While less innovative than the first installment of this series, this book delivers a good second act. It gets 4 stars (using my rating system shown at the end of this review). And in fact, IMO this isn't a book you should read without having read Terms of Service (the first book). Also, no plot descriptions here from me; I'm sure you'll find other reviewers for that. I'd rather draw attention to the good & less-good.
The good: The main *human* character(s) are still well composed. She (pronoun intentional) is still wrestling with the system of AIs that define what society and commerce look like, in two ways: ethically, and operationally. She still wrestles with the implications of what it means to have AIs operating as independently as this society allows. All the "she's" stand for the principle of "human pushing back on being coopted by the machines."
We also learn a bit more about the world Shes live in - and we learn that the dystopia described in book one might not be the way everything in the world is. This provides an interesting new landscape onto which the story can venture.
We also see the character of the Director being developed in unexpected and interesting ways.
And, it's *kind of* a happy ending…? So, all good!
What's less-good? I thought the first book introduced a bunch of novel concepts around how the AIs were constructed, how they operated in concert with the Companies that owned / operated them (which is the theme behind the "Terms of Service" title), and the questions of what constitutes consciousness and self - and are those portable? All those (admittedly not novel in idea, but novel in execution) aspects were done in an exciting and engaging way.
But this book is not quite an action novel (though there are plenty of chases & fights), but it's not quite a sci-fi novel with challenging ideas in it, either. There are one or two - for instance how the main character can experience a long period of subjective time when living digitally compared to in-the-flesh. But there were just too-few of those vs. the first one.
All in all, it's worth reading if you read Terms of Service to see what happens in part 2. But just ready yourself that it is not quite as compelling as the first one.
My rating system:
- Five stars is when you read a book to the end, put it down, take a deep breath, pick it up and start reading it all over again - or you would if you weren't so anxious to read the next book in a multi-book series. Or, it's simply really good.
- Four stars is when you tell yourself : ”This is good, this is well-written, this is full of interesting ideas/characters/plot points”, but you know you will never read it again.
- Three stars is when you read it to the end, put it down and proceed to forget all about it in the next instant.
- Two stars when it's so bad that it makes you laugh, or sigh, and want to write a review, but you can't remember the name of the book or dislike it so much that you don't.
- One star when you can't read past chapter 3, even as penance for your sins.
Disclosure: I received this book for free for a review. I commit to you, reader, not to let "free" generate a falsely-positive review.