What do you think?
Rate this book
Sword Maiden from the Moon #1
The Heavenly Sword
"An emotional, imaginative, wild ride!" - Larry Feign, author of The Flower Boat Girl
The Heavenly Sword is the first part of a spellbinding duology weaving Chinese mythical folklore and speculative history into a sweeping tale of family love, fellowship loyalty, loss, sacrifice and kung fu rivalry.
Set in a world of human conflicts, fantastical martial arts, sorcery and celestial magic, Alice Poon’s debut fantasy follows a martial maiden’s heartbreaking adventures in her quest for love and justice.
The goddess Chang’e is sent to the mortal world to stop the Sky Wolf Zhu Di’s plans to usurp the throne. Reborn as Tang Sai’er, a simple village girl, her celestial mission requires her to learn special martial arts skills, but in order to achieve unrivaled mastery, she must battle against her growing feelings for a member of the evil tyrant’s court.
To protect her family and the village people from the effects of Zhu Di’s brutal civil war, Sai’er and her allies must pit themselves against the wicked new Emperor and other adversaries including the vicious Green Dragon. But even with immortals’ help in the process, she finds that her mission might exact too steep a price!
The Heavenly Sword is the first part of a spellbinding duology weaving Chinese mythical folklore and speculative history into a sweeping tale of family love, fellowship loyalty, loss, sacrifice and kung fu rivalry.
Set in a world of human conflicts, fantastical martial arts, sorcery and celestial magic, Alice Poon’s debut fantasy follows a martial maiden’s heartbreaking adventures in her quest for love and justice.
The goddess Chang’e is sent to the mortal world to stop the Sky Wolf Zhu Di’s plans to usurp the throne. Reborn as Tang Sai’er, a simple village girl, her celestial mission requires her to learn special martial arts skills, but in order to achieve unrivaled mastery, she must battle against her growing feelings for a member of the evil tyrant’s court.
To protect her family and the village people from the effects of Zhu Di’s brutal civil war, Sai’er and her allies must pit themselves against the wicked new Emperor and other adversaries including the vicious Green Dragon. But even with immortals’ help in the process, she finds that her mission might exact too steep a price!
390 pages, Paperback
First published January 10, 2023
11 people are currently reading
1521 people want to read
About the author
Alice Poon
6 books322 followersBorn and raised in Hong Kong, Alice Poon received a fully bilingual (English and Chinese) education and also learned French in her youth.
Since the release of her two historical Chinese novels: The Green Phoenix and Tales of Ming Courtesans, nostalgia for the magical world of wuxia fiction, which she grew up with, has spurred her desire to write in the Chinese fantasy genre. With the passing of the wuxia fiction icon Jin Yong in 2018, she has felt an urge to help to preserve his legacy and to promote this unique genre of Chinese folk literature to a wider global audience.
Overall, inspiration for her fiction writing comes from Jin Yong’s wuxia novels, the wuxia/xianxia media, and French and Russian realist classics.
She lives in Greater Vancouver, Canada and wishes to indulge herself in putting her imagination on the page.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 50 reviews
December 14, 2024
Not for me. As you know, I have difficulty with East Asian fantasy, mythology, and retellings. While this cover looks young adult, another problem area for me, the book is very much adult. This should come with trigger warnings, for all the misogyny and mention of virgins.
I don't know if I just couldn't get into it, but I found the story hard to follow. I am semi-familiar with the story of Chang'e at this point, so that part should've made sense at least. For all the mention of Sai'er going on a quest, I found it a little non-linear. I realize this is the first in a series, but the ending came up rather abruptly.
📱 Thank you to Earnshaw Books
I don't know if I just couldn't get into it, but I found the story hard to follow. I am semi-familiar with the story of Chang'e at this point, so that part should've made sense at least. For all the mention of Sai'er going on a quest, I found it a little non-linear. I realize this is the first in a series, but the ending came up rather abruptly.
📱 Thank you to Earnshaw Books
January 23, 2025
NOTE: THIS IS AN ADULT FANTASY NOVEL.
Media Reviews:-
“Poon has created a cast of dynamic and lively characters that continue to raise the stakes with every passing chapter, and the world of prophecies, spirituality, and politics forces them into more threatening situations. Sai'er is a strong and complex character who you are rooting for throughout the novel and you want to see her succeed as her skills, beliefs, mind, and heart are challenged by others in the book...The narrative is well crafted. The balance of politics and mythology is wonderful as both topics play off of one another and work together to create a world where you, as the reader, feel the weight of every decision that the characters make and how it will affect them and those they care about…”
~ Notes from the Library, Bookstagrammer
“Alice Poon’s The Heavenly Sword is a great and engrossing adventure story that is steeped in Chinese mythology. If you’re a fan of classic wuxia novels and films, like those by Jin Yong and King Hu, you’ll love this elegantly written novel. I highly recommend this book for both those who are familiar with Chinese culture, and for those who want to learn more about China and its literary history.”
~ Jeffrey Wang, Film Critic for The Cinema Files
"Only one thing could prevent a goddess in the earthly form of the young warrior Sai'er from vanquishing the usurping tyrant Zhu Di and his henchmen: love. A lyrical martial arts saga."
~ Seattle Public Library (Shelf Talk Blog)
The Heavenly Sword is my epic fantasy debut (adult, not YA) and a personal tribute to Jin Yong (1924 – 2018), the iconic grandfather of wuxia (martial heroes) novels. In a lot of ways, this novel and its sequel have been inspired by his works, especially where themes, martial arts feats and history retellings are concerned.
Media Reviews:-
“Poon has created a cast of dynamic and lively characters that continue to raise the stakes with every passing chapter, and the world of prophecies, spirituality, and politics forces them into more threatening situations. Sai'er is a strong and complex character who you are rooting for throughout the novel and you want to see her succeed as her skills, beliefs, mind, and heart are challenged by others in the book...The narrative is well crafted. The balance of politics and mythology is wonderful as both topics play off of one another and work together to create a world where you, as the reader, feel the weight of every decision that the characters make and how it will affect them and those they care about…”
~ Notes from the Library, Bookstagrammer
“Alice Poon’s The Heavenly Sword is a great and engrossing adventure story that is steeped in Chinese mythology. If you’re a fan of classic wuxia novels and films, like those by Jin Yong and King Hu, you’ll love this elegantly written novel. I highly recommend this book for both those who are familiar with Chinese culture, and for those who want to learn more about China and its literary history.”
~ Jeffrey Wang, Film Critic for The Cinema Files
"Only one thing could prevent a goddess in the earthly form of the young warrior Sai'er from vanquishing the usurping tyrant Zhu Di and his henchmen: love. A lyrical martial arts saga."
~ Seattle Public Library (Shelf Talk Blog)
The Heavenly Sword is my epic fantasy debut (adult, not YA) and a personal tribute to Jin Yong (1924 – 2018), the iconic grandfather of wuxia (martial heroes) novels. In a lot of ways, this novel and its sequel have been inspired by his works, especially where themes, martial arts feats and history retellings are concerned.
October 17, 2022
This is a beautifully woven story which is shared through interlacing Chinese mythology with the changes that have followed over time. This begins with the reincarnation of a goddess, Chang’e of the Moon Palace, who returns as a girl named Tang Sai’er. A girl who has been given a monumental task. A task which often includes dangerous moments. There are also those who are also on her side, and she is driven by the need to protect not only her family, but the entire village.
”The trick is to be a needle wrapped in cotton,” Sai’er’s father said.”
Set in China in a small village in Shandong, an eastern Chinese province on the Yellow Sea, this is where Tang Sai’er and her foster brother Binhong lived, along with their Ba. Sai’er and Binhong have been training in their backyard, but Sai’er is yet to understand the key to her strength as this story begins.
As this begins, Sai’er and her foster brother, Binhong are engaged in a duel, with Binghong slamming her, using the full weight of his body to take her down with his sword. Without hesitation, she reacts, engaging her qi, which causes her body to react in unexpected ways, and she falters, if briefly, it is enough for Binghong to send her sword flying.
As Sai’er and Binhong become more advanced in their schooling of these arts, learning the subtleties underlying the art of meditation, Chinese breathing, the use of the mind-body connection, and using that to assess one's internal self, while also listening to one’s internal self and to the signs from your body.
Sai’er is tasked with a mission, one that will, essentially, change the course of history. While she is counseled by those wiser than she, those among The Eight Immortals, she, in turn, must coach those who reside in the village in order to save the village and those who reside there. She becomes the voice of The Eight Immortals as she begins to train the villagers. An auspicious challenge for one so young. It would be a daunting challenge for most, but Sai’er seems to be aware that there is little choice. They must win.
There is another war going on for Sai’er, a war within herself on the natural desire for love vs. physical desires. In order to win the battle for the villagers, she must focus on strengthening her resolve and set aside her physical desires, or all will be lost.
I loved reading this, loved the customs this explored, the Chinese mythology at the heart of this story, the symbolism sprinkled throughout, the strongly felt theme for love of family, and most of all, the heartfelt determination that Sai’er had to save the village and its people.
For those who have followed her previous books, this one is for adults, and has some adult scenarios. There’s nothing that is shocking, but depending on what you want your children to read or not read, it isn’t written for children.
Pub Date: 10 Jan 2023
Many thanks for the ARC provided by the author, Alice Poon
June 5, 2023
I was rather conflicted whether to post this review. On one hand, the chance to read a woman-led wuxia inspired novel really excited me. On the other hand, the book left me feeling rather disappointed.
