Three stars? 2.5? This was a difficult one to pin down, and I’ll be honest I was hoping I’d give it a higher rating than I did. I always try and review titles with as much honesty as I possibly can, I just genuinely wish this caught on as well with me as it seemed to with so many others.
The plot line is what really solidifies this story, as I’ve never read a book that focuses on a witches familiar- or thirteen of them for that matter! As a practicing witch myself, (regardless of how anyone feels about that,) I love reading books about women like me, and by that I mean witches not “butchers” if you catch my drift. I loved Edith best, surprise surprise. I loved most of the names of her cats too, being unique and completely underused. The concept is strong with this one, and in Edith’s multiple flashbacks the atmosphere seems to really work.
But then we get back to Rhode Island. That’s where my issues start.
I could not stand Rebecca. I honestly didn’t care much about Brian either, although he was tolerable. Their relationship felt pointless to me, and I just could not connect with their storyline in virtually any way. Granted, that could be because I’m a mentally deteriorating carnie, but I digress. I was bored of their normie lives, and I feel like the cats entering them didn’t even shake things up quite enough for me.
Senator Hyde is supposed to bring a lot of meat to the plot, but again, I couldn’t care less about him and found myself not only confusing him for Duncan multiple times but hardly remembering who he is. Maura was an interesting piece of this story- but she is NOT given enough “screen time” in my opinion, and her story is left way too unexplored when I think it should’ve been a much broader section of the book. But, these are all really subjective and personal opinions.
I’m certainly not here to nit pick. I think that this idea rocks. I think the parts that explored Edith Penn, including the “present day” lead ups to her eventual demise, were almost impossible to put down. I just didn’t feel any excitement when it came to our Rhode Island natives and their more worldly struggles. Part of me wishes this had taken place somewhere like Salem, but I could also see how that would be overdone. Overall, I think the author can certainly write his ass off, and I would most definitely dive into his other works.
Not a complete loss from me, but I did have my grievances with it. Edith Penn, however, as a character, is brilliant. I would not shy away from any more lore concerning her and her black cats. However, the townspeople felt like a dull coat of paint over her intriguing and multi layered story.
Side note, the “limbo” scene was a pretty vivid fever dream, and I want to give a giant props to Sean McDonough for coming up with that! If you like folklore or anything magick related, you may just wanna try this one out. It could appeal to you easily.