Sarah Milne, The Book Lover’s Guide to London, White Owl, an Imprint of Pen & Sword Books Ltd
Thank you NetGalley and Pen & Sword, for providing me with this uncorrected proof for review.
I was thrilled when my request for this book was granted. Perhaps the height of my expectations made my disappointment sharper. I feel that readers of this review need to take this into consideration as I must admit to being disappointed.
Briefly, taking a positive approach, The Book lover’s Guide to London does provide an extensive list of authors and locations that feature in fiction and characters that would be useful to any person, tourist, or relatively knowledgeable London visitor, in investigating London through literature.
However, I felt that there was too much dependence on familiar sources such as Dickens for the more colourful commentary; a greater variety of works and authors given such treatment would have been a welcome addition. At times the narrative lacked the warmth I associate with any discussion of books. Both authors and characters would have benefitted from a more engaging style so that they could be envisaged moving through the many locations covered in this book.
Geographic areas provide the structure, making this an ideal literary map for exploration. Writers who lived in and/or used them as locations for their fiction are featured in the relevant sections. Although at times this leads to repetition, the usefulness of this way of assembling the information overrides any problems here. Repetition can be a good memory jogger, after all. Geographic entities, Central London, North West London, North London, South London, South West London and West London, feature. Within these, suburbs and authors are named, so that, for example, Kensington and Earl’s Court highlight the authors, Beatrix Potter, Nancy Mitford, Virginia Wolf, William Makepeace Thackeray, and T.S. Eliot and novels in which Earls Court provides the location, include Andrea Levy’s A Small Island and Patrick Hamilton’s Hangover. An interesting comment on one of Agatha Christie’s novels is its location in the apartments in which she lived, Swan Court in Chelsea.
A comprehensive list of the authors and their works, and an extensive bibliography provide further reading. There is an abundance of photographs, which as well as being a tremendous source for understanding the authors’ or their characters’ lives are a pleasure to spend time contemplating.