I wanted to like this book, I really did. I'm also a writer, I also moved to a completely new country at a young age, I also know what's it like to not fit in and be lonely. But Asking for Trouble fell flat in so many ways and I couldn't relate to it.
The entire book just seemed silly to me. An immature heroine, multiple cliches (the hot school editor. Check! The popular mean girls. Check! Stereotypical English behavior--I'm pretty sure people don't say chockabloc as often as the author suggests--check! A preachy faith message. Check! And the list goes on), a weak plot, and amateurish writing.
I could maybe see girls in the 10-12 age group liking this. It's marketed as a teen book, but I'm a teen and it felt like a book I should be reading to my young niece instead. To be honest, I'm sick of these fluffy teen books. Most of the teens I know, myself included, are going through tough situations and they have more important things to worry about than the cute boy in school. Christian YA fiction needs a good dose of realism. Teens need to be reading about real-life situations, things they can either relate to or learn from (divorce, abuse, losing a loved one, having an accident or getting a chronic illness, financial problems, losing their house from a storm, depression, having a loved one overseas fighting in a war, eating disorders... c'mon, authors, use your imagination!).
To give a fair review, there were a few things I liked. I actually liked the part with Father Christmas (even though I find it unrealistic that he would "preach" the way he did in a few scenes) and the way it tied in with the ending. I liked Aunt Maude (I think that was her name?) and thought she provided a tiny bit of interest. I liked how Savvy's family seemed pretty normal, they had their arguments but also loved each other.
All things said, I'm being generous and giving it a two star.