The What Do We Know About? series explores the mysterious, the unknown, and the unexplained. Will we ever learn the truth about what actually landed at Roswell?
From the #1 New York Times Best-Selling Who Was? series comes Where Is?, a series that tells the stories of world-famous landmarks and natural wonders and features a fold-out map!
In 1947, an unusual object crashed in the New Mexico desert and was recovered by the Roswell Army Airfield officers. People everywhere began to speculate what the object could be. Could it possibly be a flying saucer? Would that be proof of aliens and life beyond Earth? Even decades later, some people still believe that the Roswell Incident is the most famous UFO sighting ever. Still, those who worked at the airfield insist it was just a weather balloon that had fallen from the sky. Was the Roswell Incident evidence of alien life, a government cover-up, or just a myth? Here are the facts about what we do know about Roswell.
Ben Hubbard is an accomplished non-fiction author of books for children and adults. He has more than 160 titles to his name and has written on everything from Space, the Samurai and Sharks, to Poison, Pets and the Plantagenets. His books have been translated into more than a dozen languages and can be found in bookshops, libraries and schools around the world.
What Do WE Know About The Roswell Incident? Author: Ben Hubbard Publisher: Penguin Workshop Publishing Date: 2023 Pgs: 107 ======================= REVIEW MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS Genre: Children’s Literature Aeronautics Space Aliens Mystery
Why this book: While searching for other books, I went down the rabbit hole of UFO and aliens books at my local branch library and…well, here we are. _________________ The Feel: Informative.
Favorite Concept: “It’s all fake. It’s all fake.” But then, you have people, believable people, telling the story, not the UFO or alien or flying saucer story, of how they were told to shut up and not say anything ever, either because it would be unpatriotic or because “something bad will happen to them.” Seems like a lotta work for a weather balloon in the New Mexico desert.
Tropes: The photographer being brought in to take the photos, then having his camera and film taken from him, and finding himself on a transfer to Antarctica immediately afterwards is classic. That is exactly the type of thing that the Army/Army Air Corps were notorious for in that era. Friend’s brother went through a similar no notice transfer, his to an Alaskan outpost, though this was because he danced with an officer’s wife, not aliens.
Uhm Moments: The nurse, Naomi Self, isn’t real. But a refuation of what she saw is mentioned in the Air Force’s Case Closed file that was supposed to be their final word on the subject. :/
The Sigh: The nurse story was debunked.
Labeling Bob Lazar a security guard is erroneous too. He was decidedly more than that.
Suspension of Disbelief: Much is expected of something that tries to explain conspiracy theories. This leaves its facts in a bad light with limited research and bad reporting.
Confirmation Bias: This plays hard to my confirmation bias.
As always though, I learn new things-- like I didn't realize that MIB, the movie was based on previously written about version of "men in black" who supposedly enlisted to wipe people's memories of events.
It's a curious bit of history for sure and it does a great job of encapsulating the important points to provide balance of truth and folklore around it, but that there is still room for curiosity and questions.
A rather superficial and greatly over-simplified account of the Roswell Incident, that doesn't do a very good job of separating fact from fiction early enough to keep young readers from being confused by the hoaxes that are later debunked. I think this was just too complex of a subject for this series that is geared for younger middle-grade readers to tackle. My concern is with how the book begins by telling various stories that have been told about the Roswell Incident over the years, as though they are true, and only at the end does it debunk some of it. This could lead a reader to mistakenly believe some of the hoaxes, especially if they do not finish the book. I would strongly recommend an adult discuss the material with the child.
"...the residents of Roswell—and the world—wanted to know more."
This book is not just about what happened in Roswell, and what witnesses said they saw, but also about how the story went from being a small town current event to a global story to capturing the interest, and imagination, of multiple generations.
No aliens. We are the only planet with life in the universe. There is God, angels, the souls of the saved and lost, Satan, and demons. That’s it. Cathy R.