2/5
I was very excited about this book, I’m always looking for more sci-fi with queer protagonists, but sadly this novel didn’t work for me.
The initial idea was interesting and I liked the characters, but apart from that, I don’t really have anything very positive to say. The pacing was very awkward, dragging through scenes that were unnecessary and completely forgettable. It took so long to get to the exciting moments that once they were happening, I didn’t care anymore. This book was way too long for how little plot there was.
The romance didn’t satisfy me either, as it happened so fast and for no reason, giving us weird interactions and dialogues. The stakes were so high for the characters, they found themselves facing great danger, and all the narrator did during those scenes was comment on how cute his boyfriend is.
Add to that the fact that I couldn’t possibly suspend my disbelief enough to appreciate this book. Sci-fi-y stuff happens without any explanation, and doesn’t really get resolved. It’s just a bunch of events happening one after the other and not making any sense. The writing wasn’t my cup of tea either, I thought it wasn’t really flowing and it was sometimes hard to see who was talking, especially in the first half.
Last, I gotta say I really don’t enjoy the closeted homophobe trope, and the way these characters are used in 90% of the cases I’ve come across, including in this book. I don’t like reading about a shitty character who’s presented as a villain from the start, and have them suddenly come out and be forgiven. I feel like I’ve read this story a hundred times before and it’s time now to write something different. It feels kind of outdated to me.
I’m honestly gutted about this, I wanted to enjoy this novel because it looked like a lot of fun and was very promising. I can only hope that it’ll find its audience. It wasn’t for me, but might be enjoyed by young teenagers or readers who aren’t bothered by illogical plot progressions. It’s always nice to see more queer protagonists represented in YA science fiction though!!
Thank you so much to NetGalley and Disney Publishing Worldwide for this eARC!