In July of 1900, Emma and Derrick make their Society debut as an engaged couple at a party at Beacon Rock, home of Edward Morgan, cousin of James Pierpont Morgan. As Derrick is a member of the New York Yacht Club, he was invited to discuss strategy for the upcoming America's Cup race. Unfortunately, ladies are not invited in on the discussion, not even the wealthy widow, Lucy Carnegie, the only female member. Emma is not much of a sailor anyway but neither is she stimulated by the desultory conversation about fashion and social life. She wanders out on the terrace to escape, followed by Lucy Carnegie. Emma notices a strange sound slapping against the dock and when she investigates, she discovers the body of a young woman! Lucy is quick to jump in and rescue the girl, but she's beyond help. Emma searches for the girl's identity and comes up with a risque photo taken back in New York. Who was the "Wally" the photo was signed to? The search yields no concrete answers but Emma does learn the young woman was the 18-year-old daughter of yacht engineer Eben Fahey. The police, under pressure from the 400 Club, dismiss the death as sucicide over a broken relationship. After all, women are so emotional and easily overcome by the smallest things. ("Barf!" and Emma agrees) Emma is certain that was not the case for young Lillian dressed very sensibly and was known to assist her father with his work. Emma is determined to find out who killed this girl and see justice done, even if it further alienates her from the 4o0 Club, her future social circle.
This story is set at a more obscure mansion. It's been in private hands since it was built and luckily for Alyssa Maxwell, it was sold recently so there are photos easily available. There are also Gilded Age photographs to showcase the interior as it was at the time. All that research shows through the story just as much as the famous museum mansions. I liked visiting a home I will never see in real life unless the new owners open it up to visitors. The plot has plenty of twists and turns. It kept me guessing even though there were a limited number of fictional characters. I had an idea of who and why based on the photograph. Then I thought the story went in a different direction and then back to my original guess.
Lillian's death was a real tragedy. She was a young woman in the prime of her life just as a new century is about to begin. It sure sounds like she was the real brains of the business and her father was the public face who dealt with the sexist men to imrpove their yachts. As race cars didn't quite exist yet, yachts were the 19th-century equivalent and Lillian was a major part of improving the yachts. Emma's powers of observation and feelings about being a working woman come into play here. Is she projecting her own feelings onto Lillian or was Lillian as sensible and practical as Emma wants to believe? Either way, she was a much-loved daughter and an asset to the yachting community. Her father seems like a nice man. He sounds so lost and confused as to why anyone would want to kill his beloved daughter. However, like most fathers, he sees her as a perfect little girl and not as a young woman with a woman's thoughts and feelings. Did he catch her doing something unethical? Did he kill her for loving someone he didn't approve of? Is he that good of an actor or is he simply a single father who doesn't know what his adult daughter was actually up to? I'm wondering if Lillian caught wind of some plan and was doing an Emma and investigating the shady business and it got her killed?
I still really like Emma. Her thoughts and feelings are complex and very valid for her time and even our own. She loves Derrick and wants to build a life with him that includes marriage and children but she doesn't want to give up her career. She also feels like a failure in regards to fitting in with his social circle. Emma is too intelligent and quick and not idle enough for them. I think she's a little old to be having children in the early 1900s so we'll see where her journey takes her. I understand her concerns and fears and how they're holding her back. Derrick has come a long way since they first met and he seems supportive and understanding of Emma's hang-ups and her dreams. However, in one scene he acts out of character for him because of something going on in their relationship and I didn't like that. It would make me think twice about marrying him. Mostly he manages to be a bit swoony but I still feel lukewarm on him in terms of their relationship but professionally they work well together and I liked seeing them sleuth together. Emma's sleuthing style is like a bulldog. She's tenacious and impatient. Derrick has more finesse and puts people at ease.
