaithe, Ratline (and Hand until he died)--meet for dinner every Thursday night, and are joined from time to time by other officers or senior crew and, on this trip, the passenger, Bigelow Fife. When Bhatterji's repairs start to look like taking too long and not being especially carefully planned, this little group starts to think about the sails, and decide to check them out and do whatever repair work is necessary so that, when the time comes, they can present Gorgas with another option, sailing The River into port one last time. And so begins a great struggle for resources, on the mundane level, and, on another level, the soul of the ship.
It's no spoiler to say what the title says: this is a tragedy. What's important is that it's a well-done tragedy; no one here does anything stupid just because the plot requires it. These characters, with their mix of virtues and flaws and virtues that are flaws would make just these kinds of mistakes. You might want to whack them on the head with the book, but you won't want to whack Flynn on the head with it.
This is a good read, well worth a few hours' time.
Then her latest captain, Evan Dodge Hand, died while en route from Mars to Jupiter. And then her luck turned bad.
When two of her four Farnsworth engines are wrecked by a freak encounter with an asteroid (even in the asteroid belt, space is mostly empty), the crew, minus Evan Hand, has to get her fixed quickly or they'll miss turnover and not reach Jupiter orbit when Jupiter's there. Unfortunately, the crew minus Evan Hand is a disaster waiting to happen. Some of them are survivors of the old sailing days, and regard engines as an abomination. Some of them are of the generat ion that grew up regarding sails as old-fashioned and obviously inferior, while the cargo wranglers and the engineer's mate, Miko, are too young to regard sails as anything but stories out of a romantic past. Stepan Gorgas, the new acting captain, is obsessed with detail and contingency, and very slow to make decisions. He tends to assume that everyone has worked out the contingencies as thoroughly as he has, and that therefore when he gives order, it will be followed immediately without need for further explanation or follow-up. Most of the crew has come to assume that if Gorgas really wants something, he'll ask again. The engineer, Ram Bhatterji, is a firm believer in spontaneity and inspiration, not careful and detailed planning. 'Abd al-Aziz Corrigan, the second officer, is rigidly by-the-rules, hates the unexpected, and finds Gorgas and Bhatterji about equally incomprehensible. The third officer, Eugenie Satterwaithe, is also the sailing master (required by the ship's hybrid designation), and was briefly the captain of The River in the last of her sailing days and when she was converted to fusion drive. This explains why the cargo master, Moth Ratline, the longest-serving member of the crew (he came aboard as a cabin boy in the luxury liner days), tends to address her as "captain", to the ever-lovin' delight of Gorgas and Corrigan.
From there on down the characters start to get strange.
It's important to note that this mismatch of characters apparently worked, under Evan Hand. He chose his crew based on the potential he saw in them, put the effort forth to make sure he got that potential out of him while he was in command, and didn't properly think through what would happen if he weren't there.
None of the crew is incompetent. Not one of them intends to be irresponsible. They're all trying to do their best to save the ship--but in the right way, their way. And Bhatterji and Satterwaithe, in particular, aren't really trying to save the same ship.
The old sailors of the crew--Corrigan, Satterwaithe, Ratline (and Hand until he died)--meet for dinner every Thursday night, and are joined from time to time by other officers or senior crew and, on this trip, the passenger, Bigelow Fife. When Bhatterji's repairs start to look like taking too long and not being especially carefully planned, this little group starts to think about the sails, and decide to check them out and do whatever repair work is necessary so that, when the time comes, they can present Gorgas with another option, sailing The River into port one last time. And so begins a great struggle for resources, on the mundane level, and, on another level, the soul of the ship.
It's no spoiler to say what the title says: this is a tragedy. What's important is that it's a well-done tragedy; no one here does anything stupid just because the plot requires it. These characters, with their mix of virtues and flaws and virtues that are flaws would make just these kinds of mistakes. You might want to whack them on the head with the book, but you won't want to whack Flynn on the head with it.
This is a good read, well worth a few hours' time.
March 21, 2018
Some characters are such that you have no choice but to look up to and identify with them, keenly sharing their hopes and dreams and fears while reveling in the exciting adventures they're undergoing. And while that's one way to tell a story, author Michael Flynn decides on a different tactic, crafting a story in such a way as to make you look at the characters and go, "Geez, I'm awful glad I'm not these people."
Its not that they're bad people, they're just on the wrong ship at the wrong time making the wrong decisions at the wrong moments, all at once, existing in a novel called "The Wreck of the River of Stars" and not "The Unexpected Last Second Heroic Salvation of the River of Stars". So you can see what the chances are of this ending well. The question will be how much you want to see these people blunder forward to their tragic and inevitable doom.
It takes place on the titular River of Stars, a former space sailing ship converted to engine propulsion and making a run out near Jupiter with a full crew and single passenger. Er, make that a full crew minus one as in nearly the first chapter the captain Evan Hand decides to finally succumb to some strange illness, leaving the rest of the ship to ponder in the wake of events whether he was an awesome captain or they're a really incompetent crew.
Even knowing that doom is going to eventually wrapping its vaporous tentacles around events, its clear that its not going to be happening right away as the book is over five hundred pages and very deliberately paced. In fact, for anyone without a nautical background the beginning may be rough going as he introduces character after character that seem to go out of their way to not win over your heart with their various off-putting flaws and the fact that very few of them seem to like each other very much, peppering their thoughts with various jealousies and slights real or imagined. Its very much an ensemble cast without much in the way of standouts and until the actual plot starts to accelerate like a barrel heading for a waterfall you're stuck learning about the workings of a future spaceship as various characters reminisce about when the ship was more important or prestigious back in the good old days when it had sails everywhere. Its not bad and Flynn's writing is quite lyrical in spots but his tone is strangely flat for long stretches and since the characters are not that dynamic (or hate each other) it can make for some tedious writing due to how dense the material is. And having made it through several volumes of William Hodgson stories set on actual sailing vessels its not that I'm somehow allergic to terms like "mizzenmast", its just that Flynn's presentation is such on a slow burn that it might as well be in a crock pot.