What I liked about the book:
-I really enjoyed how this book unapologetically places a female character in narratives that have traditionally been reserved for men. Tang Sai’er is the chosen one. She is given a divine mission. She is the reincarnation of a goddess. Not only does she learn martial arts, but she is considered the best in her specialty. She frequently engages in martial arts bouts and wins them. She makes decisions. She drives the plot. When she becomes a leader, the people closest to her don't question her authority. Although she remains incredibly naïve and she makes mistakes, her heart is always for the people. She is a very admirable wuxia hero.
-I really liked the setting. It was an unique mix of wuxia tropes, historical fiction, and Chinese mythical folklore all in one tale.
What I didn't like about the book:
-There is a point in the novel where the main character is questioning a potential love interest if he raped two women WHILE he is sexually assaulting her. I'm not kidding. Spoilers for the text:
This is the point where I almost DNF'd. But I've never DNF'd a book, so I kept going. Tang Sai’er pines for this rapist for almost the entire book. Yes, there are other love interests but I found all the scenes where Tang Sai’er interacts with Zhu Di to be extremely problematic. And although part of her character arc in the book is realizing this guy is a giant turtle egg, I did not enjoy reading it. This guy straight up shows who he is again, and again, and again all throughout the novel. It should not have taken Tang Sai’er an entire novel to come to this realization. I guess that's why Chang’e is the goddess of the moon, and not of wisdom.
-I did not like how the magic system was tied to Tang Sai’er's virginity. In order for her to be the strongest martial artist, she must remain a virgin, which means that there are several attempts on her virginity throughout the novel. It makes her a strategically sexual target in a way that male heroes aren't. I truly wonder why this choice was made. Male heroes don't have to go through this, so why her? Why must her strength and power be predicated on that fact she remain a virgin? Why can't she be strong and powerful just because she is a woman, or masterful at martial arts, or a reincarnated chosen one? This choice doesn't feel like a trope subversion. It feels cheap and unimaginative. I really really hope this is subverted in some way in the sequel.
-I don't feel that this book ends in the right place. The current ending feels too abrupt, and personally, I think that the book would have ended better after Sai'er's defeat of Monk Yao and as she walks out of the palace, because that is the resolution of Sai’er's character arc as she finally decides on her feelings for Zhu Di and she embraces her mission to be the Protector of Shandong.
-I'm not a romance person. I came for the martial arts and the fact that her adoptive brother, the eunuch, and Zhu Di were all constantly pining after Sai'er was a lot for me. And then there was Lin San... and... and... everybody hated this dude. His own mother hated him. But everyone was like, well, you were married to him in another life so suck it up and marry this trash even though we know he is a terrible dude and will most likely eventually bring you harm. Of which, of course he does. Sai'er marries Lin San because that is what her deceased mother wanted, but I don't believe her mother would have wanted that for her if her mother had known of his character. Yes, historically, she marries this guy, but what is the significance of this story told this way? I do like the idea of a character who might be forced to marry a guy she does not like, but has the power to keep going about her work of raising a rebel army. But this plotline, in combination with all of the other sexual assault and abuse, was too much for me.
Overall, this was a conflicting reading experience. This book felt both progressive and regressive at the same time, and the latter really affected my enjoyment of it.
What I liked about the book:
-I really enjoyed how this book unapologetically places a female character in narratives that have traditionally been reserved for men. Tang Sai’er is the chosen one. She is given a divine mission. She is the reincarnation of a goddess. Not only does she learn martial arts, but she is considered the best in her specialty. She frequently engages in martial arts bouts and wins them. She makes decisions. She drives the plot. When she becomes a leader, the people closest to her don't question her authority. Although she remains incredibly naïve and she makes mistakes, her heart is always for the people. She is a very admirable wuxia hero.
-I really liked the setting. It was an unique mix of wuxia tropes, historical fiction, and Chinese mythical folklore all in one tale.
What I didn't like about the book:
-There is a point in the novel where the main character is questioning a potential love interest if he raped two women WHILE he is sexually assaulting her. I'm not kidding. Spoilers for the text:
This is the point where I almost DNF'd. But I've never DNF'd a book, so I kept going. Tang Sai’er pines for this rapist for almost the entire book. Yes, there are other love interests but I found all the scenes where Tang Sai’er interacts with Zhu Di to be extremely problematic. And although part of her character arc in the book is realizing this guy is a giant turtle egg, I did not enjoy reading it. This guy straight up shows who he is again, and again, and again all throughout the novel. It should not have taken Tang Sai’er an entire novel to come to this realization. I guess that's why Chang’e is the goddess of the moon, and not of wisdom.
-I did not like how the magic system was tied to Tang Sai’er's virginity. In order for her to be the strongest martial artist, she must remain a virgin, which means that there are several attempts on her virginity throughout the novel. It makes her a strategically sexual target in a way that male heroes aren't. I truly wonder why this choice was made. Male heroes don't have to go through this, so why her? Why must her strength and power be predicated on that fact she remain a virgin? Why can't she be strong and powerful just because she is a woman, or masterful at martial arts, or a reincarnated chosen one? This choice doesn't feel like a trope subversion. It feels cheap and unimaginative. I really really hope this is subverted in some way in the sequel.
-I don't feel that this book ends in the right place. The current ending feels too abrupt, and personally, I think that the book would have ended better after Sai'er's defeat of Monk Yao and as she walks out of the palace, because that is the resolution of Sai’er's character arc as she finally decides on her feelings for Zhu Di and she embraces her mission to be the Protector of Shandong.
-I'm not a romance person. I came for the martial arts and the fact that her adoptive brother, the eunuch, and Zhu Di were all constantly pining after Sai'er was a lot for me. And then there was Lin San... and... and... everybody hated this dude. His own mother hated him. But everyone was like, well, you were married to him in another life so suck it up and marry this trash even though we know he is a terrible dude and will most likely eventually bring you harm. Of which, of course he does. Sai'er marries Lin San because that is what her deceased mother wanted, but I don't believe her mother would have wanted that for her if her mother had known of his character. Yes, historically, she marries this guy, but what is the significance of this story told this way? I do like the idea of a character who might be forced to marry a guy she does not like, but has the power to keep going about her work of raising a rebel army. But this plotline, in combination with all of the other sexual assault and abuse, was too much for me.
Overall, this was a conflicting reading experience. This book felt both progressive and regressive at the same time, and the latter really affected my enjoyment of it.
March 18, 2024
3.5 STARS
My only problem is that the writing style and dialogue really made this book more stoic than it should be.
My only problem is that the writing style and dialogue really made this book more stoic than it should be.
February 15, 2025
Tang Sai'er has lived a relatively simple life with her Ba and her adopted brother Baihong studying martial arts. And while she hopes to eventually become a student of Master Zhang, she knows she has a lot of work to do before that's even a consideration. Unfortunately for her fate comes crashing into her life when she discovers that she actually the reincarnation of the Goddess Chang'e and she now must face off against Zhu Di the reincarnation of a Sky Wolf who was banished from the heavens due to his behavior. To make matters worse, she still has to fully her destiny as Hou Yi's wife!! Will Sai'er be able to master her martial ability in time to stop Zhu Di's tyranny? And, just as importantly, how does she get out of this marriage!?
Honestly, it's just a solid wuxia. Like literally one of the most solid, it stands up to any others I've read solid. The pacing, the plot line, everything is just as good as any book, TV show, or movie I've read, and I'm definitely stoked that I've got the second book already to read.
There are just a couple of notes that I think are important for Western readers: This isn't written for our sensibilities, in the least, which I applaud Poon for this. Like genuinely love her for that. Once we decide to write another cultures genre for our lens, it loses so much of its meaning and, quite frankly, what makes it amazing to begin with. That means some of this may not make sense if you aren't familiar with certain terms and Chinese mythology. And it's not a crash course into it either. This also means there will be cultural differences that are pretty standard in a wuxia novel that may seem unfamiliar or even outdated to a Western reader.
Other than that, I have zero complaints here. And that's not even really a complaint, just a heads up.
Overall, as an avid fan of wuxia and just Chinese fantasy in general while there are some rough patches here I am chalking those up to this being the author's first book, I have a feeling whatever small complaints I may have had will work themselves out as the author continues to write.
As always, thanks to NetGalley and Earnshaw Books!
Honestly, it's just a solid wuxia. Like literally one of the most solid, it stands up to any others I've read solid. The pacing, the plot line, everything is just as good as any book, TV show, or movie I've read, and I'm definitely stoked that I've got the second book already to read.
There are just a couple of notes that I think are important for Western readers: This isn't written for our sensibilities, in the least, which I applaud Poon for this. Like genuinely love her for that. Once we decide to write another cultures genre for our lens, it loses so much of its meaning and, quite frankly, what makes it amazing to begin with. That means some of this may not make sense if you aren't familiar with certain terms and Chinese mythology. And it's not a crash course into it either. This also means there will be cultural differences that are pretty standard in a wuxia novel that may seem unfamiliar or even outdated to a Western reader.
Other than that, I have zero complaints here. And that's not even really a complaint, just a heads up.
Overall, as an avid fan of wuxia and just Chinese fantasy in general while there are some rough patches here I am chalking those up to this being the author's first book, I have a feeling whatever small complaints I may have had will work themselves out as the author continues to write.
As always, thanks to NetGalley and Earnshaw Books!
