One of the worst books I've read in my life. And honestly, I wish I had counted my time before starting this one.
I rarely give a book 1 star, because even an average book usually manages to teach me something.
With Count Your Chickens Before They Hatch, I struggled to find that value.
I went into this expecting a meaningful book on success, self-development, leadership and management.
Instead, I found myself repeatedly thinking:
“Where exactly is this going?”
The book starts with the usual motivational territory—attitude, success, positive thinking, famous personalities and inspirational anecdotes. But much of it felt familiar, repetitive and unnecessarily stretched.
Several readers have made similar observations: the book can feel repetitive, the ideas can seem dated, and the management concepts aren't always presented with enough originality or continuity.
The ASK framework—Attitude, Skill and Knowledge—could have been interesting if developed with greater depth.
The same goes for the book's “Theory I” / India-centric management philosophy. There is an interesting idea buried here: that management approaches should take cultural and social context into account rather than simply copying Western models. Some readers actually found this to be the strongest section of the book.
But for me, those interesting ideas were buried under too much pep talk, repetition, familiar examples and digressions.
I also found the structure frustrating.
It feels like the book wants to be:
a motivational book + a self-help book + a management book + a leadership book + an India-centric business philosophy
—all at once.
And somehow, it ends up not being particularly convincing as any one of them.
The biggest problem?
I didn't feel I was learning.
I felt I was being told.
And there is a huge difference.
A good management book should make you stop, rethink something and perhaps change the way you approach a problem.
This one mostly made me wonder how much longer I had to read.
Even some relatively positive reviews describe it as useful mainly for beginners to self-help and management, while noting that some of its ideas now feel outdated.
Maybe this book made more sense when it was first published in 2001.
Maybe its ideas were more refreshing at that time.
But reading it today, I found very little that felt fresh enough to justify the amount of time invested.
And that's my biggest takeaway:
A book about managing your time shouldn't make you regret the time you spent reading it.
For me, this was a complete time waste. There may be a few useful ideas buried inside—particularly the India-centric management concept—but I found the execution repetitive, dated, unfocused and far too heavy on motivational rhetoric.
Definitely not a book I'd recommend when there are so many genuinely outstanding books on management, leadership and personal development available today.