Still, while a number of writers have captured what it might feel like to be on spaceship, he's probably in a genre of one in terms of setting here as he seems to be shooting for reenacting that old Gordon Lightfoot song but in space, with all the scientific accuracy it requires. And much like the beloved Canadian folk singer's seven minute epic, Flynn appears to be in for the long payoff, layering character developments and motivations while taking his sweet time in doing so in the hopes that people will stick around long enough to see the culmination. He seems especially interested in tracing out the rivalries and mistrust that exists among the various crew members, whether its philosophical differences, ego, or the age old problem of when you can't be with the one you love trying to love the one you're with (and while the approach pays some dividends later there is enough of a focus on who is thinking about sleeping with who that you wonder how any actual sailing gets done) . . . in the process he starts to lay down the building blocks for what will end up being a lot of things going wrong at once.
So an engine goes and the egotistical engineer confidently takes his time. Members of the crew from the glory days start to plot using the ship's sails instead without telling anyone else. The new captain decides to play in an outer space version of "Hamlet" and make zero decisions whatsoever. Meanwhile people make mistakes, withhold crucial information from each other, make the wrong estimates and generally prove that there's never any situation so bad that people can't go and make it worse.
And weirdly, almost despite yourself, you start to care about what happens in the story. Not so much about the characters, although one or two odd ones here and there tug at our sympathies, but as it becomes clearer that almost none of these people seem fated to survive the novel engenders this weird fascination as you wait to see what the final straw is going to be for their hopes. You watch the collision of carefully laid down plans that counteract each other when a little trust and communication would have saved the day. You watch simple errors compound and come back to haunt people. You watch the lone passenger, a dude from Luna, look at what he's surrounded by and wonder if the crew of the Enterprise ever had these problems.
In its own way its effective, conveying the bones of a tragedy that didn't need to happen and giving the cast just enough time to realize how profoundly they've screwed this up before letting cruel fate have its way with them. Once events have accumulated enough weight to make it clear that the book title isn't being ironic things start to pick up and all the sea chickens come home to their roosts the book develops a car crash aspect to it as you watch people who were very confident that not only survival but glorious victory was in their grasps not only come to terms with the idea of utter futility but also the reality that they tied their own ropes around their necks in the process. And because you've spent so much time with the characters you do start to feel for them . . . you may not like them that much but there's no outright villains, just people driven by pettiness and self-interest and an unswerving confidence that they're more right than anyone else. Even so, none of them deserve to die any more than your neighbors do, but some wrong choices you pay for with money and some you pay for with much more.
The sheer feel of the downhill slide of the back portions of the book rank with some of the most funereal and inevitable passages I've ever heard and while its easy to garner sympathy in people faced with the reality of not leaving the ship alive, its harder to do without being maudlin. Flynn pulls it off and while I was skeptical when starting the book he does eventually justify almost every narrative and structural decision he's made when crafting the novel. His reliance on the nuts and bolts of sailing, his curiously even prose and emotional distance from the characters are going to make the early stages rough going and a decent number of people aren't going to be convinced its worth the slog. And maybe it was just me settling in and getting used to the style but I think he pulls it up and brings it home. It won't outrank that classic of doomed seaman Hodgson's "The Ghost Ship" in terms of "oh boy these guys are screwed" but while Hodgson's story pivoted on a sort of cosmic "ghosts are killing you because you're there and nothing matters" this one does one-up that by giving everyone a chance to put their hands on the steering wheel and sail the ship right over the edge. If nothing else, its a five hundred page lesson in the value of communication with your coworkers.
Its not that they're bad people, they're just on the wrong ship at the wrong time making the wrong decisions at the wrong moments, all at once, existing in a novel called "The Wreck of the River of Stars" and not "The Unexpected Last Second Heroic Salvation of the River of Stars". So you can see what the chances are of this ending well. The question will be how much you want to see these people blunder forward to their tragic and inevitable doom.
It takes place on the titular River of Stars, a former space sailing ship converted to engine propulsion and making a run out near Jupiter with a full crew and single passenger. Er, make that a full crew minus one as in nearly the first chapter the captain Evan Hand decides to finally succumb to some strange illness, leaving the rest of the ship to ponder in the wake of events whether he was an awesome captain or they're a really incompetent crew.
Even knowing that doom is going to eventually wrapping its vaporous tentacles around events, its clear that its not going to be happening right away as the book is over five hundred pages and very deliberately paced. In fact, for anyone without a nautical background the beginning may be rough going as he introduces character after character that seem to go out of their way to not win over your heart with their various off-putting flaws and the fact that very few of them seem to like each other very much, peppering their thoughts with various jealousies and slights real or imagined. Its very much an ensemble cast without much in the way of standouts and until the actual plot starts to accelerate like a barrel heading for a waterfall you're stuck learning about the workings of a future spaceship as various characters reminisce about when the ship was more important or prestigious back in the good old days when it had sails everywhere. Its not bad and Flynn's writing is quite lyrical in spots but his tone is strangely flat for long stretches and since the characters are not that dynamic (or hate each other) it can make for some tedious writing due to how dense the material is. And having made it through several volumes of William Hodgson stories set on actual sailing vessels its not that I'm somehow allergic to terms like "mizzenmast", its just that Flynn's presentation is such on a slow burn that it might as well be in a crock pot.
Still, while a number of writers have captured what it might feel like to be on spaceship, he's probably in a genre of one in terms of setting here as he seems to be shooting for reenacting that old Gordon Lightfoot song but in space, with all the scientific accuracy it requires. And much like the beloved Canadian folk singer's seven minute epic, Flynn appears to be in for the long payoff, layering character developments and motivations while taking his sweet time in doing so in the hopes that people will stick around long enough to see the culmination. He seems especially interested in tracing out the rivalries and mistrust that exists among the various crew members, whether its philosophical differences, ego, or the age old problem of when you can't be with the one you love trying to love the one you're with (and while the approach pays some dividends later there is enough of a focus on who is thinking about sleeping with who that you wonder how any actual sailing gets done) . . . in the process he starts to lay down the building blocks for what will end up being a lot of things going wrong at once.
So an engine goes and the egotistical engineer confidently takes his time. Members of the crew from the glory days start to plot using the ship's sails instead without telling anyone else. The new captain decides to play in an outer space version of "Hamlet" and make zero decisions whatsoever. Meanwhile people make mistakes, withhold crucial information from each other, make the wrong estimates and generally prove that there's never any situation so bad that people can't go and make it worse.