February 4, 2025
A fantasy comprised of a mix of Chinese mythology and martial arts. Our heroine is able to move back and forth between the immortal and mortal worlds while being pursued by an evil monarch. Certainly good versus evil, but with the Chinese background and words this is an interesting twist on much fantasy, which often has medieval (Europe/UK) overtures. I am not a expert on Chinese history, but based on the names of cities and terms, I would guess this fantasy takes place during the Ming Dynasty (1368 to 1644 AD). The Ming Dynasty followed the collapse of the Mongol-led Yuan dynasty (1206-1368 AD) for those who may have (as have I) read much of Genghis Khan and his descendants.
There is zero closure in this book one, so book two, [book:The Earthly Blaze
, is a necessary read if you want to conclude the tale. I do not usually continue with such things, but the ancient Chinese culture is compelling.
There is zero closure in this book one, so book two, [book:The Earthly Blaze
, is a necessary read if you want to conclude the tale. I do not usually continue with such things, but the ancient Chinese culture is compelling.
April 12, 2023
The Heavenly Sword by Alice Poon is a unique blend of wuxia, Chinese historical fiction, xianxia and Chinese mythology. If some of the terms are unfamiliar, the author has written a guest post on the Asian Books blog outlining her inspiration, influences and the meaning of wuxia and xianxia. I had the honour of being a beta reader for this novel last year, with thanks to the author for providing a copy. My comments and review will pertain to that version.
The Heavenly Sword is set during the period of early Ming Dynasty, China with young Tang Sai'er as the protagonist. Sai'er, along with Zhu Di (who becomes the Yongle Emperor) and Zheng He, are real life important historical figures of that time. They slot seamlessly into a wuxia story of resistance and justice by the White Lotus Sect, with great homage to classic wuxia author Jin Yong. The worldbuilding is excellent with attention to detail and meticulous research. In particular, I liked the detail on the Chinese celestial pantheon and mythology (Chi You, Xuannu, Sun Wukong, Chang Ji, Nezha, Heavenly Empress and her famous celestial peaches, the four mythological dragons), traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) as well as wuxia martial arts training.
Sai'er, in addition to her mortal self, has an immortal persona which gives her a mission. Without spoilers, the action is fast and intense, setting up for book two. The writing is assured and mature, with historical figures imaginatively integrated into a wuxia and xianxia adventure.
On a personal note, I am Goodreads friends with Alice and I've found that she is always gracious and generous in sharing her knowledge of wuxia and Chinese history. Her other book, Tales of Ming Courtesans, shines a light on three historical female courtesan artists during the Ming Dynasty. Her championing and celebration of striking female historical figures who would otherwise be overlooked in the annals of history is important. Being a wuxia enthusiast myself, I once wailed to Alice in a message "Why can't the female be the one who finds the sword, who falls into the cave and gets taught by a mysterious old master, is surrounded by a bevy of handsome men, who becomes sect leader, and is betrayed?" [This is prior to my knowing of the existence of the Sword Maiden from the Moon series]. Alice said she smiled when she saw my message.
The Heavenly Sword's publication date is 10th January 2023 by Earnshaw Books Ltd.
The Heavenly Sword is set during the period of early Ming Dynasty, China with young Tang Sai'er as the protagonist. Sai'er, along with Zhu Di (who becomes the Yongle Emperor) and Zheng He, are real life important historical figures of that time. They slot seamlessly into a wuxia story of resistance and justice by the White Lotus Sect, with great homage to classic wuxia author Jin Yong. The worldbuilding is excellent with attention to detail and meticulous research. In particular, I liked the detail on the Chinese celestial pantheon and mythology (Chi You, Xuannu, Sun Wukong, Chang Ji, Nezha, Heavenly Empress and her famous celestial peaches, the four mythological dragons), traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) as well as wuxia martial arts training.
Sai'er, in addition to her mortal self, has an immortal persona which gives her a mission. Without spoilers, the action is fast and intense, setting up for book two. The writing is assured and mature, with historical figures imaginatively integrated into a wuxia and xianxia adventure.
On a personal note, I am Goodreads friends with Alice and I've found that she is always gracious and generous in sharing her knowledge of wuxia and Chinese history. Her other book, Tales of Ming Courtesans, shines a light on three historical female courtesan artists during the Ming Dynasty. Her championing and celebration of striking female historical figures who would otherwise be overlooked in the annals of history is important. Being a wuxia enthusiast myself, I once wailed to Alice in a message "Why can't the female be the one who finds the sword, who falls into the cave and gets taught by a mysterious old master, is surrounded by a bevy of handsome men, who becomes sect leader, and is betrayed?" [This is prior to my knowing of the existence of the Sword Maiden from the Moon series]. Alice said she smiled when she saw my message.
The Heavenly Sword's publication date is 10th January 2023 by Earnshaw Books Ltd.
May 12, 2025
I received an e-book copy from the author in exchange for an honest review.
You will enjoy this duology if you love:
- wuxia and xianxia vibes,
- world of martial arts,
- mythology and history incorporated into a fantasy setting,
- characters learning their life lessons and growing into formidable heroes they didn't expect to become,
- focus on family and strong friendship bonds,
- strong female heroine,
- unexpected and tragic endings,
- the importance of a moral code in a cruel world,
- political intrigues and secret schemes.
The Heavenly Sword is a perfect book for lovers of wuxia and xianxia novels, Chinese mythology and Jin Yong's work. It's written like a fairytale, so it almost feels like someone is telling you the story in the old classic tale style. The writing style also gives a bit of classic book vibes, so maybe that's why I felt like I was reading an old legend about young heroes from ancient times. I needed a few pages to get into the story and get used to the writing style because I read different books before I started this one, but once I dove into the words, the story and the characters grew on me chapter by chapter.
My favourite aspect was Chinese mythology and how it was woven into the story. You very well know that I'm in my Chinese fantasy obsession era, so I enjoyed every mention of ancient myths and legends and how well they were incorporated into the main plot. The story is magical and mythical, and goes quickly from a childish fairytale to very grim dark reality checks. This also corresponds with our main heroine, Sai'er, and her journey of growing up. She's a likeable character and my favourite of all the characters we were introduced to in the first book. Since our heroes were teens, there was some naivety, and Sai'er was sometimes way too trustworthy to everyone she met (at least she had Binhong, that boy was way too clever). But I truly liked how she was able to learn her lessons, and every encounter with danger or human cruelty shaped her as a person. I'm curious to see how her fate will continue in the second book and how much it will differ from the myth it was inspired by. Plus, I hope that the friendship among the main characters will survive everything, and I don't want to see anyone get hurt or, worse, killed.
Rating: 4,5 stars
You will enjoy this duology if you love:
- wuxia and xianxia vibes,
- world of martial arts,
- mythology and history incorporated into a fantasy setting,
- characters learning their life lessons and growing into formidable heroes they didn't expect to become,
- focus on family and strong friendship bonds,
- strong female heroine,
- unexpected and tragic endings,
- the importance of a moral code in a cruel world,
- political intrigues and secret schemes.
The Heavenly Sword is a perfect book for lovers of wuxia and xianxia novels, Chinese mythology and Jin Yong's work. It's written like a fairytale, so it almost feels like someone is telling you the story in the old classic tale style. The writing style also gives a bit of classic book vibes, so maybe that's why I felt like I was reading an old legend about young heroes from ancient times. I needed a few pages to get into the story and get used to the writing style because I read different books before I started this one, but once I dove into the words, the story and the characters grew on me chapter by chapter.
My favourite aspect was Chinese mythology and how it was woven into the story. You very well know that I'm in my Chinese fantasy obsession era, so I enjoyed every mention of ancient myths and legends and how well they were incorporated into the main plot. The story is magical and mythical, and goes quickly from a childish fairytale to very grim dark reality checks. This also corresponds with our main heroine, Sai'er, and her journey of growing up. She's a likeable character and my favourite of all the characters we were introduced to in the first book. Since our heroes were teens, there was some naivety, and Sai'er was sometimes way too trustworthy to everyone she met (at least she had Binhong, that boy was way too clever). But I truly liked how she was able to learn her lessons, and every encounter with danger or human cruelty shaped her as a person. I'm curious to see how her fate will continue in the second book and how much it will differ from the myth it was inspired by. Plus, I hope that the friendship among the main characters will survive everything, and I don't want to see anyone get hurt or, worse, killed.
Rating: 4,5 stars
June 29, 2024
***I was given a copy in exchange for an honest review***
This was a wonderful read. I've recently gotten into the Xianxia and Wuxia genres of storytelling and this book was a wonderful addition to my growing collection of books from this genre that I've read. Poon has created a cast of dynamic and lively characters that continue to raise the stakes with every passing chapter, and the world of prophecies, spirituality, and politics forces them into more threatening situations. Sai'er is a strong and complex character who you are rooting for throughout the novel and you want to see her succeed as her skills, beliefs, mind, and heart are challenged by others in the book. The rest of the characters, including Binhong, Sanbao, and more, continue to add more layers to the story as each of them is also just as complex as Sai'er. throughout the narrative, you get to explore each character and learn about their history, mindset, and actions. It was a great balance of following the main character while also learning about the others.
The narrative is well crafted. The balance of politics and mythology is wonderful as both topics play off of one another and work together to create a world where you, as the reader, feel the weight of every decision that the characters make and how it will affect them and those they care about. The intensity of the world around them, mixed with the softness of a growing relationship between Sai'er and Sanbao, as well as the love for family, balance out the more intense parts of the story. All of this comes together with beautiful writing that paints a picture in your mind of the story.
