The GOOD:
Being a Bible-believing Christian and a foster parent, I thought the overall narrative was very thought-provoking, heart-wrenching, and relatable. Her heart for hurting kids is easily picked up.
She added some very insightful thoughts and quotes. For example, in answering the typical question, "How do you protect your heart in fostering?" Jillana Goble wisely answers: "[A child] deserves healthy attachment more than I need to keep my heart protected from shattering. Love is a risk, a vulnerable heart move. There is no risk-free path in parenting no matter how our children come to us. We know that at any moment our hearts could be scraped by tragedy, trauma, or rebellion. This doesn't stop us, however, from loving our children and continually being shaped by them."
The BAD:
The author claims to be non-judgmental and spends considerable time assuming that the judgments of others are based on skin color. Yet, in many interactions Goble recalls with the police, she suspects evil motives (racism or some other character flaw) based on a uniform.
" 'Ma'am I'm gonna let you go with the warning. Just be mindful of your speed.' the officer said. I thanked him and was on my way. I suspected the reason I didn't get a ticket that day (other than my skin color not working against me) was that the officer couldn't stand the noise emanating from my car long enough to write me one."
Scripture teaches that we can not know the motives of others unless they disclose them to us. “For who among people knows the thoughts of a person except the spirit of the person that is in him?” 1 Corinthians 2:11. Rather, love should believe the best about everyone whenever possible. (1 Corinthians 13:7). It is disappointing that she did not apply the non-judgemental standard universally.
Overall, she had a low view of the Church. :( I am heartbroken if her experiences lead her to this conclusion.
The author shares this from a trauma-informed (circumstance-centered) perspective. She asserts that sinful behavior is the "vocabulary of the deeply wounded." I agree, that is helpful to look on others with mercy, understanding that they are shaped by trauma… by brokenness. But that perspective can’t be the focus of our counseling. No, encouraging others to view life from a victimhood mentality is hopeless. The most merciful course is to help others understand their sinfulness and need for a savior. Hope is found in fixing our eyes on the Savior, not on our circumstances. Hebrews 12:2 “Let us fix our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy set before him endured the cross, scorning its shame, and sat down at the right hand of the throne of God.” This book just needed more of Jesus.