And weirdly, almost despite yourself, you start to care about what happens in the story. Not so much about the characters, although one or two odd ones here and there tug at our sympathies, but as it becomes clearer that almost none of these people seem fated to survive the novel engenders this weird fascination as you wait to see what the final straw is going to be for their hopes. You watch the collision of carefully laid down plans that counteract each other when a little trust and communication would have saved the day. You watch simple errors compound and come back to haunt people. You watch the lone passenger, a dude from Luna, look at what he's surrounded by and wonder if the crew of the Enterprise ever had these problems.
In its own way its effective, conveying the bones of a tragedy that didn't need to happen and giving the cast just enough time to realize how profoundly they've screwed this up before letting cruel fate have its way with them. Once events have accumulated enough weight to make it clear that the book title isn't being ironic things start to pick up and all the sea chickens come home to their roosts the book develops a car crash aspect to it as you watch people who were very confident that not only survival but glorious victory was in their grasps not only come to terms with the idea of utter futility but also the reality that they tied their own ropes around their necks in the process. And because you've spent so much time with the characters you do start to feel for them . . . you may not like them that much but there's no outright villains, just people driven by pettiness and self-interest and an unswerving confidence that they're more right than anyone else. Even so, none of them deserve to die any more than your neighbors do, but some wrong choices you pay for with money and some you pay for with much more.
The sheer feel of the downhill slide of the back portions of the book rank with some of the most funereal and inevitable passages I've ever heard and while its easy to garner sympathy in people faced with the reality of not leaving the ship alive, its harder to do without being maudlin. Flynn pulls it off and while I was skeptical when starting the book he does eventually justify almost every narrative and structural decision he's made when crafting the novel. His reliance on the nuts and bolts of sailing, his curiously even prose and emotional distance from the characters are going to make the early stages rough going and a decent number of people aren't going to be convinced its worth the slog. And maybe it was just me settling in and getting used to the style but I think he pulls it up and brings it home. It won't outrank that classic of doomed seaman Hodgson's "The Ghost Ship" in terms of "oh boy these guys are screwed" but while Hodgson's story pivoted on a sort of cosmic "ghosts are killing you because you're there and nothing matters" this one does one-up that by giving everyone a chance to put their hands on the steering wheel and sail the ship right over the edge. If nothing else, its a five hundred page lesson in the value of communication with your coworkers.
January 27, 2012
Not often do I so like the title of a book, but this one really caught my imagination and also gives an idea about the book.
The "River of Stars" is a spaceship that carried both passengers and cargo and flew the routes on magnetic sails. She is long past her glory days and her magnetic sails are an outdated technology and she becomes a hybrid retrofitted ship using new engine designs. Though she is now like a magnificent sailing ship that now runs only on diesel engines.
The fact that the title of the book starts with "The wreck" gives you the storyline in that you know the direction of the plot and that there is a disaster coming. Though knowing this there is still all the needed plot tensions in the book and the enjoyment is getting there.
What I so enjoy about Michael Flynn in that while his stories and world building are great SF, it is his characters that truly add flesh to the bones of the SF plot. His skills at character dialog are delightful and have a depth that does beyond so much SF, or really so much of any genre. The crew of The River of Stars are a hodge podge of people who like the ship have fallen on hard times. They are an assortment of hard luck stories that have been gathered together as the crew of this aging ship. Put all together this novel just works on every level.
The "River of Stars" is a spaceship that carried both passengers and cargo and flew the routes on magnetic sails. She is long past her glory days and her magnetic sails are an outdated technology and she becomes a hybrid retrofitted ship using new engine designs. Though she is now like a magnificent sailing ship that now runs only on diesel engines.
The fact that the title of the book starts with "The wreck" gives you the storyline in that you know the direction of the plot and that there is a disaster coming. Though knowing this there is still all the needed plot tensions in the book and the enjoyment is getting there.
What I so enjoy about Michael Flynn in that while his stories and world building are great SF, it is his characters that truly add flesh to the bones of the SF plot. His skills at character dialog are delightful and have a depth that does beyond so much SF, or really so much of any genre. The crew of The River of Stars are a hodge podge of people who like the ship have fallen on hard times. They are an assortment of hard luck stories that have been gathered together as the crew of this aging ship. Put all together this novel just works on every level.
June 26, 2020
Second reading, and it’s just confirming my first impressions that this is a beautifully contrived and beautifully written novel that resonates much more deeply than its space opera subject matter and its jaunty tone might suggest.
I love this novel. There, I’ve said it. Having been tempted by its “Spoiler Alert” title, when I first read it about 15 years ago, I remember being impressed by the way that Flynn cleverly strips away the artifice, and still manages to create almost unbearable suspense. He tells you exactly what’s going to happen. Much of the time, he tells you exactly what’s going on in the minds of each character, and exactly how they are fatally misreading what going on in the minds of any other given character. He creates a premise that requires massive infodumps – technical, historical, personal – to work. And IMHO, not only does it work, but it’s a delight. And not only is it a delight, it has fascinating depths and insights – insights into human nature, insights into how endeavours (personal, professional, perhaps even societal) work, or more crucially, don’t work. Insights into how one person can make a crazy, complicated system (again personal, professional, perhaps even societal) work, and how taking him/her away can result in the whole dam’ pack of card collapsing.
Why do I love this book? Wellll ….
1) It’s about so much more than (wait for it) the wreck of the MSS River of Stars, the formerly fabulous luxury liner that used to ferry the great and the good back and forth between the planets, asteroids and artificial habitats of the inner Solar System. This novel is about every toxic workplan, and failed venture; how it got that way, and what might have been done to make it different. As Flynn tells it, this is something of a ghost story, and the catastrophe of the title results on one crucial absence (which commences on page 4 of my edition) and gradually, slowly, inexorably develops as a disparate bunch of misfits follow their own agendas, misunderstand their colleagues motivations, and just don’t listen. If that doesn’t sound familiar, you have never had to work with other people. If you are recently emerged from a bad working situation, you might have to read River as you’re hiding behind the sofa, peeping through the fingers held to your horrified eyes. This will be hard, but worth it.
2) I love Flynn’s style. Yes, sometimes (often ... always …) he gets a bit carried away with himself. In the immortal words of Prime Minister Benjamin Disreali, he can be “inebriated with the exuberance of his own verbosity.” So what? When the verbosity is this exuberant, when the asides are this snarky – what’s not to love? And Flynn is comfortable with poking fun at himself ...
English, ‘Kiru decided, had too many words, and its speakers felt obliged to play with the extra ones.
