I have mixed feelings about this book. I have a lot of connections to the subject. I've enjoyed many of Redford's films over the years. I was raised in Provo and spent a lot of time at Sundance. I know quite a few people who are friends with Redford and/or have worked closely with him. And I've admired Redford as a supporter of independent film and an environmental activist. So I picked up this book because I already had an interest in Redford, and I wanted to know more about what makes him tick. My quibbles with this book are not so much the subject but the writing.
Yes, I learned a lot that I didn't know about the man. But I think that my main complaints go to Callan's approach and execution. For one thing, I often felt overwhelmed by details. There didn't seem to be a sense of proportion, with more important themes or incidents getting more in-depth coverage and others getting less. The treatment kind of hovered at about the same level from beginning to end, at least for me. As a result, I was bored at times by what to me seemed like an excess of detail, while other times I wanted to know more. For example, I would have liked to know more about his relationships with family and close friends, his interactions with Utah culture, his assessments of his career, etc.
Granted, Redford is probably a hard person to know. But if that's the case, then either the book should have been shorter or Callan should have done more analysis of the evidence he amassed over ten years. I would have liked to see more of a clear focus on major themes in Redford's life, a more thoughtful exploration of the key events. I know some of that was there, but the book kind of jumped around a lot and felt unnecessarily superficial.
Finally, I wish there had been more of a sense of story in the book. Some writers have a knack of capturing and rendering key events from a person's life that reveal his or her character. For me, Callan lacked the ability to tell Redford's story in a vivid or compelling way. Having read this 400 page bio, there aren't many incidents that were particularly memorable. There are some, but not as many as there should have been over 400 pages.
On the whole, however, I'm glad I read the book, and I enjoyed getting a behind-the-scenes look at Redford and his career. I appreciated getting a glimpse into the events that shaped him, how he worked as an actor and director, and his influence on the motion picture industry.