To say I was disappointed in this book and the new-to-me author after how much I enjoyed the first book in the series (by K.L. Hiers) is a massive understatement. This was maaaaybbeeee a 2.5 star at best, so I'm rounding up because, after all, I didn't DNF it, but just... no. The worst part is that it truly could have been an engaging story. It had a lot of great elements, but the author didn't pull them together. Some of my biggest almost-DNF moments (here come the spoilers): NONE of the issues with Caleb's father, or even his relationship with his brother, were even remotely touched on (in the first case) or at all fleshed out (in the second) so that the climactic moments those two played in the plot were totally out of left field and had more of a reverse-Deus Ex Machina feel than any actual emotional engagement. And also, speaking of just springing shit into the plot without developing it AT ALL: at 88% into the story, Caleb suddenly remembers his time as a ghost... and it's completely summarized for the readers in just a few short paragraphs of tell-not-show, with absolutely no emotional component? I'm sorry, that's just... unskilled craft of writing. And finally, Darcy's troubled past is hinted at, but then it goes nowhere. It's not fleshed out enough to give him emotional depth, but nor is it resolved in any way to make the VERY brief hints of it worth having in there. UGH. Just... maybe my hopes were too high, even though I completely understand how these multi-author series work. Each book is its own thing, but damn. The first one was so good (and I'm definitely looking forward to some of the upcoming ones. Particularly 😍 Amanda Meuwissen's!!! 😍)
Sigh. But what I will say is that if I hadn't been hoping for a lot, this would have just been a case of "meh, three stars, I might check this author out again once she has a little more experience under her belt"... so maybe I'll do that. (And kudos to ALL authors who take the time and put in the energy to take an imaginative idea and bring it to life for us.)