3) The worldbuilding is fabulous. Flynn constructs a history. There is technology, there are societies, each with every different, and very plausible, norms and outlooks. There is biology, and prejudice. There are recipes, and sea chanties. There are great names, names that are so almost not weird, but still very SF … I want my next grandchild to be named The Lotus Jewel, but I don’t think my daughter and her partner will buy it …
I also love the way that Flynn plays with the tropes of other genres – this is, as I suggest above, a ghost story. It’s also SF’s answer to Patrick O’Brien and Horatio Hornblower. It could also be used as a textbook in a (very forward looking and imaginative) MBA as a guide to how not to organize a major project. It’s a future history, but it’s also an alternative history, with its clever nods and winks to Titanic, the near cousin to MSS River of Stars, both in its glorious launch and great prospects and its Olympian, stuff-myths-are-made-of downfall. But River of Stars is what Titanic would have been had it survived that maiden voyage, and completed hundreds of Atlantic crossings, until the paint start to chip, the fabulous fittings were damaged, or sold off, and (like Titanic’s sister ship, Olympic), she became a hospital ship and was torpedoed ignominiously in a forgotten episode of WWI.
Flynn’s lowering sense of a catastrophe about to happen even echoes Thomas Hardy’s wonderful poem on Titanic, “The Convergence of the Twain” …
And as the smart ship grew
In stature, grace, and hue,
In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too.
I love this novel.
There are, perhaps, two “elephants in the room” of my 5-star rating that I feel I have to address. I can love this novel, and give it a 5-star review, and still admit that it’s not perfect. (In my rating system, a novel doesn’t have to be perfect to get 5-stars: it just has to be better than it needed to be, and memorable in a way that I know I will never forget … )
First, are there times when reasonable people can agree that Flynn may have gotten carried away, and The Wreck of The River of Stars could have benefited from a tuck and a trim? Well … no. One of the things I enjoyed is the way that the inevitable seems to happen in real time – day by day at first, and then, as the catastrophe reaches its climax, minute by minute. I loved the detail. I loved the backstories, I loved the technology (and I am not a natural techie …).
The other aspect of the novel, which I had forgotten, but now makes me uncomfortable, is the story arc of the character of Miko, the apprentice engineer. She’s a teenage girl who has escaped a traumatic, abusive childhood, and emerged from that experience with a burning, obsessive desire to lose her virginity to an unprepossessing middle age man. Eye roll ... Flynn would probably object to that description, but hey, I call ’em as I see ‘em. Her relationships with the three men on the River of Stars who are in positions of authority over her, who know her tragic backstory, and who ought to know better run the gamut from plausible (if still very wrong), to exploitative, to downright creepy wish-fulfilment . This is a great shame in a novel that, otherwise, depicts a future that is realistically diverse, and still sensitive to the pressure of that diversity.
Still, highly recommended.
I love this novel. There, I’ve said it. Having been tempted by its “Spoiler Alert” title, when I first read it about 15 years ago, I remember being impressed by the way that Flynn cleverly strips away the artifice, and still manages to create almost unbearable suspense. He tells you exactly what’s going to happen. Much of the time, he tells you exactly what’s going on in the minds of each character, and exactly how they are fatally misreading what going on in the minds of any other given character. He creates a premise that requires massive infodumps – technical, historical, personal – to work. And IMHO, not only does it work, but it’s a delight. And not only is it a delight, it has fascinating depths and insights – insights into human nature, insights into how endeavours (personal, professional, perhaps even societal) work, or more crucially, don’t work. Insights into how one person can make a crazy, complicated system (again personal, professional, perhaps even societal) work, and how taking him/her away can result in the whole dam’ pack of card collapsing.
Why do I love this book? Wellll ….
1) It’s about so much more than (wait for it) the wreck of the MSS River of Stars, the formerly fabulous luxury liner that used to ferry the great and the good back and forth between the planets, asteroids and artificial habitats of the inner Solar System. This novel is about every toxic workplan, and failed venture; how it got that way, and what might have been done to make it different. As Flynn tells it, this is something of a ghost story, and the catastrophe of the title results on one crucial absence (which commences on page 4 of my edition) and gradually, slowly, inexorably develops as a disparate bunch of misfits follow their own agendas, misunderstand their colleagues motivations, and just don’t listen. If that doesn’t sound familiar, you have never had to work with other people. If you are recently emerged from a bad working situation, you might have to read River as you’re hiding behind the sofa, peeping through the fingers held to your horrified eyes. This will be hard, but worth it.
2) I love Flynn’s style. Yes, sometimes (often ... always …) he gets a bit carried away with himself. In the immortal words of Prime Minister Benjamin Disreali, he can be “inebriated with the exuberance of his own verbosity.” So what? When the verbosity is this exuberant, when the asides are this snarky – what’s not to love? And Flynn is comfortable with poking fun at himself ...
English, ‘Kiru decided, had too many words, and its speakers felt obliged to play with the extra ones.
3) The worldbuilding is fabulous. Flynn constructs a history. There is technology, there are societies, each with every different, and very plausible, norms and outlooks. There is biology, and prejudice. There are recipes, and sea chanties. There are great names, names that are so almost not weird, but still very SF … I want my next grandchild to be named The Lotus Jewel, but I don’t think my daughter and her partner will buy it …
I also love the way that Flynn plays with the tropes of other genres – this is, as I suggest above, a ghost story. It’s also SF’s answer to Patrick O’Brien and Horatio Hornblower. It could also be used as a textbook in a (very forward looking and imaginative) MBA as a guide to how not to organize a major project. It’s a future history, but it’s also an alternative history, with its clever nods and winks to Titanic, the near cousin to MSS River of Stars, both in its glorious launch and great prospects and its Olympian, stuff-myths-are-made-of downfall. But River of Stars is what Titanic would have been had it survived that maiden voyage, and completed hundreds of Atlantic crossings, until the paint start to chip, the fabulous fittings were damaged, or sold off, and (like Titanic’s sister ship, Olympic), she became a hospital ship and was torpedoed ignominiously in a forgotten episode of WWI.
Flynn’s lowering sense of a catastrophe about to happen even echoes Thomas Hardy’s wonderful poem on Titanic, “The Convergence of the Twain” …
And as the smart ship grew
In stature, grace, and hue,
In shadowy silent distance grew the Iceberg too.
I love this novel.