We can eliminate the real life figures who appear in the novel as suspects but I want to mention them anyway. The women are catty and mean girlish, secure in THEIR social position but quick to make Emma feel inferior. Elizabeth Morgan is the hostess and she doesn't do anything to make her guest feel at ease. Her husband, Edwin, is an affable gentleman, for the most part but make no mistake-they have money and power and do NOT want a murder investigation in their backyard. J.P. Morgan has a one track mind - the race - and he sees Emma and Derrick merely as journalists. They're not even on as radar as social aquaintances. The man had money coming out of his orfices so I guess that gives him the right to snub whoever he wants given the social mores of the time. His wife, Fanny, seems nice and at least tries to find common ground with Emma. The most interesting real life character is Lucy Carnegie. A wealthy widow, she was cut from the same mold as Molly Brown and Alva Vanderbilt Belmont. She's larger than life and forceful. She forced the men to allow her into the New York Yacht Club but she's still not on equal footing. Lucy reminds Emma of Mamie Fish and so Lucy becomes Emma's new temporary sleuthing partner. Lucy is a lot of fun and by all accounts, she was a loving smother and grandmother. Her love of outdoor sports doesn't appeal to me but I enjoy her personality and would like to be friends.
Fictional 400 Club members include Bernard and Ruth Delafield. He's a slimy womanizer who clearly has his eye on Emma in spite of her arriving with her fiance. Rumor has it his wife has asked for a divorce and he won't allow it for whatever reason. I think their failed relationship has turned her sour and bitter. I suspect either of them could commit murder. Lillian's photo resembles Evelyn Nesbitt, the Gibson Girl so I'm guessing Bernard lied about his identity and was her secret lover. He either killed her to keep her quiet or Ruth killed Lillian to make the scandal go away. Tyrone Kerr is a younger gentleman, a bachelor and the happy-go-lucky type. He seems nice enough but also kind of interested in Emma, again even though she's with Derrick.
Other suspects include Wallace Rayburn, a member of J.P. Morgan's yacht crew. His initials match a clue found on Lillian's body but he doesn't seem to fit the profile of a murderer. Emma muses that looks can be deceiving but he is young, youthful and bashful. Perhaps he was in love with Lillian and she spurned him? Perhaps he gifted her a love token and she laughed at him so he pushed her overboard? More likely is the man Brady's friend Angus saw arguing with Lillian the day of her death. He couldn't have been her lover since he appeared to be a rough crew member or dock worker but certainly he was the last person to have seen her alive and was seen arguing with her. Maybe ther argument got heated and he pushed her and she fell into the ocean to her death? There's another woman, a working class woman, who is angry enough to protect her own interests. Does she know what happened to Lillian?
The second death is also an incredible tragedy and it is kind of unresolved. Obviously this person was a threat to the villain somehow. The photographer identified Lillian and therefore, he probably knew the identity of her lover.
As usual, Jesse is the good cop but his hands are tied by his superiors who bow to the wishes of the wealthy summer cottagers. No one wants to lose their job based on a whim of someone with too much money but Jesse is willing to risk it to a certain extent. He respects Emma's intelligence and perceptions too much to let this one go but if he's caught investigating, it will cost him his job. Jesse is getting along with Derrick better now but he still seems a bit mistrustful. Katie and Nanny are on hand again to provide encouragment and comfort. They both adore Derrick and even Katie feels comfortable with him around. She's no longer the terrfied little mouse she once was. That says a lot about Derrick that she feels she can trust him. Emma's family only appears briefly. Her bohemian parents are still in Paris, unaware of her engagement but the gossip grapevine spread the word to Aunt Alice and Brady. Oops! Aunt Alice is happy if she's in charge and I expect there will be a lot of drama before Emma and Derrick walk down the aisle. Brady has grown up a lot but he's still very much a boy. His little sister has to give him wise counsel in matters of the heart. Will we see a double wedding before long?
I always enjoy this series even if the writing style doesn't sound 19th-century. Derrick and Emma would never behave so scandalously in real life. They'd sit on a porch and he would "make love" to her (not the same definition we use today, more like whispering sweet nothings into her ear). That's OK because it's fiction and some readers just can't grapple with 19th-century writing. I would like a little more period sounding langauge because I understand it but I don't mind not having it.
I'm eager for the next now. Will Emma and Derrick become man and wife finally?
Read with a cup of tea on a rainy day while listening to the sounds of the ocean slapping outside.