Overall a decent book and I do think teenagers need to be taught more about personal finance…but I have a few issues.
1) When listing all of the expenses associated with having a car, you can’t list both the purchase price of the car and annual depreciation for the car. Depreciation is just spreading out the purchase price over time (either by the actual value loss in the vehicle or by a set depreciation schedule). By listing both, the author is double counting that expense.
2) I really dislike the notion that your house is a “false asset”. He isn’t the first author to do this (and I do feel calling it a false asset is at least better than Kiyosaki calling it a liability). I understand what the author is saying, but I feel it downplays the value of a owning your residence too much.
The idea behind this book is to get more money to Steps 3&4 (Save and invest) by increasing Step 1 (income) and decreasing Step 2 (expenses). Owning your own house should do that just like owning a rental property unless you have purchased a more expensive house than you need.
If you buy a rental property and rent it to someone else, you increase Step 1 (income) by the difference between the amount you charge in rent and the taxes, maintenance, insurance, interest, etc.
If you are living in your purchased home, you decrease Step 2 (expenses) by the difference between the amount you would pay to live elsewhere (market rate rent for equivalent housing) and the amount you pay for taxes, maintenance, insurance, interest, etc.
Both of these strategies allow the same exact amount of additional money to pass through steps 1&2 and get to steps 3&4. (plus potentially some additional tax benefits associated with a primary residence for owning a property you live in).
The only way this isn’t true is when you have purchased a more expensive house than you need. If you have the option to live at home with parents, then you don’t need to purchase a house at all. If you have the option to rent at a lower price than the cost of buying the house you are looking at, then you don’t need that particular house as you have a better option. If you are in a position where house hacking is possible, that can be a great option as well. But if you bought the appropriate residence for your needs, it definitely isn’t a false asset as it increases the amount of money remaining for Steps 3&4 vs the available alternative. It is only a “false asset” in the author’s sense of the term when you purchase a house that exceeds your needs.