There are, perhaps, two “elephants in the room” of my 5-star rating that I feel I have to address. I can love this novel, and give it a 5-star review, and still admit that it’s not perfect. (In my rating system, a novel doesn’t have to be perfect to get 5-stars: it just has to be better than it needed to be, and memorable in a way that I know I will never forget … )
First, are there times when reasonable people can agree that Flynn may have gotten carried away, and The Wreck of The River of Stars could have benefited from a tuck and a trim? Well … no. One of the things I enjoyed is the way that the inevitable seems to happen in real time – day by day at first, and then, as the catastrophe reaches its climax, minute by minute. I loved the detail. I loved the backstories, I loved the technology (and I am not a natural techie …).
The other aspect of the novel, which I had forgotten, but now makes me uncomfortable, is the story arc of the character of Miko, the apprentice engineer. She’s a teenage girl who has escaped a traumatic, abusive childhood, and emerged from that experience with a burning, obsessive desire to lose her virginity to an unprepossessing middle age man. Eye roll ... Flynn would probably object to that description, but hey, I call ’em as I see ‘em. Her relationships with the three men on the River of Stars who are in positions of authority over her, who know her tragic backstory, and who ought to know better run the gamut from plausible (if still very wrong), to exploitative, to downright creepy wish-fulfilment . This is a great shame in a novel that, otherwise, depicts a future that is realistically diverse, and still sensitive to the pressure of that diversity.
Still, highly recommended.
December 1, 2020
Michael Flynn es un autor curioso. Es difícil ya de por sí, en una ''Space opera'', encontrar un desarrollo que se centre más en los personajes que en todo lo que les rodea. La idea parece simple, una nave en este caso ''El río de las estrellas'' queda varada en medio de su ruta espacial, con el peligro de quedar para siempre como simple basura y con la reciente muerte de su capitán, tendrán que dejar sus diferencias al lado para buscar una solución. La fuerza de la novela es presentarnos a cada personaje, sus motivaciones, sus preocupaciones, las relaciones entre cada uno de ellos y la lucha eterna entre sus egos. No estamos ante una obra que se centre en lo futurista de las naves o en la lluvia de ideas tecnológicas, no se debe esperar una obra tipo ''Star Wars'' o sus derivados, aquí encontraremos que no importa si estamos en la época de las cavernas o en el año 5000, los problemas interpersonales o ente caso ''intermarcianales'' siempre estarán presentes. Esta es una obra que se cocina a fuego lento, pero que al terminar tienes ese sentimiento de haberte encariñado con los personajes. La recomiendo ampliamente.
January 9, 2009
I enjoyed this hard sci-fi novel more than many I've read recently.
Flynn explores many of the themes of space adventure and flips them on their head: a disaster in space, a rag-tag crewing working to fix it, people acting like heroes. But nothing comes out quite right.
Very moving at the end (just like his other great book, Eifelheim).
Flynn explores many of the themes of space adventure and flips them on their head: a disaster in space, a rag-tag crewing working to fix it, people acting like heroes. But nothing comes out quite right.
Very moving at the end (just like his other great book, Eifelheim).
September 10, 2014
I really did not like this book. I expected to like it -- could not stand it. I gave up halfway through and skimmed through to the end to see what happened; I felt like the book just kind of meandered its way without any real impetus to the story.
You know, upon reflection, I disliked Gone Girl for the same reasons I disliked this book. Entirely too much navel gazing and too little story.
You know, upon reflection, I disliked Gone Girl for the same reasons I disliked this book. Entirely too much navel gazing and too little story.
May 20, 2009
Slow to pick up, but powerful when it does.
June 16, 2009
Wow! What an amazing book. Intelligent, complex, shining, heroic and poignant. Hard SciFi - space travel at it's best.
January 18, 2022
It was just too slow for me... I stopped reading after a hundred fifty pages or so. It just didn't hold my interest.
October 3, 2024
With the name like that, you kind of know what to expect, ending-wise. The only question that remains is "why write this?". Is it a condemnation of "bosses", like "Wreck of the Old '97"? Or maybe a war tale, like "Sinking of the Reuben James"? Or even a vessel for humor, like "The Last of the Irish Rover"?
What we have here is a deconstruction of a trope. You know the one: a charming Captain, kind and wise, who gathers the crew of misfits and outcasts and turns them into finest company to ever sail the seas, or the solar system, or whatever. This is what happens here, only captain Evan Dodge Hand is on his deathbed on the very first page of the book, and the dream crew is not yet quite all the way there where he envisioned them. Like, not even close. And so, "The Wreck of the River of the Stars" is what happens when the kind and wise captain dies leaves his "children" in a crisis with his aloof and indecisive First Mate as a leader.
Michael Flynn is one of the finest writers in modern sci-fi when it comes to characters, and this book is no exception. The small crew is colorful, interesting, and mostly broken. The First Mate is paralyzed by indecision, which already cost him his career in Space Guard, and probably his wife. The Second Mate "never had an original idea in his life". The Third Mate actually was a captain on that same spaceship many years ago, but her fortunes turned. The doctor is a drug addict, Chief Engineer loves younger men, Engineer's Mate lived her teenage years in crawlspaces of an asteroid while plotting revenge against the man who took away her home. Et cetera. And that's not the whole characterization for any of them: Flynn's characters are complex and deep and have many a story in their past, which they slowly tell us over the course of the book.
Another interesting feature of the book is the omnipresent and omniscient narrator. Flynn doesn't give us an illusion of first-person, or even third-person viewpoint. The narrator is clearly detached from the characters, and knows more about them then they do themselves. So the reader often gets side remarks that don't belong in anyone's words or even thoughts. Somehow, instead of being irritating, they help understand the characters and their conflicts.
Despite being quite serious and dramatic, the book is also not bereft of humor. Mostly, it is concentrated in those same little narrator's remarks, and consists of clever wordplay. The author employs it in the right places, so it doesn't take away anything from the drama and gravity of the book.
All in all, this is one of the best books I've read this year, and I recommend it very much. The only thing that bothers me about it is that if someday a TV producer discovers this text, it will make a fine Netflix show (there is also quite a lot of lust and sex here). But they will throw away the narrator - there is no place for such entity in cinema - and the result would be far worse for it.
What we have here is a deconstruction of a trope. You know the one: a charming Captain, kind and wise, who gathers the crew of misfits and outcasts and turns them into finest company to ever sail the seas, or the solar system, or whatever. This is what happens here, only captain Evan Dodge Hand is on his deathbed on the very first page of the book, and the dream crew is not yet quite all the way there where he envisioned them. Like, not even close. And so, "The Wreck of the River of the Stars" is what happens when the kind and wise captain dies leaves his "children" in a crisis with his aloof and indecisive First Mate as a leader.