Reading this book was a true joy, and I am very excited to read the second one in this duology to see where Poon takes readers next.
This was a wonderful read. I've recently gotten into the Xianxia and Wuxia genres of storytelling and this book was a wonderful addition to my growing collection of books from this genre that I've read. Poon has created a cast of dynamic and lively characters that continue to raise the stakes with every passing chapter, and the world of prophecies, spirituality, and politics forces them into more threatening situations. Sai'er is a strong and complex character who you are rooting for throughout the novel and you want to see her succeed as her skills, beliefs, mind, and heart are challenged by others in the book. The rest of the characters, including Binhong, Sanbao, and more, continue to add more layers to the story as each of them is also just as complex as Sai'er. throughout the narrative, you get to explore each character and learn about their history, mindset, and actions. It was a great balance of following the main character while also learning about the others.
The narrative is well crafted. The balance of politics and mythology is wonderful as both topics play off of one another and work together to create a world where you, as the reader, feel the weight of every decision that the characters make and how it will affect them and those they care about. The intensity of the world around them, mixed with the softness of a growing relationship between Sai'er and Sanbao, as well as the love for family, balance out the more intense parts of the story. All of this comes together with beautiful writing that paints a picture in your mind of the story.
Reading this book was a true joy, and I am very excited to read the second one in this duology to see where Poon takes readers next.
August 27, 2024
In this incredible fantasy novel, readers explore the world of Alice Poon’s debut novel where martial arts, magic, and the conflicts of humans and gods all reside. Reborn as mortal girl and martial artist Tang Sai’er, the goddess Chang’e returns to the mortal world to stop Zhu Di, the Sky Wolf, from becoming a tyrant over the mortal world. However, Zhu Di begins a war that threatens her village and the White Lotus Sect, Sai’er must lead her people to safety, navigate the feuds of these immortals, and fight her feelings for Ma Sanbao, a member of Zhu Di’s court. With its mix of fantasy and Chinese mythology, Poon’s debut novel is magical, immersive, and fascinatingly complex. The conflict at the heart of the novel is complicated and spans immortal lifetimes, and having these immortals reborn as mortals entangles them in other equally important conflicts. Sai’er is a complex, powerful protagonist with flaws and emotions readers will find relatable. Bringing her relationships with her peers, her family, Zhu Di, and Ma Sanbao to the center of the story, this is a powerful, detailed, and exciting debut novel that brings magic, family, and change to the forefront of Sai’er’s village and community.
Thanks to NetGalley and Earnshwa Books Ltd. for the advance copy.
Thanks to NetGalley and Earnshwa Books Ltd. for the advance copy.
Want to read
October 14, 2022This book is for adult audiences?????
Cover could have fooled me.
Epic Fantasy is not at all my genre, but I will absolutely make an exception for an East Asian voice taking on the task.
Cover could have fooled me.
Epic Fantasy is not at all my genre, but I will absolutely make an exception for an East Asian voice taking on the task.
December 1, 2023
As a fan of Chinese mythology, wuxia, and xianxia, I was so excited to discover this book and it did not disappoint! The story is inspired by Jin Yong’s novels and the interwoven mythology, historical figures, and deities make it even more compelling.
Alice Poon spares no detail in environments, characters, martial arts moves, qi specifics, and fight scenes, and this really made me feel like I was transported into one of my favourite C-dramas 💛
As one of my favourite books of 2023, I can’t wait to see where Sai’er’s, Binhong’s, and Yinho’s adventure takes them in book 2! 💛
Alice Poon spares no detail in environments, characters, martial arts moves, qi specifics, and fight scenes, and this really made me feel like I was transported into one of my favourite C-dramas 💛
As one of my favourite books of 2023, I can’t wait to see where Sai’er’s, Binhong’s, and Yinho’s adventure takes them in book 2! 💛
July 7, 2024
Thank you netgalley and the publisher for an earc of this book in exchange for a review.
DNF. Multiple love interests, one being a sexual assaulter and one being her adoptive brother who pines over her, and her magic is tied to her virginity, meaning people try to defeat her by taking care of her virginity and that she is only strong if she's a virgin. No thanks, I'm out.
DNF. Multiple love interests, one being a sexual assaulter and one being her adoptive brother who pines over her, and her magic is tied to her virginity, meaning people try to defeat her by taking care of her virginity and that she is only strong if she's a virgin. No thanks, I'm out.
October 30, 2022
Wow. I love wuxia stories and Alice Poon did not disappoint.
The story begins with Sai'er who is the reincarnation of Chang'e of the Moon Palace. Sai'er has been tasked to stop the Sky Wold Zhu Di's plan to ursurp the throne. A highly dangerous task which Sai'er needs to do everything to prepare for. Sai'er lives with her foster brother Binhong and they are often training together, day by day increasing their strength and mastering new techniques such as the sword-as-whip technique.
Sai'er learns her true identity and the task entrusted to her and soon sets out with her foster brother, meeting new allies and growing stronger. Sai'er enlists the help of The Eight Immortals in her struggle against the new Emperor and soon becomes the voice for these immortals and begins to train villagers. Sai'er understands the weight of the misson and what fate awaits the people she loves if she fails, so she knows she needs to get stronger. There is no failure if she wants to protect.
I love how Sai'er is not battling with the mission entrusted to her but she is also battling her desire for a member in the enemies court. I love how she sorts out her priorities to save people and sets aside her desires for the greater good. It made me appreciate her a lot more.
I am a sucker for martial arts and Alice Poon has provided plenty of martial arts feats and fighting scenes to quench my thirst. I love how there was everything to the art of qi, cultivation and secret techniques passed down from master to disciple (a big favourite of mine). I love the exploration of Chinese Mythology and immortals. Sai'ers determination to save the people she loves and how she deals with her mission by strengthing herself physically and preparing herself emotionally. I loved the way her character was developed and can't wait to see more of her in book 2.
Thank you to Alice Poon for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
The story begins with Sai'er who is the reincarnation of Chang'e of the Moon Palace. Sai'er has been tasked to stop the Sky Wold Zhu Di's plan to ursurp the throne. A highly dangerous task which Sai'er needs to do everything to prepare for. Sai'er lives with her foster brother Binhong and they are often training together, day by day increasing their strength and mastering new techniques such as the sword-as-whip technique.
Sai'er learns her true identity and the task entrusted to her and soon sets out with her foster brother, meeting new allies and growing stronger. Sai'er enlists the help of The Eight Immortals in her struggle against the new Emperor and soon becomes the voice for these immortals and begins to train villagers. Sai'er understands the weight of the misson and what fate awaits the people she loves if she fails, so she knows she needs to get stronger. There is no failure if she wants to protect.
I love how Sai'er is not battling with the mission entrusted to her but she is also battling her desire for a member in the enemies court. I love how she sorts out her priorities to save people and sets aside her desires for the greater good. It made me appreciate her a lot more.
I am a sucker for martial arts and Alice Poon has provided plenty of martial arts feats and fighting scenes to quench my thirst. I love how there was everything to the art of qi, cultivation and secret techniques passed down from master to disciple (a big favourite of mine). I love the exploration of Chinese Mythology and immortals. Sai'ers determination to save the people she loves and how she deals with her mission by strengthing herself physically and preparing herself emotionally. I loved the way her character was developed and can't wait to see more of her in book 2.
Thank you to Alice Poon for providing an eARC in exchange for an honest review.
May 25, 2024
Review: 2.5 stars
I adore c-dramas so this is a no brainer when this would be my cup of tea. While it does give me c-drama vibes, I find myself seriously struggling to finish this book and there were just some things bought up in the book that lead me to really question my love for this book. Hence, the low rating…
Pros:
- a xianxia novel with a strong female lead and great side supporting side characters. Sai’er started out as a headstrong and stubborn character but her character progression grew very quickly leading her to be a strong female lead.
- the worldbuilding and magic system is interesting and immersive leading to subplots within subplots built
Cons
- Magic tied to virginity: I do not like the fact that her most prized possession to keep her magic is tied to this. I feel because of this, this has lead to attempts made by other male characters lusting for her “just because” she feels like a forbidden fruit
- How is it that we have not one, not two but at least 3 males being “in love” with her…it feels like all the males she associates with often have a tendency to fall for her…
- Some of the scenes mentioned feel very surface level in terms of character’s growth and progress. Eg: when Sai’er joins her first battle and kills for the first time, it felt like she just shrugged it on and move on like there were no repercussions to oneself even though it was done for a reason. As such, this story lack the grip factor that makes you want to read it to know what happened
Overall, I feel very unsure about this first book given the cons cannot be ignored on my end. I’n gonna give the last book of the duology another try and hope it will be better!
Thank you to the author who provided me with an epub addition of the book in exchange for an honest review
I adore c-dramas so this is a no brainer when this would be my cup of tea. While it does give me c-drama vibes, I find myself seriously struggling to finish this book and there were just some things bought up in the book that lead me to really question my love for this book. Hence, the low rating…
Pros:
- a xianxia novel with a strong female lead and great side supporting side characters. Sai’er started out as a headstrong and stubborn character but her character progression grew very quickly leading her to be a strong female lead.
