A hungry old man chops off the tail of a curious creature that creeps into his cabin, cooks it, and eats it for dinner. Satisfied, he goes to bed, but is awakened by the scratching of something climbing the side of his cabin and calling, Tailypo, tailypo, all I want is my tailypo! The thing is persistent, and the story does not end well for the old man.
This is one of my favorite Halloween read-alouds for 1st and 2nd graders. The quieter my voice and the creepier the tailypo's, the bigger their eyes get. Afterward we discuss what they think the creature was (cat? giant rat? wolf?) and how it got its tailypo back, as it sings in the closing lines. I don't tell them what happened, I just let them look at what the story says and figure it out for themselves. When they really think it through, they make some good grossed-out faces. Terrific, and perfect for Halloween week.