Michael Flynn is one of the finest writers in modern sci-fi when it comes to characters, and this book is no exception. The small crew is colorful, interesting, and mostly broken. The First Mate is paralyzed by indecision, which already cost him his career in Space Guard, and probably his wife. The Second Mate "never had an original idea in his life". The Third Mate actually was a captain on that same spaceship many years ago, but her fortunes turned. The doctor is a drug addict, Chief Engineer loves younger men, Engineer's Mate lived her teenage years in crawlspaces of an asteroid while plotting revenge against the man who took away her home. Et cetera. And that's not the whole characterization for any of them: Flynn's characters are complex and deep and have many a story in their past, which they slowly tell us over the course of the book.
Another interesting feature of the book is the omnipresent and omniscient narrator. Flynn doesn't give us an illusion of first-person, or even third-person viewpoint. The narrator is clearly detached from the characters, and knows more about them then they do themselves. So the reader often gets side remarks that don't belong in anyone's words or even thoughts. Somehow, instead of being irritating, they help understand the characters and their conflicts.
Despite being quite serious and dramatic, the book is also not bereft of humor. Mostly, it is concentrated in those same little narrator's remarks, and consists of clever wordplay. The author employs it in the right places, so it doesn't take away anything from the drama and gravity of the book.
All in all, this is one of the best books I've read this year, and I recommend it very much. The only thing that bothers me about it is that if someday a TV producer discovers this text, it will make a fine Netflix show (there is also quite a lot of lust and sex here). But they will throw away the narrator - there is no place for such entity in cinema - and the result would be far worse for it.
August 2, 2025
When I was in middle/high school, we received the SFBC catalogues, and I would flip through each and every one as it came in, hunting for the next epic book that I wanted to read. We didn't order from them often, but once I convinced my mom to order this one for me. Never got around to reading it. Wonder if I still have it somewhere.
—
And then she read it.
You know those scifi movies that are so bad you watch just to make fun of them? Yeah, that, but in book form.
—
The problem with this book (well, one of many) is that the writer has managed to put all of the subtext, all those aggravating minutia and quirks of character psychology, into the actual narrative, which then makes all the interesting character development and even PLOT POINTS into subtext. You know the saying, “show don’t tell”? You ever get confused what is “showing” and what is “telling”? This book is telling. It’s 480 pages of telling. There is absolutely no room in this book for the characters to do anything that shows how they think or feel because it’s all been laid painfully (not painstakingly) bare for us the reader, which in turn takes away all the nuance and joy of character development. This book is not character development. This book is telling. And that’s why it’s fucking boring. It’s 14 or so characters stuck in a failing spaceship who can’t communicate to save their lives (literally!) because the writer got so in his head about how their psychology makes them think that he forgot that people manage to communicate outside of that, and it’s that communication, spoken and unspoken, that creates the misunderstandings that create the tension that ratchets up the stakes that actually drive the plot, both between the humans and the ticking time bomb of their ship and transit.
I DIDN’T NEED TO GET AN MFA TO TELL YOU THAT.
“Oh, but he’s flipping the script, he’s doing something unusual in his writing, it’s experimental.” NO. IT’S NOT. And let this book be a lesson that, as written here, IT DOESN’T WORK.
Because here’s the other thing. I said even the plot points feel like subtext, the big extra-environmental actions that keep making things more dangerous for the characters. Y’know, the explosions that readers of hard scifi come for. And I could’ve been well intrigued by a human drama in the middle of a catastrophe, had the human drama been written well (I cannot emphasize enough that it wasn’t), but the fact that plot points happened that were so obscured in the writing, the actual language of the narrative, that afterward I truly didn’t know if they had happened or not. Take, for instance, the cutter getting launched. This is a big thing. This is a truly tragic disaster (except how did all the boring characters survive, dear god why), but there’s no description of it. The characters on board don’t experience it. So the reader doesn’t experience it. So to me I’m wondering if the cutter actually launched from the ship or if ship just forgot its existence and it’s now stuck inside. I SHOULDN’T HAVE TO WONDER THIS.
And the ROCK. This is truly the only big thing that happens the entire book, and it reads as just ludicrously unimpressive. Like, a lot of “build-up” (or lack thereof, honestly) for nothing.
—
Who’s your least favorite character? I’ll go first. I can’t fucking stand Fife. I didn’t care about a lot of these characters (like I said, how did all the boring characters survive), but from the moment he walks on Fife was truly insufferable. Both poorly written and what was written was utterly deplorable.
But I’m willing to bet that Satterwaithe was Flynn’s least favorite character. She’s old, she’s fought to be captain, she’s hidden her emotions from herself, so she’s a bitch. Great. Awesome. Thanks for leaning into that trope. But more than that, every time the narrative turns to Satterwaithe it constantly editorializes on how she’s wrong. The narrative itself doesn’t think that Satterwaithe is competent. She can be a bitch, sure, people can just be bitches, but she did make her way to captain. At least give her some credit? Because I dare say the men aren’t any better at the job.
As for the others, I wanted to like Bhatterji, Corrigan, and Wong, and Miko to an extent (the Lotus Jewel was too poorly written from the get-go for me, and poor Okoye I found, well, boring). The problem with Bhatterji is that he’s not a gay man, he’s not written like a gay man, he’s written by a straight man leaning on homophobic tropes because that’s probably all he knows. Bhatterji could have been a very interesting character, gay or not, and the scenes of Bhatterji actually focusing on the engines with Miko might have been some of the most interesting scenes in the book, but his only motivation is young boys and “whine whine you don’t love me”? Please.
Corrigan also. Wanted to like him. Could have been an interesting character. The sudden lean into Islamic tropes near the end felt, well, trope-y and problematic (why is it that a Muslim character, who really isn’t religious until 3/4 of the way through the book, surrenders completely to god, but none of the other characters, when some of them seem to be just as if not more so religious?). Plus his confusion over Miko and the Lotus Jewel is grossly problematic. And also, why is he the one who breaks out in weird HR-violating quips? That doesn’t fit his psychology.