- the worldbuilding and magic system is interesting and immersive leading to subplots within subplots built
Cons
- Magic tied to virginity: I do not like the fact that her most prized possession to keep her magic is tied to this. I feel because of this, this has lead to attempts made by other male characters lusting for her “just because” she feels like a forbidden fruit
- How is it that we have not one, not two but at least 3 males being “in love” with her…it feels like all the males she associates with often have a tendency to fall for her…
- Some of the scenes mentioned feel very surface level in terms of character’s growth and progress. Eg: when Sai’er joins her first battle and kills for the first time, it felt like she just shrugged it on and move on like there were no repercussions to oneself even though it was done for a reason. As such, this story lack the grip factor that makes you want to read it to know what happened
Overall, I feel very unsure about this first book given the cons cannot be ignored on my end. I’n gonna give the last book of the duology another try and hope it will be better!
Thank you to the author who provided me with an epub addition of the book in exchange for an honest review
March 5, 2023
Check out this review and more on The Quill to Live!
I got cozy with The Heavenly Sword by Alice Poon. It was so easy to sit down and read Sai’er’s adventure, it was like listening to an epic oral tale. I looked forward to opening up my book before bed each night to see where Poon would take me next. The story flowed so nicely and I couldn’t help but snuggle in and relax into Sai’er’s tale of love and justice.
Tang Sai’er has lived all her life in a small village training in martial arts alongside her adopted brother. When the time comes for the two siblings to leave their home and master new skills, Sai’er discovers she’s the reincarnation of the goddess Chang’e. Sai’er has returned to the mortal world to carry out a celestial mission: defeat the Prince of Yan before he wreaks havoc on the world. Sai’er will take on this quest, aided by the immortals and her friends, and rely on her incredible wits and skills to protect all that she holds dear.
You don’t sit with anything too long in this story. It’s like watching the landscape roll by in a car. The plot, character development, action scenes, and immortal interference occur at high speed.
This pace was difficult for me at first because I love diving deep into my fantasy worlds. However, I came to appreciate Poon’s unique storytelling cadence. It felt as if she was telling me a bedtime story, and I was often lulled into a comfortable state of mind as I read on. The other great benefit of this pace is that a lot happens in this book. The events take place over several years of Sai’er’s life, and the story never gets hung up on long training sequences or lulls between the action.
Sai’er’s journey is tumultuous and interesting, and there is a large cast of supporting characters that aid her in her celestial mission. Poon highlights Chinese folklore throughout Sai’er’s tale. We get sneak peeks into the celestial realm, the shared histories between immortals, and new dramas that are being played out in the moral world. I like how there was no pomp and circumstance surrounding the magic in the story as well. The fantastical elements appear and influence Sai’er’s journey, and it’s accepted as easily as the characters eating taro root for dinner. It helped me stay grounded in the fast plot without letting me spiral into the why’s and how’s of the world’s inner workings. It served the story well and let us keep up with Sai’er’s next move.
The only drawback of this book is that it ends abruptly. It’s like Poon decided it was my bedtime, closed the book, and stood up to turn off the lights. It was a jarring end because the story cuts off mid-conversation right before a dreaded, impending battle. It was an odd choice to end the book here. However, I’m happy Sai’er’s story will continue. It’s incredible how much happened in this one book, and I look forward to the culmination of this determined woman’s mission.
Read The Heavenly Sword for its inspiring heroine and action-packed adventure. There is a lot of entertainment provided in its short page count, and for that alone, I think it’s worth your time.
Rating: The Heavenly Sword - 7.0/10
I got cozy with The Heavenly Sword by Alice Poon. It was so easy to sit down and read Sai’er’s adventure, it was like listening to an epic oral tale. I looked forward to opening up my book before bed each night to see where Poon would take me next. The story flowed so nicely and I couldn’t help but snuggle in and relax into Sai’er’s tale of love and justice.
Tang Sai’er has lived all her life in a small village training in martial arts alongside her adopted brother. When the time comes for the two siblings to leave their home and master new skills, Sai’er discovers she’s the reincarnation of the goddess Chang’e. Sai’er has returned to the mortal world to carry out a celestial mission: defeat the Prince of Yan before he wreaks havoc on the world. Sai’er will take on this quest, aided by the immortals and her friends, and rely on her incredible wits and skills to protect all that she holds dear.
You don’t sit with anything too long in this story. It’s like watching the landscape roll by in a car. The plot, character development, action scenes, and immortal interference occur at high speed.
This pace was difficult for me at first because I love diving deep into my fantasy worlds. However, I came to appreciate Poon’s unique storytelling cadence. It felt as if she was telling me a bedtime story, and I was often lulled into a comfortable state of mind as I read on. The other great benefit of this pace is that a lot happens in this book. The events take place over several years of Sai’er’s life, and the story never gets hung up on long training sequences or lulls between the action.
Sai’er’s journey is tumultuous and interesting, and there is a large cast of supporting characters that aid her in her celestial mission. Poon highlights Chinese folklore throughout Sai’er’s tale. We get sneak peeks into the celestial realm, the shared histories between immortals, and new dramas that are being played out in the moral world. I like how there was no pomp and circumstance surrounding the magic in the story as well. The fantastical elements appear and influence Sai’er’s journey, and it’s accepted as easily as the characters eating taro root for dinner. It helped me stay grounded in the fast plot without letting me spiral into the why’s and how’s of the world’s inner workings. It served the story well and let us keep up with Sai’er’s next move.
The only drawback of this book is that it ends abruptly. It’s like Poon decided it was my bedtime, closed the book, and stood up to turn off the lights. It was a jarring end because the story cuts off mid-conversation right before a dreaded, impending battle. It was an odd choice to end the book here. However, I’m happy Sai’er’s story will continue. It’s incredible how much happened in this one book, and I look forward to the culmination of this determined woman’s mission.
Read The Heavenly Sword for its inspiring heroine and action-packed adventure. There is a lot of entertainment provided in its short page count, and for that alone, I think it’s worth your time.
Rating: The Heavenly Sword - 7.0/10
June 17, 2024
4.0*
Book 1 of the Sword Maiden of the Moon duology. What a ride of wuxia/xianxia Fantasy story, so delightful, but let's wait to Book 2 for full review.
Fantasia wuxia/xianxia amb una dona empoderada com a protagonista, de moment, el viatge val la pena, a més per un territori conegut i estimat de la Xina, com la província de Shandong. La ressenya després de la lectura del llibre 2 d'aquesta duologia.
Book 1 of the Sword Maiden of the Moon duology. What a ride of wuxia/xianxia Fantasy story, so delightful, but let's wait to Book 2 for full review.
Fantasia wuxia/xianxia amb una dona empoderada com a protagonista, de moment, el viatge val la pena, a més per un territori conegut i estimat de la Xina, com la província de Shandong. La ressenya després de la lectura del llibre 2 d'aquesta duologia.
September 27, 2024
“It’s ill-fate that there’s a history of bad blood between the Imperial family and then Shandong people.”
Foreshadowing, anyone… ? 👀
This series was such a fun read! Poon does a great job of creating a world that incorporates so many interesting aspects for the reader to hook into.
I found this story to be extremely character-driven, which is a good thing because the way the author revolves the world around the characters is phenomenal. I enjoyed how the characters interacted with different aspects of Chinese lore and history while also dealing with all their own shit. They build and develop complex relationships (both good and bad) all while mastering kung fu, protecting their loved ones, and playing key roles in an ancient battle of immortals.
This series has intriguing storylines, engaging fights, mythical beasts, gods, and tons of history and depth. For those into wuxia/xianxia novels (my understanding is that this series is a combination of both writing styles - with Poon’s own twist on it) I definitely recommend picking it up.
Foreshadowing, anyone… ? 👀
This series was such a fun read! Poon does a great job of creating a world that incorporates so many interesting aspects for the reader to hook into.
I found this story to be extremely character-driven, which is a good thing because the way the author revolves the world around the characters is phenomenal. I enjoyed how the characters interacted with different aspects of Chinese lore and history while also dealing with all their own shit. They build and develop complex relationships (both good and bad) all while mastering kung fu, protecting their loved ones, and playing key roles in an ancient battle of immortals.
This series has intriguing storylines, engaging fights, mythical beasts, gods, and tons of history and depth. For those into wuxia/xianxia novels (my understanding is that this series is a combination of both writing styles - with Poon’s own twist on it) I definitely recommend picking it up.
January 24, 2023
"It is not wise to trust people too easily. Let time and observation be your guide."
Born in a backwater village in Shandong Province, Tang Sai'er lived with her Ba and adopted brother, Binhong. She often experienced a strong pull from the moon. In her previous life, she had been Chang'e of the Moon Palace. The Queen Mother of the West (who governs all female Deities) sent her to the Mortal World, as Tang Sai'er, to complete a daunting mission.
Zhu Di, the cruel Prince of Yan had usurped the Emperor's throne from the Crown Prince, the duly chosen Emperor. Zhu Di and his cohorts were purging, pilfering, taxing and conscripting many innocent and impoverished commoners. His ruthless, Embroidered Uniform Guards along with the marauding armies carried out his vindictive agenda. Could Chang'e, in the form of Sai'er, change the outcome by tempering Zhu Di's behavior and convince him to stop his tyrannical hold over his subjects? Sai'er, assisted by mortals and immortals alike, would fight Zhu Di and his army using Kung Fu, weaponry, deception and celestial magic.
