Emily Hamilton is an English lady sent to marry a Scottish laird by order of their kings, but she has no idea when she arrives that she is among a clan of shape-shifters called the Crechte. She makes friends with her betrothed's sister, Cait, but her betrothed, Talorc despises her, nor does Emily feel anything for him. When Lachlan, an enemy clan's chieftain, kidnaps Emily and Cait and forces Cait to "mate" with his second-in-command, Emily is torn between her desire to escape and her attraction to the rugged highlander. She soon falls in love with him, but Lachlan and his clan keep the secret of the existence of the Crechte and Emily is still betrothed to Talorc.
Okay, so for sheer entertainment value, this story gets a lot of credit. I was interested and engaged throughout, it had plenty of action, drama and passion among the characters. There's actually two romances here - Lachlan and Emily, as well as Cait and Drustan (the second in command). Cait and Drustan have the whole true mates thing going and the fact that they're both shifters...so Cait doesn't really fight being forced into marriage with him, but she certainly resents the fact that it's not based on love...plenty of lust though. Lachlan and Emily have a bit more angst in their relationship since they can't really have a future together and Lachlan is pretty prejudiced about the idea of marrying humans. I think I might have liked a bit less focus on the secondary romance, just to give a bit more attention to Lachlan and Emily.
My primary problem with this story comes down to the fact that neither Lachlan nor Drustan actually listen to the women or learn anything from them...and Emily ends up being a bit of a doormat because of it. Lachlan kidnaps the two women as a form of revenge against their laird, which, as Emily points out is a pretty shitty thing to do...to wage war against innocent women (and force one of them into marriage). She rails against how they've had any choice taken away from them. Lachlan doesn't care to be insulted and offers no excuse or apology or his actions. There is the revelation that it was a better option to killing so many people in Cait's clan, but nobody pointed out that a diplomatic option existed and that was even better (and could have been tried first without any loss of life or freedom). I do respect the fact that Emily never apologizes or changes her opinion about her insults, but I would have hoped that Lachlan would understand what he'd done or at least come full circle with realizing that he needs to listen to Emily or give her choices. And it's obvious he didn't learn the lesson because he then more or less forces her into marriage at the end. I do note that she was only unwilling because she thought he didn't love her or still had prejudice, but he doesn't admit he loves her until after they're married...so he didn't listen, didn't learn the lesson. That irked me quite a bit. And I also feel like there wasn't really a resolution between Cait and Drustan. She resented that he treated her like a child, making her ask permission for everything, and there was no confirmation that he'd changed.
Good story and excellent storytelling. I will be going on to the next in the series (they're all in my library e-service, yay!) so I'm excited to read Abigail's story.