Wong, on the other hand, is the most interesting character … the first and last times we see her. The nature of her addiction, especially at the beginning, had so much potential, and so much nuance, so much conflict (she’s the ship’s doctor!), but then Fife gotta come in (literally?) and she spends the rest of the book as pathetic and awkward.
And then Miko. Miko just. *sigh*
Okay so the sex in this book. It’s fucking stupid. It’s really here as a distraction from character development. The only thing every. Single. Character. thinks about is sex (even Okoye, in her own way), and it intrudes at the worst moments when INTERESTING THINGS ARE OTHERWISE HAPPENING and it doesn’t even MAKE SENSE WITH THE CHARACTER IN THE MOMENT. Every single character, and even worse the fucking author, has confused love with lust, and guess what. It’s not interesting and it does nothing and it goes nowhere. And all of these characters, even the boring ones, have interesting back stories that get hinted at once and then we never hear of them again. THOSE are the interesting revelations. THOSE are what I want developed and pulled out over the course of 480 pages. I want to see the characters grappling with their previous faults and have that affect the way they respond to each other and the disaster of the ship, NOT how in space no one can be single.
Unrelated, as someone who’s been studying Hungarian for two years, Stepan Gorgas … not a Hungarian name? Gorgas sounds wrong as a surname (I feel like I could believe it as Gorgás), and Stepan should be István. Stepan is Slavic.
But minor bonus points for having the most Armenians in space? (But is Miko Armenian? She names the cat Queen Tamar, who was Georgian, and Mikoyan is a last name, so …?)
—
There was another review who called this book the “Slow train wreck of the River of Stars” and honestly, I’d rather read that book than this. I’m really glad I didn’t read this when I bought it in high school.
—
And then she read it.
You know those scifi movies that are so bad you watch just to make fun of them? Yeah, that, but in book form.
—
The problem with this book (well, one of many) is that the writer has managed to put all of the subtext, all those aggravating minutia and quirks of character psychology, into the actual narrative, which then makes all the interesting character development and even PLOT POINTS into subtext. You know the saying, “show don’t tell”? You ever get confused what is “showing” and what is “telling”? This book is telling. It’s 480 pages of telling. There is absolutely no room in this book for the characters to do anything that shows how they think or feel because it’s all been laid painfully (not painstakingly) bare for us the reader, which in turn takes away all the nuance and joy of character development. This book is not character development. This book is telling. And that’s why it’s fucking boring. It’s 14 or so characters stuck in a failing spaceship who can’t communicate to save their lives (literally!) because the writer got so in his head about how their psychology makes them think that he forgot that people manage to communicate outside of that, and it’s that communication, spoken and unspoken, that creates the misunderstandings that create the tension that ratchets up the stakes that actually drive the plot, both between the humans and the ticking time bomb of their ship and transit.
I DIDN’T NEED TO GET AN MFA TO TELL YOU THAT.
“Oh, but he’s flipping the script, he’s doing something unusual in his writing, it’s experimental.” NO. IT’S NOT. And let this book be a lesson that, as written here, IT DOESN’T WORK.
Because here’s the other thing. I said even the plot points feel like subtext, the big extra-environmental actions that keep making things more dangerous for the characters. Y’know, the explosions that readers of hard scifi come for. And I could’ve been well intrigued by a human drama in the middle of a catastrophe, had the human drama been written well (I cannot emphasize enough that it wasn’t), but the fact that plot points happened that were so obscured in the writing, the actual language of the narrative, that afterward I truly didn’t know if they had happened or not. Take, for instance, the cutter getting launched. This is a big thing. This is a truly tragic disaster (except how did all the boring characters survive, dear god why), but there’s no description of it. The characters on board don’t experience it. So the reader doesn’t experience it. So to me I’m wondering if the cutter actually launched from the ship or if ship just forgot its existence and it’s now stuck inside. I SHOULDN’T HAVE TO WONDER THIS.
And the ROCK. This is truly the only big thing that happens the entire book, and it reads as just ludicrously unimpressive. Like, a lot of “build-up” (or lack thereof, honestly) for nothing.
—
Who’s your least favorite character? I’ll go first. I can’t fucking stand Fife. I didn’t care about a lot of these characters (like I said, how did all the boring characters survive), but from the moment he walks on Fife was truly insufferable. Both poorly written and what was written was utterly deplorable.
But I’m willing to bet that Satterwaithe was Flynn’s least favorite character. She’s old, she’s fought to be captain, she’s hidden her emotions from herself, so she’s a bitch. Great. Awesome. Thanks for leaning into that trope. But more than that, every time the narrative turns to Satterwaithe it constantly editorializes on how she’s wrong. The narrative itself doesn’t think that Satterwaithe is competent. She can be a bitch, sure, people can just be bitches, but she did make her way to captain. At least give her some credit? Because I dare say the men aren’t any better at the job.
As for the others, I wanted to like Bhatterji, Corrigan, and Wong, and Miko to an extent (the Lotus Jewel was too poorly written from the get-go for me, and poor Okoye I found, well, boring). The problem with Bhatterji is that he’s not a gay man, he’s not written like a gay man, he’s written by a straight man leaning on homophobic tropes because that’s probably all he knows. Bhatterji could have been a very interesting character, gay or not, and the scenes of Bhatterji actually focusing on the engines with Miko might have been some of the most interesting scenes in the book, but his only motivation is young boys and “whine whine you don’t love me”? Please.
Corrigan also. Wanted to like him. Could have been an interesting character. The sudden lean into Islamic tropes near the end felt, well, trope-y and problematic (why is it that a Muslim character, who really isn’t religious until 3/4 of the way through the book, surrenders completely to god, but none of the other characters, when some of them seem to be just as if not more so religious?). Plus his confusion over Miko and the Lotus Jewel is grossly problematic. And also, why is he the one who breaks out in weird HR-violating quips? That doesn’t fit his psychology.
Wong, on the other hand, is the most interesting character … the first and last times we see her. The nature of her addiction, especially at the beginning, had so much potential, and so much nuance, so much conflict (she’s the ship’s doctor!), but then Fife gotta come in (literally?) and she spends the rest of the book as pathetic and awkward.