Sai'er and elder brother, Binhong were initially schooled by their Ba in neigong (breathing and meditation) and once proficient, progressed to controlling their qi flow (fundamental force or energy). They then traveled to the Wudang Mountains and were apprenticed to Master Zhang Sanfeng. Sanbao, manservant in the Palace of Beiping, trained along with them. Lessons from Master included "retract...qi in order to lessen the impact and give the false impression of retreat when in fact qi was reserved for new attack moves...the trick is to be a needle wrapped in cotton-using qi as a disguise power."
How could such a harrowing assignment to alter the trajectory of a civil war be accomplished by teenager Sai'er? Guided by immortal beings such as Lan Caihe, of The Eight Immortals, a parakeet-sized sprite, half-immortal Master Zhang, and the White Lotus Society, the goal was to train villagers to defend themselves against abusive officials and marauding bandits.
Sai'er must put any feelings of love and passion aside. Spiritual love, where two hearts beat as one, is all she can experience since the highest Wudang technique, North Star Qi-Extracting, required chastity. A lesson to be learned: "Nothing is free in life. To gain something you must give up something."
"The Heavenly Sword (Sword Maiden from the Moon, Book 1)" by Alice Poon is a wuxia-myth fantasy novel enticing the reader to enter the world of civil war and rebellion in the early Ming Dynasty. The novel was inspired by a little known woman rebel, called Tang Sai'er, during the Yongle Emperor reign.
Peaches, symbolizing immortality, are served at the Feast of the Queen Mother of the West. According to folklore, peach trees would bear fruit every 3,000 years. Immortal Chang'e had been gifted 2 Magic Peaches. She must use them wisely! Two treasures, celestial in nature, were unearthed from a cave and would be needed to thwart Zhu Di's (the Prince of Yan ) plans. Hexes and Shamanistic magic might roadblock or delay the implementation of Sai'er's strategy.
Alice Poon had created a fantasy world this reader was reluctant to leave. The primary and secondary characters were fully detailed, some through back stories. Amazing, dogged determination mixed with the uncertainly and mixed emotions of love, made Sai'er come to life! The evil inflicted by the Prince of Yan's so called righteous war included the uncalled for, inhumane
treatment of his enemies.
Alice Poon's spectacular novel had me cheering for Sai'er and the members of the White Lotus Society. The demise of several key characters brought tears to my eyes. Poon, very adept at ending Book 1 of the novel at a momentuous juncture, has me craving for Book 2 of "The Heavenly Sword" duology! Highly recommended.
Thank you Alice Poon for the digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
Born in a backwater village in Shandong Province, Tang Sai'er lived with her Ba and adopted brother, Binhong. She often experienced a strong pull from the moon. In her previous life, she had been Chang'e of the Moon Palace. The Queen Mother of the West (who governs all female Deities) sent her to the Mortal World, as Tang Sai'er, to complete a daunting mission.
Zhu Di, the cruel Prince of Yan had usurped the Emperor's throne from the Crown Prince, the duly chosen Emperor. Zhu Di and his cohorts were purging, pilfering, taxing and conscripting many innocent and impoverished commoners. His ruthless, Embroidered Uniform Guards along with the marauding armies carried out his vindictive agenda. Could Chang'e, in the form of Sai'er, change the outcome by tempering Zhu Di's behavior and convince him to stop his tyrannical hold over his subjects? Sai'er, assisted by mortals and immortals alike, would fight Zhu Di and his army using Kung Fu, weaponry, deception and celestial magic.
Sai'er and elder brother, Binhong were initially schooled by their Ba in neigong (breathing and meditation) and once proficient, progressed to controlling their qi flow (fundamental force or energy). They then traveled to the Wudang Mountains and were apprenticed to Master Zhang Sanfeng. Sanbao, manservant in the Palace of Beiping, trained along with them. Lessons from Master included "retract...qi in order to lessen the impact and give the false impression of retreat when in fact qi was reserved for new attack moves...the trick is to be a needle wrapped in cotton-using qi as a disguise power."
How could such a harrowing assignment to alter the trajectory of a civil war be accomplished by teenager Sai'er? Guided by immortal beings such as Lan Caihe, of The Eight Immortals, a parakeet-sized sprite, half-immortal Master Zhang, and the White Lotus Society, the goal was to train villagers to defend themselves against abusive officials and marauding bandits.
Sai'er must put any feelings of love and passion aside. Spiritual love, where two hearts beat as one, is all she can experience since the highest Wudang technique, North Star Qi-Extracting, required chastity. A lesson to be learned: "Nothing is free in life. To gain something you must give up something."
"The Heavenly Sword (Sword Maiden from the Moon, Book 1)" by Alice Poon is a wuxia-myth fantasy novel enticing the reader to enter the world of civil war and rebellion in the early Ming Dynasty. The novel was inspired by a little known woman rebel, called Tang Sai'er, during the Yongle Emperor reign.
Peaches, symbolizing immortality, are served at the Feast of the Queen Mother of the West. According to folklore, peach trees would bear fruit every 3,000 years. Immortal Chang'e had been gifted 2 Magic Peaches. She must use them wisely! Two treasures, celestial in nature, were unearthed from a cave and would be needed to thwart Zhu Di's (the Prince of Yan ) plans. Hexes and Shamanistic magic might roadblock or delay the implementation of Sai'er's strategy.
Alice Poon had created a fantasy world this reader was reluctant to leave. The primary and secondary characters were fully detailed, some through back stories. Amazing, dogged determination mixed with the uncertainly and mixed emotions of love, made Sai'er come to life! The evil inflicted by the Prince of Yan's so called righteous war included the uncalled for, inhumane
treatment of his enemies.
Alice Poon's spectacular novel had me cheering for Sai'er and the members of the White Lotus Society. The demise of several key characters brought tears to my eyes. Poon, very adept at ending Book 1 of the novel at a momentuous juncture, has me craving for Book 2 of "The Heavenly Sword" duology! Highly recommended.
Thank you Alice Poon for the digital ARC in exchange for an honest review.
November 22, 2022
Score: 4,5 out of 5 stars
Full text review: https://jamreads.com/reviews/the-heav...
Interview with Alice Poon: https://jamreads.com/interviews/some-...
The Heavenly Sword is the first book in the Sword Maiden from the Moon wuxia duology, from the Canadian author Alice Poon. It follows the story of Tang Sai'er, a martial maiden who is the reincarnation of Chang'e, in her quest to dethrone the Sky Wolf Zhu Di, the cruel prince that has dethroned the emperor, trying to protect her village and her beloved ones from the violence and the consequences of the civil war that has arisen due to the ambition of Zhu Di.
Our novel starts with Tang Sai'er in her village, fighting with her foster brother, Binghong; as an excuse to show that she's a learning student trying to get control over her qi. Soon, she's sent by her father to take lessons from Master Zhang Sanfeng in the Wudang Mountains; marking the start of what I would call the first arc of the novel, a learning one, focused on the progress of Sai'er as a martial artist, improving her techniques, being a more relaxed one, and where she will discover her actual nature as Chang'e reincarnated.
In comparison with Occidental novel tradition, we get many exposition parts, where we are introduced to the Chinese traditions and myths, in a more relaxed style. The novel is divided into three different arcs, being the first one about the formation and the real nature of Sai'er; the second one is more about the civil war and the desire of protecting her beloved ones; with the third one involving more the mythical figures and finally, being able to know Zhu Di directly.
Sai'er is a really compelling character, an excellent martial artist who is compelled to fulfill a task that she hasn't chosen due to her celestial nature; sometimes the dimension of this task overwhelms her, as she's only a simple village girl in her human nature. The rest of the secondary characters around her are also relatable, mostly supporting to keep the story flowing, and sometimes the reason why Sai'er takes different decisions. Zhu Di is portrayed as a really cruel person, and to be fair, once we get to know him, it's even worse that it was portrayed, becoming the big Evil (yes, with caps) to defeat, justifying the sacrifices that our character will have to make.
Alice Poon weaves in a great way historical fiction with traditional myths, portraying a civil war whose stakes are bigger than the country's leadership, but also implying a war between different powers in the pantheons, powers that will fight in order to stop the Sky Wolf from taking the power. The novel is also a tribute to martial traditions, featuring several great scenes of fighting and the use of different techniques, especially great the ones that feature Sai'er after the first arc of training.
I enjoyed my time with Sai'er in The Heavenly Sword. Despite I'm not familiar with the wuxia tradition, that hasn't been a problem to find myself always craving for a chapter more; I can recommend this novel to people who enjoy epic fantasy, and that want to read a different kind of story. I really want to see what will happen in the second book of this duology.
Full text review: https://jamreads.com/reviews/the-heav...
Interview with Alice Poon: https://jamreads.com/interviews/some-...
The Heavenly Sword is the first book in the Sword Maiden from the Moon wuxia duology, from the Canadian author Alice Poon. It follows the story of Tang Sai'er, a martial maiden who is the reincarnation of Chang'e, in her quest to dethrone the Sky Wolf Zhu Di, the cruel prince that has dethroned the emperor, trying to protect her village and her beloved ones from the violence and the consequences of the civil war that has arisen due to the ambition of Zhu Di.
Our novel starts with Tang Sai'er in her village, fighting with her foster brother, Binghong; as an excuse to show that she's a learning student trying to get control over her qi. Soon, she's sent by her father to take lessons from Master Zhang Sanfeng in the Wudang Mountains; marking the start of what I would call the first arc of the novel, a learning one, focused on the progress of Sai'er as a martial artist, improving her techniques, being a more relaxed one, and where she will discover her actual nature as Chang'e reincarnated.
