I started off really liking this one, and thought the premise was an interesting one.
I’ve seen reviews talking about how Marin, the fmc, was too mean to Max for most of the book but I disagree. Yes, she was mean, but honestly he deserved it 🤷🏻♀️
He breaks up with her after his parents die, “for her own good,” because of his own fears of losing her, and then doesn’t speak to her for EIGHT YEARS. They’ve known each other since birth, but he doesn’t ever reach out to apologize??? It takes her coming back to her parents house in the town they grew up in, for him to apologize. After spending six years worth of Christmas with HER family where she’s never there, you’d think maybe he would try to reach out beforehand??? But no, he never did and it took her being in front of him for him to make the apology. I understand his trauma, I get it I do, but she was severely hurt by him not only as a lover but as a best friend since childhood, and it felt like he never fully got that.
Her parents, ooof. I was so frustrated with them. They discount her heartbreak at every turn. Her mom pushes and pushes her to forgive him, but he literally broke her heart and still hasn’t apologized while her mom is pushing them together. He’s acting like nothing happened between them, trying to be friendly, but I may be just as “immature” as her then, bc i wouldn’t want to be friendly with him either. And I’d be pissed at my family for not telling me he was there either, especially after so many years.
Honestly, i wanted him to grovel a little more. In the end, she’s the one that helps him deal with his trauma, which ok great, but she has to kind of suck up her heartbreak and it’s her growth that allows them to be together.
I also hate the plot point of “woman gets heart broken, turns to work to fill the void, and can’t have any serious relationships bc of the one that got away.” I wish she could’ve had at least one other meaningful relationship in these eight years.
This is not steamy.
No OW/OM drama