A good read, but not exactly what I was expecting.
First I just want to state for anyone else looking to reviews for the answer - yes. This is a stand alone novel. We do get a conclusion in this one book.
I appreciate that and am actually surprised how much was packed into this, realizing how much unnecessarily ‘fluff’ ends up in most trilogies.
Secondly, had I not read other reviews prior to reading this, I’m not 100% sure I would have seen this as an allegory for God or (un)answered prayers. I can see it - sort of - because of those reviews, but I’m not entirely certain what the author’s aim was in making it such. That even when tragedy strikes, it feels like God doesn’t care or isn’t there, He is? It seems a bit…short of the mark, for me. The Wishkeeper is only human, after all. Using human knowledge to make decisions and with limits to his power and ability to grant wishes, it’s not exactly on-par with God as our Caregiver. But, I digress.
As for the story itself… It was good enough to engage and occupy me. It had a decent amount of mystery, as well as a couple of plot lines running throughout. But I felt the two storylines (one in the past as well and the other being the main line story from the books’ synopsis) and their placement didn’t quite intersect well and the transitions were always jarring. But I’m not sure how it could have been done better.
Perhaps if the book had opened with our main characters instead of those from the past, and then an introduction to those in the past to make sense of why we were reading about them to begin with. (If this sounds convoluted, I apologize. I’m trying not to give away spoilers.)
I found the world and the story and the characters engaging, but it also felt a bit lacking. Like I was waiting for more depth or connection and it didn’t really come. Maybe that’s due to the underlying ‘mystery’ to everything. But I would have enjoyed a little less interior monologue and more interaction between all of the characters. Seeing their relationships and affections growing. And experiencing them along with them.
The romance was decent. I enjoyed the depth to which the hero felt for the heroine, and I would have liked a bit more from the heroine, but with her preoccupation with her brother, it’s understandable she would be too split emotionally to really focus. Which is unfortunate, but is a good example of just another aspect falling a bit short.
The reveal in the end felt strange. I have so many questions and no answers. And I won’t voice them here so as to spoil it for anyone else, but I think more could have been given with regard to how Briar is to fulfill her new role especially with no training. In addition, I don’t see how a relationship between her and the love interest could possibly work out from a TITLE standpoint. (Again, so as not to give away spoilers.) How could she, being what she is, being with him, being who he is. With the work each of them has to do? IS it doable? Sure. Likely? No. But I’d have loved an epilogue to give a bit of explanation, even if done as recap/summary.
But, in all, I enjoyed the read and am glad I read it. But I’m thinking I probably won’t continue along with this author as her style doesn’t quite fit my preferences.