In comparison with Occidental novel tradition, we get many exposition parts, where we are introduced to the Chinese traditions and myths, in a more relaxed style. The novel is divided into three different arcs, being the first one about the formation and the real nature of Sai'er; the second one is more about the civil war and the desire of protecting her beloved ones; with the third one involving more the mythical figures and finally, being able to know Zhu Di directly.
Sai'er is a really compelling character, an excellent martial artist who is compelled to fulfill a task that she hasn't chosen due to her celestial nature; sometimes the dimension of this task overwhelms her, as she's only a simple village girl in her human nature. The rest of the secondary characters around her are also relatable, mostly supporting to keep the story flowing, and sometimes the reason why Sai'er takes different decisions. Zhu Di is portrayed as a really cruel person, and to be fair, once we get to know him, it's even worse that it was portrayed, becoming the big Evil (yes, with caps) to defeat, justifying the sacrifices that our character will have to make.
Alice Poon weaves in a great way historical fiction with traditional myths, portraying a civil war whose stakes are bigger than the country's leadership, but also implying a war between different powers in the pantheons, powers that will fight in order to stop the Sky Wolf from taking the power. The novel is also a tribute to martial traditions, featuring several great scenes of fighting and the use of different techniques, especially great the ones that feature Sai'er after the first arc of training.
I enjoyed my time with Sai'er in The Heavenly Sword. Despite I'm not familiar with the wuxia tradition, that hasn't been a problem to find myself always craving for a chapter more; I can recommend this novel to people who enjoy epic fantasy, and that want to read a different kind of story. I really want to see what will happen in the second book of this duology.
Read
September 24, 2023Full Review: http://10x347.home.blog/2022/11/06/th...
In Alice Poon’s adult debut, a young woman is assigned the momentous task of preventing an oppressor from usurping the throne but relationships from her past make her hesitate.
A brilliant tribute to Jing Yong — dangerous and exciting, The Heavenly Sword, is the beginning of a kick ass duology.
I received an e-ARC from the author in exchange for an honest review.
In Alice Poon’s adult debut, a young woman is assigned the momentous task of preventing an oppressor from usurping the throne but relationships from her past make her hesitate.
A brilliant tribute to Jing Yong — dangerous and exciting, The Heavenly Sword, is the beginning of a kick ass duology.
I received an e-ARC from the author in exchange for an honest review.
April 2, 2025
I have been looking for books like Jin Yong's Condor Legends Saga and I really enjoyed reading the Heavenly Sword. A must read if you enjoy wuxia :)
January 29, 2023
The Heavenly Sword is an epic, action-packed work of Chinese martial arts historical fantasy, a genre of books and especially movies known as wuxia or xianxia. In a world where the gods are regularly reincarnated in human form, the moon goddess Chang'e is living in the province of Shandong as a humble village girl and martial arts maiden called Tang Sai'er. Upon discovering that she was sent to earth on a mission—to stand against the evil usurper Emperor Zhu Di, who himself is the god Sky Wolf reincarnated for crimes in the celestial realm, and with whom she had a history as Chang'e—Sai'er take action. First she trains with kung fu masters to become even more exceptional than she already is, learning the a rare and valuable North Star technique. Then she team up her teachers, her family, the army, her celestial allies, and a special sect of rebels she helps create to overcome the Emperor's reign of terror and his own deadly immortal allies—all while her confused and conflicted romantic feelings for a key member of the Emperor's court, with whom she has history as Sai'er, stands in direct opposition to her goals.
It was really interesting learning about Chinese mythology through this book—the various gods and goddesses and their interactions with humans, monsters, and folktales—as well as some of the history and way of life in ancient China. The martial arts study and battles were really interesting. Sai'er and her companions practice both neigong, which involves harnessing and utilizing one's qi as an attacking or defending force, and also ginggong, which is when the fighter is able to use their qi walk on air or water like in movies such as Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.
The whole story is like a movie in your head. The fight scenes are so visual and both the scenery of various mountains, rivers, villages, and even the celestial realm are lovingly described. Sai'er is an enjoyable character, granted the rare privilege for a girl to become a kung fu expert on account of her heavenly mission, but whose duty to her family and the people of Shandong come into conflict with the needs and desires of her heart. I did find the writing a bit uneven in the book. Often it was lovely and atmospheric, but at times it sounded too modern for the time period, and at other times a bit over-complicated. But the story is engaging and ends on a dramatic cliffhanger that will be resolved in the concluding instalment of this exciting duology.
It was really interesting learning about Chinese mythology through this book—the various gods and goddesses and their interactions with humans, monsters, and folktales—as well as some of the history and way of life in ancient China. The martial arts study and battles were really interesting. Sai'er and her companions practice both neigong, which involves harnessing and utilizing one's qi as an attacking or defending force, and also ginggong, which is when the fighter is able to use their qi walk on air or water like in movies such as Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon.
The whole story is like a movie in your head. The fight scenes are so visual and both the scenery of various mountains, rivers, villages, and even the celestial realm are lovingly described. Sai'er is an enjoyable character, granted the rare privilege for a girl to become a kung fu expert on account of her heavenly mission, but whose duty to her family and the people of Shandong come into conflict with the needs and desires of her heart. I did find the writing a bit uneven in the book. Often it was lovely and atmospheric, but at times it sounded too modern for the time period, and at other times a bit over-complicated. But the story is engaging and ends on a dramatic cliffhanger that will be resolved in the concluding instalment of this exciting duology.
July 11, 2024
I received an ARC from the publisher in exchange for an honest review
The Heavenly Sword by Alice Poon is a multi-POV historical Chinese fantasy blending elements from the xianxia and wuxia genres. Sai’er is young woman from Putai in the Shangdong Province and the reincarnation of the goddess of the moon, Chang’e. When she meets Sanbao, a war orphan serving the future emperor, she starts on the path to fighting for love despite the obstacles between them and the safety of her people.
What I really liked was the use of Chinese mythology. It's always nice to see Chang’e and the Jade Rabbit appear and this version of a Chang’e incarnate who also was raised as a warrior was a new spot for me. I wasn't super familiar with the Sky Wolves or the Yellow and Green Dragons but I thought the terminology was fairly accessible and got easier to piece together the more I read.
There is a glossary and a cast of characters provided, which is very helpful. The novel does have a large cast as many xianxia I've seen do and it can take time for individual relationships and connections to solidify if you're reading in chunks like I did. The writing feels quite grounded in the time period and the terminology used really assist in that, such as using the Hour of the Ox instead of the times we would use today in many places.
The martial arts and familial connections take more of a center stage than the romance as the impending struggle with Prince Zhu Di, who covets Sai’er for himself, builds up. When they were Chang’e and the Sky Wolf, he declared his love for her, creating a bit of a love triangle between Sai’er, Zhudi, and Sanbao that none of them really want. While I normally prefer romance and am a big fan of Romantasy, I do think it was the right call to let the martial aspects intertwine more with Sai’er’s family as it added a lot of depth to why Sai’er needs to be the one to fight.
Content warning for depictions of sexual assault, brief depictions of castration, and mentions of child abuse
I would recommend this to fans of the wuxia and xianxia genres, readers who prefer less romance in their historical fantasy, and those looking for a historical fantasy with a large cast
The Heavenly Sword by Alice Poon is a multi-POV historical Chinese fantasy blending elements from the xianxia and wuxia genres. Sai’er is young woman from Putai in the Shangdong Province and the reincarnation of the goddess of the moon, Chang’e. When she meets Sanbao, a war orphan serving the future emperor, she starts on the path to fighting for love despite the obstacles between them and the safety of her people.
What I really liked was the use of Chinese mythology. It's always nice to see Chang’e and the Jade Rabbit appear and this version of a Chang’e incarnate who also was raised as a warrior was a new spot for me. I wasn't super familiar with the Sky Wolves or the Yellow and Green Dragons but I thought the terminology was fairly accessible and got easier to piece together the more I read.
There is a glossary and a cast of characters provided, which is very helpful. The novel does have a large cast as many xianxia I've seen do and it can take time for individual relationships and connections to solidify if you're reading in chunks like I did. The writing feels quite grounded in the time period and the terminology used really assist in that, such as using the Hour of the Ox instead of the times we would use today in many places.
The martial arts and familial connections take more of a center stage than the romance as the impending struggle with Prince Zhu Di, who covets Sai’er for himself, builds up. When they were Chang’e and the Sky Wolf, he declared his love for her, creating a bit of a love triangle between Sai’er, Zhudi, and Sanbao that none of them really want. While I normally prefer romance and am a big fan of Romantasy, I do think it was the right call to let the martial aspects intertwine more with Sai’er’s family as it added a lot of depth to why Sai’er needs to be the one to fight.
Content warning for depictions of sexual assault, brief depictions of castration, and mentions of child abuse
I would recommend this to fans of the wuxia and xianxia genres, readers who prefer less romance in their historical fantasy, and those looking for a historical fantasy with a large cast
April 11, 2024
I'm conflicted with this one.
I loved that this is a female led wuxia/xianxia genre-bending story. Sai'er is an amazing lead who, while naive at times, is an absolute baddie. She learns to fight, excels in it, trains hard, is immortal spirit Chang'e in mortal form, and becomes the leader of a strong, tight knit rebellion. Everything about her checks lists for me and her story is so interesting. Based off a real rebellion leader, I found her character amazing, as a whole.