And then Miko. Miko just. *sigh*
Okay so the sex in this book. It’s fucking stupid. It’s really here as a distraction from character development. The only thing every. Single. Character. thinks about is sex (even Okoye, in her own way), and it intrudes at the worst moments when INTERESTING THINGS ARE OTHERWISE HAPPENING and it doesn’t even MAKE SENSE WITH THE CHARACTER IN THE MOMENT. Every single character, and even worse the fucking author, has confused love with lust, and guess what. It’s not interesting and it does nothing and it goes nowhere. And all of these characters, even the boring ones, have interesting back stories that get hinted at once and then we never hear of them again. THOSE are the interesting revelations. THOSE are what I want developed and pulled out over the course of 480 pages. I want to see the characters grappling with their previous faults and have that affect the way they respond to each other and the disaster of the ship, NOT how in space no one can be single.
Unrelated, as someone who’s been studying Hungarian for two years, Stepan Gorgas … not a Hungarian name? Gorgas sounds wrong as a surname (I feel like I could believe it as Gorgás), and Stepan should be István. Stepan is Slavic.
But minor bonus points for having the most Armenians in space? (But is Miko Armenian? She names the cat Queen Tamar, who was Georgian, and Mikoyan is a last name, so …?)
—
There was another review who called this book the “Slow train wreck of the River of Stars” and honestly, I’d rather read that book than this. I’m really glad I didn’t read this when I bought it in high school.
January 25, 2018
Chronologically this is the last of the Firestar series of books that Flynn wrote, unless the Spiral Arm stories take place in the same universe. The earlier stories (the Firestar, Rogue Star, Lode Star, Falling Stars novels, plus the novel In the Land of the Blind) all had a sense of optimism and adventure underlying them, which made reading them just plain fun.
If you're looking for that same sense of adventure and promising horizons, with struggles along the way.. you're barking up the wrong tree. This book is relentlessly depressing. It's not even a comedy of errors; it's a tragedy of errors instead. Imagine a novelization of the causes of the Challenger or Columbia disasters. Now make it so that ALL of the people involved are relentlessly self-centered, with the result that they constantly and incessantly make poor decisions, resulting in the deaths of every character in the story.
The story-telling is excellent. The story makes the reader want to reach for the nearest straight-edged razor, and maybe some orange juice to squeeze into the wound.
If you're looking for that same sense of adventure and promising horizons, with struggles along the way.. you're barking up the wrong tree. This book is relentlessly depressing. It's not even a comedy of errors; it's a tragedy of errors instead. Imagine a novelization of the causes of the Challenger or Columbia disasters. Now make it so that ALL of the people involved are relentlessly self-centered, with the result that they constantly and incessantly make poor decisions, resulting in the deaths of every character in the story.
The story-telling is excellent. The story makes the reader want to reach for the nearest straight-edged razor, and maybe some orange juice to squeeze into the wound.
January 7, 2019
A scifi book that I picked up off the side of the road and pleasantly discovered that it involves not only a space ship but also sailing! Off to a good start.
The book reads fairly long as it really takes the time to get into how everybody is feeling about everything, so that's also a bit different and it's written well enough that it's enjoyable.
Another change of pace is that this is a beat up ship and the problems just keep coming. However, the author puts the problems mainly in the background with the focus remaining on interpersonal developments. Lots of insight on the human heart from the author and I thought it read true, however a bit long. It's ~530 pages and isn't super faced paced.
The book reads fairly long as it really takes the time to get into how everybody is feeling about everything, so that's also a bit different and it's written well enough that it's enjoyable.
Another change of pace is that this is a beat up ship and the problems just keep coming. However, the author puts the problems mainly in the background with the focus remaining on interpersonal developments. Lots of insight on the human heart from the author and I thought it read true, however a bit long. It's ~530 pages and isn't super faced paced.
November 14, 2017
This book was slow to start: I recommend it only to truly committed sci-fi fans. I think it took about 200 pages to understand the characters, and another 50 for anything mildly exciting to happen. The action was long and drawn-out in a methodical way: less dramatic than your typical space book. There is an intimacy between the reader and the characters that took me a while to appreciate, but once I finally figured out the author's point of view in that regard, I really enjoyed the gentle attitude of the writing.
This book is about love, in so many subtle ways, and understanding one another in spite of our differences in training or belief or upbringing.
This book is about love, in so many subtle ways, and understanding one another in spite of our differences in training or belief or upbringing.
November 7, 2018
I picked this book up because of the title and some nostalgia for other books with Wreck there. However as I got into it more and more it became a fascinating tale of a hodgepodge crew all at odds with each other fighting to save their ship, The River Of Stars. There is hard science in this science fiction, at least it sounds like that to me. The real story and what intrigued me no end is the interaction between the characters and their development as the story goes along. You had to keep reading just to see what happens next!
August 9, 2025
4.5 stars
This is not a book without issues. I could easily whittle it down to a 2.5 or 3 between substantive complaints and nitpicks. Flynn is not a neanderthal writing scifi from the 60s, but there are certainly some aspects that earned some side-eye from me, and I'm not the most sensitive reader.
But it won me over. This is a cool slice-of-life type novel that doesn't get anywhere near the dreaded c-word ("cozy"). Just a rogue's gallery heading away from the captain that held them together and towards disaster.
This is not a book without issues. I could easily whittle it down to a 2.5 or 3 between substantive complaints and nitpicks. Flynn is not a neanderthal writing scifi from the 60s, but there are certainly some aspects that earned some side-eye from me, and I'm not the most sensitive reader.
But it won me over. This is a cool slice-of-life type novel that doesn't get anywhere near the dreaded c-word ("cozy"). Just a rogue's gallery heading away from the captain that held them together and towards disaster.
May 2, 2018
This was such a satisfying read. The deep and intimate reveals of the characters' psyches, and how they interact during crises, reminded me very much of reading Dostoyevsky. Not centered around tech, plot, or "big cool ideas," this book differs from much of the written SF and thus is likely to bore some readers; taken as a rich novel in an SF setting, however, this is worth the time and effort.
January 7, 2023
A Bright Star in the Firmament of Sci-Fi
It is difficult to sum up, in so many words, so fine and harrowing a tale. Flynn is a grandmaster of his craft and each of the crew, and indeed the Ship itself, unfolds as real and intricate a soul as anyone you might meet on the street. With these misfits, murderers, and merry men and women I have laughed and cheered and cried.
It is difficult to sum up, in so many words, so fine and harrowing a tale. Flynn is a grandmaster of his craft and each of the crew, and indeed the Ship itself, unfolds as real and intricate a soul as anyone you might meet on the street. With these misfits, murderers, and merry men and women I have laughed and cheered and cried.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 100 reviews