The world-building was also a huge win for me. Poon's writing is immersive and I could see the world come alive in my mind as I read, especially the fight scenes. The training sequences and fight scenes really set the stage for future battles, and I enjoyed joining Sai'er, Binhong and Yinho on that journey.
Where this book lost me at times was the virgin magic (an absolute no for me) and Sai'er's inexplicable attraction to a known tyrant and rapist (also, ick). Due to the virgin magic, there are attempts to make her not one (ahem), and I did not enjoy those sequences. With regards to the evil Sky Wolf, the main adversary and the man Sai'er is drawn to, she's transported fairly early on in the story to an old memory from her life as Chang'e. In that vision, Sky Wolf sexually assaults her, and she's walks away from that vision still drawn to him and trying to better understand his psyche. I wish her disillusionment happened earlier, as that was a big nope for me.
This book had strong writing and fantastic world building, but some of the cons really conflicted with the pros. I'm curious to read book 2, as the end of this book cuts right at the 50% mark of the plot, but this one was a miss for me.
TW: violence, injury detail, sexual assault, suicide attempt, vomit, rape, torture, war, death, kidnapping, death of an animal (not dog, hunting); mentions cannibalism
eARC gifted by Alice Poon, the author, in exchange for an honest review.
I loved that this is a female led wuxia/xianxia genre-bending story. Sai'er is an amazing lead who, while naive at times, is an absolute baddie. She learns to fight, excels in it, trains hard, is immortal spirit Chang'e in mortal form, and becomes the leader of a strong, tight knit rebellion. Everything about her checks lists for me and her story is so interesting. Based off a real rebellion leader, I found her character amazing, as a whole.
The world-building was also a huge win for me. Poon's writing is immersive and I could see the world come alive in my mind as I read, especially the fight scenes. The training sequences and fight scenes really set the stage for future battles, and I enjoyed joining Sai'er, Binhong and Yinho on that journey.
Where this book lost me at times was the virgin magic (an absolute no for me) and Sai'er's inexplicable attraction to a known tyrant and rapist (also, ick). Due to the virgin magic, there are attempts to make her not one (ahem), and I did not enjoy those sequences. With regards to the evil Sky Wolf, the main adversary and the man Sai'er is drawn to, she's transported fairly early on in the story to an old memory from her life as Chang'e. In that vision, Sky Wolf sexually assaults her, and she's walks away from that vision still drawn to him and trying to better understand his psyche. I wish her disillusionment happened earlier, as that was a big nope for me.
This book had strong writing and fantastic world building, but some of the cons really conflicted with the pros. I'm curious to read book 2, as the end of this book cuts right at the 50% mark of the plot, but this one was a miss for me.
TW: violence, injury detail, sexual assault, suicide attempt, vomit, rape, torture, war, death, kidnapping, death of an animal (not dog, hunting); mentions cannibalism
eARC gifted by Alice Poon, the author, in exchange for an honest review.
August 30, 2024
Rating: 2.75-3 /5 ⭐
Review:
✨This review is tough to write because I really need to articulate my thoughts.
✨Truthfully, I nearly DNF this story several times but I persevered until the end.
✨By the way, this is an adult fantasy novel but the cover for me, seems like a YA novel. But I guess the main story started during Sai’er’s teen years so the cover does suit the story a little bit.
✨From what I see, this story told a lot of worldbuilding details such as about people, the rulers, the history, and the martial art skills. So, it could be quite heavy to get into the story sometimes.
✨Personally, I do not agree with the main martial art skills in this story which is better performed by a virgin but because it is related to yin and yang, I just go on with the story.
✨But it really irritates me when the enemies want to take her virginity in order to diminish her special skills. I know it is understandable for conflict but it still makes me annoyed.
✨However, the one who annoyed me the most is Tang Sai’er. I’m sorry.
✨For me she is a kind-hearted person, but she’s not really the brightest in my opinion. Luckily, she has good friends, family and allies with her.
✨For me, if you are an avid watcher of wuxia and xianxia C-dramas or movies, it is easier to get into the story because of the familiarity with the story’s environment.
✨I actually want to know what happened in the next book because the plot is interesting to me.
✨Thank you to Earnshaw Books Ltd. and NetGalley for this ARC! This review was voluntarily written by me.
Review:
✨This review is tough to write because I really need to articulate my thoughts.
✨Truthfully, I nearly DNF this story several times but I persevered until the end.
✨By the way, this is an adult fantasy novel but the cover for me, seems like a YA novel. But I guess the main story started during Sai’er’s teen years so the cover does suit the story a little bit.
✨From what I see, this story told a lot of worldbuilding details such as about people, the rulers, the history, and the martial art skills. So, it could be quite heavy to get into the story sometimes.
✨Personally, I do not agree with the main martial art skills in this story which is better performed by a virgin but because it is related to yin and yang, I just go on with the story.
✨But it really irritates me when the enemies want to take her virginity in order to diminish her special skills. I know it is understandable for conflict but it still makes me annoyed.
✨However, the one who annoyed me the most is Tang Sai’er. I’m sorry.
✨For me she is a kind-hearted person, but she’s not really the brightest in my opinion. Luckily, she has good friends, family and allies with her.
✨For me, if you are an avid watcher of wuxia and xianxia C-dramas or movies, it is easier to get into the story because of the familiarity with the story’s environment.
✨I actually want to know what happened in the next book because the plot is interesting to me.
✨Thank you to Earnshaw Books Ltd. and NetGalley for this ARC! This review was voluntarily written by me.
March 20, 2023
Full review is on My Blog
I'm also on Twitter and Instagram
Alice Poon delivers the first of a duology epic fantasy based in Chinese mythology and kung fu. In this first novel, Sai'er is a simple village girl training in the ancient arts of kung fu. Thanks to a helpful sprite, she learns she is the reincarnation of the goddess Chang’e. She must go on a quest to stop the wicked Sky Wolf, who is reincarnated as the Ming Dynasty Emperor Zhu Di. Aided by her foster brother Binhong and several other friends, both mortal and supernatural, Sai’er embarks on an adventure rivaling any in the fantasy genre.
I don’t think this necessarily has to be an adult novel, either. Yes, there’s some sex and gore, but I don’t think it was gratuitous or anything inappropriate for a teen to read. Maybe that’s just my Gen X showing. My parents had no clue what I was reading - or where I was, really - most of the time. So maybe take it with a grain of salt, but this read-all-of-Stephen-King’s-and-V.C.-Andrews'-then-published-works-by-the-time-I-was-12 GenXer thinks it’s totally fine for teen readers as well.
I'm also on Twitter and Instagram
Alice Poon delivers the first of a duology epic fantasy based in Chinese mythology and kung fu. In this first novel, Sai'er is a simple village girl training in the ancient arts of kung fu. Thanks to a helpful sprite, she learns she is the reincarnation of the goddess Chang’e. She must go on a quest to stop the wicked Sky Wolf, who is reincarnated as the Ming Dynasty Emperor Zhu Di. Aided by her foster brother Binhong and several other friends, both mortal and supernatural, Sai’er embarks on an adventure rivaling any in the fantasy genre.
I don’t think this necessarily has to be an adult novel, either. Yes, there’s some sex and gore, but I don’t think it was gratuitous or anything inappropriate for a teen to read. Maybe that’s just my Gen X showing. My parents had no clue what I was reading - or where I was, really - most of the time. So maybe take it with a grain of salt, but this read-all-of-Stephen-King’s-and-V.C.-Andrews'-then-published-works-by-the-time-I-was-12 GenXer thinks it’s totally fine for teen readers as well.
January 29, 2025
The Heavenly Sword is the first part of a spellbinding duology weaving Chinese mythical folklore and speculative history, set in the world of human conflicts, fantastical martial arts, sorcery and celestial magic.
The goddess Chang’e is sent to the mortal world to stop the Sky Wolf Zhu Di’s plans to usurp the throne. Reborn as Tang Sai’er, a simple village girl, her celestial mission requires her to learn special martial arts skills, but in order to achieve unrivaled mastery, she must battle against her growing feelings for a member of the evil tyrant’s court. - You have to admit it sounds good.
Unfortunately this book was not my favourite.
The writing felt flat, the dialogue too modern at times, too robotic in few instences. Like I said not for me.
The romance....well, it could be better (I don't have energy to get into it).
The stranges thing for me was that Sai'er's magic is tied to her virginity (I don't have idia how to feel about it) and (just so you know tw.) that results in multiple SA attempts.
And so you know - this is and adult fantasy novel!
The goddess Chang’e is sent to the mortal world to stop the Sky Wolf Zhu Di’s plans to usurp the throne. Reborn as Tang Sai’er, a simple village girl, her celestial mission requires her to learn special martial arts skills, but in order to achieve unrivaled mastery, she must battle against her growing feelings for a member of the evil tyrant’s court. - You have to admit it sounds good.
Unfortunately this book was not my favourite.
The writing felt flat, the dialogue too modern at times, too robotic in few instences. Like I said not for me.
The romance....well, it could be better (I don't have energy to get into it).
The stranges thing for me was that Sai'er's magic is tied to her virginity (I don't have idia how to feel about it) and (just so you know tw.) that results in multiple SA attempts.
And so you know - this is and adult fantasy novel!
Displaying 1 - 29 of 50 reviews